News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by meatsauce on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:12AM (#31893419)
Why do leftists believe they have the right to tell others what their interests are?
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by andrepd on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:15AM (#31893452)
As the other other poster says: whatever those interests are, you cannot fight for them alone vs a trillion dollar corp like Amazon, so that point is moot. Collective action is the only way you stand a chance.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by meatsauce on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:24AM (#31893547)
You can work someplace else if you hate the company. Imagine that.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by andrepd on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:33AM (#31893658)
Okay. So your company treats you like shit and you quit. Where do you go now? You need to sell your labour to survive, so you lost all your income. Your employer has other sources of income, has reserve capital, so that even if your job was critical and production is now shut while they look for a replacement (unlikely), they're gonna be fine. But you need to eat tonight. Not next quarter or next month or even next week, tonight. You need to pay the bank/landlord a steady sum or you'll become homeless. And god forbid you get less than perfectly healthy.

So you don't quit actually, because it is not possible for you to quit. Capital has far more power than a (so-called) "unskilled worker", especially if there's no collective action. They have all the leverage, the worker has none, so they can dictate the conditions, i.e. the bare minimum for the worker to survive and continue working, and the worker has only to accept.

I feel like I'm saying really basic stuff.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by ETH_start on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:43AM (#31893764)
The employer owes you nothing. You're citing your difficult circimstances to justify getting the government to seize control of an employer from its shareholders, in dictating its hiring decisions.

But as a practical matter, opportunities expand faster when labor markets are free, and capital owners are secure in their rights.

Employment growth has been widely observed to be stronger where labor laws are less restrictive.

Detroit was the richest city in America in 1950. Within 40 years of the UAW Union taking over the Big Three automakers (membership rose through the 50s and 60s, peaking in 1979), the big automakers have lost their market dominance, and Detroit is a shell of its former self.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by andrepd on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:56AM (#31894644)
>The employer owes you nothing. You're citing your difficult circimstances to justify getting the government to seize control of an employer from its shareholders, in dictating its hiring decisions.

It's not about "difficult circumstances" at all. It's about the fundamental divide between those who need to sell their labour to survive, and those who can extract rent without working due only to having a monopoly on capital. It's a qualitative distinction, of class, not a quantitative matter of being more or less poor.

Also I did not even say anything about "government seizing control". But I will say this: the current economic system based on joint-stock ownership of firms by capital monopolists is an entirely fabricated system, and not a rule of Nature. So don't argue "but you would seize property from their rightful owners" as if the very particular system of property rights currently in force wasn't a social invention enforced with violence by the state.

>Employment growth has been widely observed to be stronger where labor laws are less restrictive.

This is simply not true. Notice how the best countries to live in the world are invariably those with more labour protections and a mixed economy with heavy public participation. Limiting ourselves to the US, compare the standard of living in the gilded age vs the golden age of American labour organisation.

>Detroit

Also, it's very rich trying to link the downfall of American industry to unionisation... I could go on for an hour about this topic.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by ETH_start on Monday June 27, 2022 @01:02PM (#31897418)
>>and those who can extract rent without working due only to having a monopoly on capital.

No capital owner has a monopoly on capital, and capital owners do not collude to act as one with respect to recruiting workers, making your claim totally specious. Also, typically businesses don't extract economic rent. Investment is a difficult and risk-filled enterprise, that adds value to the economy, making it by definition, not a form of rent extraction.

I suggest putting aside Marxist narratives and studying mainstream Economics, which would dispel you of these fallacies on which your claims of class victimhood rest.

>>This is simply not true. Notice how the best countries to live in the world are invariably those with more labour protections and a mixed economy with heavy public participation. Limiting ourselves to the US, compare the standard of living in the gilded age vs the golden age of American labour organisation.

You just criticized me for making the correlation equals causation argument with respect to Detroit and then you go on to make a far more egregious use of this argument in claiming that conditions being worse in an era 80 years prior tell us the policies in place 80 years prior were worse.

A rational analysis compares the trajectory of an economy relative to its contemporaries when trying to use comparisons between different eras to decipher what works. The fact is wages and productivity grow faster on average in countries where labor markets are more free. The Nordic countries saw far faster economic growth relative to the rest of the world when they were more free market economies and have been leapfrogged by Singapore and Hong-Kong in life expectancy since abandoning those free market policies and embracing socialism-lite.

>>Also I did not even say anything about "government seizing control"

The government mandating companies to enter into collective bargaining to the exclusion of negotiating with any other worker is the government taking control of the shareholder's negotiating agency with respect to their property. Without this compulsion, the ability of unions to extract economic rent would be non-existent.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by krolden on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:23PM (#31896819)
>Detroit was the richest city in America in 1950. Within 40 years of the UAW Union taking over the Big Three automakers (membership rose through the 50s and 60s, peaking in 1979), the big automakers have lost their market dominance, and Detroit is a shell of its former self.

Oh yeah blame the unions for the downfall of the american auto industry. It had nothing to do with the biggest recession in the last 40 years and the fact that no one wanted new cars when they were losing their house to the banks.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by ThrowawayR2 on Monday June 27, 2022 @06:46PM (#31901914)
> 1950

That prosperity almost certainly more to do with the post-WW2 economic boom than anything else. There are arguments to be made against unions but citing what happened in the golden era of the '50s-'60s isn't one of them.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by ETH_start on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @02:06AM (#31904609)
Detroit being the richest city in America in 1950 was a culmination of many decades of economic development stretching back to the late 19th century.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by atwood22 on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:15AM (#31893460)
Because workers' rights are a zero-sum game. There is a total amount of power that can be had in the workplace, and it is either held by the owners or the workers.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by collegeburner on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:50AM (#31893855)
Do you really believe the owners will simply accept lower profits and not just pass on the cost to the consumer? This is how you get increasing costs but no actual improvement. Wage-price spiral.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by rwooster on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:26AM (#31894285)
This sounds like you think it's ok for companies to exploit workers if it keeps costs low - is that really your intent?
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by jahnu on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:20AM (#31893503)
We all have the right to discuss our opinion of what is best for each other. The OP there isn't arguing for taking away the right of someone to decide.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by sAbakumoff on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:18AM (#31893488)
A much better question would be – why does the American ruling class deny basic human rights – decent wage, affordable health care, good education, safety?
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by meatsauce on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:32AM (#31893641)
Amazon starts at $18/hr.

You want $100/hour to pack and move boxes? Start a moving company.

Healthcare isn't a right. It is a luxury. Self defense, free speech, freedom of movement and association; those are human rights. Healthcare is only expensive because of the multiple layers of government and private corruption, litigation, and pie-halving. At the same time, Healthcare can save your life; what is your life truly worth? A $10 co-pay?

If we had a good education, then people wouldn't be whining about $18/hour.

Safety? Such as being insulated from ideas & opinions you don't like, or having zero risk for electrocution in electrical contracting?

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by lovelymono on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:57AM (#31894656)

    Healthcare isn't a right
From UN Declaration of Human Rights, Art. 25:

    1. Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and
       well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing
       and medical care and necessary social servicess, and the right to security
       in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or
       other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by sAbakumoff on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:32AM (#31895094)
>> Amazon starts at $18/hr

I think it's a lie. AFAIK they pay warehouse workers $15/hour. As you start your message with lying, the rest of is BS.

Safety, by the way, means not being afraid of being shut by a right-wing delusional maniac.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by TigeriusKirk on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:37AM (#31895162)
"The average starting wage of $18 an hour will be effective in regions where labor markets are tight, while the company will continue to pay a minimum wage of $15 an hour, said Dave Bozeman, vice president of delivery services at Amazon."

So "lie" is a bit strong here.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by sAbakumoff on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:58AM (#31895469)
>> while the company will continue to pay a minimum wage of $15 an hour

Like I said, it's $15/h

But anyway, the federal minimum wage is $7.25 per hour and there is zero chance that it will be increased.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by ok123456 on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:13AM (#31893436)
The have an interest in not being given demerits for using the bathroom (aka: "time off task")
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by meatsauce on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:24AM (#31893538)
That still doesn't answer the question. Nor does it address the issue of people who abuse policies, such as those who hide in the bathroom for 1/8th of the shift.

This isn't the 19th century anymore. Unions had served a good purpose, but in no way do they serve the interests of everybody, especially in modern society given labor laws. My experience in several unions only demonstrated how corrupt, inept, and self-serving they are.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by ok123456 on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:41AM (#31893737)
Yes it does. They have specific material concerns and concerns about their working conditions that aren't being addressed.

We're returning to the 19th century it seems with worker protections being eroded. It makes sense that Unionization would make a comeback.