News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by _gabe_ on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @11:48PM (#31831827)
This article seems to be saying that science and religion are trying to answer the same question, how did we get here. But I feel like that's misguided.

I've always been under the impression that science is descriptive, it answers how?

Whereas religion is deeper than that and aims to answer why?

We can explain how natural processes work, but, and I believe this is a question Aristotle asked with the immovable mover, we'll never be able to get to a root cause of why everything exists and what started it all.

Either the universe is infinite and time has no beginning, or there is a beginning and potentially an end. If there's a beginning, what was before the beginning? If it's infinite, how did it all start? These are the questions that I thought religion tried to answer. Science can (most likely) never answer why. Science is fundamentally based on repeatable experiments, and that's fine. We can use it to build a model of how the universe works, but as of today, we can't use science to answer the fundamental questions about the reason for the universe.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by badrabbit on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:08AM (#31831921)
Sort of. Academic theologians want to answer why. A religious person already knows, if you have to find data and infer things then it is philosophy not religion. Religion is based on information directed by the creator either directly to the believer or via trusted proxy. For example if you asked me why the universe exists I already know: because God willed it so. Most religious questions are a whether or not something is the will of the creator and how to implement that will. Of course that is monotheistic but with hinduism for example their many gods do things and that is why things are, how to do things to align with them is also a question as is with buddhism and reincarnation based on how well one implements the universe's will but my point is religion is what is there based on the answers to the questions you mentioned not the pursuit to answer that question. If you come up with a religion on your own I suppose you can call it that (although I must question the difference between that and a philosophical principle) but religion as is organized religion already has answers for the believer.

Tangentially, I am a bit baffled by folks that are not believers yet try to make sense of a religion, don't they understand hierarchy of belief? As in you need to know arithmetic before you can do linear alegbra? How can one understand anything religious without being theistic (buddhism aside). Most of the common atheist questions about faith are easily answered with the prerequisite of theism fulfilled for example.

The fundamental difference between science and religion in my opinion is that science says "I will believe things only if I can understand them" while religion says "The things you can understand and that are beyond human capacity to understand are described this way" religion is based on the acceptance that one cannot understand all things in reality, that things beyond our understanding or currect capacity or ability to know are still real and have effect in our reality.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by throw0101a on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @07:36AM (#31834658)
> The fundamental difference between science and religion in my opinion is that science says "I will believe things only if I can understand them" […]

There are certain metaphysical assumptions that you have to make before you can start science:

* That there is an objective reality shared by all rational observers.

* That this objective reality is governed by natural laws;

* That reality can be discovered by means of systematic observation and experimentation.

* That Nature has uniformity of laws and most if not all things in nature must have at least a natural cause.

See:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_(philosophy)#Provid...

Not all world views have those. Take the first one: AFAIK, Buddhism (and Hinduism?) believe that the world is an illusion. Why would do empirical experiments on illusions?

I don't think it was an accident that science took off in Europe. Certainly there were individuals in other parts of the world that were curious about how the cosmos worked, but the overall worldview of their societies wasn't as receptive to such endeavours. There were many scientists in Muslim areas, but Islam generally ended up denying the fourth point above:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occasionalism

TL; DR: Science itself cannot prove science is true.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by azth on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:35PM (#31839976)
As a Muslim, Islam's stance is quite nuanced. God does lay out rules that govern our world (called Sunan in Arabic, plural of Sunnah - path or way or method, etc.), and we accept causality in general. At the same time, we believe that God is the ultimate root cause of everything. If He wills, He can break these laws (e.g. we have the narrative of how Abraham Peace be upon him was thrown into the fire when he denied and destroyed the idols of his tribe, only for the fire not to harm him because God ordered it not to: https://quran.com/21/68-69), and nothing happens without God's knowledge or permission. This is why we have bases such as: https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:2517

As you point out, we have had many Muslim scientists in our history that pushed the boundaries of discovery and knowledge. We're proud of our history and their achievements.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by trhway on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:29AM (#31832025)
>Tangentially, I am a bit baffled by folks that are not believers yet try to make sense of a religion, don't they understand hierarchy of belief?

I'd not give a damn about religion if it weren't shoving itself in my face everywhere. For example I don't care whatever religion some people on some remote islands may be practicing because they aren't forcing their religious dogmas on me (and as long as they don't abuse other people). The Big Religion though that we have around is forcing it's tentacles everywhere trying to strangulate everything, and thus even non believers have to deal with it defending themselves.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by yummies on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:28AM (#31832371)
But if they are abusing other people, you'd care, and intervention would be justified? Is that not imposing your dogma on them?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by daseiner1 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:37AM (#31832415)
I’d assert that an anti-dogma stance is inherently non-dogmatic.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by yummies on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:53AM (#31832503)
I challenge the assertion that the gp is really antidogmatic. The definition of abuse and the appropriate response to it, while generally unquestioned in one society, may not be the same in a remote island society.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by LocalH on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:22AM (#31833340)
Let's jump right in the deep end. Let's say you have a remote culture where genital mutilation is done for purely religious reasons. This is done in an unclean fashion, as it's a tribal culture. Would you argue against intervention?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by trhway on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:39AM (#31832721)
it isn't a dogma, it is my personal dislike of [unconsented] abuse. Depending on situation/domain i may be wrapping it into legal/dogmatic/moral/etc. devices, whatever works, yet in the end at the very core it would be just that my personal dislike of abuse.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by badrabbit on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:08AM (#31834971)
You don't care so much you use every opportunity to tell people how much you don't care?

Clearly I meant atheists that criticize things they don't even believe in.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by Rechtsstaat on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:36AM (#31837415)
What's wrong with criticizing things one doesn't believe in?

Especially if, as the parent noted, that thing one doesn't belief in has—through the actions of people that do believe—negative impacts on one's life?

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by badrabbit on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:59PM (#31840319)
Nothing. But you did a strawman there by changing the subject about what you care or don't care about. If you don't care about relgion then why are you commenting? If you do enough to criticize and take time to comment then don't strawman and address what i said not what you implied.

We are talking truth and belief not impact on ones life.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by trhway on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @05:41PM (#31842220)
>If you don't care about relgion then why are you commenting?

my original comment contains clear answer.

>address what i said

i clearly addressed your stated requirement that one have to meet some your criteria of understanding of religion in order to criticize - as i clearly disagree with such a requirement because my involvement with religion isn't at my will, it is a defense from the religion forcing itself upon me everywhere.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by Fezzik on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:44AM (#31832108)
Maybe it’s pedantic, but in my experience the best summation of a scientific approach to beleif is to say ‘I will withhold belief until sufficient evidence is provided to support the belief.’ Most noticeably, this stance does not exclude the currently unknown from being true or known at some point, it simply holds a person to the honest — and truly humble — mindset of never thinking things are true on insufficient evidence, no matter how badly the conclusion is desired.

You seem to be asserting that religious persons are willing to believe things on insufficient evidence, for example those “things beyond our understanding or currect capacity or ability to know,” and that is somehow a good thing?

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by KMag on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:39AM (#31832433)
I think they're rather asserting that the scientific method is built upon materialist axioms, whereas religions are almost definitionally come with non-materialist axioms as foundational.

It may seem self-evident that purely materialist axioms are more useful as a basis for starting the discussion, but depending on the end goal, starting the discussion more easily may not be advantageous in reaching the end goal. It's possible that restricting ourselves to purely materialist axioms is a case of looking for our keys under the light post because it's dark in the alley where we dropped them.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by keane on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:25AM (#31832358)
This is just Positivism or Empiricism and there are huge problems with it as a method of epistemology. The link is discussing the First Cause argument and you, like others in this thread, are reducing metaphysical arguments to “others believe differently from me only because they want their belief to be true”.

As for the sufficient evidence, regardless of the personal perspective in the parent comment, you should know that a fundamental (Abrahamic) theological claim is that all humans have sufficient evidence of their creator’s existence. That’s mainly where the dispute is: the religious say what we all have universal access to /is/ sufficient; the non-religious claim what we have is insufficient.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by dickersnoodle on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:01AM (#31836089)
If it were only that clear-cut. "What we all have universal access to" is (so far) ineffable, which makes it open to lots of individual interpretations. The result is a great deal of what H. L. Mencken called "a great deal of theological blather and turmoil" because there's no way of telling truth from falsehood.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by keane on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:30AM (#31837352)
Here’s the thing: the religious believe that everyone on Earth, in that they experience reality alone, have sufficient evidence that reality has a creator. That elements of reality may be indescribable or that individuals experience reality in a subjective way doesn’t affect that claim. Resigning truth and falsehood into a single category is a nonstarter. The conclusion here from HL Mencken’s quote is a fallacy called inflation of conflict.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by dickersnoodle on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:23PM (#31838073)
That first sentence sounds too ontological to be useful. St Anselm made the same mistake - because he could imagine a perfect God, that perfection required God to exist. He (and countless other apologists) believed that the universe and its nature were subject to the requirements of their ideas of God, without accounting for the inevitable limitations and imperfections of those ideas.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by keane on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:15PM (#31843567)
The claim was “the world existing rather than not existing is proof of the existence of God”. Ideas about characteristics of God, limited and imperfect as they may be, were not cited.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by rembicilious on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:37AM (#31832417)
Most Protestant christians believe that the christian bible is divinely inspired. Everything else they believe follows from this first unprovable belief. They may not accept an idea if they feel it conflicts with their personal interpretation of the christian bible, no matter how convincing the evidence. On the other hand, some protestants are not so attached to their beliefs, and can adapt them to mesh with reality when presented with convincing evidence.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by KMag on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:41AM (#31832444)
Let's not confuse theologians with most theists. Most theists (and most atheists, for that matter) haven't delved deeply into the foundations of their belief systems.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by dickersnoodle on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:43AM (#31835882)
"Everything else they believe follows from this first unprovable belief."

Not accepting an idea if they think it conflicts with their personal interpretation of the Christian Bible can be a crippling inflexibility, and it (IMO) betrays a kind of inverted hubris when it's not accompanied by a strong admonition to not be too cock-sure about one's personal interpretation, because that will evolve as a person changes through growth and experience.

Not being able to do this is the source of a lot of cognitive dissonance that happens when a religious authority (operating from a prophet motive, no doubt) makes a confident prediction that winds up not coming to pass. A really recent example is all of the evangelicals who predicted that Trump would be re-elected after he provably lost the 2020 Presidential election. Some of the "prophetic community" apologized online (which they then retracted under intense pressure); most of the rest of them took refuge in "Satan stole the election!" which helped facilitate the Jan 6 insurrection.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by badrabbit on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:06AM (#31834956)
Can you determine an evidence is sufficient if you cannot understand it? You can accept what us happening but can you accept that as evidence of someone's explanation? Water boils at 100c , ok, but why? Because energy is being transfered in the form of heat? Or because the elemental force of fire is incompatible with water and the result is violence?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by carpo on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:29AM (#31832027)
There are many things in science that scientists don't understand but still believe exist. The difference is the scientist won't then ascribe that thing to a god just because it's not understood.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by KMag on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:11AM (#31832278)
You're conflating scientists and the scientific method. Down this road lies "No true scientist"/"No true Scotsman".
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by swat535 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:03AM (#31836932)
First, in a very real sense, the modern physical sciences came from religion.

The great founders of science—Kepler, Copernicus, Galileo, Newton, Descartes, etc.—were, without exception, trained in ecclesially sponsored schools and universities. It was under the aegis of the church that they took in their physics, their astronomy, and their mathematics. More specifically, they learned in those institutions two essentially theological truths necessary for the emergence of the experimental sciences—namely, that the universe is not God and that the universe, in every nook and cranny, is marked by intelligibility. If nature were divine—as indeed it is considered to be in many religions, philosophies, and mysticisms—then it could never be an apt subject for observation, analysis, and experimentation. And if nature were simply chaotic, void of form, it would never yield up the harmonies and patterned intelligibilities that scientists readily seek. When these two truths, which are both a function of the doctrine of creation, obtain, the sciences can get underway.

Second, when science and theology are properly understood, they are not in conflict, since they are not competing for primacy on the same playing field, like opposing football teams. Utilizing the scientific method, the physical sciences deal with events, objects, dynamics, and relationships within the empirically verifiable order. Theology, employing an entirely different method, deals with God and the things of God—and God is not an object in the world, not a reality circumscribed within the context of nature. As Thomas Aquinas put it, God is not ens summum (highest being), but rather ipsum esse (the act of being as such)—which is to say, God is not a being among beings, but instead the reason why there is an empirically observable universe at all. In this way, he is like the author of a richly complex novel. Charles Dickens never appears as a character in any of his sprawling narratives, yet he is the reason why any of those characters exist at all. Accordingly, the sciences, as such, can never adjudicate the question of God’s existence nor speak of his activity or attributes. Another type of rationality—not in competition with scientific rationality—is required for the determination of those matters.

And this brings me to my third point: scientism is not science. Sadly rampant today, scientism is the reduction of all knowledge to the scientific form of knowledge. The undeniable success of the physical sciences and the extraordinary usefulness of the technologies to which they have given rise have produced in the minds of many this conviction, but it represents a tragic impoverishment. A chemist might be able to tell us the chemical makeup of the paints that Michelangelo used on the Sistine Ceiling, but he couldn’t, qua scientist, tell us a thing about what makes that work of art so beautiful. A geologist might be able to tell us the stratification of the earth below the city of Chicago, but he could never, again qua scientist, tell us whether that city is being justly or unjustly governed. There isn’t a trace of the scientific method in Romeo and Juliet, but who would be so stupid as to assert that that play tells us nothing true about the nature of love. In a similar way, the great texts of the Bible and the theological tradition are not “scientific,” but they nevertheless speak the profoundest truths about God, creation, sin, redemption, grace, etc. Both the cause and effect of scientism, sadly, is the attenuation of the liberal arts in our institutions of higher education. Rather than appreciating literature, history, philosophy, and religion as conduits of objective truth, many today relegate these to the arena of subjective feeling or subject them to withering ideological criticism.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:52PM (#31838538)
> Another type of rationality … is required for the determination of those matters.

And that is … Philosophy?

> A chemist might…

> A geologist might…

Perhaps neuroscience and data science would be more appropriate.

> … nevertheless speak the profoundest truths about God, creation, sin, redemption, grace, etc.

In the eye of the beholder.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by analog31 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:38AM (#31832075)
I take it from the opposite direction. I trust that every sufficiently mature religion has a self consistent doctrine with answers to every question. If the religion is popular enough, I can just look up the questions and answers. For this reason, I have no reason to even engage in the dialogue.

For this reason, I share your bafflement.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by whiddershins on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:15PM (#31839751)
There is a lot of non revealed theology. For an intro I would suggest The Last Superstition by Edward Feser.

Basically Aristotle lays out the framework without getting anywhere near a religious text.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by taylodl on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:07AM (#31836156)
I would argue the God concept is a poor explanation of why? because you're just kicking the can down the road: either God had a beginning and you have to explain that or God is infinite which puts us right back to the same problem of having a universe with infinite duration. If we're going to say God has existed forever then it's simpler (Occam's Razor) to say the universe has existed forever.

Honestly, I think trying to answer why? is a misguided effort. There doesn't need to be a reason why, and moreover inanimate objects don't have motives. Why are we here? Because we're here!

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by azth on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:59PM (#31840317)
We have proof (e.g. Big Bang) that the universe did not exist forever.

Secondly, asking "who created God" is similar to seeing a piece of bread, asking who baked it, then asking "who baked the baker"? It's a logical inconsistency and absurdity.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by keane on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:45AM (#31837556)
In this context you seem to be expecting a rule of thumb to do quite a lot of lifting.

You seem to imply that the universe is self-evident to all and is therefore “simpler” as something that has always existed. That’s what theists are claiming God is: already self-evident to all.

Conflating God and the universe as interchangeable is addressed by the Contingency Argument: https://youtu.be/FPCzEP0oD7I

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by taylodl on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:22PM (#31838998)
God is ascribed attributes the universe is not: omniscience and omnipotence. To a lesser extent one realizes those attributes of God also means God is conscious, which is not something we typically ascribe to the universe. I would argue since the universe lacks omniscience, omnipotence, consciousness, and by extension, will power it is a far simpler entity than God. So saying the universe has existed forever and saying God has existed forever are therefore two vastly different statements due to the different complexities inherent in the two different entities being compared. The universe is far, far, far simpler a construct than God and by using Occam's Razor I conclude a universe that has existed forever is far more likely than a God that has existed forever.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by yellowapple on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @05:49PM (#31842299)
> God is ascribed attributes the universe is not: omniscience and omnipotence.

Ain't really sure whence you'd get that impression. It's hard to exist without the universe being aware of it and causing it to be, both in the sense of the universe having been in a state enabling your existence and in the sense of your existence having effects on the universe (and thus producing new states enabling other existences).

God and the universe might not be one and the same, but they're intertwined; for the universe and the contents thereof to exist in any meaningful sense beyond some homogenous blob of cold matter, you need something dictating the interactions of matter and energy to produce something meaningful. Call it God, call it physics, call it whatever, but regardless it's obvious that it exists - the universe would be a rather boring place otherwise.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by taylodl on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:13PM (#31844784)
I don't subscribe to metaphysical BS and I don't subscribe to quantum voodoo. The universe can exist just fine without any awareness of its existence.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by taylodl on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:33PM (#31839145)
Though I suppose it is possible for a universe that has existed forever to have yielded a God that has also existed forever! Strange things are possible when we allow for infinite timelines!

That's why it makes more sense that the universe had a definite beginning and asking about time before that beginning is undefined - time simply doesn't exist before the beginning. Roger Penrose has some interesting ideas on what happened before the Big Bang (the universe "forgets" how to "tell" time and so time doesn't exist between different "epochs" of the universe):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7o0gAglNdZw

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by keane on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @07:57PM (#31843435)
There’s issues with the idea of a universe existing forever, namely Kant’s First Antinomy: if the universe existed for an infinite time, then an infinite amount of events would have already taken place.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by taylodl on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:18PM (#31844814)
That's why I think Penrose may be on to something by saying the universe "forgets" how to tell time between different "epochs", where each "epoch" appears to have begun with a time zero corresponding with a big bang. If the universe "forgets" how to tell time between those "epochs" then those epochs are causally separated and you sidestep the infinite amount of events. The interesting bit is what evidence would reveal that to be the case?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by atoav on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:57AM (#31832831)
But there is intersection between science and believe systems. Knowing what we know about space for example, it would be hard to justify the believe a certain subjective perspective onto a star constellation influences a persons fate based on their birth date =astrology.

In this case the more we know about the how of the stars in the sky the less we can believe the uninformed why astrology is trying to present us.

Similar conflicts happen with religion and one cannot ignore that knowing the how deeply influences the why. Most members of our species can't stand the lack of meaning and the will use what they know to create stories that convey it. This is an understandable mechanism and in itself not a problem, but it can become one if the story is told in a way where it starts to clash with the facts.

In the end these stories, even when they call themselves holy texts are written by humans from their own limited perspectives of the time. That doesn't mean, there can not be wisdom in there, but there can also be wisdom in other texts so that doesn't really cut it..

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by pqs on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:58AM (#31835456)
Astrology is not a religion. It seems to me that it is just plain wrong science.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by atoav on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:35PM (#31841543)
It is a believe. For most people religion is also just a believe
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by pqs on Thursday June 23, 2022 @04:56PM (#31855054)
Then almost everything is religion. Even science, which is based on axioms. For example, in science we believe that nature is inteligible. This cannot be proven.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by nestorD on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:17AM (#31832309)
One thing I learned recently is that some religions[1] do not try to explain the world and its origin. It is just that the dominant religions do so we assume it is part of a religion's definition.

[1]: One example would be Gardnerian Wicca.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by givemeethekeys on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:05AM (#31832244)
I propose that religion incorporates the most accepted science of the time it was established.

We haven't had a new popular enough religion that incorporates the current state of accepted science.

It benefits the leadership of any organization to give its members a reason for its existence. The better the reason, the greater chance of growth. Religions aim to provide the complete package - rules for society and the individual and rules for life and what comes after it.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by djokkataja on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:14AM (#31832298)
I think it could be handy if there was a "religion" that looked at the various ways that historical religions are beneficial for their adherents (in practices and beliefs) and tried to distill things down and build some new things up from whatever gets worked out in that way. From a secular perspective, religions contain quite a bit of invented material, so this doesn't seem that unreasonable. And this could potentially be combined with more scientific perspectives, where the whole set of beliefs and practices can be updated as new things are learned, though presumably the most foundational elements wouldn't change as much.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by KMag on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:54AM (#31832512)
What if it turns out that for many actions, the game-theoretically optimal strategy for the individual isn't optimal for the society, and people's gut instincts are reasonably close to game theoretic analysis? In other words, what if it turns out that it's really objectively best for society if everyone is tricked into being good?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by djokkataja on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @07:33AM (#31834629)
Even for something as simple as the prisoner's dilemma, there's quite a bit of variety in both situations and agents, so how do you decide what the "optimal" game theoretic strategy is for actual people in much more complex situations in reality?

I'm not sure that it's tricking people, because society is people. I mean, suppose that people aren't tricked into being good, and then society is worse off. How could everyone in the worse off society be doing better than everyone in the better off society? This doesn't seem like a trick to me so much as adopting a different perspective.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by KMag on Friday June 24, 2022 @08:40PM (#31871307)
I'm talking about cases where society's best outcome isn't a Nash equilibrium, but due to deception about the rewards of different actions, the socially optimal solution appears to be a Nash equilibrium. Some citizens would be better off if they defected, and society worse off, but due to deception, they don't realize they'd be better off.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by pqs on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:59AM (#31835471)
That is strange. There is no contradiction between Catholicism and science. Genesis is not a scientific book. It is not a scientific treatise on cosmology, at all.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:19PM (#31838949)
Church teaching about Adam and Eve and sin?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by pqs on Thursday June 23, 2022 @04:58PM (#31855076)
Sin is not a scientific concept. The story of Adam and Eve is about the origin of sin. It is not a scientific theory. The Catholic Church does not deny the truth of scientific theories of evolution.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:16PM (#31866993)
How does the story about the origin of sin work without a primordial Adam and Eve?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by bmitc on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:03AM (#31831901)
> I've always been under the impression that science is descriptive, it answers how?

This may be philosophical, but has science ever actually, and by that I mean explicitly, answered how? Is how even possible to answer?

I think probably not, given our current understandings, or probably not just period. Science is about building models of the reality we experience. The models are not reality themselves, so they don’t answer how. They only answer how relative to our own knowledge and experience. Also, it isn’t clear if our experience of reality is objective. I have a feeling that there is such a thing as relative objectivity among the different participants of the universe.

> Whereas religion is deeper than that and aims to answer why?

Religion is more of an organizational collective of power and control, but religion proper, let’s call it, and spiritually are more about consolation, in my view. This is related to why, but I think it also helps to frame religion and spirituality as “what now”? We’re here, there’s this life, this Earth, this Universe, so what are we supposed to do? I think why creeps in there as well.

I’m reminded of A Serious Man and the repetitious “what’s going on?”.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by virtualwhys on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:52AM (#31832167)
> If it's infinite, how did it all start?

Ha, good one! Certainly would be quite wonderful if, despite death, there is neither a beginning nor end to it.

I can't imagine life being finite, is that even possible given what we're in?

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by analog31 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:38AM (#31835276)
I think it's simpler. Religion and science answer different questions, because if they ever disagree on an answer, it instantly ceases to be a religious question. Never the other way around. This asymmetry is like the arrow of increasing entropy, always pointing towards science.

Another asymmetry is that it's possible to hold scientific and religious beliefs at the same time (thanks to the above), but never two different religions at the same time. I know lots of Catholic scientists, but no Catholic Buddhists.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by shakna on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:08AM (#31836166)
> Another asymmetry is that it's possible to hold scientific and religious beliefs at the same time (thanks to the above), but never two different religions at the same time.

That's not true at all. Religious syncretism is a very old concept, and involves the blending of religions.

There are Catholic Buddhists, for example, and there have been those professing to follow that since around the 1600s. You'll also find many blends of traditional Incan beliefs and Catholicism, despite the surface-level incompatibilities, in South America.

One specific example might be Caodaism, which blends elements of Catholicism, Buddhism, and Taoism. Caodaism has about 2.5Mil followers in Vietnam. One of the core tenants of the religion is that we are now living in a period of time called the Third Amnesty, the end of which will be marked by the syncretism of _all_ religions into one.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by yellowapple on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @05:54PM (#31842358)
Hell, there's even the hypothesis that Christianity itself is a blend of Buddhism and Judaism.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:10PM (#31838813)
> … the blending of religions.

And when they conflict?

We can blend oil and vinegar but they'll settle out into oil and vinegar.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by shakna on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:16PM (#31838902)
Incan beliefs are polytheistic, and Catholicism is monotheistic. There are still a myriad of syncretic forms of the two.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:25PM (#31839039)
Doesn't seem like you responded to the question?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by shakna on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:34PM (#31839149)
Polytheism and monotheism are completely incompatible. However, syncretic religions of incompatible elements actually exist. Thus, the assumption that they can't, is wrong.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:04PM (#31840403)
That doesn't seem like holding incompatible religious beliefs at the same time ("… possible to hold scientific and religious beliefs at the same time…"). That seems like picking one religious belief over another, on an ad hoc basis.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by shakna on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:11PM (#31840483)
> "never two different religions at the same time."
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:56PM (#31841760)
And "syncretic religions of incompatible elements" are neither of the original "two different religions" but a new third religion.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by analog31 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @07:34PM (#31843289)
Ultimately it's 8 billion religions. It all breaks down when you look at what people believe at an individual level. It's possible that no two people believe the same thing, even if they claim to be adherents to the same sect. And if an individual's beliefs are at odds with their church, who am I to decide who's right, if I don't even share the beliefs of either?

For instance, the majority of American Catholics believe it's OK to use birth control. So, who represents "Catholicism," the people or the church fathers? It's just my nature to give benefit of the doubt to the people.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by shakna on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @05:33PM (#31842144)
So you're splitting the concept between "religious syncretism" and "double belonging", and claiming that the latter [0] is impossible?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_religious_belonging

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @07:39PM (#31843328)
Please don't put your words in my mouth.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by pqs on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:56AM (#31835439)
There are Catholic Zen Masters [1], so, somehow, it is possible to be Catholic and Buddhist. As a Catholic who dabbled in Zen when I was lost, I don't really understand how this can be combined, but this exists. My current view is that in Catholicism you'll find everything that Zen has to offer (silence, meditation, living in the present, honor the little details of life, etc.) and a lot more [2].

From a Catholic point of view, there is no contradiction, whatsoever, between science and religion. It is perfectly compatible and there is no contradiction with scripture. The problems are with scientism.

[1]: https://www.ncronline.org/news/i-wanted-faith-was-deeper-jes...

[2]: See, for example, Saint Thérèse of Lisieux.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by andrewmcwatters on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:25AM (#31836384)
Religion doesn’t answer why we are here. Non-religious people think that’s what religion does.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by azth on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:01PM (#31840357)
Depends on which religion. Islam does:

* https://quran.com/51/56

* https://quran.com/67/2

And more.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by andrewmcwatters on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:44PM (#31841641)
The Book of Isaiah says the same thing. That's not the point of either religion, and practitioners know this.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by azth on Sunday June 26, 2022 @12:27PM (#31885338)
Your accusing Muslims of knowing that the point of religion is something different from what the Quran says? That's quite brazen.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by t0bia_s on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:51PM (#31840996)
"I've always been under the impression that science is descriptive, it answers how?"

And yet, that "how" is relative to actual knowledge that is shaping with time or even point of view.

Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by xupybd on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @05:29AM (#31833699)
I don't know if religion can totally answer the why question either. You end up with the unanswerable why is God?
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by igouy on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:24PM (#31839026)
… I am that I am…
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by pqs on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:57AM (#31835447)
Science deals with quantities in the material world, religion deals with meaning.
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by renox on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:03AM (#31833223)
Religion doesn't have a good answer for that too, except 'burn the heretics who ask who created God'
Re:For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point by gxt on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:13AM (#31835016)
Religion's only purpose is to fabricate legitimacy for those who want the power to dictate what people should do.

Any other meaning that might be perceived is only there to deceive you.

Kingdoms fabricate legitimacy by birthright. Democracies by elections (not the people LOL). Etc.