News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by a-dub on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:10AM (#31559137)
so here's a fun question: it's become quite trendy in policy circles in california to incentivize the removal of lawns and gardens as part of water conservation efforts.

doesn't removal of fertile topsoil and replacement of it with rocks and cacti at scale actually reduce carbon sequestration and heat absorption capacity?

Re:Climate Spiral [video] by turtledove on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:19AM (#31559240)
I don't think so in any meaningful way. Also, removing and wasting the water to keep a lawn green heats the river that water was pulled from.

Plus, mowing a lawn is usually done with some of the dirtiest engines out there.

Removing lawns is always a net good.

Re:Climate Spiral [video] by a-dub on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:40AM (#31559490)
sure, but don't we put lawns on roofs in cities to try and cool them down in the summer?

i understand the notion of returning to existing vegetation, but these places are already irreversibly altered by the presence of humans anyway. buildings and parking lots and roads and sidewalks have been built.

it's pretty striking when you see what little soil remains being replaced with rocks.

Re:Climate Spiral [video] by pickovven on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:38AM (#31560148)
In many places green roofs are primarily about reducing rainwater runoff, which causes pollution. However in hot areas like LA, they also reduce building temperatures which reduces energy consumption. Lawns don't reduce building temperatures.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by turtledove on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:49AM (#31559606)
Rooftop lawns in cities are to offset the increase in heat generated by having the city there. They are an attempt to return the environment to something closer to natural.

And yes, xeriscaping is striking. Absolutely beautiful to see native plants, well adapted to the climate, thriving and taking center stage.

Re:Climate Spiral [video] by DoughnutHole on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:01AM (#31559735)
[EDIT: Below I have demonstrated a slow brain rot that has robbed me of my ability to do basic dimensional analysis. My lecturers are spinning in their graves, least of all because I forgot that the kilogram is between the gram and the tonne. Luckily I was off by 3 orders of magnitude in both directions so I guess it sort of balances out?]

The heat absorption is a good point, I don't know what native foliage is like to live in compared to the concrete hell you'd be left with without lawns. But, I find it hard to imagine that turf grass in climates where it can't survive without massive irrigation and ceaseless human intervention sequesters more carbon than it costs to maintain.

The numbers I've quickly gathered are all over the place, but given that:

- The average Californian lawn is ~500 sqm [0]

- Grass sequesters ~ 85g of carbon per sqm per year, or 42 tonnes per year [1]

- As of 2011 the average Californian household uses 190 gallons of potable water a day on landscaping [2]

- About 0.004 metric tonnes of carbon is generated processing 1000 gallons of potable water or 0.76 tonnes per day of watering [3]

So, the average Californian lawn sequesters 42 tonnes of carbon a year, while the energy cost of irrigating it emits about 277 tonnes.

This is all quick back of an envelope math, but the carbon cost of irrigating a lawn where it wasn't meant to grow is massively larger than the amount that the grass sequesters. It's honestly bad enough that you could tear up every lawn in California and not even bother replacing them with native foliage, and it would still result in a net decrease in carbon emissions.

[0]: https://www.homeadvisor.com/r/average-yard-size-by-state/

[1]: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282543110_Modeling_...

[2]: https://www.kqed.org/lowdown/11525/how-much-water-do-califor...

[3]: http://leansixsigmaenvironment.org/index.php/how-much-impact...

Re:Climate Spiral [video] by leto_ii on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:10AM (#31559849)
> - The average Californian lawn is ~500 sqm [0]

> - Grass sequesters ~ 85g of carbon per sqm per year, or 42 tonnes per year [1]

500 * 85g/m2 = 42500 g/m2 - that's 42.5 kg, not 42.5 tonnes.

I haven't checked your original sources, but based on the numbers you provided you're off by 3 orders of magnitude. Intuitively this makes sense, I mean 42 tonnes is a huge amount of carbon to sequester in a lawn. Where would all that mass go? It would mean that the average lawn produces >> 42 tonnes of grass per year.

Re:Climate Spiral [video] by DoughnutHole on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:15AM (#31559914)
You're completely right that was a misstep, I was thinking that seemed high but didn't really think it through - that would be a ludicrous mass of trimmings... So the sequestration is even lower.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by a-dub on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:58AM (#31560336)
[3] seems like a bit of a stretch to me. we know for a fact that different communities have different energy needs for moving water around based on simple geography. we also know that different communities have different electricity sources providing municipal power. (the bay area's primary water system makes use of hydroelectric power, for example). finally, i'm not convinced that the marginal cost per gallon makes up the total cost of moving water around. much of the costs are fixed infrastructure costs that don't necessarily move with utilization.

here's a thought experiment: assume infinite clean electricity and desalination capacity in the face of an overcarbonated atmosphere and climate change. do you install and irrigate as much vegetation as you can or do you rip it all out and put in rocks?

Re:Climate Spiral [video] by engineer_22 on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:15AM (#31559909)
Imagining 42 tons of yard waste piling up outside every year, seems a little off the mark.

500 sqm X 85 g/yr is 42.5 kg/yr

Also, 190 gpd / 1000 gal = 0.19 kgal per day

0.004 tons per kgal per day x 0.19 x 365 days = .277 tons per year

Therefore 0.0425 tons sequestered, 0.277 tons produced by irrigation.

The ratio of carbon sequestered to carbon produced on irrigation is the same as your original calculations.

But I think the major source of carbon won't be in irrigation, but in the maintenance, mowing the lawn, transportation for the landscaper, transporting pesticides and fertilizers, etc.

Re:Climate Spiral [video] by halfmatthalfcat on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:16AM (#31559206)
The water conservation need outweighs the marginal carbon sequestration I’d imagine.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by ceejayoz on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:17AM (#31559220)
Grassy lawns and lush gardens in dry areas require so much water any water any possible benefit of carbon sequestration is counterbalanced by the irrigation infrastructure required.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by 0des on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:18AM (#31559237)
Do cashew farms and strawberries next
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by piva00 on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:39AM (#31559468)
As far as I know almonds are a major water-guzzler of Californian crops, no?
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by djbusby on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:11AM (#31559864)
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by Victerius on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:17AM (#31559218)
What was the vegetation like before humans arrived? We should go back to that.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by lobocinza on Monday May 30, 2022 @05:07PM (#31563635)
Lawn is net zero if you ignore all secondary emissions because the grass will be cut and decompose into methane. When the many secondary emissions are considered it's certainly emitting more carbon than it capture. But it improve the micro-climate of the city and possibly reduce AC usage.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by titzer on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:04AM (#31559778)
Most of LA would be a rocky semi-desert without irrigation. If you want to sequester carbon, maybe do it someplace that does have rainfall to support an effective carbon-sink ecosystem and doesn't require huge amounts of energy input?
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by ianai on Monday May 30, 2022 @02:46PM (#31562236)
I wonder if there’s some vegetation that could be watered with seawater and take the place of grass? Places like LA have plenty of that, seemingly.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by iandinwoodie on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:19AM (#31559243)
In addition, I wonder what effect this sort of “manual desertification” has on the soil when done en masse.
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by Majestic121 on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:25AM (#31559301)
It seems odd to me to frame this as manual desertification. Isn't it the opposite, return to a natural state after manual "grassification" that requires strong human intervention?
Re:Climate Spiral [video] by turtledove on Monday May 30, 2022 @10:30AM (#31559357)
It's not an environment that naturally supports soil. The energy and water needs to support an unnatural environment are quite large.