News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Does Apple's Magic Trackpad improve your productivity?

I've been wondering if Magic Trackpad adds any value to my workflow. I use my MBP in two ways:

(0) clamshell mode when connected to an external display;

(1) as a laptop.

If (0) is the case, I use mouse and keyboard but sometimes I miss the fact that I can just scroll quickly on the MBP's Trackpad. However, pressing on the Trackpad for long hours isn't fun either as my fingers get tired.

( 3 comments | 3 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Does Apple's Magic Trackpad improve your producti... by bradknowles on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:24PM (#31795852)
Many years ago (in the mid to late 90s), I developed carpal tunnel syndrome. The problem turned out to be the mouse. I tried lots of alternative solutions, and some of them helped, but nothing I tried really solved the problem.

When I started using laptops more frequently (because by then I was doing a lot of consulting, and therefore using laptops), my CTS went away. I figured out it was because of the trackpad.

When I went back to more static computer use with an external monitor, I also made sure to have an external trackpad, and my CTS still has not returned.

These days, I do have a bit of pain issues with my right thumb, and the wrist braces for De Quervain's tenosynovitis are the main thing I have found that will help. But to be honest, at my age, it could just as easily be arthritis. I will check this out with my orthopedist to be sure, but for now the wrist braces work when I have pain.

So, yes -- the Magic Trackpad in particular is a key part of what allows me to continue to work and be a contributing member of society.

Re:Ask HN: Does Apple's Magic Trackpad improve your producti... by nniroclax on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:17PM (#31791230)
When I'm in clamshell mode, I love having an external trackpad. I used to have a trackball mouse which was decent enough - it's just that it was a pain when working in Adobe products & Figma and wanted gestures. I see no need to go back to a regular mouse or use anything else.

Personally, I haven't noticed any fatigue. I also do have tap to click mode on which I feel helps.

Re:Ask HN: Does Apple's Magic Trackpad improve your producti... by sircastor on Saturday June 18, 2022 @07:12PM (#31794661)
I was at an On-site meeting last week with my team and one of my fellow members was complaining about the trackpad on his Dell. I told him he could get a Mac and get the nicest trackpad money can buy.

I doubt it makes me more productive. For me, the best way to describe it is that I never think about it when I’m using a trackpad on a Mac.