Too tired of the "include us -> we demand change -> we demand you be kicked out -> build your own place" cycle.
I used to be very against any form of gatekeeping. And lost a few really nice communities through that cycle.
We should be kind to each other, for sure, regardless of what _Group_ we're in. Everyone should have equal access to their needs and desires. But. I am not _obligated to allow you to influence me_.
It's also "you are your friends". If you're normally a mild-mannered guy that starts hanging around belligerent unscrupulous types, well, to outsiders you're one of them.
i must be really unique ._.
It reminds me of a modified version [1] of one of the Webcomic Name comics [2]:
grey blubs: you do not fit here
pink blubs: okay we will make our own place
grey blubs: why are you excluding us?
pink blubs: oh no
grey blubs (inside the space pink blubs just built): you do not fit here
[1]: https://twitter.com/reactjpg/status/1272042422340669440
Not accepting someone into group for me does not fall under 'ostracizing' - for me ostracizing is not accepting someone into the group and making such person feel worse and even feel attacked.
Not accepting Joe Badbreath to the "Fresh Teeth" group and letting him know "Hey Joe, you don't belong here because X" for me is not ostracizing.
Not accepting Joe to the group by "we don't accept smelly people here, go away you XX" and then mocking smelly people in the group regarding them as lesser people. - that is ostracizing for me.
Besides those places that are "defending themselves" the community is very healthy.
Somewhere in the vastness of the Internet, it is happening even now. It was once a well-kept garden of intelligent discussion, where knowledgeable and interested folk came, attracted by the high quality of speech they saw ongoing. But into this garden comes a fool, and the level of discussion drops a little—or more than a little, if the fool is very prolific in their posting. (It is worse if the fool is just articulate enough that the former inhabitants of the garden feel obliged to respond, and correct misapprehensions—for then the fool dominates conversations.)"
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/tscc3e5eujrsEeFN4/well-kept-...