News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by politician on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:24PM (#3155203)
TLDR: "The easiest way to stop piracy is not by putting antipiracy technology to work. It’s by giving those people a service that’s better than what they’re receiving from the pirates," Gabe Newell said.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by wccrawford on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:32PM (#3155240)
But it should be noted that Steam's pre-release anti-piracy has no yet been broken. So it's not like they don't do DRM...

Having said that, the conclusion is pretty much in line with what many gamers and pirates have been saying: Stop screwing the customer and creating pirates of them.

I'm lucky enough to live in an English-speaking country, but I'm sure that if I lived in a country that typically sees long delays before localization, I'd find a way to get it early. Even if that meant learning English and engaging in piracy.

These companies understand hype and the way it drives sales, and then completely fail to use that knowledge when it comes to other countries. They won't wait! The hype has pushed them into getting it NOW, by hook or crook.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by parfe on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:43PM (#3155282)
>But it should be noted that Steam's pre-release anti-piracy has no yet been broken. So it's not like they don't do DRM...

In regards to pre-lease, A bit of a stretch calling what Valve does DRM. The pre-release stuff is straight up encrypted. It's a convenience for the end-user to pre-load the data. Once the game gets released you don't need to contact valve's servers for decryption keys every time you want to play.

Steam itself will install any game I own on any machine I log into. Steam competes directly with The Pirate Bay, and wins.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by Cushman on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:01PM (#3155384)
That's Steam's secret right there, yeah? Use DRM to make the product more convenient, and pirates will pay you for the privilege.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by InclinedPlane on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:18PM (#3155703)
DRM by itself offers no benefit and significant down sides to end users. It's a bitter pill to swallow on its own. Most game makers slap DRM on a game and call it a day, then wonder why users complain. Valve adds enough sugar to their DRM to make it woorthwhile overall. To offset the downsides of DRM you get the benefit of super easy digital distribution, "cloud" storage of game saves and settings, easy installation on multiple computers, etc.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by ineedtosleep on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:55PM (#3155603)
Right, and even if the user does not play it the instant it gets decrypted, the user still benefits by having preloaded days in advance (especially with huge games > 10GB, i.e. BF3). So when the user finally finds time to play a preordered game, it's already sitting in the Steam library, ready to be played.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by aeturnum on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:53PM (#3155595)
I think this is one of the things that good DRM can provide the end-user that has been largely ignored by everyone. I mostly blame the industry for ignoring the possibilities, but they're exciting. You could "loan" games to people without physical contact, you can securely transfer ownership of the digital item, you can play your games from anywhere, etc. There's a lot of potential in having strong digital copy protection that protects the rights of all parties.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by nene on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:54PM (#3155840)
Well... you can do all these things when there's no DRM at all. It's like counting up all the things you can do in a new modern prison, but it's still a prison.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by aeturnum on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @05:15PM (#3155910)
You can do that sometimes...as long as your key isn't bound to a user account (Battle.net), and as long as you have the patience to get it working (mail the cds, give them your steam account password, find them a crack, etc). Some of those restrictions are reasonable and some aren't.

My point is that good DRM can protect rights of both parties , but never does. Instead, if often restricts the consumer's rights in favor of the publisher. Steam comes closest to balancing interests, but falls short as well.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by wmf on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @06:15PM (#3156116)
I'm skeptical that rental business models can work without DRM; the temptation is just too great.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by shuzchen on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @09:16PM (#3156690)
I can see where you're coming from, but in my view the general consumer won't put in the effort to exploit your model if you make it appealing enough. I've known people that rented from blockbuster|netflix and just made rips of the VHS|DVDs for their own collection, but it sure wasn't those pirates that destroyed (or is destroying) their business. GOG sells DRM free games and nothing stops me from giving it away to all my friends, but I still end up paying for a new "copy" when I gift one away.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by te_chris on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @08:27PM (#3156552)
It doesn't need to though, the key thing with the rental business model is it needs to be easy and convenient enough. It's clear that it's a rental in the name, but people will get pissed off if it's not easy to get the content and outlandishly priced, and just go back to BT.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by Maxious on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @07:32PM (#3156373)
They also just leave key .exe/.dll files out of the downloadable content until release day. With Dead Island, Steam accidentally distributed debug builds on release, leading to some hilarious misuse of cheats.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by lreeves on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @10:57AM (#3158838)
I'm pretty sure Steam didn't do that; the developer and publisher are responsible for uploading the bundles to Valve for distribution.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by nickolai on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @05:20AM (#3157740)
>I'm lucky enough to live in an English-speaking country, but I'm sure that if I lived in a country that typically sees long delays before localization, I'd find a way to get it early. Even if that meant learning English and engaging in piracy.

Add to this that the translations are often very badly broken - my eyes and ears bleed when I play French versions of games. I actually prefer to get the english version through Steam, and I am sure a sizeable fraction of players would agree.

The only successful localization ive seen to date is stracraft2 - so good that I didnt even bother redownloading the english version from Blizzard. Admittedly i havent even been checking out most localized versions for a while - so it may have been improving lately without me noticing.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by Derbasti on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @07:15AM (#3158057)
> I'm lucky enough to live in an English-speaking country, but I'm sure that if I lived in a country that typically sees long delays before localization, I'd find a way to get it early. Even if that meant learning English and engaging in piracy.

Translations are often bad and delayed. This is as true for games as it is true for movies or books. I hate it. The obvious solution is to just get the english versions.

But the worst thing is, there is often no legal or practical way to get the english version. Books are easy. You can get just about any english book through Amazon (.de, .fr, .etc). Movies are somewhat bad. DVDs usually include english language. iTunes doesn't feature (many) english movies, but Ebay sells US iTunes gift cards. Games are actually really hard. It is possible to order from Amazon UK or Amazon US, but shipping will be weeks and there is a good chance you will have to pay customs. Steam requires a VPN and a foreign account and a credit card proxy (Entropay works fine). Not what you would call convenient.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by w1ntermute on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:22PM (#3155715)
> I'm lucky enough to live in an English-speaking country, but I'm sure that if I lived in a country that typically sees long delays before localization, I'd find a way to get it early.

Localization isn't just bureaucratic nonsense that was conjured up to aggravate gamers in foreign countries - the games actually need to be translated to the local language.

As for if you were living in one of those countries as an expat, as you suggest, that's a very small market and not worth pursuing.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by kelnage on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @05:06PM (#3155881)
But yet they pirate the games anyway. My guess is that you'll find that a large percentage of "gamers" in non-English speaking countries speak English well enough to understand most games and don't want to wait the 6+ months required to translate the game to their local tongue when they could be playing online against US players.

This was especially true a few years back, when some publishers wouldn't release games in the UK until the "European" translation was finished!

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by GreenNight on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @07:05AM (#3158040)
It depends. A shooter? Yeah, piece of cake. An RPG? Sorry, but depending on the country no that many people could understand it well enough to follow the story.

TV Series do get around the moment they get on a torrent site, but many many people can follow them thanks to the subtitles provided by fellow viewers. If not they would have a harder time following them.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by tjoff on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @05:23AM (#3157745)
the games actually need to be translated to the local language.

Uh. No.

Also, most games are not translated at all.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by tjoff on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @08:24AM (#3158251)
When I said that most games are not translated I kind of focused on my country (Sweden). If you are from Germany or France you probably have another view of it.

Point is that localization really isn't the only thing that delays a launch in, for instance, Sweden. I guess we have to wait for it to be localized to other parts of Europe before we get to play it in English (or German, but I'd guess that few Swedes prefer German over English). Which is just stupid.

And if it really is translated to Swedish you'd pick English anyway (exception: if you are a group of friends it can be quite fun to laugh at the poor translation).

In a country where you don't dub movies/TV you get quite good at understanding English at a young age and in such a country I don't really think gamers would prefer a localized version anyway.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by wnight on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @02:14PM (#3159743)
It is (just bureaucratic nonsense) if they aren't willing to sell a foreign version of the game to those who want it.

Steam uses region codes, much like DVDs, to deny you the language of your choice - because they screw with prices by area and don't want to lose this ability.

Even Steam's DRM is too much. If for whatever reason they disable your account or some of your games there's nothing you can do. Your games are just gone. As if someone came in and cut up your DVDs. Except that if you had had DVDs you could just re-download them and your keys would still work.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by DanielStraight on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:43PM (#3155285)
EDIT: It was rightly pointed out that I directed my comments to music whereas the topic was games. My thoughts drifted due to the more common association with piracy. Everything I said still applies though. To have a fair discussion, we need to be clear on who is screwing whom and how. And we need to be clear on how they can stop, and whether it is actually within their power to stop.

Original post follows:

Who should stop screwing the customer? And how should they stop?

Any discussion of fixing the music (EDIT: or gaming) industry or stopping piracy needs answers to these questions.

One of the advantages of piracy, one of its conveniences, is that you can get anything you want in one place. But no one is in a position to provide this legally. Spotify (and others (EDIT: such as Steam for games)) would like to, but they can only legally provide what record companies (EDIT: or gaming companies... I think I can stop with the line by line clarifying now; the point is that this applies to all pirated digital content) will provide to them. And they will only provide what it is cost-effective for them to acquire and license. They aren't going to have truly independent artists, because dealing with artists rather than labels isn't cost effective on such a large scale.

The only way to overcome this I can think of is a compulsory license for distributing music, akin to the compulsory license for playing covers. But there's no way I can foresee the unintended consequences of such a fundamental change in how copyright is understood.

But whether or not such a compulsory license is a good idea is not the point. The point is that "stop screwing the customer" is vague to the point of meaninglessness.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by LarrySDonald on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:18PM (#3155446)
There is no law against making your catalog widely available. Yes, currently they seem unable to do so. That isn't the consumers problem (quite literally). Very few things are so awesome that you'll have people begging you to take their money (and root access on their box, the right to revoke the product at any time, etc), so few in fact that the publishers should firmly assume they are not it. If they can't sort that out between themselves, tough shit - customers/pirates/in-betweens will not care. The ball is not in their court and it will be extremely hard to put it there by force.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by wccrawford on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @06:25PM (#3156161)
Who should stop screwing the customer? I thought I was clear on that.

When 90% of the world gets the game in January, and you get the game in July, you feel pretty screwed. Everyone has already explored and spoiled everything. There's very few people left to have a discussion about anything, because they already know. You get to watch everyone else play the game, wishing you could.

That's assuming the game EVER comes to your country. It might not.

And you'll probably pay more for the privilege, even though the game is worth less, for the reasons stated above.

That is, unless you pirate it.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by jamesgeck0 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:18PM (#3155451)
But we're not talking about music piracy. :)

Steam is missing a few major titles (mostly from EA and Blizzard), but it's one of the most complete digital download services. It also seems to be rather indie friendly.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by officemonkey on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @12:31AM (#3157173)
>But we're not talking about music piracy.

But all types of digital piracy are connected by similar economical choices of the consumer.

Valve, iTunes, Spotify, Hulu, and Netflix all combat piracy by being more convenient than the alternative. I'd much rather use those services to get what I want.

However, if content is not readily available digitally, then plenty of people have no problem getting that content via piracy. And the reason they do that is simple: the risk of getting caught and punished is vanishingly small. Even when the RIAA was at it's most aggressive, the number of people sued was trivial compared to the people who were file-sharing.

I think it boils down to this: if you are not in the marketplace, your stuff will be pirated. So get in the digital marketplace and "close the buggy-whip factory" already.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by seabee on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @06:19AM (#3157882)
Steam missing EA's titles is a recent development caused by EA starting their own competitor, Origin.

It remains to be seen whether Origin can gain any traction as a (currently) single publisher platform, but it is required by their new releases, just like Steam back at Half-Life 2's release.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by DanielStraight on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:24PM (#3155480)
Thank you for pointing out my mental lapse. I've edited the post to clarify. I still think the questions are important though.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by forrestthewoods on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:51PM (#3155826)
"Steam's pre-release anti-piracy has no yet been broken"

That's because it can't be broken. You can't break what isn't there. Pre-load only downloads 99% of the game. Let the user download the game sans a few important bits, say the entire executable, and upon release enable download for the last tiny bit. Most retail games release weeks early because it's impossible to stop once the disc hits manufacturing.

Retail discs that require one-time Steam activation can be uncrackable because those important bits aren't on the physical disc. Once a Steam game is unlocked for play it's immediately cracked and released into the wild.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by kornholi on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @08:18PM (#3156523)
I'm pretty sure that it downloads 100% of the game in an encrypted format, and the decryption keys get sent out on release.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by Symmetry on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:15PM (#3155438)
Steam certainly does use DRM, but they use it to provide a service that ends up being providing a better user experience than their competitors. It lets them safely let you do things like download games ahead of the release date or re-download a game from their servers whenever you want onto as many computers as you want.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by polymatter on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @08:52PM (#3156614)
> But it should be noted that Steam's pre-release anti-piracy has no yet been broken. So it's not like they don't do DRM...

I'm not sure what you mean. If you mean that there's been no Steam game that has not been pirated before it was released, I know for a fact the recent game "Orcs Must Die" was pirated. I was impressed playing it at a friends place, tried to buy it on Steam when I got back home but it hadn't been released yet.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by bluedanieru on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @09:54PM (#3156775)
>I'm lucky enough to live in an English-speaking country, but I'm sure that if I lived in a country that typically sees long delays before localization, I'd find a way to get it early. Even if that meant learning English and engaging in piracy.

Well lucky you. Steam is no better in this regard than anyone else though; they do region lockouts. Valve doesn't with their games afaik, but Steam certainly does.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by Tsagadai on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @10:31PM (#3156875)
They do and it is a pain. There is a way around it though. You can use Steams website to buy games. Use http://store.steampowered.com/?cc=XX where XX is the two letter country code you have access to. They still check address and payment details match but this does allow you to use paypal.

The sooner the content world gets rid of silly region restrictions the better we will all be. It is ridiculous that even with trade agreements North American companies insist on charging non-US customers more for a usually sub-par service.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by jasonlotito on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @12:59AM (#3157235)
In many ways, the content world is also limited by local laws. For example, in Canada, media distribution is required to provide a certain amount of Canadian content (iirc). The point is, it's not just one sided.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by sdm on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @12:21PM (#3159249)
This only covers radio and television. The CRTC has been very clear it can't/won't regulate online services. See it's decision a few months back about Netflix.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by wnight on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @02:21PM (#3159778)
Watch it. If they find out you do that they'll disable the games and perhaps your whole account.

Region coding should be illegal. Or rather, enforcing it.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by dorian-graph on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @10:26PM (#3156862)
> .. creating pirates of them.

People choose to become 'pirates' because no one is forcing them to play video games. They have choices—pay for a game, don't play a game (A horrible thing to suggest, I know) or get a game without paying for it (Often called pirating). It's always amused me that people seem to speak of playing videogames as some right that they have and how dare anyone take that away from them.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by redthrowaway on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:30PM (#3155744)
It was a 250-word article; not sure a tl;dr is warranted. I certainly don't think it should be the top-voted comment.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by mattgreenrocks on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:34PM (#3155762)
Yes, it is discouraging seeing willful ignorance (aka, tl;dr) voted up on HN.

If people can't take the time to read the article, they shouldn't comment. Period.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by tjoff on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @05:15PM (#3155911)
Who said anything about commenting? I often enjoy a tl;dr because a tl;dr will, with more accuracy than the title, tell me whether the article is worth reading.

And yes, I almost always check the comments before reading the article (but I always read the article before commenting).

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by mattgreenrocks on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @10:15AM (#3158631)
Oops, my fault.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by rick888 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @06:48PM (#3156242)
so, you need to give them everything for free at the fastest bandwidth possible.

The only way to stop piracy is:

1) give all of your stuff out for free 2) have a service that can't be pirated

The reason big companies don't want piracy to become mainstream is because at a certain point, it becomes part of culture and "normal" to just pirate something, which means they won't be able to charge money for it (everyone will expect it for free). This is exactly what is starting to happen.

Back in 1999, there was no antipiracy technology, yet piracy was just as rampant as it is today. We have: Last.fm, Pandora, Youtube, Grooveshark, etc,etc. Yet, people still pirate music.

It's funny because back when Napster first started, everyone said that the artists weren't getting treated right, so that's why they were downloading music. Now that any artist can pretty music start a website with no record label, those reasons have changed.

I don't think it has anything to do with any of those reasons. Nobody wants to spend their hard-earned money on something they can just as easily get for free.

This parallels many of the people protesting wall street: Just as investing in an education doesn't mean you are guaranteed a good job, investing your time and effort in software, music, and movies doesn't mean you are guaranteed a profit.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by henrikschroder on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @04:04AM (#3157594)
> Yet, people still pirate music.

Do they really?

I remember 15 years ago when a lot of my friends started building mp3 libraries, ripping the CDs they had, and downloaded huge amounts of music.

Now, none of my friends have their libraries anymore, or care about it at all. They use Spotify, or Last.fm, or something similar and never pirate music, because it's simply too much work to do it, compared to just searching for exactly what they want in some paid service.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by towelrod on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @08:25PM (#3156544)
People have spent billions of dollars buying music on iTunes. Its pretty obvious that people will pay for things if its more convenient than pirating it.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by rick888 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @10:08PM (#3156807)
But piracy hasn't stopped or slowed down.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by bad_user on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @04:43AM (#3157671)

     Yet, people still pirate music.
I pirate music from time to time, because (1) I can't find the albums I want from my country on iTunes or similar and (2) wages are lower where I live, and these services are still too expensive. Both issues are fixable however.

It's also the case that some people will always pirate stuff -- but does it really matter when the market got a lot bigger? To me it's really not an issue of price -- BUT I do refuse paying for crappy content or for content that's too expensive relative to my monthly revenue.

The biggest problems with the movies/music industries for example is not piracy, but crappy content. For instance I go watch movies at my local movie theater, and I regret paying for 25% of all movies I'm seeing, even though I'm pretty selective about it. That's just sad.

    Nobody wants to spend their hard-earned money 
    on something they can just as easily get for free.
This is true, but the MP3 file itself is not the only thing you're paying for when using iTunes or similar.

Other things would be convenience (searching for stuff on PirateBay is totally not fun), free online backup (100 GB on DropBox is $20 / month - and with my current needs, I would need 3 times that storage and constantly growing) and the insurance that you're buying quality.

You see, even if people prefer Free all the time, people also think that quality reflects directly in the price paid. That's why people still buy Nike shoes, even though there are hundreds of brands producing cheaper clones with reasonable quality.

And back to searching on PirateBay, I can't count the number of times I downloaded something, only to find that it was not what I wanted or that it was of poor quality. Sometimes whole hours would pass until I found something that I liked, or until I gave up.

And that's the thing -- some people will always pirate, but other people will prefer buying if it is more convenient. And yet other people have this feeling of accomplishment when rewarding authors that they like (me included) ... like 2 days ago I bought a copy of an ebook called "The Making of Prince of Persia", even though you can find the whole book in the author's blog.

Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by rick888 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @10:13PM (#3156828)
I wish people would not downvote based on their own personal opinions.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by contravert on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @11:15PM (#3156966)
The obvious question that I don't see anyone asking is what happens when pirates build a more convenient service than Steam? There is no way a legitimate digital distributor can offer more convenience when they are saddled with many business and legal limitations.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by law_of_poe on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @11:27PM (#3157005)
The obvious question to your obvious question is that if it was possible, wouldn't there be one already?
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by contravert on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @12:02AM (#3157095)
Well it's not beyond the realm of imagination for pirates to create a platform like Steam but offer all games for free. Torrents are somewhat inaccessible to the average user and they they lack content management support.
Re:Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price by alttag on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @08:53AM (#3158328)
PIrates are saddled with legal limitations too. One of the "features" that has allowed torrent sites to be a bit more difficult to challenge is that they're hosting trackers, not actual files. Legal issues affect both sides.