I still haven't dived into it, it felt obscure and obtuse last time I checked, but are the cool kids actually using it? I.e. do you have any more link to this niche community, to check what's the status of the project?
~bitbet-bolbel/urbit-community
Justin Murphy also has a pretty cool guide here: https://imperceptible.computer/
You could boot a comet and message me (~piclyx-docsun) there with your HN name and I'll link you cool groups I'm in.
What I find weird about Urbit is that it isn't mainstream, but most groups I'm in are pretty active. The UI also adds to the experience, it is soothing.
Would be happy to show you more stuff.
Edit:
To answer the status, you could check the blog (https://urbit.org/blog) or you could join the network and follow the beginner groups (i.e. ~bitbet-bolbel/urbit-community).
--
"Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents."
"Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity."
Yarvin's own writings indicate that Urbit was written to be that of a medieval castle, limited landed ownership (with 2^32 stars) with the intent that new people would have to buy from these star-landlords. Those "political views" were encoded into the basis of Urbit at the deepest architectural levels.
So again, saying to avoid "flamebait" is just a distractor from discussing the real issues with Urbit itself. The "politics and technology" are one in the same.
None of this fits the fascist political ideology.
Let us discuss the merits and cons of a technology that promotes artificial scarcity (cough IPv4 cough). It's an interesting topic, but it's not what you were doing with your previous comment and you know that.
"It is difficult to know how best to approach this material analytically. As Gilroy (2019: 3) suggests, when discussing fascist ideas ‘there is always a danger that critics end up taking them more seriously than their adherents do’. It is also the case that much of the material with which we need to engage is located online and often in a form outwith the usual protocols and stylistics of the academy. The NRx political project is essentially ‘anti-egalitarian’, ‘anti-progressive’, and argues that ‘democracy is bust; rule by the people doesn’t work, and doesn’t lead to good governance’ (Gray, 2017)."
I'm also looking at Francis Tseng, lead independent researcher of the Jain family Institute http://distributedweb.care/posts/who-owns-the-stars/
"However, given that Yarvin basically laid out the general design for Urbit independently, as he worked on it alone for 11 years and in parallel with his political writings, and that Urbit, as a P2P project, is a fundamentally social and thus incorporates ideas about how people should be organized, Yarvin’s politics should be considered as something that influences his design decisions and his long-term vision for the project. Dog-whistles have been identified in some of his writing about Urbit and its design, including his leaning on Nazi philosopher Carl Schmitt for questions around Urbit’s governance."
Again, I'd argue that you're attacking a "decorum" argument, and not the actual content at hand.
>(with 2^32 stars)
the point of finite identities is to create cost and deter spam/bad actors, it's not in anybody's interest to artificially prevent some set of humans from using the network. see here https://urbit.org/faq#more-planets
Who exactly are you to stop people from enjoying something impractical and controversial? Accept the fact that some might have a more open and curious mind.
It’s more that I don’t want to interact with the general group of people that would be seriously attracted to Urbit.
I tried doing something with it once and my impression was that it is just needlessly/deliberately obtuse/arcane. There are much simpler alternatives.
If you find it 'gimmicky' which I don't, but lots do, just focus on the 'Groups' app.
https://urbit.org/getting-started
To communicate you need a 'ship' (an ID). This could be a free 'comet' and a paid planet. Layer 2 Planets are relatively cheap, and they'll be yours forever too, so it's just a one time payment.
You can find them here:
https://subject.network/buy/
https://azimuth.shop/ (3.5 bucks atm in this one)
https://wexpert.systems/
https://mocbel.house/
Any questions, lmk. (not affiliated, just a fan)