News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All software is web software now by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:18PM (#31683119)
Except, of course, for browsers themselves.

Oh, and video editors. DAWs. Console-y video games. Compilers. Linkers. Operating systems. The overwhelming majority of mobile apps. Dental imaging systems. Robot assisted surgery systems. CNC controllers. Scientific data analysis. GPT-N.

Jeesh. Browser-at-platform offers some amazing possibilities, but get your head out of the sand and grasp the scope of what software actually is and does.

Re:All software is web software now by bobkazamakis on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:40PM (#31683422)
Funny you should mention

>video editors. DAWs. Console-y video games. Compilers. Linkers. Operating systems. The overwhelming majority of mobile apps. Dental imaging systems. Robot assisted surgery systems. CNC controllers. Scientific data analysis. GPT-N.

Because many of those already offer web interfaces, or can be done online

>get your head out of the sand and grasp the scope of what software actually is and does.

Re:All software is web software now by jrumbut on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:51PM (#31683582)
Interestingly, your experience is a stronger counterpoint to the article than the OP's.

The author says that every software domain that gets touched by the web browser gets swallowed by it.

Perhaps it is early days and all compilers will be web based soon (makes me think of that dystopian horror story "The Right to Read"), but browsers have touched every aspect of the compilation process and besides JS I would say the majority of compilers are not online.

Re:All software is web software now by paulgb on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:07PM (#31683863)
The point is not so much that the browser itself swallows the software, as that browsers become the standard bearer for those domains.

For a compiler-related example, Rust's cargo build tool (the interface that most developers use to the rustc compiler) interoperates with other tools by outputting JSON: https://doc.rust-lang.org/cargo/reference/external-tools.htm...

Another example that's more of a standard is the Language Server Protocol, which is JSON over HTTP even though it doesn't (always) touch a browser: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_Server_Protocol

Re:All software is web software now by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday June 09, 2022 @03:30PM (#31685699)
"outputting JSON" does not in my opinion make something "web software".

In these very comment threads, we've seen proposals for stuff like

    df -h --json
making it abundantly clear that JSON is a data format, not a technology inevitably associated with browsers or even just HTTP.
Re:All software is web software now by fathyb on Thursday June 09, 2022 @04:49PM (#31686657)
WebAssembly is a sort of web-based compiler. Compiling WebAssembly to x86 isn't that much different from compiling LLVM's IR to x86. And nowadays, you can interop WebAssembly with most modern languages, making it a target of choice for libraries with cross-platform/language needs.
Re:All software is web software now by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday June 09, 2022 @03:28PM (#31685680)
a web interface to a fully-non-browser implemented system is not in my opinion evidence that "all software is web software now".
Re:All software is web software now by brundolf on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:23PM (#31683193)
Gentle reminder to read the article
Re:All software is web software now by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday June 09, 2022 @03:32PM (#31685729)
I read the whole article.

The final two sentences of the opening paragraph:

> As browsers become more capable, this is encompassing a large fraction of software standards. In a certain sense, (nearly) all software is now web software.

This is just bullshit, that can only be written by someone too immersed in web-centric development to understand the full scope of software development and design.

Re:All software is web software now by brundolf on Thursday June 09, 2022 @05:04PM (#31686858)
They were being intentionally hyperbolic. Most of the domains you listed have at least been touched by one web technology or another, whether that be JavaScript, HTTP, video codecs, etc. Nobody's saying literally all software, but virtually every domain has been affected at least a little bit by a web-related standard or technology. Chill out.
Re:All software is web software now by waffletower on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:30PM (#31683291)
Gentle reminder to the author that naming is hard.
Re:All software is web software now by brundolf on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:39PM (#31684299)
I think it was an intentional riff on/reframing of the phrase. They lay out the intended meaning very plainly at the top
Re:All software is web software now by galdosdi on Thursday June 09, 2022 @02:43PM (#31685183)
Out of that list, OS and browser itself are the only one that couldn't be done in the browser in theory. Yes, even robot assisted surgery systems, although that kind of disturbs me a little too. You could just do the GUI in the browser and the actual hardware control in a real time scheduled process. But even then, what's stopping some sort of WASM real time scheduling type extension from being created?

The rest are gradually moving towards the browser as performance issues get fixed, e.g., WebGPU, WASM, etc. It's going to take time but the incentives still strong to gradually try moving whatever can be put in the browser in the browser, and to keep creating more web extensions to enable any remaining roadblocks.

In the long run, the OS under the browser, the browser itself, and real time/embedded type code that runs on hardware too constrained or critical, are the only things safe from being swallowed up by the browser's world. The modern browser platform is like what POSIX or the JRE were meant to be, except it actually worked.

Re:All software is web software now by thefz on Thursday June 09, 2022 @04:59PM (#31686798)
Web engineers have the tendency to think everything should run into a browser and it's a disgrace of the modern times.
Re:All software is web software now by hbn on Thursday June 09, 2022 @05:06PM (#31686881)
I was recently trying to get some basic stuff done in the web version of Excel. I have an Apple Magic Mouse which has a touchpad so you can do gestures and scroll in any direction. The spreadsheet had a lot of columns, so I was doing a lot of left and right scrolling to get around, but most of the time I tried to scroll to the left (by swiping right on the touchpad), it'd start activating the browser's back gesture to take me back to the last page I was on before opening the spreadsheet. Eventually I gave up and used the desktop app and it was like a breath of fresh air (which is saying something for an Office app)

Trying to port desktop apps to the browser is already so limiting from the fact that the browser itself gets first claim to so many keyboard shortcuts. Want to make your app do something when the user hits Cmd+L ? Well good luck cause that already focuses the address bar. And you certainly don't get to use Cmd+W because that will close your entire app!

Re:All software is web software now by anonymouse008 on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:41PM (#31683438)
Yeah, this is rub with the genericfication of everything - application design for most folks will begin to look bland (already has happened with WWDC) in an effort for WebAssembly, Swift UI and the like to “write once run anywhere.”

We’ve forgotten that the beauty of computers is that we get to do things we’ve never done before, not just pump out code.

Re:All software is web software now by lioeters on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:10PM (#31683906)
"Any application that can be written in JavaScript, will eventually be written in JavaScript." — Jeff Atwood