News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by fbn79 on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @06:48AM (#31502669)
Cookie banner has ruined the whole web. - Does not protect people (99% are just fake. If you reject cookies you keep get them) - Cost money to company (so cost to customers). A simpler browser extension where you manage your preference once far all (default) with the possibility to personilize x site (think like you do for camera permission) would have solved the problem in a real way and without all the hussle.
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by nikeee on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:47AM (#31503167)
> 99% are just fake. If you reject cookies you keep get them

Note that cookies that are technically required to serve the site don't need a cookie banner. This is something many people get wrong. Other people shift to LocalStorage instead. But the actual legislation does not distinguish between cookies and local storage (and similar techniques).

Also, there must be a "reject all" button which should appear visually equivalent to the "accept all" button. Rejecting all has to be as easy as accepting all. Additional clicks are not legal.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by karaterobot on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:26AM (#31505916)
Another thing that is often ignored is that you have to wait for someone to consent before you give them cookies. Many sites just create the cookies when you open the page, then throw the banner, then whether you accept or reject, it makes no difference. Talk about compliance theater.
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by martin_a on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:25AM (#31502969)
Cookie banners just make visible how hard you and your private data have been fucked all over the internet in all the years.

It creates visibility where there was none.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @08:15AM (#31503414)
Indeed, kind of like the graphic disease labels on cigarette packs. It doesn't directly stop people smoking, but it does raise awareness of what can happen.
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by solarkraft on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:51AM (#31503214)
> 99% are just fake. If you reject cookies you keep get them

That's illegal, then.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by Radim on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @06:53AM (#31502700)
That's something the article should have mentioned:

4 years on, and people still think GDPR is about cookies โ€“ and even responsible for the intrusive consent pop-ups!

It is a testament to the power of the adtech giants and all the other shitty shady businesses, how they managed to twist the narrative.

And that's on HN, a presumably tech savvy audience. What chance does the "normal" population stand?

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by jacquesm on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @08:37AM (#31503661)
Lots of people on HN work for advertising companies such as Google, Facebook etc, tech savvy or not has little to do with it.
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by GiorgioG on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @12:57PM (#31507210)
I don't work for an adtech company and I think GDPR has made the web demonstrably worse for everyone. I'd rather void EU clients altogether than put up a cookie banner/popup.
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by jacquesm on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @05:24PM (#31510778)
If that is your response then you haven't begun to understand the reason why the GDPR exists in the first place. You don't have to put up a cookie banner/popup. Have a look at my website: jacquesmattheij.com , no banner, no popup and yet 100% GDPR compliant.
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by dmitriid on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @02:15PM (#31508382)
1. GDPR isn't about cookies, or cookie banners

2. It's not GDPR that made it worse but ad-tech and similar leeches who want to continue vacuuming up all available data without reprecussions

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by adhesive_wombat on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @04:33PM (#31510156)
Here's a genius hack around the GDPR: don't abuse people's data and you don't need a banner at all!
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by happymellon on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:21AM (#31502938)
And if they did that it would also make them GDPR compliant.

They chose to put up cookie banners as a way of making to seem like the people making the laws told them to do it.

> 99% are just fake. If you reject cookies you keep get them

This is silly. The rule is that people are allowed to opt ๐š˜ฬถ๐šžฬถ๐šฬถ in to tracking. Just because some companies use cookies for this doesn't mean that cookies are banned.

If you are using cookies to store your website's settings then that is perfectly fine.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by TamDenholm on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:32AM (#31503038)
> The rule is that people are allowed to opt out of tracking

Sorry to correct you, but the rule is that people are allowed to opt-in to tracking. This fundamental misunderstanding is kinda the problem...

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by happymellon on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @08:05AM (#31503327)
Although I would say that this misunderstanding is not the problem.

The problem is that people think the cookies are the problem, when in fact it's not the cookies but the tracking.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by happymellon on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:33AM (#31503051)
Sorry, yes this is correct.

And even after opting in, you are allowed to opt out.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @08:15AM (#31503410)
Opting-in should be a client feature, not a website feature... make browsers block cookies by default, and then add a button next to the title bar to accept cookies for this webpage (for them to remember the login).
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by happymellon on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @10:51AM (#31505394)
Other people tracking you has nothing to do with the browser.

They need explicit permission to track you. The browser doing absolutely nothing is what most people want.

The website can set whatever cookies it wants for the activity of the website itself.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by Nextgrid on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @10:42AM (#31505268)
GDPR is not just about cookies. In fact cookies are already next-to-useless for tracking because modern browsers have countermeasures against it (which unfortunately does hinder legitimate usage like cross-domain SSO).

The GDPR is about data processing consent as a whole, regardless of how the data was collected. It includes data that you canโ€™t withhold such as your IP address, browser fingerprint, etc.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by gspr on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:32AM (#31503033)
> Does not protect people (99% are just fake. If you reject cookies you keep get them)

Fake cookie banners are illegal under the GDPR. Seriously, in what other aspects of life do people respond to terrible enforcement by saying the law is the problem? (Of course there exists a bunch of stupid laws that are also terribly enforced, but here the objective of the GDPR is not stupid โ€“ it's merely a matter of terrible enforcement)

> Cost money to company (so cost to customers)

Most regulation comes with a cost. The fact that this does, too, is kinda meaningless on its own. Food safety regulation comes at a cost โ€“ that, in itself, is not an argument against such regulation.

> A simpler browser extension where you manage your preference once far all (default) with the possibility to personilize x site (think like you do for camera permission) would have solved the problem in a real way and without all the hussle.

Are you seriously arguing that legislation to enforce such privacy standardization would be easier to enforce than the current GDPR? By all means, what you're proposing sounds great โ€“ better than the GDPR even โ€“ but massively harder to do.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @10:36AM (#31505179)
> in what other aspects of life do people respond to terrible enforcement by saying the law is the problem?

Every other case where the law is widely broken and selectively enforced? From low-level traffic offenses to drug legalization.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by croon on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:23AM (#31502948)
> Cookie banner has ruined the whole web.

No, all websites that have cookie banners do so because they were already ruining the web, the only thing you can blame GDPR for in that regard is visualizing it.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by corrral on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @12:25PM (#31506737)
> Cost money to company (so cost to customers)

You can't necessarily raise prices just because your costs go up.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by titaniczero on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:18AM (#31502908)
GDPR is about personal data, not just cookies.

I agree they should have thought better of that cookie law, which is a different one. But GDPR really was and is on point.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by gpderetta on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @08:14AM (#31503404)
GDPR notices are obnoxious, but they are not the only source of popups, not even the most annoying (most of them are converging to standard patterns, so you can dismiss them quickly). These days many sites have a constant barrage of all kind of popups, browser notifications requests, registration nags, adverts and so on, often on a delayed trigger.
Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by adhesive_wombat on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @04:35PM (#31510183)
> GDPR notices are obnoxious,

They're not obnoxious because GDPR made them that way, they're obnoxious because companies who think they have a right to unfettered and undisclosed abuse of people's data (because that's what they were used to) are trying to pretend that the law is the problem and not their malfeasance.

A fully compliant GDPR banner has two buttons, of equal prominence: reject all, and accept all. That's it. Any obnoxiousness is on thy implementor, and it's likely illegal.

Another fully compliant solution is to only collect the data you actual need and then you don't even need a banner at all.

Re:Statement on 4 Years of GDPR by gpderetta on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @06:43PM (#31511775)
Of course! I'm just pointing out that getting rid of GDPR wouldn't get rid of the popups.