News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by zionic on Friday June 03, 2022 @12:46PM (#31610685)
gas stoves vent toxic fumes into the house, run the risk of blowing your house up, and are inferior to induction stoves in almost every way.

Any time this comes up I love to singe the praises of induction!

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by formerkrogemp on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:16PM (#31611806)
> gas stoves vent toxic fumes into the house, run the risk of blowing your house up, and are inferior to induction stoves in almost every way.

Funny story and rather infamously, the researchers who studied the fumes from gas stoves almost immediately ripped out their gas stoves after the results came back from the studies. Several states are passing or have passed copy-paste laws, written by gas companies, making ripping out gas stoves cost a fee even if the gas company isn't ripping out the gas stoves themselves.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by carapace on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:27PM (#31611932)
> singe the praises

Ah, that's lovely. :)

- - - -

Also pilot lights: older gas ranges have tiny flames burning 24/7 just in case you want to cook something in the middle of the night. (Most newer models use electric sparks "on demand" to light.)

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by zionic on Saturday June 04, 2022 @11:37AM (#31621586)
Lol that was a typo but I’m keeping it!
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by throwaway4aday on Friday June 03, 2022 @12:54PM (#31610772)
> are inferior to induction stoves in almost every way

the one way in which they surpass induction stoves is the only thing that counts, instant control of the heat applied to the pan.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by mike00632 on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:01PM (#31610875)
I think you're confusing induction with electric stoves.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by cecilpl2 on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:03PM (#31610894)
Induction does have instant control since it induces heating directly in the pan.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by hgomersall on Friday June 03, 2022 @12:57PM (#31610816)
Have you used induction? My experience is that it's much more responsive than gas.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by throwaway4aday on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:02PM (#31610884)
Yes, it turns on quickly but it also has to vary on and off to maintain the temperature which leads to it either running too cool part of the time or too hot. Gas allows you to set the exact temp you need and it makes a smooth, quick transition and then maintains it perfectly.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by ryukafalz on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:21PM (#31611118)
> Gas allows you to set the exact temp you need

No gas stove I’ve used has had this functionality. They let you set the exact output you want, which is not the same (and induction cooktops can do that too).

Yes, if you want to set a specific temperature induction cooktops will cycle, but you can also use them the same way you’d use a gas stove and then they don’t.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by gkop on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:48PM (#31611491)
Would you spell it out for us? If induction cooktops are capable of continuous control of their output, why do they cycle significantly in set temp mode? At least, I would expect them to cycle minimally for fine tuning, relying on the continuous control of output as much as possible instead of cycling.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by ryukafalz on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:35PM (#31612037)
This made me look it up because you’re right, that should also be possible. It looks like some indeed are capable of that, while others are not.

My experience with induction cooktops is admittedly mostly with portable ones, because I’m renting for now and can’t install my own stove. I suspect mine’s just not sophisticated enough. :)

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by tomtheelder on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:29PM (#31611958)
Well they don't have perfect output control, but also cycling is just usually a good way to maintain a temperature when you've got a pan and some food sitting on top of it since there's quite a bit of inertia in actually changing the temperature of whatever is on the stove. There are very expensive ones with separate temperature probes that do a lot less cycling and hold the temperature really steady, but most people don't really need that.

Gas stoves would likely cycle as well if they had a temperature set feature. It's what gas ovens do.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by gkop on Friday June 03, 2022 @03:58PM (#31612917)
Thanks for the reply, I’m still curious though

> cycling is just usually a good way to maintain a temperature when you've got a pan and some food sitting on top of it since there's quite a bit of inertia in actually changing the temperature of whatever is on the stove.

Why precisely is cycling more effective than attenuating down (better word please?) the output? I don’t see what the thermal inertia of what’s on the cooktop has to do with making the optimal (for cooking) choice between cycling and modulating the power.

Without detailed knowledge of the precise energy and time costs, I think it’s a fair default assumption that continuous power modulation should be more efficient, because it’s in a sense a superset of cycling, with much more fine grained control, but you can always set the continuous power output to 0 or 1 to accomplish cycling if in a specific scenario it is helpful.

Maybe when you say “a good way” you mean “a good enough way”? That makes sense, but doesn’t really sell induction stoves relative to gas (if you want to sell induction stoves relative to gas, I suggest to downplay any cycling and promote the continuous output modulation)..

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by cgriswald on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:45PM (#31611453)
Decreasing temperature isn't a function of the range.

Increasing temperature is a function of the range, and in my experience induction is significantly faster.

To the extent that "it must vary on and off to maintain temperature" is true, that's not really relevant. As a sibling poster states, you're not setting a temperatures. You're setting a level of output on both induction and gas. Your food is separated from the output by a heat reservoir and cannot possibly respond quickly enough to induction's on/off switching for this to matter. This does however, seem to be an area where induction can vary greatly in quality, and I suspect most of the complaints people have about induction have more to do with dodgier induction units than they do with the technology versus gas.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by olivermarks on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:18PM (#31611078)
My experience of induction stoves is that they are v expensive and have a very short lifespan. Induction heaters to release fasteners on cars are excellent though
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by Ekaros on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:21PM (#31611874)
Doesn't gas have trouble with very low outputs? Which really isn't such problem with either resistive or induction?
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by AlgorithmicTime on Friday June 03, 2022 @12:52PM (#31610756)
Induction stoves are seriously inferior to gas, in every way.

They are slower to heat.

They are more expensive to operate.

They are more fragile.

They rely on complex electronics vs. simple mechanics.

They require specific cookware made out of only certain materials.

They require direct contact with the "burner" to work.

In what possible way are they superior?

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by cecilpl2 on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:15PM (#31611805)
They are faster to heat than gas since they can deliver all energy directly to the pan, whereas gas wastes ~75% of the energy heating the surrounding air. They boil water much faster than even an electric kettle for this reason.

Pot handles don't get hot from the hot air going up the side.

They are much easier to clean. Spills don't get burnt onto the cooktop.

There's no risk of fire or burning oneself.

No risk of a gas leak from bumping a knob.

No harmful pollutants emitted by combusting fossil fuels in an interior space.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by briandear on Friday June 03, 2022 @03:02PM (#31612321)
And when there is a power failure, what then? I live in hurricane country and being without power is a real concern. I happen to have a backup generator which runs on natural gas. But electrical outages are a real thing.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by cecilpl2 on Friday June 03, 2022 @03:17PM (#31612482)
I guess you use a BBQ or eat food that doesn't require cooking for a couple days?

Power failure is very rare where I live so it didn't occur to me. I have never experienced a power outage for more than a few hours in my entire life.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by fsociety on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:47PM (#31615247)
Ironically in today’s world betting on natural gas seems like a losing proposition. I’d feel more comfortable betting on access to electricity than I would betting on access to natural gases.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by MisterBastahrd on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:54PM (#31612229)
That's not even mentioning that you can simply by steel discs the size of the burner and use whatever kind of cooking vessel you like.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by chociej on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:31PM (#31611979)
Consumer Reports, for one, is happy to report that "No other cooking technology we’ve tested is faster than induction."

I would think a lot of the advantages of induction are really obvious, so I don't think your statement that they are "inferior to gas in every way" is particularly in good faith. No gas in a building should be obviously advantageous. Reduced ability to cause burns or fires too. Reduction of use of a potent greenhouse gas.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by briandear on Friday June 03, 2022 @03:05PM (#31612346)
Why can’t people have the choice for gas or induction? Why must government tell us what kind of stove to use? If reducing greenhouse gases from stoves matters to you, you can make the choice to do that.
Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by danShumway on Friday June 03, 2022 @04:14PM (#31613097)
I think this mostly comes down to externalities. I somewhat doubt that consumer usage of gas stoves actually matters that much to emissions (though it might be important for getting rid of gas lines, possibly), but in the abstract people doing something with a negative universal externality isn't a purely private choice.

It's a bit like saying, "if you care about the neighborhood being quieter, then you're free to turn off your own radio at night, but don't yell at me for blasting a boombox at 4AM, that's my choice". The greenhouse gases you let out don't stay on your property, they "trespass" onto everybody else's -- so it's more difficult for me to view pollution as a purely individual choice because air pollution is effectively dumping waste onto other people's land.

Of course, sometimes there are ways we can influence outcomes without outright banning things. Maybe you're allowed to play your boombox at full volume at 4AM but have to pay an noise tax? Maybe we subsidize replacing your boombox with an iPod and some decent headphones? Policy is complicated.

But even if you approach this from a pure Libertarian perspective, Libertarianism has a concept of conflicting rights and acknowledges that a recursive "right to infringe other people's rights" doesn't actually work and is reasonable in many situations to ban. I suspect that the pure Libertarian perspective would be that you can burn as much carbon as you like as long as those emissions stay entirely on your property and aren't being dumped into the collective atmosphere for everyone else to deal with.

Re:What a gas stove ban means for restaurants by ramtatatam on Friday June 03, 2022 @04:47PM (#31613414)
In the past 15 years I happened to rent in many cities and use all three technologies to heat my food (that is, gas, resistive and induction) and indeed, induction heats in shortest amount of time.