News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by mediaman on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:18PM (#31658867)
Drops in containerized freight, and the following drops in China-US freight prices, will start putting pressure on a lot of manufacturing onshoring initiatives started during the pandemic.

For many classes of bulk goods, freight was becoming 50-100% or more of total landed cost for goods imported from China, which overwhelmed labor cost differentials. In addition, Chinese production problems provided more reasons to move production closer to demand.

But US labor costs increased substantially during the labor crunch of 2021. Prevailing wages that were around $15 ramped to $18-22 as companies worked to compete against the likes of Amazon hiring hundreds of thousands of warehouse workers. Entry level Chinese wages have not increased nearly as much.

So if freight costs collapse such that the landed cost only has 25% of landed cost as freight, and US manufacturers have experienced an increase in labor costs relative to Chinese production, this could spell some very challenging times over the next 1-2 years as a recession applies cost management discipline on the supply chain and US manufacturers find themselves in potentially an even worse comparative cost position than pre-pandemic, vis-a-vis offshore production.

This is also why many US manufacturers were wary about adding capacity: they know about the bullwhip effect, and they also knew that it would affect not only consumer demand but also their supply chain advantage versus offshore production, and so any capital intensive capacity added to meet short-term demand may go idle 1-2 years afterward. And most manufacturing capacity doesn't pencil out if you only get a couple years of good utilization out of it.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by throwawaymaths on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:32PM (#31659055)
I think there is an argument for semi-onshoring, aka not quite getting it to the US but reducing supply chain risk: Mexico for low cost labor with low value-added and near zero supply chain risk (if it's a maquiladora on the border), Colombia for low cost with high value added but slightly higher supply chain risk.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:39PM (#31659779)
> there is an argument for semi-onshoring, aka not quite getting it to the US but reducing supply chain risk

"Friend shoring" [1].

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-06-24/-onshorin...

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by somethoughts on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @10:10PM (#31662409)
Perhaps what would be interesting would be to enable some sort of reverse special economic zone just within the US border such that the corporations would be in US jurisdiction but the employees could flow through with minimal overhead - with some sort of fast pass checkpoint. A separate more tightly controlled border checkpoint could then happen as you move further into the US.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by foogazi on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @02:36AM (#31664062)
For what purpose ?

Mexico already has the “maquiladora” model were raw materials flow tariff free into the factory in Mexico, get assembled / transformed there, and go back across the border to the US duty free

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maquiladora

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by _s on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @10:43PM (#31662598)
So exploit workers by bringing them from overseas, and treat them differently to the local laws?

You’ve just described Qatar, Bahrain, UAE etc.

Maybe reconsider why local labour is expensive and why it’s worth paying for.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @10:58PM (#31662677)
> So exploit workers by bringing them from overseas, and treat them differently to the local laws?

OP said they would be "in US jurisdiction," and thus, presumably, subject to American labor laws. What I think they were suggesting was a visa-free zone within the U.S., which is an interesting idea.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by _s on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @01:04AM (#31663445)
Hmmm I didn’t get that impression from this;

> corporations would be in US jurisdiction but the employees could flow through with minimal overhead

It implies to me that the corporations get to be US based and reap those benefits while employees are not and can be taken advantage of.

Though I do agree with you - there’s a few experiments happening with special economic areas / designated cities in a few places (again, a few in the Middle East) to attract talented individuals and companies to whom local laws may not apply.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by somethoughts on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @01:47AM (#31663726)
Your initial impression is probably an indicator of why it could probably not happen politically - it sounds off. But speaking pragmatically - the US population demographics is aging versus Mexico's still growing working age population. Just any hint of US on-shoring/supply chain/pandemic has led to US wage and consumer goods inflation.

Assuming its highly regulated with US minimum wage laws - a SEZ would be much more about arbitraging the strong US dollar/US High Cost of Living (which is strong due to the US's Tech/Finance/Trade strength leaving US manufacturer stuck) versus the more moderate Mexican peso/lower cost of living.

An employee from Mexico working at US factory would be living quite well if they could freely go back after work to living south of the border.[1]

I'd also mention the realistic alternatives to this are: - just import finished goods from other developing countries produced under highly unknown labor or - locate the factory fully within the US and have the undocumented employees cross the border illegally and live in precarious, unmonitored conditions hundreds of miles away from their families and exacerbating housing issues.

[1] Apartment in Matamorosa Mexico is $400 versus $1020 in McAllen, Texas

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by norvvryo on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @02:05AM (#31663830)
How is that any worse than exploiting Chinese workers, funding the CCP, and wasting time and resources to ship goods halfway across the world?

We need to stop being so hung up on ethics that we fail to arrest our civilization's descent.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by _s on Thursday June 09, 2022 @07:01PM (#31688051)
It isn't - we should be (and a lot of larger corps are) encouraging higher standards for workers in those places, and it is significantly better compared to a decade ago. Not to mention as those workers demand better wages and conditions, it suddenly starts to make economic sense to hire locally.

We should not be taking steps backwards and making that sort of behaviour acceptable, because if we do that at home - then places with already lower standards will compete by lowering theirs further.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by gumby on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @06:27PM (#31660795)
The US also has to take antitrust seriously so that there aren’t single points of failure at a corporate level.

Geographically it’s a huge country so really would benefit from having factories scattered around the country/NAFTAland. Even if some of them clustered in a preferential region (lumber in Canada, car parts in Mexico, certain foodstuff is in California) it offers some risk.

Remember when a fire in a single factory in Japan crippled the semiconductor industry world wide a few years ago?

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by tharkun__ on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @07:36PM (#31661358)
Canada would like to talk to you about car parts and being a preferential region for that as well (Ontario, think Windsor i.e. right across from Detroit - not that Detroit's car manufacturing is going strong or anything like that but still).

Growing food in California should be re-thought if you ask me, given the prolonged drought conditions. At some point shipping water to California just doesn't make sense any longer. Instead of shipping the water to California, grow the food where the water is, even if the yields aren't as high. Like you said, a single crop failure in California can wipe out near 100% of the US' food production for certain fruits and vegetables or at least a very very sizable portion of it.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by fennecfoxen on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:14AM (#31665717)
No one is shipping water to California. The water for California agriculture is diverted from its natural flow, yes, but it comes from mountains located on the east side of California.

On the far side of these mountains you will find the humid wetlands and the wide rivers of ... Nevada. Perhaps you can try kayaking on Groom Lake someday.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by Teever on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:35PM (#31659089)
Is Mexico really a zero supply chain risk?

I don't know much about the cartels or violence in Mexico, but that's the first thing I think of when you describe Mexico as low risk.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by wsinks on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:54PM (#31659302)
I think their parenthetical about a maquiladora on the border was the hedge on Mexico as zero supply chain risk.

There is increased cartel risk. I follow a former White House geopolitical analyst after I met him at a conference. Here's his latest talk on Mexico: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yilSJg5CMd4

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by toolz on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @05:20PM (#31660224)
This guy speaks with a great deal of confidence. I love listening to him talk, but the claims he make are breathtaking and he seems to make them without a second thought. For that reason I was curious to see what sort of predictions he's made in the past and see how accurate he has been.

Well, maybe not quite as powerful at predictions as he is at making geopolitical claims.

(He made a bunch of claims in 2009, for the coming decade I'll paraphrase and link to his predictions)

He claimed the middle eastern wars would be withdrawn from and the world would see it as American weakness. That appears to be incorrect from any metric I can find.

He claimed chinas economy would collapse within the decade in 2009. Well, that's not anywhere approaching corret.

He claimed Germany in the same timeframe would ascend to late 1930 levels of political power. I'm not sure how to quantify that, but I sincerely doubt anyone looks at Germany as strongly as they looked in late 1930s.

He predicted Russia would push their western front, but I'm not so sure that was a bold prediction given the russia-georgia war, but he's definitely correct here.

Made a soft prediction of an eastern asia conflict due to Japans collapsing demographics, not correct, but not a strong prediction either.

Concluded by saying we're going to invert into a deflationary economy, which also appears to be very wrong.

I don't know nearly enough to call the guy out by any means, but I do take his word with a lot of hesitancy. I can't think of anyone who speaks as boldly and confidently across such a large domain without feeling the need to evidence their claims.

https://www.businessinsider.com/stratfor-predictions-for-the...

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by wolverine876 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @01:35AM (#31663646)
> He claimed Germany in the same timeframe would ascend to late 1930 levels of political power. I'm not sure how to quantify that, but I sincerely doubt anyone looks at Germany as strongly as they looked in late 1930s.

Agreed literally, but post-Ukraine Germany has made an historical shift, for the first time since WWII, to invest seriously in their military and support foreign militaries, and before that, during the Trump administration, they gained much influence and stature as arguably the world leader on human rights.

> He claimed the middle eastern wars would be withdrawn from and the world would see it as American weakness. That appears to be incorrect from any metric I can find.

That actually has been US policy under Obama, Trump and Biden: Trump tried to withdraw from everywhere. Under the Democratic Presidents, the policy has been that the US is less dependent on Middle Eastern oil, the Middle East is consuming not-unlimited US geopolitical power (including military power), and we need to shift geopolitical resources to China while deepening our relationship with NATO.

Obama withdrew from Iraq, made a deal with Iran, and instead of supporting the Saudis he tried to balance them and Iran; he also began the shift of geopolitical resources, including military, to China. Trump withdrew from Iraq and Syria, and undermined various other relationships. Biden pulled out of Afganistan (Middle East adjacent, bordering Iran), explicitly stating the the reasons above (China, etc.) and is shifting more resources to China, and has clearly defined them as 'the pacing threat'.

And many have claimed, including after the two Iraq/Syria pullouts and the Afghan pullout, that America is weaker.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by toolz on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:16AM (#31666153)
We have not withdrawn from the middle-east - troops increased during trumps era substantially and obama era created new war fronts. We've redeployed troops to somolia this year (technically not middle east, but I think most people associate it with those wars), iraq combat didn't stop until last year, so while technically not within the decade of his predictions, close enough. We're still killing noteworthy figures in syria. I don't consider this an accurate prediction given it was made in 2009 and had a decade window. I think 99% of people would've made the same prediction and have been surprised by todays middle east involvement if they could've seen into the future.

I don't have my thumb on the global pulse of American strength perception so I really can't comment there, but my perception is that people do not perceive America as anything approaching weak with their military.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by wolverine876 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @03:58PM (#31673157)
A lot of these are all or nothing arguments. Yes, the US didn't withdraw completely, fighting in Iraq didn't stop completely, but that isn't meaningful. There were substantial reductions, and policy dictates more.

Also, statistics and drawing dividing lines on Oval Office changes isn't as meaningful as it appears. First, policy takes months or years to develop, and then it's implemented, and then we see the consequences for years or decades after; no president affects policy much on their first day. Second, it needs to be evaluated in context: Obama withdrew combat forces substantially from Iraq, which IIRC was a campaign promise, and then ISIL grew and became a threat and Obama had to deal with them, sending forces back but in a limited fashion - leaving almost all ground combat to the Iraqi and Kurdish militaries. Trump IIRC sent more forces to finish off ISIL and then pulled almost everyone out (causing the resignation in protest of the Secretary of Defense and of the top diplomat for the region). There's a clear message that the US wants to withdraw, which tells Middle East states that the US won't be as much of a force and tells Russia and China that there is room for them to move in.

> people do not perceive America as anything approaching weak with their military

We are talking about America's overall geopolitical power, which depends on far more than the military - 99% of the world isn't fighting a war. The point isn't that the military lacks firepower, but geopolical power is perceived to be lacking - especially the political will and unity to use that power. For example, Russia and China use the Afgan pullout extensively in propaganda, telling people in places like Taiwan that the US wouldn't defend them. The support for Ukraine has changed that substantially, however.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by brendoelfrendo on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:49PM (#31659234)
It's unquestionable that violent crime in Mexico has gone up over the past several years, but the question is: does that represent a supply chain risk? I don't have the data, but it doesn't seem like cartels or violent criminals typically target civilian manufacturing infrastructure.

Mexico has a lot of manufacturing already, and a relatively healthy demographic distribution (that is, unlike the US and some other developed countries, they actually have enough young folks to replace the old folks leaving the workforce). I feel like Mexico would have to try very hard to fail at being a manufacturing powerhouse in North America.

As an aside, this is a good reason for the US to really strengthen its relationship with Mexico and try to help Mexico fix its problems; the US is probably going to be even more dependent on Mexican manufacturing in the future when this whole supply chain shuffle shakes out.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:53PM (#31659289)
The cartels generally don't wanna destroy the factories. They wanna tax them.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by anonAndOn on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @05:18PM (#31660188)
>try to help Mexico fix its problems

Do you mean like returning the former Defense Minister to Mexico before trial? It's so nice that we can "help".

[0]https://www.cbsnews.com/news/salvador-cienfuegos-zepeda-dism...

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by galaxyLogic on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @08:01PM (#31661588)
Cartels are bad, but they really want to do more business rather than less, import more into the US. More ordinary trade there is, easier it is also to smuggle drugs I would guess.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by qiskit on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:54PM (#31659932)
They are zero risk in that they are completely within our sphere of influence. Canada and Mexico are as zero risk as you can get from an american perspective.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by Teever on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @05:55PM (#31660529)
As a Canadian I agree with you on Canada but im a little skeptical about Mexico.

Again, im no expert on Mexico but from my understanding of the cartel situation Mexico isn't even in the sphere of influence of Mexico.

I don't thing the US would want to put critical supply chains Ina country like Mexico unless they're willing to put troops there to eliminate the cartels, which to be honest would be a terrible idea.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by 8note on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @08:30PM (#31661764)
Wouldn't the us just pay off the cartels?
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by Teever on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @10:24PM (#31662489)
And when the cartels alter the deal?
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by munk-a on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:00PM (#31659380)
If we saw increased off-shoring to Colombia would it possibly finally result in a continuous Freight rail line through Central America? It's always struck me as exceedingly odd that Panama is the terminus for all land-borne transportation.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by derevaunseraun on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:07PM (#31659450)
> It's always struck me as exceedingly odd that Panama is the terminus for all land-borne transportation.

Might be because there's this chunk of Panama/north Columbia that's run by Guerillas and is one of the most dangerous places in existence (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dari%C3%A9n_Gap)

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by mullingitover on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @08:23PM (#31661720)
There's this whole massive project that bombs the Darrien Gap with sterilized screwflies to prevent them from getting into North America[1]. I suspect opening that route to vehicles would probably help get them past the gap and into North America where they'd wreak havoc on livestock.

[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/north-ame...

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by minsc_and_boo on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:50PM (#31659895)
Not just that, you have some of the highest concentrations of sea shipping lanes in the world competing nearby, with rugged landscape, earthquakes, and multiple socipolitical barriers along the route.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by R0b0t1 on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @07:07PM (#31661132)
Sounds like they need some freedom.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by hackernews1134 on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @07:27PM (#31661296)
What an immediately cynical, hilarious and eventually thought provoking response.

I suspect it violates HN guidelines (too snarky?!?!). However, I for one applaud it's pith!

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by scythe on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:29PM (#31659689)
There has also been concern that a land-based link would hamper the containment of foot-and-mouth disease that was eradicated from North America, and there are environmental concerns. Colombia proposed building a road through the whole gap:

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1995-08-20-mn-36988-...

But this has been heavily protested by environmentalists and natives alike. It might be less controversial to go northeast to Acandí by tunneling under the mountains, which would leave almost all of the forest untouched. Then you could build a long bridge, a coastal highway, or just keep using the ferry.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by wahern on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:20PM (#31659601)
Nobody seems to have figured out how to make bridging the Darién Gap cost effective. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dari%C3%A9n_Gap#By_land

Plus, there's not even any rail line reaching Panama. The southern terminus of the North American rail infrastructure is Mexico, I think. I doubt trucking everything through Central America would be very cost effective. So you're not only building a new line through 66 miles of some of the most difficult and remote terrain in the world, you're building or refurbishing another ~1500+ miles of rail.

And then you're only reaching Columbia and Venezuela, with the Andes and the Amazon between you and the two biggest markets in South America: Brazil and Argentina.

It would be cool if it happened, but I think it would have to be a regional public works project funded primarily by the U.S. government. Unless Musk is looking for his next challenge (and he can make it pencil out with his Fermi-math voodoo). Maybe the U.S. can sell it to taxpayers as a jobs and economic development program to stem the tide of Central American refugees.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by aunty_helen on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @11:42PM (#31662942)
I flew across the Darien gap twice in the last week and the area has always interested me for the very subject of why don’t they join south and north. Simply, there’s no cost effective way.

The landscape is wet. You would effectively be building a bridge the whole way. Whilst fighting a guerrilla war, disease and ruining an ecological system in the process.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by barelysapient on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:25PM (#31659662)
Who needs rail when there's massive port capacity in Cartagena and Panama?
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by i_am_proteus on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:26PM (#31659664)
Such a rail freight line would have to compete with comparatively-inexpensive sea freight, and probably couldn't do so cost-effectively.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by presidentender on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:51PM (#31659904)
The Darien Gap is insufficiently friendly to construction to permit that.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by jameshart on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:07PM (#31659454)
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by gumby on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @06:23PM (#31660757)
> Panama is the terminus for all land-borne transportation.

Does the Panamerican highway not qualify as land-borne transportation?

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by justinator on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @09:30PM (#31662222)
I don’t believe one can travel across the Americas via the Panamerican highway. It’s more idea than reality.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by aperson_hello on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @11:45PM (#31662960)
You absolutely can, except for a good chunk in the middle of the highway in the Darien gap.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by milkytron on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:38PM (#31659120)
Auto manufacturers are already doing this.

https://tax.thomsonreuters.com/blog/mexico-as-a-new-capital-...

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by outside1234 on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @07:38PM (#31661379)
Or just basically anywhere but "always in China"

We are at systemic risk from our reliance on China.

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by chrisseaton on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:26PM (#31658973)
> freight was becoming 50-100% or more of total landed cost

How can freight be more than 100% of total cost? Everything else was zero or negative?

Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by ketzo on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:30PM (#31659017)
Maybe just sloppy language, but OP might have meant “50-100% or more of the cost of producing the good itself”.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by mediaman on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:50PM (#31659244)
Yes, you're right, I meant as a percent of the FOB price of the product. So 100% of the FOB price would be 50% of the landed cost. 100% of landed cost doesn't make sense and was the wrong term.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by chrisseaton on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:33PM (#31659060)
‘Landed’ means total cost for producing and getting into country.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by akira2501 on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:37PM (#31659117)
A $4 item costs $4 to ship, making it $8 to get it on shore.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by chrisseaton on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:44PM (#31659180)
That’s $8 landed so that freight is 50%.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by arcticbull on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @03:49PM (#31659233)
I assume they meant percentage of the cost excluding shipping. Probably shouldn't have said 'landed' but I do know of some goods that cost over 100% of BOM to ship.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by Zigurd on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @05:12PM (#31660120)
Both globalization and deglobalization can become fashionable herd mentalities. As long as the populist isolationists can be held at bay in the US and most of Europe, a sane balance should return.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by taf2 on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @05:02PM (#31660008)
If what you say is true/correct than it stands to reason removing the tariffs, would just make this issue even worse for US manufacturers and drive us into an even deeper recession?
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by lumost on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @11:07PM (#31662718)
A smart move would be tostart ratcheting up tariffs. Given the amount of international capacity, the bullwhip effect should be bluntable via tariffs.
Re:Inbound container volumes to the US are reverting to pre-... by whatshisface on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @11:14PM (#31662768)
If the bullwhip effect obeyed predictable timing, companies would already be compensating for it. If you have a secret formula that can predict when it will hit, don't bother trying to convince the polity to do something about it - become a billionaire by buying ahead of the shortages and fix the problem yourself.