Ask HN: Should I quit my job to sell my stock options?
I am an early employee of a company that IPO'd in the last few years. As such, I am sitting on a (for me) life-changing amount of stock options - mostly already vested. Since IPO I have stayed with the company while many other early employees have left, because I love my job and love what the company do.
However, as an early employee with deep technical knowledge of our tech I find myself frequently brought in to advise on big deals or acquisitions. I am therefore often informed by legal that I am party to material non-public information about these deals and forbidden from trading company stock. This has happened now in three of the last four trading windows, and I have just been informed that it's happening again.
So, do I need to quit in order to be able to realise the value of my stock options? It seems bizarre to me that I should be driven away from a job that I love by something that was meant to be an incentive to stay.
(
15 comments
| 33 points
| on HN
)
However you might want to talk to somebody about setting up a 10b5 plan or talk to somebody knowledgeable to see if it would even make sense. My understanding is these plans are created exactly to avoid the situation that you're in where you want to sell some of your equity but you might hold insider information.
The way it basically works is that you can set rules as to when you want to sell your stock but in the future. For example you might say 6 months from now as long as the stock is over $50 sell it.
The fact that you are establishing the rules in which a sale would execute means that you would not know what the stock price was going to be 6 months from now. Since it's all set way in the future you shouldn't be accused be accused of insider trading, you would have no idea where the stock is going to be in 6 months.
This is how many high level executives sell their equity since they would always have insider information.
When nice thing about this is I think you can even sell during a blackout.
The downside is that you lose the flexibility if the stock was to pop up 200% tomorrow you couldn't sell it since you would not be able to sell on the open market you would be selling through your plan.
Again I've never used one of these so I might not have it correct but I think it's worth talking to somebody about whether this would solve your problem.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/rule-10b5-1.asp
Also, get an attorney. TODAY! Don't even log into your broker until you do. (Joking, but not really.) This is the aspect of your professional life most likely to ruin you and send you to prison if you mess it up. Pleading ignorance to the judge will not save you.
There are also tax-favorable trades you can do, e.g. if you want to donate some of your wealth to charity there are better ways than cash (for both parties). An attorney can advise you and possibly save you many times their fee.
The thing is, if your company has trading windows, you may have to set up (or at least, finalize) the plan during a window and also when you don't hold insider knowledge; but OP has been on notice about holding insider knowledge during the last several trading windows.
It might behoove OP to schedule a vacation/leave leading up to the next window?
You won't need a leave. But you will need a Lawyer, as noted in other comments. GET A LAWYER FOR THIS ASAP SERIOUSLY.
However overall, having substantially all of your net worth and also your paycheck dependent on the performance of your employer is pretty risky and you are likely better off diversifying.
My employment agreement doesn’t say anything about murder or robbery on it. Does that mean I can kill that guy I don’t like and take his stuff?
No? Right, because my employment agreement doesn’t supersede federal laws about violence and theft. Nor, as it turns out, does it grant me immunity from prosecution for insider trading.
The legal team isn’t dick waving here. They’re trying to keep him out of jail and them from being subpoenaed, or worse.
What little I know about the SEC is that, like the IRS, you don't want them to pay any special attention to you, and having employees up on insider trading charges, even if they are dismissed, tends to get you special attention.
The fines for being found doing something bad are pretty high, but the immediate and long-term costs of being found 'dubious' are very high as well. Your company may have to re-file years of paperwork, and then be fastidious for the next ten years. Once you are on their radar you can't skate by doing spirit-of-the-law levels of hygiene on a bunch of tasks. You are having to do letter-of-the-law work on top of it (rules lawyers only lawyer rules that benefit themselves).
I don't know what it takes to trigger an audit by the SEC but I'm pretty sure someone going to jail is one of the boxes on that checklist.
You do probably want to consult a lawyer who is working for you rather than the company to advise on this.
Note: I’m not a lawyer, just someone know knows a thing or two about this.
It's a little odd your legal department is telling you it's forbidden. Maybe there's something in the policies/contract at the company that forbids it. If not, they could be telling you what the company wants you to believe so that you don't sell (violation of the Bar's professional code).