News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by godshatter on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:35PM (#31614530)
> ...a Dalit rights activist was not allowed to give a presentation on caste following emails by employees calling her "anti-Hindu."

I must be the last person still alive that keeps their opinions to themselves while on the job.

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by hellohowareu on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:46PM (#31614634)
I'm so glad no one at my current technology workplace discusses politics anywhere-- not in Slack, Email, nor Conference calls. I literally haven't heard a single political opinion at work, and I freakin love it!

I previously worked at Unity Technologies (3d game engine company) and as well as a CRM Consultancy, and I was amazed by how much time people spent arguing their political agenda. It was a major contributing factor of why I left both places. I had this feeling of "Why are these people chatting about things irrelevant to our work, while I am working? They should be working too-- they're paid to work, not chat & check their slack feed for 30-60 minutes a day about politics"

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by Beltalowda on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:45PM (#31615236)
> I'm so glad no one at my current technology workplace discusses politics anywhere-- not in Slack, Email, nor Conference calls. I literally haven't heard a single political opinion at work, and I freakin love it!

Honestly, this seems boring as hell.

I've often discussed politics, religion, and all sorts of things with coworkers, and we've often disagreed. And then we went about our day working together, or having a beer after work. No problems. It's just part of normal regular socializing, and I'd argue that socializing with co-workers is somewhat important for a healthy workplace.

Excessively pushing politics is a different thing of course, but "absolutely no politics allowed" has just a kind of boring superficiality to it. And also leaves us with the rather tricky question on what "politics" is, exactly.

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by hellohowareu on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @09:21AM (#31653857)
Boring? That's a funny assumption. The presence of politics is required for work to be fun? Sounds like a nightmare to me.

I love the lack of politics at work. It really makes it more pleasant-- almost an escape from an otherwise over-politically involved society. I can't turn on the news or open the browser (sometimes even IRC) without politics seeping in.

It allows me to stay focused on work, not on what people think about/how I might be judged on my non-work related opinions. Nor that there could be favoritism based on such things.

It levels the playing field.

There are numerous articles discussing any non-liberal voices resulting in people being let-go/fired at various California-based technology companies.

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by munk-a on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:48PM (#31614661)
Unfortunately just because people don't openly discuss their politics it doesn't mean that there isn't hiring discrimination going on.
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by ushakov on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:43PM (#31614611)
maybe Basecamp’s no politics at work policy wasn’t that bad after all…
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by epistasis on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:45PM (#31614631)
That policy doesn't mean that there's no politics at work, just that there's no open discussion of the politics that are affecting employees and the company. See for example:

https://www.wired.com/story/trapped-in-silicon-valleys-hidde...

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by ushakov on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:49PM (#31614684)
i seriously doubt that no politics at work policy was to undermine discussions about employees struggles

to me it seems that people got carried away by political debacle so much they forgot what they should actually be doing on their job

moreover i doubt Basecamp had a caste problem to begin with

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by epistasis on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:29PM (#31615101)
I didn't mean to say that this was Basecamp's intent, merely that it is the inevitable result.

The luxury of ignoring politics is usually reserved for those who are not threatened by the dominant politics. And that luxury is one that most people in tech management have, so it can produce unintentional harm.

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by Qworg on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:20PM (#31615015)
Why do you doubt this?

This policy only came into play after leadership was called out.

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by ushakov on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:33PM (#31615140)
i mean what happened is that some employees called their customers funny names

the management said no funny names no more

and this has made some of the employees very upset

they just couldn’t accept they won’t be able to call their customers funny names no more while being hired to do a job

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by salawat on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:10PM (#31614909)
It amuses me how many people rate economic life as taking primacy over civic life.

Economic activity is an outcome that happens in the presence of a stable civic situation. Economic activity does not spontaneously create polite and cooperative groups of people.

If anything, civic/political matters take primacy over economics any day. Once your political landscape degenerates, your economic underpinning is generally quick to follow in the ensuing chaos.

How have people not realized this yet?

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by ushakov on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:27PM (#31615082)
yep, that’s why we should ban political agenda at work

why talk shit about politics when we can spend time together making money!

we already contribute a significant portion of our income to taxes

maybe we should have political debates with the very people we sponsor and not our coworkers?

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by frostburg on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:44PM (#31614623)
How does that work when apparently there are Indian managers that discriminate against lower caste Indians under them?
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by criddell on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:48PM (#31614667)
Does the Indian-ness of the manager matter? Nobody actually thinks discrimination is okay.
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by frostburg on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:54PM (#31614739)
This is basically invisible to "us" (assuming you're not Indian); I'm a comparatively well read westerner regarding this issue but I have no practical ability to spot the subtle signifiers that let people familiar with system glean who "belongs" to what caste if they care to.

Also non-Indian managers are very unlikely to be interested in discriminating against specific subgroups of Indians even if they're huge bigots or something, so this is a pretty specifically inter-Indian issue.

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by seoaeu on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:20PM (#31615008)
Opposing things that everybody is against isn't political. The fact that this topic is being labeled as politics is proof that some people are OK with it.
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by madeofpalk on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:46PM (#31614635)
"No politics at Google" is an impossible stance.
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by thriftwy on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:43PM (#31614613)
That's likely because you belong to a social group whose opinions are considered worthless.
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by godshatter on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:47PM (#31614650)
I don't align well with most of the most outspoken social groups, so, yeah, probably true.
Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by thoms_a on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:53PM (#31614728)
This doesn't mean that the opinions of powerful people do not affect you, however.

The Civil Rights Act and its consequences have meant that America will forever be politicized along every fault line of human identity. Whether it can withstand this burden and remain a functional civilization remains to be seen.

Re:Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallo... by seoaeu on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:20PM (#31615017)
Wait, you're against the civil rights act?