News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by colpabar on Thursday May 19, 2022 @09:08PM (#31442213)
Do people of color ever roll their eyes at websites like this? Does it ever just seem silly?

edit: I am white, and my question is not for white people. I call it “peopleofcoloronhackernews” :^)

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by kenjackson on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:01PM (#31442521)
It’s a little on the nose, but the point is to be an example for other people of color. An illustration that this type of work can be done by “us”.

What I don’t like is when the claims are needlessly exaggerated.

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by colpabar on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:42PM (#31442763)
I can understand that. I just can't not draw the comparison to the way we segregate sports by sex, since males are generally bigger and stronger than females, and I wonder if any POCs see stuff like this in a similar way.

And to clarify - I am not suggesting there is any similarity to that and intelligence, I am just pointing out that websites like this sort of make it seem like that's the case. Please don't assume this is racism, I am here to gain perspective about something I don't understand.

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by kache_ on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:30PM (#31442683)
it's pretty offensive to me, what the huwites would call a racial bipoc

look! he did a thing even though he's one of those XYZs!

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by colpabar on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:46PM (#31442781)
> look! he did a thing even though he's one of those XYZs!

This is exactly what I was wondering. I think I'd feel the exact same way.

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by balls187 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:00PM (#31442513)
No.

It's nice to see positive stories being highlighted.

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by skizm on Thursday May 19, 2022 @09:14PM (#31442247)
"POCIT" was too good of an acronym to pass up on.
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by drc500free on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:17PM (#31442613)
It seems like you want them to. Why is that?

I would think a good number of under-represented people would be interested and maybe inspired.

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by colpabar on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:27PM (#31442666)
I'm genuinely curious what they think, because I am not one, and yeah websites like this do seem kind of silly to me. My question was also for them, and I'm guessing since you said "them" and "I would think", you are white, so why are you responding to it? I understand the intention; I am asking about the actual effect.
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by braingenious on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:43PM (#31442767)
I don’t really mind when people make websites about others folks like me in tech.

I do roll my eyes when people ignore the contents of an interesting article and unprompted go out of their way to inform everybody that they find the existence of sites like that to be silly.

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by PKop on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:46PM (#31442785)
You wouldn't approve of a "Whites in tech" blog so why be so self righteous about this?
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by balls187 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @11:14PM (#31442944)
> You wouldn't approve of a "Whites in tech" blog so why be so self righteous about this?

You mean all the other blogs?

It's safe to assume you also rail against the practice of "Wellness Rooms" being exclusively for use by nursing mothers...

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by PKop on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:15AM (#31443287)
There are no "Whites in tech blogs". Only certain races are allowed to do this. Point me to one? Post it on Hacker News and observe the reaction afterwards.
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by braingenious on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:31AM (#31443363)
I don’t think anyone should or would stop you from buying a whites in tech domain, building a site around the concept and submitting your articles here.

I’m kind of confused as to why you’d ask somebody else to go through the process of building that theoretical site and posting it here though. If that’s something that you would like to exist, why not make it yourself?

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by PKop on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:31PM (#31449648)
>ask somebody else to go through the process of building that theoretical site

What are you talking about?

The poster claimed these types of sites exist, I only asked them to show me the evidence of it, and I implied the reaction would most certainly not be one of passive acceptance or lack of comment like we see with this one. I obviously did not say they themselves should build it.

>or would stop you from buying a whites in tech domain, building a site around the concept and submitting your articles here

I disagree, but I acknowledge someone would have to run the experiment to know for certain.

I do commend you for not being a hypocrite, and supporting others who may also "not mind" when people "make websites about others folks like them in tech".

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by braingenious on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:26PM (#31453295)
>I obviously did not say they themselves should build it.

I’m not sure that that is obvious. You posted this bit of instruction:

>Post it on Hacker News and observe the reaction afterwards.

If the “whites in tech” site doesn’t exist, wouldn’t your command necessarily include creating it? How is the poster you’re talking to supposed to follow your instructions exactly?

>I disagree, but I acknowledge someone would have to run the experiment to know for certain.

How would someone _stop_ you from buying a “whites in tech” domain, using it to write a blog, and submitting a link to this website?

You are trying to make a bit of a fuss about a website that you say doesn’t exist, so why not build it and post about it? I don’t really understand being impassioned about something so squarely theoretical.

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by PKop on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:30PM (#31464656)
It would be flagged instantly.

>I'm not sure that that is obvious.

No, it is. You just missed it.

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by balls187 on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:25PM (#31450872)
People of Color is a race?
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by sackerhews on Friday May 20, 2022 @07:16AM (#31445829)
> You mean all the other blogs? Do you mean all blogs that don't state skin colors in the domain/name are done by white people? That's one of the more racist and demeaning comments I've seen here.
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by balls187 on Friday May 20, 2022 @07:38PM (#31453915)
I mean, all the other blogs that highlight stories of predominantly white men in tech.

If you really feel that white people are poorly represented in online literature, feel free to create a "Whites In Tech" blog.

Also, can you be racist against a ethnic group that is in the majority and wields nearly limitless power?

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by braingenious on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:47PM (#31442790)
Hi do you have any thoughts about bricks made with plastic or are you just here to air your grievances about some perceived cultural slight?
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by PKop on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:53PM (#31442825)
When a blog is titled "Black Woman Engineer Turns Plastic Into Bricks That Are Reportedly Stronger Than Concrete" on a blog called People of Color in Tech, it's going to get commented on, don't be naive.

Maybe if these qualifiers aren't worthy of discussion, they shouldn't be used. If the article was titled "Engineer does X.." on a tech blog not singling out a particular race, it wouldn't be an issue. If bricks and plastic were all that mattered, they wouldn't mention race all over the website. Ctrl+F "Black" on main page... does race matter or doesn't it?

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by braingenious on Thursday May 19, 2022 @11:29PM (#31443032)
> If the article was titled "Engineer does X.." on a tech blog

The title on HN is:

Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly stronger than concrete

I clicked on it and read it because of that. I am, unfortunately for the sake of this conversation, of the opinion that it’s an article about somebody that made plastic bricks. I understand that you appear to have read some sort of referendum about race that didn’t involve engineering or bricks.

If you scroll around the rest of the responses to this article, you’ll find that many people are discussing bricks. Considering that so many of these people, myself included, have completely mistaken the subject of this article, I encourage you to continue complaining about race!

Thank you for your bravery, without your valuable input, nobody would know how important it is to be offended by this!

Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by PKop on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:14AM (#31443275)
They editorialized the title, which they aren't supposed to do, because the real title made them uncomfortable. But forget about all that. The title on the real site is what it is.
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by colpabar on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:49PM (#31442800)
I know it's off topic, but I'm just curious. Also, the website does seem to be silly regardless of who it's for, given that two of the top stories are about NFTs.
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by braingenious on Thursday May 19, 2022 @11:34PM (#31443063)
I think everybody can and should roll their eyes at any site that shills NFTs, no matter the race, gender or creed of the URL 8-)
Re:Engineer turns plastic into bricks that are reportedly st... by chrsw on Thursday May 19, 2022 @11:42PM (#31443105)
No, it doesn't show up on the scale of concern over people who are skeptical of my ability and dismiss my contributions because they're blinded by bias.