If you're using a menstruating-cycle app, GPDR will protect you against the app owner publicizing your name that you're pregnant, and thus protect you against anti-abortion mobs, if you wish to abort. A cookie banner wouldn't do that. Because GPDR is NOT about the cookies.
If we were to speak exclusively about tracking (which is, again, a very very small part of GPDR), even simply dismissing as a browser-side "feature" is yet another brainwashing win from anti-GPDR marketing. The number of ways to track people in a browser is infinite. From canvas rendering, to DRM, from cache leakage to window size. Hell, even the GPDR banners explicitly say so! Most GPDR banners now contains an option to allow site owner to fingerprint your browser to track you.
Considering the way we went with browsers (was it right adding so many features? I don't know. But the effects are there), we CAN NOT put this on browsers, it is technically impossible. If Google wants to prove the world that it is possible, fine, I'll grab popcorn. But at the moment they are not even trying.
So no, history has proven again and again that those privacy issues can not be handled technically. Only through regulation can privacy be preserved.
Absolutely. I'm not arguing against GDPR, which includes many important rights and protections that don't have much to do with cookies. I'm arguing against intrusive and pointless cookie pop-ups.
Browsers are generally only working on stopping cross-site tracking, but cookie banners are needed even for first-party cookies (ex: local telemetry, shopping carts).
See this earlier discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29530890
Mechanically if you add something into a physical shopping cart it will remain there forever until you take it out. But legally the pdf has the claim "a merchant could set the cookie either to persist past the end of the browser session or for a couple of hours" [1] and to me that means indefinitely or a few hours.
[1]: https://ec.europa.eu/justice/article-29/documentation/opinio...
And every browser offers a private browsing mode which is more or less the same effect.
The cookie-blocking features in modern browsers (except Chrome, probably, haha) effectively make tracking opt-in anyway, don't they? The cookie pop-ups are pretty redundant today.
Not to suggest that this makes all the down sides of Brexit worthwhile, but it does make me happy that this can now be addressed. Cookie popups seriously harm the usability of the web and have been one of the most highly visible and ill-conceived pieces of EU legislation.