News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet drama in Canada by toast0 on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:52AM (#31526399)
Is Canada allowed to look to England for inspiration? I know the US is prohibited from doing so, but OpenReach is a not terrible model to go with. You've always got to be careful to provide continuity of service, but if you can force the incumbents to operate the infrastructure separately, so that all providers, including the incumbent retail product, must go through the wholesale department, and make those rates FRAND, and prevent cross-subsidization, you can get at least some competition; if you can work towards making that wholesale department independent, even better. In the US, when we had mandatory line sharing, incumbent retail would regularly charge below the wholesale cost, which made it impossible to compete on price, which makes customer acquisition for competitors really hard; then our regulators neutered the law until it barely applied to anything.
Re:Internet drama in Canada by sgt101 on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:16AM (#31527553)
The Openreach model does work in the UK, for now at least. There are scenarios that will bring this down but so long as the government is wise to them all will be ok. Essentially all the government need to make sure of is that the pension liabilities are well managed and no deal that loads it with vast debt or pushes it overseas goes through. Still we will see.

Canada is an interesting one though; the geography is wildly different both in terms of scale (~40x?) and population (60%). Most important : Canada does not have a megacity (London, Paris, New York, LA, etc) London is a pain in the arse to wire up (due to being compact and medieval) but it is very very profitable if you do manage it. This pays for wiring up the tail of the distribution of settlements.

Now in the UK we have a tiny fraction of places that are ~10k from exchanges/local offices (places where the backhaul terminates and you have power and space to put kit in). My feeling is that this proportion in Canada will be much much greater.

This really screws the economics. Repair overhead is exponential on line length (because you have to mount expiditions to get out and fix the thing). Optics is pretty resilliant (it's not bothered by water) but I think those burdens are going to stretch a neutral pipe provider to the limit.

The answer is really that this is a matter for the government and not for private enterprise. Profit motives have limits, the Canadian people need to figure out how much they are willing to pay for rural Canada to have fast internet (> than LEO).

Re:Internet drama in Canada by denton-scratch on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:20AM (#31529944)
As my peer says, Openreach works OK, for now.

But it doesn't work any better than it would work if the network infrastructure were publicly-owned - and arguably coverage in remote areas would be better. And cost and time wouldn't have to be expended on regulation. And there would be no risk of the monopoly infrastructure-provider being bought-out.

There's no sense in having a natural monopoly such as a water or gas pipeline network be operated by a commercial monopoly, and then regulated to blazes. That's just make-work for civil servants. Same for internet cabling. Instead, let the government provide dark cable/fibre, and let retail operators negotiate peering, provide NOCs, and add services like Sport TV (which I don't have a use for).

It's good that there's a market in retail internet provision; I use a fantastic boutique ISP, with almost-instant telephone support from people who know what they're talking about, and don't have scripts. Because it's a market, I can choose to pay more for a superior service.

Re:Internet drama in Canada by zarzavat on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:16AM (#31527557)
If you are looking up to Openreach then I feel bad for your situation. I’m in London and the best I can get from BT is 70 down / 20 up VDSL - advertised as 50 Mbps because presumably some people don’t get even 70. I shudder to think what it’s like if you live in a rural area.
Re:Internet drama in Canada by bpye on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:32AM (#31526969)
> I know the US is prohibited from doing so

I'm assuming this is just a joke, or is there something I've actually missed?