News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by goodpoint on Thursday May 12, 2022 @07:23AM (#31352366)
> cyberpunk’s nihilistic dystopian vision has run out of steam

Cyberpunk is NOT advocating for dystopia, it's WARNING US about it.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by causi on Thursday May 12, 2022 @08:39AM (#31353142)
That's exactly the type of savior complex mixed with breathtaking miscategorization you get from solarpunk advocates. They want a cool name and an aesthetic to go along with a socio-political movement so they pretend other artistic movements and styles are also some type of socio-political movement. Imagine seriously believing that steampunk enthusiasts see steampunk as a way to remake the world.

my personal favourite solarpunk inspired designs, was Vincent Callebaut Architectures’ proposal for the new roof of the Notre-Dame Cathedral after the fire

Imagine being so fucking smug you want to radically alter the reconstruction of a priceless historical building to make a political statement.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LewisMumford on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:44PM (#31358440)
It was literally a speculative design. These things happen a lot in architecture. They lay the way for future projects even if they themselves will never be built. They are rebuilding the roof exactly as it was...
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by goodpoint on Thursday May 12, 2022 @01:29PM (#31357228)
> pretend other artistic movements and styles are also some type of socio-political movement

Pretend? It's literally in the first sentence of the wikipedia page:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyberpunk

"combination of lowlife and high tech" ... juxtaposed with societal collapse or decay

Citation: Thomas Michaud, "Science fiction and politics: Cyberpunk science fiction as political philosophy"

It does not get more political than that.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LargoLasskhyfv on Thursday May 12, 2022 @01:43PM (#31357473)
Have you seen the reference you are talking about?

https://www.dezeen.com/2019/05/09/notre-dame-roof-vincent-ca...

I see nothing smug there, just a smart and appropriate upgrade. It fits seamlessly onto the rest of the structure, while the former roof was just a boring affair.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by causi on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:03PM (#31357788)
Restoring a historical object and making deliberate, unnecessary alterations is perverse. If the bottom half of the Mona Lisa was destroyed in a fire would you find it acceptable for the conservator to paint her in a blazer?
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LargoLasskhyfv on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:12PM (#31357950)
I don't care about Mona Lisa. Like I also don't care about many things other people seem to care about. They could tear down Cologne Cathedral and I'd shrug. Back to Paris, I think the Eiffel Tower and Centre national d'art et de culture Georges-Pompidou is more relevant to me, than a place built to worship something which I'm considering a cargo cult. But that's just me.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by robonerd on Thursday May 12, 2022 @12:59PM (#31356772)
> artistic movements and styles are also some type of socio-political movement

Cyberpunk was social and political commentary from the start. Solarpunk is too, but feels less genuine. It feels like a corporate feel-good aesthetic designed for pharmaceutical television commercials hocking anti-depressants.

I've never seen much in the way of social or political commentary from steampunk. Steampunk is extremely kitsch. It looks cool, but there's not much more to it than looking cool and invoking pseudo-nostalgia for the 19th century. At best you get some weak commentary about 19th century colonialism and industrialization chewing people up, but mostly this genre is about glorifying the Victorian/Industrial style.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LewisMumford on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:48PM (#31358501)
To me it feels absolutely anti corporate, even if that twee cartoon was a from a corporate ad. Solarpunk is about conceptualising new ways to invent the future. It's not kitsch like steampunk. It seems like the early days of a movement that could become extremely influential, and I think pushing that idea forward could lead to positive things in the future. Let's reserve our cynicism for things that need it and push these ideas as far as they can go.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by kingkawn on Thursday May 12, 2022 @08:58AM (#31353436)
That redesign looks pretty cool tbh
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by causi on Thursday May 12, 2022 @09:30AM (#31353871)
Sure does. They should go build it. Somewhere other than on top of the eight hundred and sixty year old cathedral.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by tremon on Thursday May 12, 2022 @11:14AM (#31355374)
Why? The original roof is lost, and while we can painstaking recreate it, it still won't be the same roof. So why can't we upgrade such a historical landmark to be a beacon of the future?
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by causi on Thursday May 12, 2022 @11:57AM (#31355994)
Is that a serious question? The same reason we don't add dairy cows to cave drawings or put shiplap on the great wall of China or conduct civil war reenactments with predator drones . It's a historical landmark.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by kingkawn on Thursday May 12, 2022 @12:47PM (#31356598)
Na, the part that’s left is a historical landmark. The huge gaping hole in the roof is whatever we like it to be.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by cupofpython on Thursday May 12, 2022 @11:01AM (#31355242)
okay but why not just take down the entire thing and make something even cooler
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by kingkawn on Thursday May 12, 2022 @10:10PM (#31362466)
Because that would be destroying history. Filling in a fire-made gap with something new is no more intrusive to the building than a restoration that bears all the hallmarks of this era anyway.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by cupofpython on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:00AM (#31368537)
It is no more a destruction of history than to intentionally make it different than it was. It isnt ideal to need to repair it, but the more we can preserve the effect on our senses (sight) of the original the better.

If you fundamentally alter the way it looks, it is no longer a historical reference. It is something new, albeit with an interesting history / story.

If you redesign it, you should also rename it.

When something is repaired to the best of our ability, the future can look back on it and understand the context that we were trying to make it as it was - and all the hallmarks of this era will be identifiable as the minimum amount.

If we redesign it, we make it more about us and our current time. the future will likely be able to redesign it better, so it's just going to look like an ugly patch that is way too extra.

If we prefer to make the building about us and our current time, we should just destroy the entire thing and rebuild it from scratch as a full redesign.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by kingkawn on Tuesday May 24, 2022 @10:27AM (#31492575)
The idea that we can make preservation repairs will be exposed as a fallacy a few decades after we've tried, when it becomes clear that our objectivity at the time was just regular hidebound contemporary trend following. Might as well embrace it and make something cool.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LargoLasskhyfv on Thursday May 12, 2022 @01:34PM (#31357309)
Depends on how you look at it. It could also be seen as desensitization,

to soften you up for acceptance of "there is no alternative" via shock doctrine.

Furthermore, also depending on how and where you look at it,

we've long overtaken the warnings of 1984, Brave New World, Fahrenheit 451 and following, at least partially.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LewisMumford on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:44PM (#31358425)
It didn't say anything about advocating. It was a vision of the future that cam true in a lot of senses. But now it's run out of steam. It seems dated. New visions of the future are necessary, and solarpunk is one of them. That's the point.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by tomc1985 on Thursday May 12, 2022 @09:47AM (#31354110)
Yeah this article seems to have a really poor understanding of 'cyberpunk' and it's motivations.

He also calls an underground, generally unpopular aesthetic "tired". Cue my eyes rolling to the back of my head so hard they snap connecting nerves...

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LewisMumford on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:52PM (#31358578)
Underground and generally unpopular aesthetic? Really? Biggest sci-fi movie of the 80s? Blade Runner. Biggest sci-fi movie of the 90s? The Matrix. And these aren't just the biggest sci-fi movies, they were huge cultural phenomena when they came out. They definitely transcended the genre. Following those kinds of things the cyberpunk aesthetic became so ingrained in reality we barely even see it anymore. Screens of adverts plaster every new city centre. Even the term 'cyberspace' and other internet slang literally came from cyberpunk novels. All of that is mentioned in the cyberpunk articles. But the point is it's outdated and we need to work beyond it and create something new which can have a similar influence on the future.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by tomc1985 on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:20PM (#31358999)
They were practically the only cyberpunk movies with any significant impact. And what have we had over all these years on the gaming front? CP2077? Deus Ex? Shadowrun? And a handful of indie games? Sure there were a bunch... in the 90s.

So... one big cyberpunk movie every 10 years? Games every few?

Marvel, fantasy, all that other pop culture garbage sees new movies on a seemingly monthly cadence.

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely adore cyberpunk as a genre and warning and seethe at watching the optimistic yuppies drag 'punk' through the mud with their 'rebellion against negativity' garbage. But cyberpunk is not a popular genre.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LewisMumford on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:40AM (#31366788)
The fact that the two most inflential sci fi movies of all time are both cyberpunk tells you all you need to know. Even the fact they decided to make a modern CP2077, and how hyped it was, shows how much cultural force the genre still has. Neuromancer and Snow Crash are two of the best selling SF books of all time. Facebook literally named their new company Meta so they could push the 'metaverse' which was coined in Snow Crash... The list is endless honestly. Saying it's not as popular as Marvel means basically nothing. Superheroes are like modern day capitalist myths at this point. The whole purpose of those movies is to sell.
Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by tomc1985 on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:27AM (#31368874)
And my point is that over the last 20 years or so, I found myself spending a lot of time wishing there was more cyberpunk content out there.

Also I'm pretty sure Star Wars and Star Trek were as big, if not bigger.

Yes, The Matrix had a huge impact -- I was there for it. But that was as much about the revolution in VFX and cool shots than it was about having a cyberpunk setting. Besides, all of the followups (save for the Animatrix) have been duds.

CP2077 came to be because CDPR likes to take unknown franchises and elevate them to greatness; this is true for both The Witcher polish novels and the Cyberpunk TTRPG. While I think the demand for cyberpunk is certainly there, as evidenced by the folks' enthusiastic support for CP2077, I would not consider cyberpunk to be the dominant force in sci-fi. (The lukewarm reception for both the modern Blade Runner remake and the new Matrix confirm this opinion for me) I would suggest you consider your thoughts in a wider context.

> two most inflential sci fi movies of all time

Can you qualify this statement a bit more? I don't really agree here. The Matrix doesn't even appear in this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-grossing_films and the numbers here aren't worthy of the kind of praise you're heaping on it: https://www.the-numbers.com/movies/franchise/Matrix#tab=summ...

It wasn't even the highest grossing film the year it came out, as it was eclipsed by Star Wars: Episode 1.

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by LewisMumford on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:32AM (#31407120)
>Can you qualify this statement a bit more? I don't really agree here. The Matrix doesn't even appear in this list

It's obviously going to be somewhat subjective, but if take film critics or scholars words to have any weight since they are constantly comparing these things, The Matrix and Blade Runner are almost always at the top of 'Most Influential Sci-fi Movies of All Time' lists. e.g.

Empire: 1. BR 4. Matrix https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/best-sci-fi-mov...

Screenrant: 1. Matrix 4. BR https://screenrant.com/most-influential-sci-fi-movies-of-all...

Vogue: Not ranked but both are in the top 10 https://www.vogue.com/article/most-influential-sci-fi-films

Cultural ifluence doesn't equal financial success. (There are tons of best seller books out there that sell far more than classics ever have, but are forgotten about almost immediately after). The impact both films have had on popular culture is gigantic. Think of all the movies, TV shows, and cartoons that parodied or copied their styles. There's tons of scholarship out there on it too, but still it's always going to be somewhat subjective.

But yeah I somewhat agree that cyberpunk style was starting to die out in the early 2000s, I just think it had a revival recently due to the fact that certain elements of cyberpunk really came to fruition in recent years. https://bluelabyrinths.com/2018/12/05/cyberpunk-1-0-visions-...

Re:From Cyberpunk to Solarpunk: Technics and the Cities of t... by _Microft on Thursday May 12, 2022 @07:39AM (#31352497)
Elon Musk has entered the chat.