News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by dbrgn on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:21AM (#31777736)
The announcement says it wants to "protect consumers", but it changes user tracking from opt-in to opt-out... How about ensuring that companies stop tracking people unnecessarily?

I see so many websites – even club websites or private blogs – that have a cookie consent banner, but which wouldn't actually need one if they'd just turn off Google Analytics. I just don't get it.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by kmeisthax on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:57AM (#31778231)
The goal of the announcement is purely to make the EU look stuffy and bureaucratic. "Look, we got rid of those annoying cookie pop-ups THEY forced on US!"

Tories need this because of two reasons:

1. Brexit is hurting the UK economy

2. They need to distract from the Partygate scandals[0]

As for Google Analytics... I've talked with multiple clients who have wanted to improve site performance on their stores. The first thing I usually point out is the multiple overlapping analytics packages downloading multi-megabyte JavaScript files. Those are, of course, absolutely untouchable for whatever reason, and we just have to work around the most obvious performance flaws in their site.

The reasons why someone might tank their site performance with a bunch of conflicting ad trackers is not just because "data is valuable". We're conditioned to think of ad tracking as solely interest targeting[1] and remarketing[2], but a huge part of it is also just attribution. Advertising is paid for on a per-click or per-conversion basis, and nobody trusts nobody in this industry, so everything needs to be tracked or the people buying ads get gamed out of their money by the people they buy ads from.[3] So even if you just want to buy ads, you often also need to have tracking on your website purely so that the ad network can either protect you from click fraud, or if you're paying per conversion, actually track how much you owe them.

[0] For those who are not in the UK, like me: The scandal is the fact that the PM and his staff were running a bunch of illegal parties while the whole country was on COVID lockdowns.

[1] When ad networks track your interests to serve more relevant ads. As the ad buyer you can purchase ads based on these specific interest categories; i.e. "I want this ad to be served to 40-year-old men with an interest in cars"

[2] When ad networks track your history to serve ads based on what sites you've visited recently. This is actually a different thing from interest-related ads; it's more like "I want this ad to be served to anyone who has just gone car shopping".

[3] This is also why on-domain advertising will never be a thing outside of the big social media networks.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by phh on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:26AM (#31778698)
> The reasons why someone might tank their site performance with a bunch of conflicting ad trackers is not just because "data is valuable". We're conditioned to think of ad tracking as solely interest targeting[1] and remarketing[2], but a huge part of it is also just attribution. Advertising is paid for on a per-click or per-conversion basis, and nobody trusts nobody in this industry, so everything needs to be tracked or the people buying ads get gamed out of their money by the people they buy ads from.[3] So even if you just want to buy ads, you often also need to have tracking on your website purely so that the ad network can either protect you from click fraud, or if you're paying per conversion, actually track how much you owe them.

Thanks. I think this is severely understated. Ad people managed to force the debate to "customized ads" vs "privacy", saying that websites could make money exclusively with customized ads. We've seen here on HN a lot of examples of people realizing that was bullshit (I would guess there are some cases where customized ads can be beneficial, but overall they seem little).

Apple showed how to make attribution privacy-friendly (I have no idea whether there implementation works and scale), yet debates still manage to ignore that totally.

That being said, solving attribution doesn't actually... solve attribution problem. The reason being for the case where I search Nokia D3500 on Amazon, then I go on random website, which will show me ads for Nokia D3500 on Amazon, and I click on this ad to buy what I already planned to buy. In that case, the random website will get money, with current unprivate ads, while they won't with the private one. I didn't change my consumption based on that ad, so the ad has literally 0 value, "private-friendly ad" properly reflects that, however the migration from not private to private ad will reduce the revenue for websites (even though this didn't have any impact on my purchasing behavior).

Edit: It does solve attribution for "proper meaningful" ads: If I'm reading camera reviews on some websites, and they have affiliated links for those reviews, then they'll rightfully get money for it, whcih is good!

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by kmeisthax on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:56PM (#31781876)
The role that remarketing played in poisoning the well can't be forgotten either. Targeted ads were sneaky (and, arguably people preferred them to untargeted), while remarketing ads made you feel seen. It was almost waving in the user's face how much data you have on them. "You like to watch Netflix's Castlevania!"
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by that_guy_iain on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:02AM (#31778318)
>I see so many websites – even club websites or private blogs – that have a cookie consent banner, but which wouldn't actually need one if they'd just turn off Google Analytics. I just don't get it.

Actually, most are probably not even correctly following the law since the cookies will probably be set before the popup is accepted. For most, people just assume they need a cookie banner. I'm pretty sure I've seen cookie banners on sites that had no cookies.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by qclibre22 on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:13AM (#31778482)
Google will down rank if you don't use their analytics cookies.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by eropple on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:21AM (#31778634)
Is this true? I'd believe it (edit: though, as noted elsewhere in the thread, it seems like it'd carry some business risk), but I haven't seen it.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by that_guy_iain on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:36AM (#31778835)
If it is true it's an anti-trust lawsuit waiting to happen. I highly doubt it is true. Keeping that secret in the bag would be hard in my opinion. We're constantly getting leaks from Google.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by thayne on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:30AM (#31779683)
A lot of stuff google does would be an anti-trust lawsuit waiting to happen. If you know, anti-trust was actually enforced.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by that_guy_iain on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:57PM (#31781041)
The EU would 100% enforce that. The EU hits them constantly for their bs.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by thayne on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:11PM (#31786443)
What we really need is for these big companies to be split up. I'm not sure if the EU has jurisdiction to do that.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by that_guy_iain on Saturday June 18, 2022 @09:43AM (#31789745)
> What we really need is for these big companies to be split up. I'm not sure if the EU has jurisdiction to do that.

There have been non-binding votes to split it up. And they can tell them to split up or be banned from operating within the EU.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jokethrowaway on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:14PM (#31782953)
Sure, and fined them pennies
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by that_guy_iain on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:28PM (#31783851)
Have you seen the EU fines? Latest one is 1.6 billion againist Google.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by fmajid on Monday June 20, 2022 @09:39AM (#31810235)
The Irish DPC is doing a bang-up job this far sheltering companies like Facebook headquartered in Éire from GDPR.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by mhoad on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:19AM (#31779500)
This is some completely made up bullshit for the record.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by lakomen on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:27PM (#31782340)
I have a domain that was ranked #1 for a decade, it always had GA. I removed GA replaced it by Piwik, it dropped in rank. Nowadays I'm not eben on the 1st page anymore, despite having the most authentic design and simple use.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by mhoad on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:53PM (#31784231)
That is not how any of this works.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jasonkester on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:57AM (#31778234)
The popups are annoying specifically because the rules lumped Google Analytics in with all the bad tracking that evil companies do.

I want to know how many people visited my website. So does every website. It's something that websites need to know. We use Analytics to handle that for us, and because of this silly EU rule we're all technically breaking the law by not bothering every single visitor with annoying popups.

Now there are in fact bad companies collecting data on individual people, correlating it between sites on the backend, and using it for nefarious purposes. Those are presumably the reason these stupid laws were passed in the first place, and it would be nice if they actually did need to show a button for you to click.

But since the law says that everybody needs to show that button or lose the ability to know how many people saw their site, you never know whether you're getting the button for an evil site or just one of the millions of other sites you visit every day.

I don't blame the evil companies even a little bit for this mess. It's the people who passed these terribly thought out laws. They'll keep passing more of them until we stop letting them.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Schroedingersat on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:34PM (#31780710)
> The popups are annoying specifically because the rules lumped Google Analytics in with all the bad tracking that evil companies do.

That's because it is the most evil one of all.

Just because you're only using it for one piece of info doesn't mean you aren't violating your users' privacy by handing over a complete record of every site they visit to a company that uses it exclusively for evil.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by weberer on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:03AM (#31778326)
>I want to know how many people visited my website. So does every website

You can do that easily without third-party tracking cookies.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by blooalien on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:39PM (#31781614)
Indeed. You get that and so much more useful information for free in your web-server logfiles. Any half-decent web server log analyzer tool will classify and graph all the useful data in those log files and present it to you in a nice shiny web page or report document of some sort. No cookies required.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by azmodeus on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:24PM (#31791302)
You sound knowledge about using logfiles for analytics.Could you recommenda good stack to do this?

I am assuming you need to do client side tracking for static pages though or you need to self host your static page.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jefftk on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:21AM (#31778631)
Google Analytics doesn't use any third-party cookies; it uses first-party cookies only. [EDIT: this is too broad; see comments below] While the JS is loaded from a third-party origin, its notion of identity is entirely per-site.

(Disclosure: I used to work on ads at Google)

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by btdmaster on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:41AM (#31779866)
It seems certain features are restricted to third-party cookies: https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection.... In practice though, moving from third-party to first-party is simply a way to reduce the probability that the spyware gets blocked by the user agent.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jefftk on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:49AM (#31779976)
> certain features are restricted to third-party cookies

You're talking about the https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection... section, right? That's only for sites that are already using third-party cookies for advertising, has to be specifically enabled, and doesn't seem very applicable to our "know how many people visited my website" discussion? But my comment above was too broad, and I've edited it to point here.

> moving from third-party to first-party

GA, back to the Urchin days, has always been built around first-party cookies though.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by btdmaster on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:59AM (#31780159)
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jefftk on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:31PM (#31780662)
I think so? It's about linking advertising activity (keyed by third party advertising cookies) with analytics activity (keyed by first party analytics cookies)
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by vips7L on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:04AM (#31778340)
...Can you not track how many people visit your site on the back end?
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jameshart on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:22AM (#31778645)
A lot of modern cloud architecture is concerned with the business of making sure web requests don’t reach your servers if they don’t have to. Edge caching, content distribution networks, browser cache handling.

If you do it right, a high proportion of your site visits leave no trace in your logs that they were ever there.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by chrismorgan on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:25AM (#31778681)
No reason why your edge CDN can’t log requests.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Thiez on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:30AM (#31778770)
Even if the CDN can't (for whatever reason) one could easily include a tracking pixel on every page that is marked as `Cache-Control: no-cache`, or insert a few lines of JS to do the same.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jameshart on Friday June 17, 2022 @06:10PM (#31785057)
Presumably at some sort of additional cost, though. So then we’re into the business of weighing up whether to spend money on obtaining raw logs or purchasing the CDN’s own traffic analytics add on… or just going with a third party. This stuff isn’t just built in.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jasonkester on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:13AM (#31778492)
Sure. Everybody can.

But Google Analytics is a 30 second setup, whereas setting up a log analyzer (or even getting logging going in the first place) is a much bigger hassle. Some of my stuff is on wacky Cloud Function hosting that I wouldn't have the first idea of how to go about logging.

Thus, nearly 100% of us just use Analytics. If they had an "evil" checkbox that I could uncheck to stop it doing whatever you're worried it will do, then I'd happily do so.

Frankly, I'm not sure what GA could do that would bother anybody. All it does is tell me how many people saw what page and how long they stayed there. It certainly can't tell me anything about you personally.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by ectopod on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:22AM (#31778648)
The problem isn't that you are invading your users' privacy. The problem is that you are allowing Google to.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Hizonner on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:11PM (#31780310)
On the other hand, if you do it yourself you'll see all the people who block all contact between their browsers and anything they can identify as an "analytics" site.

I don't have time to screw around with figuring out what uses third-party cookies, what uses browser fingerprinting, what correlates information across sites, and/or what tracks what how in general, nor to check all the time to see if any of that has changed. I'm just gonna block all of it, because it's not worth the investment of my time to make such distinctions. The most I could get out of it would be slower page loads.

Actually, I'm not even bothering to make THAT decision. My ad blocker blocks GA by default, and I'm not going to worry my pretty little head about unblocking anything unless something breaks.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by tinus_hn on Saturday June 18, 2022 @04:45AM (#31788237)
> Frankly, I'm not sure what GA could do that would bother anybody.

It puts tracking cookies on your visitors which means you need a cookie banner.

And of course it invades the privacy of your users and slows down your site.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Schroedingersat on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:36PM (#31780740)
That's a you problem. It doesn't entitle you to help google stalk your users.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by philsawa on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:26PM (#31786802)
Can't agree with most of the page but the cookie "nonster" section of this site explains one to three of such workaround:s https://www.abarim-publications.com/contact/Copyright_Names.... TL:DR is cloudflare beacon [not to be confused with sizzling bacon&] as well as a hidden method of session storage.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by user_7832 on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:00AM (#31778282)
> I don't blame the evil companies even a little bit for this mess. It's the people who passed these terribly thought out laws. They'll keep passing more of them until we stop letting them.

Apart from being a... very interesting take, how do propose to do this?

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by avianlyric on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:11AM (#31778459)
> But since the law says that everybody needs to show that button or lose the ability to know how many people saw their site, you never know whether you're getting the button for an evil site or just one of the millions of other sites you visit every day.

Not sure where you got this from. But GDPR absolutely does not require this.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jasonkester on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:16AM (#31778543)
I got it from the post that I replied to:

I see so many websites – even club websites or private blogs – that have a cookie consent banner, but which wouldn't actually need one if they'd just turn off Google Analytics. I just don't get it.

He asked why we don't turn off GA. I explained.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by mkmk3 on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:11AM (#31778460)
For sure an interesting take. Is there really no way to bypass gdpr restrictions if the only functionality you need is unique visitors? It's been a while since I read the gdpr doc, so at what point does your activity become relevant to its restrictions?
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by tensor on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:54AM (#31779107)
I looked into this, and yes, there are some services that can do analytics without the cookie. E.g https://usefathom.com. However, the vast majority use cookies and the ones that don't often have a much higher cost.

Ultimately, some of these alternatives that avoid the cookie law are simply finding tech work arounds. I have no doubt in my mind that the gov would find a way to require popups for those services if they were more prevalent.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by tinus_hn on Saturday June 18, 2022 @04:49AM (#31788257)
You could just set a cookie that is a binary ‘I have already seen you’ value, gdpr only cares if you create identifiers.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jefftk on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:23AM (#31778658)
To track unique visitors you need cookies or some other form of client-side storage. In Europe that means, per ePrivacy which predates the GDPR, you need cookie consent.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by hericium on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:36AM (#31777928)
> wouldn't actually need one if they'd just turn off Google Analytics.

Isn't one of the incentives for Analytics, that by knowing your audience Google will be able to suggest your site to their search engine users?

I've heard more than once something in the lines of "we can't disable analytics as we'd lose traffic".

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by weird-eye-issue on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:45AM (#31778045)
What are you talking about?

I've been in SEO for a while and there are a lot of myths but I've never heard anything quite this wrong before.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Ensorceled on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:49AM (#31778112)
It's a pretty persistent "myth" ... do you have any support that it's a myth other than "I've been in SEO for a while"?
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by weird-eye-issue on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:00AM (#31779184)
Google doesn't need GA data. They know how many times people see sites in search results, how many people click them, and if people go back to make the same search again.

Besides, GA data is easily faked. I can give a site a low bounce rate or make it look like people spend a long time on a page. Google can't trust their own Analytics data because of this since it is client provided.

Sounds like a myth non-SEO people believe because, again, I've never even heard this before. And SEOs believe a lot of myths but this one is just too stupid

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by mikestew on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:06AM (#31778374)
Do you have any support that it’s not a myth, other than…”a lot of people are saying…”? I mean, burden’s on the one making the claim, not the other way around.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Ensorceled on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:00AM (#31779200)
There are literally "a lot of people saying" it isn't a myth, I've heard them, and one guy saying it is a myth and is an expert ... so, seems like that expert could straighten the issue out for us?

I mean, the burden is on both sides here but one has "been in SEO for a while".

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by nicbou on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:37PM (#31780758)
What's asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Also the first claim is not falsifiable.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Ensorceled on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:21PM (#31783037)
Ummm, sure, I'm not disputing that. Just saying the expert could do us a favour ...
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by fooey on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:43PM (#31782550)
Yeah, it's obviously an urban legend

People will do an update on their site, which includes removing GA, then blame GA exclusively for tanking their rankings. All of which is probably coincidental to an algorithm change that was going to de-rank them anyways

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by hericium on Saturday June 18, 2022 @03:10AM (#31787821)
> Yeah, it's obviously an urban legend

Urban legend clearly benefiting Google.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by that_guy_iain on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:01AM (#31778293)
For most people, analytics is just about know how much traffic you're getting and where it's coming from and what they're doing on your site. For example, if 30% of the visitors from reddit.com convert to paying customers but 60% of users from indiehackers.com convert to paying customers you'll know to spend time, money, etc on indiehackers.com.

Also, my understanding is Google pretends like they don't really look at your traffic data and use that for search.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by slenk on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:43PM (#31780842)
Maybe they'd lose the ability to correlate traffic to your ad revenue, but having google analytics or not does not determine if you get traffic
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by CommanderData on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:45PM (#31780875)
The current UK govnement isn't interested in people's rights despite lots of catch phrases from Nadine Dorris which might make it seem so.

Each passing day the govnement becomes more and more deceptive

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Reason077 on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:52AM (#31778166)
> "The announcement says it wants to "protect consumers", but it changes user tracking from opt-in to opt-out... "

The cookie-blocking features in modern browsers (except Chrome, probably, haha) effectively make tracking opt-in anyway, don't they? The cookie pop-ups are pretty redundant today.

Not to suggest that this makes all the down sides of Brexit worthwhile, but it does make me happy that this can now be addressed. Cookie popups seriously harm the usability of the web and have been one of the most highly visible and ill-conceived pieces of EU legislation.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by phh on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:02AM (#31778307)
I guess anti-GDPR won. So-called "Cookie popups" are about so much more than cookies. Looks like anti-GPDR marketing managed to make even technically-literate people unaware of their rights.

If you're using a menstruating-cycle app, GPDR will protect you against the app owner publicizing your name that you're pregnant, and thus protect you against anti-abortion mobs, if you wish to abort. A cookie banner wouldn't do that. Because GPDR is NOT about the cookies.

If we were to speak exclusively about tracking (which is, again, a very very small part of GPDR), even simply dismissing as a browser-side "feature" is yet another brainwashing win from anti-GPDR marketing. The number of ways to track people in a browser is infinite. From canvas rendering, to DRM, from cache leakage to window size. Hell, even the GPDR banners explicitly say so! Most GPDR banners now contains an option to allow site owner to fingerprint your browser to track you.

Considering the way we went with browsers (was it right adding so many features? I don't know. But the effects are there), we CAN NOT put this on browsers, it is technically impossible. If Google wants to prove the world that it is possible, fine, I'll grab popcorn. But at the moment they are not even trying.

So no, history has proven again and again that those privacy issues can not be handled technically. Only through regulation can privacy be preserved.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by chrismorgan on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:23AM (#31778666)
I think the really crazy thing about the cookie banner stuff is that it’s actually nothing to do with GDPR: it’s almost entirely about the ePrivacy Directive of 2002. Yes, 2002. (At that time it was opt-out, but you still had to disclose clearly; in 2009, it was revised to opt-in, and there was again very minor fuss but not much compliance.) It’s just that most people didn’t do much about it until GDPR came along, and then people conflated the two.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Reason077 on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:39AM (#31778894)
> "If you're using a menstruating-cycle app, GPDR will protect you against the app owner publicizing your name that you're pregnant, and thus protect you against anti-abortion mobs, if you wish to abort. A cookie banner wouldn't do that. Because GPDR is NOT about the cookies."

Absolutely. I'm not arguing against GDPR, which includes many important rights and protections that don't have much to do with cookies. I'm arguing against intrusive and pointless cookie pop-ups.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jefftk on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:19AM (#31778596)
> The cookie-blocking features in modern browsers (except Chrome, probably, haha) effectively make tracking opt-in anyway, don't they?

Browsers are generally only working on stopping cross-site tracking, but cookie banners are needed even for first-party cookies (ex: local telemetry, shopping carts).

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by TheCoelacanth on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:40AM (#31779844)
You don't need a cookie banner for a shopping cart.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by jefftk on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:53AM (#31780036)
You do for the way shopping carts are usually implemented. Say you put something in your cart, close the browser, and reopen it the next day. On basically all sites, the item is still in your cart, but that requires cookie consent because it isn't "strictly necessary in order to provide an information society service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user".

See this earlier discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29530890

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by lesuorac on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:25PM (#31780558)
I agree with the interpretation that you can just leave it in the cart forever.

Mechanically if you add something into a physical shopping cart it will remain there forever until you take it out. But legally the pdf has the claim "a merchant could set the cookie either to persist past the end of the browser session or for a couple of hours" [1] and to me that means indefinitely or a few hours.

[1]: https://ec.europa.eu/justice/article-29/documentation/opinio...

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by Reason077 on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:46AM (#31778980)
Yes, but usually cross-site tracking is the creepy stuff that people are concerned about. I don't have much of a problem with first-party cookies, personally, but some browsers (Firefox) are now offering "Enhanced cookie clearing", which can automatically clear first-party cookies at the end of each session, configurable per site.

And every browser offers a private browsing mode which is more or less the same effect.

Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by lakomen on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:24PM (#31782276)
A few days ago I visited a German provincial government website that had a cookie banner for the cookie banner provider. It's really funny if it wasn't so stupid.
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by tensor on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:48AM (#31779015)
You just don't get that website owners want basic metrics to help them understand the health and performance of their website?
Re:The bait-and-switch hidden in today’s cookie announcement by zaphirplane on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:22AM (#31787636)
I found this site they as you to fill a form with your information … when you click don’t sell my data

https://smallstep.com/blog/