News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by sipefree on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:29AM (#3186185)
If the US does take him from Sweden, then it will only serve as huge negative PR against them, and call into question the motives of the UK courts. The backlash could be huge.
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by objclxt on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:53AM (#3186244)
The motives of the UK courts aren't really in question, whatever happens. No lawyers with any knowledge of EU law actually expected his appeal to succeed.

I suspect a lot of people here will rush to call some kind of politically motivated conspiracy. I suspect they don't really understand how the UK legal system works.

If you actually read the judgment [0], you'll see it's pretty iron-clad. Very few people in the field thought this appeal was going to succeed. The simple fact is that the UK has obligations to Europe, including turning over those accused of committing crimes in other member states. It is extremely hard to get out of those obligations.

I cannot overstate just how detailed the judgement is. There is very little room for maneuverer by Assange, and his legal defence during the appeal was pretty poor. His entire defence is ripped apart.

People seem to be under the mistaken impression it is somehow up to the English courts to determine whether Assange is guilty or not. It isn't. It's up to the English courts to determine whether the warrant for his arrest was issued properly, and whether it meets the relevant dual-criminality standards. Which it was, and does, on every level.

The issue of whether Assange is at risk of extradition to the US from Sweden is not relevant to this case, in any way, shape, or form.

[0] http://images.newstatesman.com/RC.pdf

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by mike-cardwell on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:36AM (#3186208)
This confuses me. Are the Swedes more likely to extradite people to the US than the UK are? If not, I don't understand your point...

I'm a Brit, and I was under the impression that our government bends over and gives the US anyone they want, whereas the Swedes give a shit about peoples rights...

I'd have thought Assange is safer from the US in Sweden than he was in the UK. Plus he'll find it a lot easier to travel to different countries if he's on mainland Europe (assuming he's not imprisoned for this rape stuff)

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by jka on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:55AM (#3186247)
It's difficult to tell - the U.K. courts until recently had seemed (following heavy lawyering from Assange) to be allowing him to stay in the country under curfew, but this recent ruling seems to overturn that.

There was a bit of an outcry last year when it turned out that the U.S. had been performing surveillance around their embassies in Norway, and I remember reading some suggestions at the time that there was actually Norwegian co-operation to some extent - but I'd have to dig back in detail to find the reports.

There was also an admission around the same time that similar monitoring had been taking place in Sweden.

And finally, one of the Swedish prosecutors raised very early on the possibility of extraditing Assange to the U.S. following prosecution.

Here are a few reading references to back these up - as mentioned in this thread, it's far from clear without knowing the full details, but here are some pieces to fill out the context:

* Swedish charges leaked

http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/02/wikileaks-sweden/

* U.S. Surveillance in Norway

http://www.newsinenglish.no/2010/11/04/officials-howling-ove...

* Similar surveillance admission in Sweden

http://www.thelocal.se/30062/20101106/#

* Prosecutor's suggestions regarding extradition from Sweden to U.S.

http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/12/14/swedish-prosecut...

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by jeza on Thursday November 03, 2011 @06:18AM (#3191070)
Something else worth noting which the last url suggests is that Sweden can't just extradite him to the US at their own will. It would also have to be approved by Britain.
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by arethuza on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:06AM (#3186286)
"our government bends over and gives the US anyone they want"

I'm pretty sure the UK doesn't hand over people who may face the death penalty - although it wouldn't surprise me if there was an exclusion to this sensible rule for the US.

http://www.cps.gov.uk/news/fact_sheets/extradition/

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by jeza on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:27AM (#3186332)
I would doubt there is any exception to this policy for the US. See also: http://www.fco.gov.uk/en/global-issues/human-rights/justice-...
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by gillianseed on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @09:48AM (#3186606)
-"whereas the Swedes give a shit about peoples rights..."

You must be thinking about the days when we had guys like Olof Palme (who incidentally got shot).

Nowadays we are being run by a right-wing coalition dominated by 'Moderaterna', which is the only political party in Sweden refusing to declare from where they get their campaign money. Just recently they also tried to take credit for being part of the movement for equal vote and against apartheid, when in reality they were against womens right to vote and also was the only party who did not want sanctions against apartheid, hilarious.

Not that our government being right-wing has anything to do with Assange, no matter what government we'd have sitting today (left,right) they would bend to US pressure just as quickly.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by chalst on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:23AM (#3186327)
Assange's camp put out an argument that it was technically much harder to extradite from the UK than Sweden, for both legal and diplomatic reasons.

http://www.swedenversusassange.com/US-Extradition.html

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by rms on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:32AM (#3186197)
I think the goals of the USA/CIA will be sufficiently served by him being sentenced to jail in Sweden for a while.
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by rdtsc on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:17AM (#3186309)
Their basic goal is to make an example out of him. Since this will obviously not put the cat back in the bag, it is just about setting an example and revenge. They are doing this to Manning as well. But it is harder to get a hold of Assange directly but they can use Sweden. Swedes, are surprisingly friendly with US govt (see jka's post above).
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by illumen on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:38AM (#3186217)
The Swedish people want his blood too, as does the Swedish Prime Minister. He is going to go into a secret trial, and possibly just disappear. Also the Australian Prime minister wants him locked up, so I wouldn't be surprised they don't do something. It's likely they will help the US take him away somewhere nasty rather than do it themselves though.

When you have multiple world leaders going after you, there's not much you can do. Basically Julian is fucked.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by niklasl on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:55AM (#3186251)
As a Swede, I can tell you we don't give a flying fuck about Assange and neither does the prime minister. If he had just come here and had his trial, he would have had about 95% chance of being acquitted (the courts being rather more cautious on sexual matters than the prosecutors here) and could go back to doing what he does.

As for the secret trials and disappearing thing. Sweden has such a good reputation on freedom that Wikileaks wanted to relocate here before Assange got into trouble. He's certainly no worse off here than in the UK.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by illumen on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:04AM (#3186279)
You are wrong. The Swedish Prime minister has made public statements that the man is guilty. So has the Swedish press.
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by marcusf on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:12AM (#3186300)
Neither of them have any control of the courts, though. And of course our press will latch on to a juicy story, as would any.
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by illumen on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @09:02AM (#3186442)
The Prime Minister creates law. The press influence the courts through criticism and informing public opinion. The courts have already been subjected to almost a year of media coverage influencing them, and the politicians influencing them.

There is a reason why the politicians are not supposed to comment on criminal cases. There is also a reason why people are supposed to make their decisions on the evidence and arguments in the court rather than being influenced by the media.

Search on the internet for "Julian Assange is a rapist" on google.se and you will find countless claims that he is guilty coming from people in Sweden. Julian Assange är en våldtäktsman, brings up 1.5 million results on google.se.

Having a secret trial, in a country proven to declare the guilt of the accused - without hearing the evidence - is not a fair trial.

The whole thing makes a mockery of justice. He should be given a fair trial - as should anyone else on this planet.

Let's try and flip nationalism around for the moment. Assume You personally were accused of something by the prosecutors of Finland, or the USA. Then the president of the USA comes out and says that you are "an enemy of the people", and states that you have bad ideas on committing crimes. Then you are going to be shipped off to the USA for a trial - but of course the evidence will not be made public, people will just have to trust the courts.

There is a great risk of an unfair trial in Sweden for this case(not all cases). There is also a high risk that he will be sent to the USA and face execution once in Sweden - as stated by the Swedish prosecution.

International law, and human rights should apply. This should be taken to a higher court in the UK.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by marcusf on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @09:51AM (#3186621)
I really don't want to argue the point too much. We've obviously got different views on this, and differing experiences with the swedish judiciary system. PM Reinfeldt would not sign anything in to law regarding this, and parliament would never approve it. There's no basis in history for assuming anything like remotely like that would occur.

Also "Julian Assange är en våldtäktsman" returns 360 hits, not 1.5 mil, where most of them are the suffix of the meaning "If Julian Assange is a rapist...", so your interpretation is a bit off. As others have stated, the verdict is still out. Swedes are not smelling blood, and I resent that interpretation of Swedes as a collective and the accusation that he would not get a fair trial in Sweden.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by tjogin on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:53AM (#3186410)
*Citation Needed.
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by Steer on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:44AM (#3186224)
Don't know where you are from, but since I am from Sweden and live in Sweden I can assure you that what you are writing is simply not true. There isn't a concensus on Assange's possible guilt in this case, opinions are divided (while most people don't care about this at all of course).

Can you give an example of any previous cases that has gone to a "secret trial" here in Sweden?

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by illumen on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:03AM (#3186276)
"Clare Montgomery QC, for the Swedish authorities, said evidence from a trial would be heard in private but the arguments would be made in public." That is a secret trial.

The Swedish Prime Minister has declared the man guilty, as well major Swedish news sources have declared his guilt. Those are the best evidence I can give - elected members, and the press. I can only give anecdotal evidence of the Swedish people accusing him of being a misogynist and a rapist - without hearing evidence. There is even an element of racism, as he is an Australia, so obviously he must have done it. My experience based on friends, and friends of friends in Sweden is that many of them think he is guilty.

There have been many instances of secret trials in Sweden. Not including the old Swedish Nazi trials of course, but more recently. See the quote from the prosecuting QC as evidence that the trial will not be public.

The Swedish Parliament make the laws, and the Prime Minister has proclaimed the man guilty. Do you not see the lack of justice there?

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by Steer on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:56AM (#3186425)
It is always hard to grasp the nuances of the political system in other countries.

The prime minister is not the head of the parliament; he is the head of the government. The head of the parliament is called "talman" (the "speaker" if I would hazard a guess at translating it). You are right in that it is the parliament that make the laws.

What the Swedish prime minister has done is defending the Swedish judicial system which, at least to me, seem like a reasonable thing for him to do. You can read more about it here for example

http://www.swedishwire.com/politics/8437-swedish-pm-slams-ju....

I can not find any reputable sources where he is quoted as saying that Assange is guilty.

Regarding the media they have written the same gossip/sensationalistic crap the media of all western countries seem to write in these circumstances, varying wildly between "totally innocent" and "guilty" with a lot of erroneous reporting and misunderstandings in between.

Oh, now I understand what you mean with "secret trials", a better way of putting it is "trials that are closed to the public" which is often done here in Sweden in trials concerning rape or children. That is put in place to protect the victims and although I don't know for sure I can't image that we are the only country in the world to practice it.

All affected parties are of course allowed in to the court room, but you and I ("the public") are not. The verdict is made public as usual.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by illumen on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @09:38AM (#3186569)
This trial happened in a UK court. Not a Swedish one.

If the the evidence is not made public in the Swedish trial, then it is a mockery of justice. How can anyone take the word of the court that it was a fair trial? It is not transparent.

Saying "Asange is an enemy of the people" is not just defending the Swedish legal system.

International law covering human rights applies in Sweden, and those rights will be violated by a secret trial. A country either respects international law and human rights, or it does not. Sweden does not respect this facet of the law, or this human right.

In some countries media can be taken to task for declaring someone a rapist without proof. How many of the media has been taken to task in Sweden for doing so? It is strange how the Swedish legal system has been suspiciously quiet in this regard.

Count the number of Swedish people sticking up for this Human in this thread. I guess flag sales are up in Sweden, because there does not seem to be many Swedish people arguing that the Swedish state could possibly be wrong here.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by piers on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:35AM (#3186357)
And can you link to reliable sources with that stuff?

And there's a different between a rape trial being held in private (see fun2have's post here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3186245) and some secret committee.

Personally, I think there are too many contradictions (like the fact that the stories have changed) for this to be something other than politically motivated. But we shall see.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by gyardley on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:38AM (#3186362)
The Swedish Parliament make the laws, and the head of the Parliament has proclaimed the man guilty. Do you not see the lack of justice there?

Is the head of Parliament also the judge at his trial? Will the Swedish people be voting on the verdict American Idol-style?

If not, then no, I don't see 'the lack of justice there'. The legislative and judicial functions are kept separate for a reason.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by fun2have on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:54AM (#3186245)
The issue is that rape trials are held not in public in Sweden. There is still a record of the trial kept, but the public and press are chucked out. See http://www.thelocal.se/31908/20110208/#
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by peteretep on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @08:13AM (#3186304)
> He is going to go into a secret trial, and possibly just disappear

Ironically, had his defense been able to show any of that was vaguely true, he probably would have been able to resist the extradition request.

Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by mike-cardwell on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @07:47AM (#3186231)
Secret trial? We're talking about Sweden here, not the USA. Besides, this case is far too public for him to be "disappeared". I wouldn't even expect that to happen in Iran for this case.
Re:Julian Assange loses appeal against extradition by eli on Wednesday November 02, 2011 @09:35AM (#3186564)
"Secret trial" is a bit of stretch, but it's the way Assange's lawyer is spinning it: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-02-07/assange-lawyer-tell...

(I'm generally a strong advocate for transparency, but I think you could make a very convincing case for preventing the public and the press from observing every detail of a trial where a rape victim is confronting her accuser.)