To draw an analogy, if I was a collector of vinyl records and I purchased a first edition album that actually turned out to be a poorly reproduced print made from modern MP3 files, with a label that was printed by some dude's inkjet printer at home, I would be furious.
I don't really buy that for functional objects. I've restored old Teletype machines, some almost a century old, and provenance is not a big issue. In fact, because of the way they were maintained, many are not an original set. There are four main components of a Model 15, keyboard, typing unit, base, and motor. All are field-replaceable, and the first two are easily swappable without tools. Maintenance was often a swap, not field repair. The units went back to a repair depot, were repaired, cleaned, and oiled, and then went to another rental customer. Retired machines rarely have the original subunit combo, and nobody cares.
It's just not the same.
Van Gogh died a pauper, not having sold a single work during his short life.
But it's normal for most people to think collectors of certain items are silly. I used to collect books, and most people think it's utterly stupid to obtain books and only read copies of them rather than the original (opening a binding causes it to deteriorate a little bit).
To you.
99% of 20 y.o. games aren't compatible with anything newer than a 2010's hardware and for 30 year old games you can't even copy/try to run them on anything modern - floppies died ~2010.
20 y.o. video games are roughly equivalent of Late modern period art.
30 y.o. video games are somewhere between the classical antiquity and the Middle ages.
40 y.o. are closer to Egyptian Pyramids.
The content on the disks are cracked copies that contain missing or modified data and are not the original game.
If you wanted to just play it you'd just play it in an emulator.
I will point out that the history of video games is not that old in itself, meaning a several decade old game is falling into the "one of the first games made" vintage tier.
There are definitely some collectors who do play the games so this is not a universal statement.
Also, the packaging apparently wasn't identical. It was hand-cut at least some of the time and imperfect.
[0]: https://www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2013/12/most-ame...
I like buying used (not collectible) books, and once in a while I find artifacts used as bookmarks - a store receipt, an airline boarding pass, a newspaper clipping. These objects are fascinating to me; I'm briefly transported into the world of the person who originally bought the book and how different it seems from that of today. The details of the 'bonus item' are like clues to the identity of the mysterious reader that preceded me, whose identity and trajectory are as entertaining to speculate about as as the fictional or theoretical subject matter of the book itself.
Over time, everything becomes an antique; competitive collecting (for well-defined subsets of items in a niche market) is arguably a way for people of similar temperaments and taste to locate each other socially, but the more effort they invest in this (by developing catalogues or price histories of their favored artifacts) the more likely they are to be crowded out speculators who recognize the hallmarks of an asset class without especially caring what they are attached to.
Why do vintage PC game collectors care whether the product in their hand was manufactured in 1995 by the original company or in 2021 by someone in their garage?
Is the goal to play the game or to acquire bragging rights about an old object just because it's an original copy?