Not really. There are a lot of people holding, mining, DCA'ing into projects they believe in who have no trouble at all keeping it to themselves.
Your remarks about gambling are similarly projecting a portion of the community onto the rest. Those traders who treat it as a speculative asset are gambling as you say, and tend to be obsessive in the way you describe, but you seem not to be aware of everyone who deals with crypto differently than you did.
There are a lot of crypto projects that people don't expect to moon, that effectively serve their purpose right now, and will just get better at it in the future. None of what you wrote is nearly as generally true as you made it out to be.
Thankfully there's cool stuff in the ecosystem that isn't a scam, but it's not newsworthy, so it doesn't go viral.
But given how online people are in general (and they're only likely to become more online in the future), it's natural they'll want digitally-native ways to organize themselves, represent ownership, qualify membership, etc.
The shift in concept required here is from viewing a token as "an investment" to viewing it as a form of legible social proof within its community context, which becomes more meaningful as communities grow beyond the "tipping point" where interpersonal proof (think webs-of-trust) is sufficient for coordination. NFTs (yes, they're still around!) are already serving this function for certain experimental communities (and even in less experimental ones, see POAPs).
In general, everything above is still in the experimental, live or die phase. We don't quite know where it's going. But it's pretty damn cool to watch if you're deeply invested in the internet as a medium (and as someone who "grew up online", I absolutely am).
* If it's a governance token system where more money == more power...well, I just don't think it's a good idea in general.
* If it's a system that tries to replicate the idea of one person/one vote, you have to have KYC (and re-KYC upon membership transfer) or it devolves into the first case. Then the entity doing KYC has centralized control over membership, so it seems like storing membership info on a ledger doesn't offer any benefits compared to just having a central membership database.
Regarding the former case, of money and power... this one is a little harder. In theory, if you're a part of some community, and a very rich person wanted to fuck up or infiltrate your community by leveraging their wealth, they could probably figure out a way to do it, crypto or not. At least in this case, the existing community members stand to reap some sort of benefit from it, in the sense that a new whale's buy-in will increase the value of their existing holdings. Then they can all cash out and start a new thing someplace else. It has a similar form and moral valence as neighborhood gentrification (but without the racialized element).
I tend to think most communities will solve this by having some external aim of coordination that discourages people from just speculating (which makes sense given that social proof exists relative to the community in question), even if the balance of power is determined based on buy-in. But again, I don't really know how it will play out in practice, if more regular people will actually take up these tools for non-speculation reasons, etc.
When I say coordination, I mean all sorts of collective decision-making and agency can take place using crypto as a medium, if someone has a vision and enough people are invested in making it happen, see: https://otherinter.net/research/squad-wealth/. Basically, if you need to get groups of people to align themselves and act in concert, and it's happening over the internet, crypto has the potential to make that happen. The technology is fundamentally social in nature, whereas an iPhone is fundamentally a personal object that happens to include some social tooling.
I don't know how it's going to look. Maybe groups will work together to purchase and maintain land. Maybe you'll see digital guilds or unions forming around creative niches. Regen (https://www.regen.network/) is working on communities for landowners who want to get carbon credits. It's really early. Maybe nothing will happen at all, and I'll look back on these posts with embarrassment. But it's exciting to work on projects building stuff that really doesn't exist yet, if only to see what happens.
(oh, and, people really aren't talking about this side of crypto at all. this is an entirely separate thing from bitcoin and defi)
I have seen very few people talking about the price of something in ETH without a parenthetical giving the current USD value.
Also, there are plenty of smart display companies popping up. Check out Infinite Objects or Atomic Forms.
really curious whether what they believe is anything other than “I’ll cash out before it tanks.”
I think that points to the best recourse we have, after the next crash: it needs to be regulated into the dirt.
I suspect they'll aggressively take out stablecoins. They are the only real source of liquidity in crypto. Price action follows liquidity, so hopefully, any future swings will be much much smaller.
Less facetiously: there is nothing orderly about our current schemes. There is nothing particularly fair about them either, unless your definition of fairness is something closer to Thucydides' than a modern one. And predictable? Cryptocurrencies handily defeat our stock market in unpredictability. Not a great set of qualifications.
"regulate it into the dirt" is commonly understood to mean the very real practice of placing so many restrictions/conditions on something that it becomes impractical to operate within the industry of whatever "it" is while explicitly not actually banning it outright.
I tend to agree that there's no reason it should exist, but I'm open to the idea that maybe there's a worthy purpose out there that I'm missing.
But then again, what if what I mean by ban is a "partial ban." Opportunities for misinterpretation abound!
I think people are more rational than you give them credit, but, yes, emotion often informs and overrides our logic. Feelings, emotional intuition, biases, and prejudices color the lens of the eyes through which we see the world. Logic can be like prescription glasses or like Stevie Wonder glasses depending on how we check our priors.
> The reason is because it's very closely related to gambling and triggers the same obsessive thinking as gambling does - based on my observations of how I felt and thought when I did some crypto investing.
I noticed the same obsessive feeling and learned more about myself through that day trading. It was an expensive lesson however.
I was also flooded with some really obvious bullshit... this crash is going to sweep the table clean. There is a chance it might come back cleaner and stronger than before. More mainstream maybe, with some regulation.
The most amusing part is how the general public instinctively reacted to NFTs as thinking they were a scam, but they had so much news coverage and big numbers behind them that it became an Emperor has no clothes situation where it can't be a scam because too many people are agreeing with it. Only for it all to unravel and the public opinion returning to its just a scam.
The SEC just doubled their "cyber" enforcement staff. They're still working down the backlog from the ICO boom of 2018-2019, at the rate of about two scams per month.
I expect the hammer to come down on a number of Metaverse schemes which collected money, promised a fancy 3D virtual world, and failed to ship. That's where an unregistered public offering becomes fraud.
The type of person who tries their hand at cryptocurrency speculation isn't much interested in learning or responsible investment. They are trying to get rich, thinking they will get ahead of the rest of the FOMO idiots. Most don't have the financial resources to consider low-return "safe" investments in mutual funds or the stock market, but they can buy a few *coins for a little bit of nothing and hope it goes up. The crypto-libertarians who see it as a solution to perceived problems with fiat currencies and/or government economic power doesn't seem to have much overlap with the "get rich quick" group.
Except 12-18 months ago we weren't entering into a recession. So, although I am generally bullish on crypto, I am not so optimistic on things coming back to normal any time soon.
Remember the old adage folks - "the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent".
The reason is because it's very closely related to gambling and triggers the same obsessive thinking as gambling does - based on my observations of how I felt and thought when I did some crypto investing - I found myself constantly checking prices and devoting huge amounts of thought to it - I even wrote a crypto trading bot to analyse strategies. If you know anyone into crypto you would know they talk about it non stop.
There are HUGE numbers of people who's brains are deeply involved with crypto. They'll be back for more.
Crypto had a big crash only recently - about 12 to 18 months ago I think, when Elon Musk made some comments that crashed the market. That crash was rapidly forgotten and people piled back in. Same thing will happen here.
Logic is not the driver of people's behavior.
Crypto is essentially legal, consensual large scale ponzi scheme participation - if you understand that then you might be able to win big.