News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kstenerud on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:22AM (#31406008)
The crux of the matter:

"The law voided Friday was on shaky ground from the get-go, with a legislative analysis saying it could be difficult to defend. Then-Gov. Jerry Brown signed it despite the potential for it to be overturned because he wanted to send a message during the #MeToo era."

The true purpose of this law was political career boosting, not actual change.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by mikeyouse on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:15AM (#31406297)
That doesn’t even make sense - Jerry Brown was 79 years old when he signed that law and had already signaled his intent to retire.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kstenerud on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:32AM (#31406387)
Pushing through a law that requires discrimination based on race/gender/etc in a state that constitutionally forbids discrimination based on race/gender/etc does not make any sense (at least not on the surface).

Brown is not stupid, nor is the legal team that worked for him.

Just because you're retired doesn't mean you're out of politics and no back scratchers are beholden to you or you can't act as kingmaker or whatnot. There's a lot more to politics than the office itself. California is famously corrupt in this regard.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by mikeyouse on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:45AM (#31406442)
Alternatively he thought it was a worthwhile policy and hoped the constitution would be amended by the time it took effect, if not, then he had multiple years of his preferred policy in place..

Are all of the unconstitutional ratchet laws that were passed during the Roe era political grandstanding? Or do you think their authors and legislators passed them hoping for changes in the judicial branch that would render them “good law”?

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by patrec on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:15AM (#31407016)
> Alternatively he thought it was a worthwhile policy and hoped the constitution would be amended by the time it took effect, if not, then he had multiple years of his preferred policy in place.

So if I believe something I know to be blatantly illegal is "a worthwhile policy", doing it anyway is OK then, especially if I feel confident I can get away with it for a few years? Does this also apply to policies you personally don't feel to be worthwhile?

> Are all of the unconstitutional ratchet laws that were passed during the Roe era political grandstanding?

Trigger laws you mean? Of course it's political grandstanding, but there is still a night and day difference between having a law which explicitly says it won't come into effect until e.g. Roe vs Wade gets overturned such as here:

https://revisor.mo.gov/main/OneSection.aspx?section=188.017#....

and just passing some law you well know is unconstitutional but trying to enforce it anyway, till the courts actually stop you a few years later.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by throwaway742 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:41AM (#31407195)
I don't think anyone ever tried to enforce it.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by patrec on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:56PM (#31414948)
You are obfuscating. The distinction that matters is if there is an intent to threaten people into compliance with a policy position of yours by creating a piece of legislation you know to be unconstitutional or not. It seems pretty clear to me that this was indeed the attempt.

> The Women on Boards law, also known by its bill number, SB826, called for penalties ranging from $100,000 fines for failing to report board compositions to the California secretary of state’s office to $300,000 for multiple failures to have the required number of women board members.

> The Secretary of State’s office said 26% of publicly traded companies headquartered in California reported meeting the quota of women board members last year, according to a March report.

As you are probably aware, it is a common legal strategy to avoid setting a precedent for some dubious legal claim you know you would lose in court but that is an effective way to coerce others. This works for patent trolls for similar reasons why it likely worked for the state of California (because a lot of times a rational actor would rather comply rather than incur the often greater costs of fighting even if a win seems near certain). It's also quite different from passing some dubious law which plainly states that it does not currently apply and why, as a symbolic act to some constituency. For what it's worth, from memory I don't think all anti-abortion legislation has been mainly symbolic like this, I think there were also cases where legislators tried to coerce people with laws they full well knew would be ruled unconstitutional.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by throwaway742 on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:50AM (#31444151)
It was not my intention to obfuscate. I was just trying to share information. You make good points regardless.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by robonerd on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:35AM (#31406755)
> Are all of the unconstitutional ratchet laws that were passed during the Roe era political grandstanding? Or do you think their authors and legislators passed them hoping for changes in the judicial branch that would render them “good law”?

If we're being real, it's obviously a mix of both. Political grandstanding with plainly dumb laws is definitely a thing that happens. And politicians passing dodgy laws hoping it will work is also something that happens.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kstenerud on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:43AM (#31406805)
> Alternatively he thought it was a worthwhile policy and hoped the constitution would be amended by the time it took effect, if not, then he had multiple years of his preferred policy in place..

That is possible. They did try in 2020, at least for government and public institutions not companies: https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_16,_Repeal_Pr...

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by epgui on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:47AM (#31406456)
> a law that requires discrimination based on race/gender/etc

This is a semantic matter that largely depends on context, but more typically, it is not considered "discrimination" in the legal or usual common sense when it's in reality a form of "affirmative action".

I'm just pointing this out to distinguish the case where "discrimination" can have positive meaning with that where it has pejorative meaning. When making value judgments either way, overloaded word choices can cause more harm than good.

Edit: for those who are taking issue with my comment, please see #7 before you downvote: https://www.usf.edu/compliance-ethics/equal-opportunity/ten-...

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by sharikous on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:22AM (#31407896)
It's not a matter of "typically". A certain political side is pushing to define "discrimination" to apply only against certain groups.

That use is not typical especially when you consider history and the fact that it still differs from the view of the constitution. Moreover it strikes me as disingenuous (like the Soviets calling Western news disinformatzya).

Where does discrimination have a positive meaning?

I am pretty sure that the folks who are against this law will also be against it if you call it "affirmative action" or "positive discrimination" once you explain the meaning to them. From a meritocratic, humanistic, democratic perspective it is just morally wrong however you spin it.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by epgui on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:02PM (#31413513)
This idea of a meritocratic system you have is very incomplete. I'd really recommend listening to what Michael Sandel has to say about that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qewckuxa9hw
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by sharikous on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @06:16AM (#31420996)
Even if you accept his caution about merit it is still morally wrong to make sweeping decisions on basis of sex if you hold to democracy, humanism, individualism... Actually an honest take of taking privilege into account will find that the most important factors are wealth and education, certainly not sex.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by epgui on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @11:01PM (#31430169)
I'm not denying that wealth and education are major hallmarks of privilege, but you can't be honest and say that sex is not an important factor in privilege. That's a whataboutism.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:33AM (#31407539)
> in a state that constitutionally forbids discrimination based on race/gender/etc does not make any sense

That's a pretty strong assertion you're making, that requiring equality is discrimination. I don't agree at all, and I'm not alone. Which means it's not on the face of it obvious if a law like that is actually unconstitutional - anymore than it's clear if the 2nd amendment applies to nukes.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by parkingrift on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:40AM (#31408486)
You’re confusing equity with equality. You can’t have both because equity is an affront to equality. Fortunately, equality is the law of the land and racist or sexist equity laws are illegal.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:53AM (#31408582)
Explain to me what's unequal about requiring boards to be 50/50 male-female? That’s not even how far the law goes, but let’s take it that far. There’s an equal number of men and women born in america. That gives every child born an equal shot at one of those seats. To allow unequal boards would be to allow people to discriminate based on gender when picking board members. To mandate that is to legally require a level playing field. That’s equality, not the equity you seem to have beef with.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by t0suj4 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @07:56AM (#31409140)
If you believed that men and women are equal then you wouldn't have to care about any men-to-women ratios at all.

If you absolutely need proportionate representation somewhere it suggests that each group is unequal.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by HelloMcFly on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @08:27AM (#31409483)
How wonderfully optimistic. Unfortunately, such a belief is built on an assumption divorced from how decisions get made and structural advantages (and disadvantages) not equally shared by groups.

I'd argue most believe that men and women are generally equal in terms of skills and potential given similar circumstances, but recognize that society does not afford them equal opportunity regardless of merit. This operates for more than just gender, of course.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by t0suj4 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:54PM (#31416170)
Giving some group an advantage through a law will worsen its position in other areas of life.

Mandating a ratio will deepen the divide not fix it. I think the society is on a good track to fix this divide in time. Any attempts by social engineers may undermine it.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by parkingrift on Friday May 20, 2022 @10:59AM (#31448382)
Equality means everyone is judged on merit instead of this dystopian view that you’re espousing where people should be considered on immutable physical properties above all.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by moralestapia on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:09AM (#31406595)
It makes perfect sense for "legacy" purposes.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by dariusj18 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:16PM (#31412863)
> The true purpose of this law was political career boosting

That's kinda the whole point of our systems, an attempt to marry personal interest and community interests. Since when is, "Politician does something his constituents want," a headline?

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by LatteLazy on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:09AM (#31407377)
Sorry if I am missing something but... Why is this his problem?

If the legislature want to pass unconstitutional laws that will get struck down, at best he is saving the court sometime by vetoing it. But it is the legislature that is at fault for passing it, not him for failing to stop it, isn't it?

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by jessriedel on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:24AM (#31407475)
He put his signature on the bill after taking this oath:

> I (Governor) do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic, that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California…

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Governor_of_California

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by native_samples on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:00AM (#31407708)
A constitution is just a piece of paper. It only has meaning because people respect it. Passing a law you know violates a constitution is a direct attack on the rule of law itself, and should probably come with penalties attached. Certainly, the fact that politicians in the USA very regularly and blatantly pass laws they know will be struck down by the courts a few years later is one of the stronger arguments I've seen for why the UK shouldn't bother with setting up a written constitution. It's got no teeth. Governments can simply pass and enforce illegal laws, exploiting the lack of speed and capacity in the court system. Then when one gets struck down, just pass another in a similar way.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by frumper on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @11:08AM (#31411853)
What you're suggesting for the UK sounds like a terrible argument. Without the constitution these terrible laws will never be struck down for being illegal because they wouldn't be illegal. Courts can, and do, issue injunctions to prevent laws from going into effect when they are likely to be struck down.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by native_samples on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:47PM (#31414089)
Well, I didn't say I agreed with it, just that it's one of the stronger arguments. Creating a constitution is a fraught project that requires referendums and the like, so people have to believe it works. If courts are willing to injunct unconstitutional laws then why didn't it happen here?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by frumper on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:49PM (#31415528)
I'm not sure why it didn't happen here, but there are a lot of times where it does. Another article mentioned that no fines had been levied because of this law. That might be a reason it was allowed to stay in effect.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by native_samples on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:58PM (#31415607)
Presumably companies were simply complying rather than getting fined. Companies are generally way more law abiding than individuals, it's a rare legal department that would sign off on "let's ignore the law and hope it gets struck down before we get fined and dragged through the mud". Would that even be compatible with the rules around ensuring shareholder value?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by frumper on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:03PM (#31415660)
Companies fail to comply with laws all the time. They suffer fines, recalls, and sometimes nothing for non-compliance. The Secretary of State at the time it was signed into law warned the Governor that it was unenforceable. The Secretary of states office testified during the trial that there was no intention of fining anyone over it.

Edit:

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/judge-says-california-...

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by native_samples on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:04AM (#31422254)
Ok thanks, that's interesting. It sounds strange, but I can see how this isn't much of an argument against constitutions after all.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by robonerd on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:11AM (#31407394)
They're both at fault. Fault isn't zero-sum.