News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by AdmiralAsshat on Monday June 13, 2022 @09:53AM (#31725606)
The two work in tandem, though. I use Firefox on mobile because I use Firefox on desktop. That and it being the only Android browser that runs uBlock Origin, of course.

I currently use Thunderbird on desktop, but use a combination of Gmail and Outlook on Android. If Thunderbird picks up K-9 mail and turns it into a first-class mobile client, I'll probably use Thunderbird instead of the Outlook app. People like consistency.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by Zak on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:17AM (#31726785)
> That and it being the only Android browser that runs uBlock Origin, of course.

There's also Kiwi. It runs pretty much any extension available for Desktop Chromium.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by Macha on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:28PM (#31729449)
Though once manifest v3 is the only option, it's hard to say that'll really be as effective as uBlock Origin on Firefox: https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-b...
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by Zak on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:33PM (#31729551)
That's an issue. I'm really puzzled my Mozilla's sudden aversion to an open repository of extensions on Android.
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by woojoo666 on Monday June 13, 2022 @06:11PM (#31732431)
I think a lot of Firefox extensions are still broken on mobile. For example, I can't find a single tab manager / session manager that works on mobile
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by Zak on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:02PM (#31733210)
Users can only easily install extensions from the "recommended" collection. Installing anything else requires running a development build and jumping through hoops. The Firefox team has been very clear that simply developing a reasonable working extension that some people might want does not create an expectation it will ever be recommended.

So why would anybody bother writing an extension for Firefox mobile?

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by woojoo666 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:31AM (#31734766)
There are already plenty of tab managers that work on desktop, and they shouldn't require a rewrite to work on mobile. I think Mozilla just hasn't finished making Firefox mobile support all the web extension APIs yet, so that's why they haven't opened the mobile app up for installing arbitrary extensions
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by Macha on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:37PM (#31729620)
Yeah, me too. My best guess is that it's PM's who are overprotective of their idea of how it should work and feel they don't have to open the box as wide as on desktop.

But 20 > 0, all the same.

[dead]
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by nvrspyx on Monday June 13, 2022 @09:58AM (#31725655)
Why be so condescending?

Also, they could use Firefox on mobile to keep their history and bookmarks in sync across devices in addition to some extensions they find useful, like uBlock Origin as they mentioned. Just because the number of extensions is less than desktop doesn't mean the extensions that do exist aren't game changers for them.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by jeltz on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:02AM (#31725716)
Yes, I enjoy them a lot. They, especially uBlock, are the reason I switched to Firefox Mobile from Chrome. No more annoying ads for me.
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by maleldil on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:13AM (#31725869)
Even if Firefox for Android had only one extension (uBlock Origin), I'd still use it. Using an ad blocker is the single best thing you can do to improve your user experience on the web.
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by AdmiralAsshat on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:12AM (#31725852)
Works great! That's three more than Chrome supports.

Plus, I'm at two now. Your post reminded me to check how many add-ons I actually have installed, and I realized that HTTPS Everywhere is no longer needed because Firefox itself rolled out an HTTPS-Only setting.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:16AM (#31725920)
uBlock by itself is enough to justify using Firefox on Android. Still sucks that they made it so limited, sure, but Mozilla's really good at nailing "somehow the least awful awful browser".
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by pritambaral on Monday June 13, 2022 @09:59AM (#31725669)
Hey, 3 > 0.

How many do you enjoy?

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by ekianjo on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:16AM (#31725916)
You missed the good old days of firefox on android supporting hundreds of extensions.

progress, I guess?

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by input_sh on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:27AM (#31726095)
Ah yeah, back when page load lasted 3x as long as Chrome (on a lower end device at least). I've installed the rewrite back when it was called Firefox Preview.
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by binarysneaker on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:25AM (#31726070)
Long time Android Firefox user here, mainly because of Ublock. Syncing with my Mozilla account was a plus, I use Firefox on desktop because of its container tabs. Lately I switched to Brave (Android), which is noticeably faster, and supports extensions too.
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by sanitycheck on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:12AM (#31725856)
I only need 1: NoScript.

I hate what they've done with Mobile Firefox but it's still better than the alternatives.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by NoGravitas on Monday June 13, 2022 @12:02PM (#31727354)
Most of the recommended extensions on Firefox Mobile are also the most widely used and most needed (in particular uBlock Origin). But if you really need more extensions, you can jump through a bunch of hoops in Firefox Nightly to get any extension you want. Some of them even work pretty well (I use Privacy Redirect, Stylus, and Bypass Paywalls Clean in addition to some of the recommended ones).
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by longrod on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:09AM (#31725814)
Firefox is a dying horse on its last throes before Hades claims it for its own. Mythology aside, I find it truly sad to see the state Firefox is in. A browser is an incredibly complex piece of software and what Mozilla did with Firefox is nothing short of brilliant. Alas, they have been left too far behind [0] I am afraid they'll no longer be relevant in a few years.

Every few months Mozilla tries to overhaul it's UI and succeeds only to try again later. What are they trying to do? What's the real reason behind their slow descent into irrelevance?

Last time I tried Firefox on Android, it was a mess. Crashing every few minutes, unpredictable. I hear its a lot better now which is great! But why did they ditch the old one?

[0] https://caniuse.com/?compare=firefox+101,chrome+102&compareC...

edit: added link to caniuse.com

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by itintheory on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:20AM (#31725984)
I'm not sure which Firefox you're using, but the description you've laid out here doesn't match my experience at all. I've been using FF on desktop and android for years and have had no issues whatsoever. In what way do you feel firefox has been "left too far behind" ?

There was a time when Chrome was faster by an ample margin, but it's no longer enough to be an important distinction. Between the privacy respecting features, and plugin support on mobile - Firefox is the best choice.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by longrod on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:29AM (#31726125)
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by prophesi on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:03AM (#31726586)
I don't think this proves Firefox is dying. A better indicator would be Chrome's past decade of 90%+ browser market share. It's also worth noting that a good amount of the features not implemented in Firefox are either Chrome-specific experiments, or features purposefully unimplemented for privacy purposes.

If anything, it shows the damage of a browser-tech monopoly which Edge and Brave aren't helping with.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by longrod on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:15AM (#31726756)
I don't think features such as Web USB, Web Bluetooth are privacy invasive. Chrome's huge market share is the very reason Firefox isn't trying very hard here. They are playing catch up. Take Manifest v3 for example; Chrome introduced it quite a while ago and made it mandatory for new extensions in 2022. Firefox just started catching up.

This is bad for Firefox because developers will eventually (and some still do) will simply stop supporting Firefox due it being so slow to catch up. Chrome already has such a huge market that a lot of web devs already don't care (e.g. Microsoft Teams).

What does this signify? It's the death of Firefox unless Firefox pulls a miracle here. Chrome is leading, all the devs are following, and they leading by leaps and bounds. Firefox is forced to catch up which causes frustration among users.

How long before Firefox gets tired of playing catch up and simply becomes irrelevant?

I am not happy about this. This is clearly bad but inevitable. The only other real competitor is WebKit which is restricted to Apple only. A huge market still. But Google's monopoly over the browsing market will only cause harm in the long run. Even though it will make devs jobs a lot easier.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by prophesi on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:43AM (#31727134)
> I don't think features such as Web USB, Web Bluetooth are privacy invasive.

Coincidentally, Brave believes they are privacy-invasive and don't support those features either (last paragraph in the article)[0].

Firefox, as with all other browsers aside from Safari, will remain with less than 5% market share for the foreseeable future. But I'd much rather continue supporting different browser engines than use a skinned Chromium to uphold the status quo.

[0] https://www.cnet.com/tech/computing/google-plan-for-chrome-c...

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by NoGravitas on Monday June 13, 2022 @12:07PM (#31727441)
> I don't think features such as Web USB, Web Bluetooth are privacy invasive.

Mozilla, Apple, and Brave all disagree (as do I).

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by stonogo on Monday June 13, 2022 @01:16PM (#31728492)
You are misinformed. Firefox had their own implementations of WebUSB and WebBluetooth years and years ago -- they were necessary for FirefoxOS. Deprecating and removing them was a conscious decision because the privacy risks were deemed too great. This is also the case for Manifest v3; Mozilla is trying to determine the 'safe' (i.e. user-friendly) characteristics to implement and ways to mitigate the rest. Some parts of v3 directly conflict with Firefox architecture. As an example, v3 requires service workers, while Firefox permits entirely disabling them.

The overarching theme of your writing on this topic is that Chrome can just spit out Web 'features' at random and unless Firefox implements all of them immediately it is dying. I hope you can try to understand that not only is this not an accurate assessment, but maybe also that Firefox has value beyond being a copy of Chrome.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by fabrice_d on Monday June 13, 2022 @06:26PM (#31732551)
The security model used in Firefox OS to gate access to these APIs was very different. We never exposed these web bluetooth to the web at large, only to signed apps.

Mozilla needs to step up and find ways to expose such APIs though, because they are useful. Just saying "no" without proposing a solution is a sure way to lose. There's a bit of hope recently with the implementation of WebMIDI in Gecko.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by dylan604 on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:20PM (#31729315)
>I don't think features such as Web USB, Web Bluetooth are privacy invasive.

It's telling that the only browser vendor that feels this way has the logo of one of the two most privacy invading companies in existence.

Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by Phelinofist on Monday June 13, 2022 @05:59PM (#31732323)
I find the lack of nonsense API implementations to be a good thing
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by longrod on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:31AM (#31726162)
Brave is a way better choice. As for plugin support on mobile, yes that's missing but I use extensions mainly on desktop. Brave comes with an adblocker built in and if that doesn't work, you could use something like Adguard.
Re:Our plans for Thunderbird on Android by lock-the-spock on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:23AM (#31726873)
I find Firefox absolutely marvelous in the state it is in now. There certainly is no mystical death.