News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by SheddingPattern on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:46PM (#31534040)
Overthinking by definition is thinking too much. What he describes is just thinking
Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by SemanticStrengh on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:46PM (#31534662)
I'd say thinking is the union type of under and overthinking. The approximation error he makes is a limit of our language. I propose to coin the word opti-thinking to fill the semantic gap.
Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by WallyFunk on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:24PM (#31533767)
I do bullet journaling. I don't write blogposts very well, and prefer little actionable 'bullet point' one liners that I execute upon later. Most of my ideas come at night when my brain is super busy. I wouldn't call it 'overthinking' as you can't think about things enough!

Thinking is valuable and not some malady we have to overcome. Come morning, after I caffeinate, and do 5 mins of meditation, I execute on as many bullets as possible. I don't care if I don't complete them all. It's nice to check some off though!

Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by diego_sandoval on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:36PM (#31533916)
If you want to be absolutely right, overthinking is necessary.

If you want to be productive (while being 80% right), it isn't.

I've spent my (short) life overthinking and being "right" about things, but I've noticed that people that don't overthink and just go for something that's just kinda right have better results than me.

Maybe in the upper echelons of achievement (Elon Musk and friends), overthinking is necessary, because they've already used other resources (like, actually doing things) to the point of diminishg returns, and then overthinking can become a competitive advantage.

For the remaining 99.9% of us, actually trying things, even if not 100% right, is better, I think. I'm personally making an effort to reduce my overthinking.

Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by yen223 on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:39PM (#31534596)
Thinking is good only when your mental model is correct with respect to reality.

The best way to get your mental model correct is to do the thing, and learn from it.

That's why people who do things are more likely to have better thought processes than people who overthink things.

Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by DiggyJohnson on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:48PM (#31534687)
> Thinking is good only when your mental model is correct with respect to reality.

Now that’s as good of a blog post thesis statement as it gets. Genuinely well said, this really simplified a really common fallacious pattern of thought that constantly frustrates me. This helps. Put it in a T-shirt.

Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by csquires on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:47AM (#31537921)
amen. couldn't agree more
Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by dqpb on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:18PM (#31534405)
My working hypothesis is that we have a hierarchy of intelligence:

1. Emotional responses are the output of a policy that has been trained over the course of evolution. If you convinced yourself out of an emotional response, but it turns out that the emotional response was correct, then you “overthought” in that case.

2. If you have a lot of experience in a domain, your initial automatic response is the output of a highly trained and compressed policy that embodies your experience, and largely bypasses deliberative thinking. If you convince yourself out of your initial automatic response, and it turns out your automatic response was correct, then this is a case of overthinking.

3. If you are in a situation where you do not have a good automatic response, you will turn to focused thought. The set of active neurons during this focused thought might be capable of reasoning through the problem, but they also might not be. If you continue to focus without making progress, this is a case of overthinking.

4. If you cannot come to an answer via focused thought, often the solution is to stop actively thinking about it so that your brain can enter the diffused mode of thinking, where it can try activating more disparate sets of neurons to find the answer. I would probably not say that someone can over-diffuse-think, but one can wait too long. At some point, its best to start using tools, like writing, or look for the information externally, like reading.

Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by asadawadia on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:01PM (#31533502)
For chronic over thinkers - writing out your thoughts will help relieve the heaviness in your head
Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by drewcoo on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#31533817)
Well the superpower here is definitely not verbosity. I expected something a little more stream of consciousness to demonstrate the alleged overthinking.

Any problem can be your superpower. Well, usually not the problem, but the coping mechanism. If you exhibit a severe disfunction and you're high functioning, there you go . . . superpower.

Maybe the real superpower on display here is concision.

Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by redavni on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:19PM (#31533717)
The risk of underthinking is just too high.
Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by 8jef on Saturday May 28, 2022 @12:07PM (#31541412)
Thinking doesn't bring desired results? Try feeling for a change.

Because the thinking brain only knows about past experiences, it may have problem adjusting to most unknown present circumstances. That's when feeling can help.

Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:34PM (#31533889)
Thinking (analyzing) is a superpower and Overthinking (over-analyzing) is an unfortunate application of Thinking.
Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by copperx on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:16PM (#31533684)
The real problem with the world is underthinking.
Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by s1artibartfast on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:07PM (#31534916)
I think it is more paralysis by over thinking leading lack of action.

If you want to do good, get off the couch and do it.

What you do might not be off the mole but it'll probably be in the right direction, and if not you can readjust

Re:Overthinking can be our superpower if we use it well by lolcat_cowsay on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:38PM (#31533941)
What a stupid post