News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by bawolff on Saturday June 25, 2022 @10:05AM (#31875392)
I have also seen this. A large number of certs on a resume (more than 4) is the most consistent negative signal i have seen.

I assume part of the reason is that certs are expensive and not well respected, so the only reason you would get them is if you had no other options.

Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by grepfru_it on Saturday June 25, 2022 @10:41AM (#31875668)
Is this recent? I held every cert under the sun in the 2000s and companies GOBBLED ME UP. In the early 2010s I could walk into companies by simply having a VCP cert. I'm sure if I held a K8s or some hashicorp cert, or AWS or Azure certs I would be pulled into any org hiring today. And I put all of my certs on my resume (that I can fit with most recent first).

I should also clarify, I only put certs that matter (why put an Azure cert on a resume submission to an AWS shop) and certs that are recent (I have 20 years on my resume, why would i put my CCNA on there). I think a large number of irrelevant certs would be a negative signal. I think a large number of relevant certs AND job history to back them up would be a super strong signal.

Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by native_samples on Saturday June 25, 2022 @11:55AM (#31876251)
I remember many years ago, Google internally knew that one of the only signals obtainable from CVs was the negative signal from number of certs. I don't think this knowledge was actually used for anything, it was just a correlation, but yeah it's sort of an open secret in the business that the sort of people who get lots of certifications do very badly when asked to demonstrate actual technical skills.
Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by BossingAround on Saturday June 25, 2022 @12:13PM (#31876432)
It's a response to large number of people who know very little and want to compensate with memorizing stuff and passing certificates without deeper understanding of what they're doing.

It's kind of a stupid response, especially considering that the same people would most likely view 10+ certs on your CV as a positive if your name is western-sounding...

Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by bawolff on Saturday June 25, 2022 @11:45AM (#31876172)
Idk, i haven't been in the industry long enough to compare. Also, i work in security (in north america and not gov), maybe other areas are more pro-cert.
Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by imwillofficial on Saturday June 25, 2022 @12:55PM (#31876792)
I also disagree with your first comment. Large amounts of difficult certs have never been a negative signal and I’ve been doing this for like 20 years. Especially in cyber security where a wide breadth of various knowledge is needed, certs can really help show who has the ”full-stack” so to speak.

That being said, 20+ CompTIA cents isn’t going to move the needle for me.

I say all that to say “it depends on the cert”

Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by evgen on Saturday June 25, 2022 @04:28PM (#31878459)
Actually cyber security is one area where a lot of certs are a strong negative signal. They basically broadcast course-taking and cert-chasing over real world experience. If you have an OSCP cert I will treat that as a potentially good signal, but if your CV includes CISSP I will walk in to an interview with low expectations and if it has CEH or similar wastes of time the recruiting lead would have known to filter the CV out so that I do not even see it. This if for FAANG environments though, so maybe if you are aiming for a corporate cube farm in a smaller market other certs will be useful. Just not with me.
Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by imwillofficial on Saturday June 25, 2022 @05:33PM (#31878901)
OSCP vs CISSP is a ridiculous line to draw, they cover very different job types.

I don’t know what jobs you’re hiring for, if any, I simply don’t see how more data is a negative signal.

I think that’s silly.

I disagree with the entirety of your reply, except for the CEH zinger ;)

Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by 0xBDB on Saturday July 02, 2022 @07:18PM (#31963406)
As a Red Team manager with both the OSCP and CISSP, in my opinion neither is worthless but they are oversold and they aren't really comparable.

The CISSP is a risk management cert that's sometimes oversold as an infosec cert. It's been quite useful to me in dealing with the (Fortune 1000 mostly) bureaucracies that take Red Team and pen test findings and turn them into remediations or risk acceptances.

The OSCP is a technical cert that's oversold in a different way: because the test is fairly difficult, lots of people assume it's an advanced cert. It's a beginner cert (and Offensive Security has several more you can take after it). What it does prove is that you probably have the right mindset to be a penetration tester (which is not necessarily the same mindset you need for Red Teaming, i.e., unannounced adversarial simulation).

tl;dr: I don't think any cert is bad as long as everybody understands what it's for. But I'm one of those people who collects them (at employer expense) as a way to structure my learning, and then never renews them.

Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by 2snakes on Saturday June 25, 2022 @06:35PM (#31879302)
SANS certs? CCIE? GSE? OSEE?
Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by imwillofficial on Saturday June 25, 2022 @08:15PM (#31879856)
SANS certs are great
Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by bawolff on Saturday June 25, 2022 @02:06PM (#31877366)
I think that's fair. I more saw it as the 20+ comptia certs.
Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by yourapostasy on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:50AM (#31882199)
I'm enough of a domain expert in certain niches that I've participated in creating certification exams. The reason it can develop into a negative signal: the question banks are rapidly exhausted by the exam dump industry, and for even some esoteric exams 90%+ of the question bank with exactly correct answers are generated within a year of the exam's introduction.

With the popular exams, it is mind-numbingly fast. Think days to weeks. Crowdsourcing / MTurking the question banks is depressingly effective if you sweated over nearly a thousand question bank items for a few months with a few other expensive experts.

Labs in the exams are a way to blunt this, but I think the exam dump industry has probably come up with a way to defeat labs as well by now, because the labs run a fixed set of scenarios with variations in parameters but not the general gist. It's better, but still hackable.

What I've come up with requires discipline by a team documenting the issues they've fixed in the past, but it is so far 100% foolproof. Pick a random relatively self-contained issue your team fixed in the past; this is the most critical step governing the quality of this technique's results. Reproduce the issue in a scratch environment.

Sit down the candidate in front of a workstation set up to their preferences you gathered in advance, with all the tooling they prefer, simplifying your superfluous environment specifics where possible (like logging them into various accounts ahead of time). Set their expectations ahead of time that they will be team / pair troubleshooting for half an hour, that you aren't evaluating whether they find the root cause or not, you're evaluating how well they work with others troubleshooting an issue in some system/language/etc. they claim they are a domain expert in. Dive in.

Without fail, the ones who exam dumped their way to a certification will thrash about. Hard. Most common is they will not know where to even start, deer-in-the-headlights. Even telling the candidate straight out where to start, by using your 20/20 hindsight and artificially picking a starting point 1-2 steps away from the root cause still does not unlock them; jumping to a known good starting point is useful for the experienced candidates who freeze under interview pressure, as they usually unfreeze when given such a big head start from your IRL issue that you ran into for the first time.

You can often get a good gauge of how much and how deeply the candidate worked with the stack they claim competency in by how they navigate around, ask questions, probe for error messages, etc.

Re:Ask HN: Any certification that is worth it? Legitimately ... by wyclif on Saturday June 25, 2022 @09:32PM (#31880231)
I'm interested in an informed discussion of a comparison of the merits of the differing tech certs, not so much talking about scuba, finance, or truck driving.

How does the quality and value of, say, CompTIA, Cisco, AWS, OSCP, K8s, Linux+ and other certs compare with each other?