News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by zolosa on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:10AM (#31340174)
Indians account for 73.9 percent out of the total number of H1B visa holders in the USA.

Now i wouldn't want anyone to be discriminated but still it makes sense to limit green card based on nationality

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 0xcafecafe on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:46AM (#31340719)
Why though? If Google is hiring an engineer, it doesn't make a distinction and does so purely on skill. Why should it matter if said engineer is from Argentina (arbitrary example) instead of India?

The US issues roughly 1 million green cards each year. 86% of those go to family based immigration. The rest 14% are for employment based immigration. Even in there the dependents (spouse + kids) are counted against that quota. So net effect is close to 5% employment based immigration if we count only primary applicants. What purpose is discrimination by country of birth serving here?

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by meowtimemania on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:13AM (#31341158)
Benefit is greater diversity. Rather than have majority of immigrants from hugely populated countries like China or India, immigrants are more evenly distributed from all around the world. The system obviously has big downsides to individuals from India/China. If it can be proved to US citizens that it’s in their interests to get rid of the cap, I think it will be gone.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by screye on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:31AM (#31341472)
What makes arbitrary geographic borders markers of diversity ?

The language, religious practices, food, festivals and traditions change every 100 miles in India. It is an old civilization with as much or more diversity than all of Europe.

Small countries like Belgium, Netherlands and Austria can balkanize and claim diversity over minor differences. Yet, Indians are clumped together under 1 umbrella ? How does that make sense ?

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by geodel on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @01:43PM (#31343335)
What makes skin color marker of diversity ? This is world we live in.

India can have diversity claims if they let individual states in India their passports, languages, flags and so on. It's on them to show diversity before expecting others to appreciate it.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by screye on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @01:56PM (#31343507)
It gets even more ridiculous if we try to use 'physical' differences. It then becomes about genes.

Guess what ? Everyone who lives out of Africa has a common-ish ancestors as far as 80k years ago. So, Africans are significantly more diverse than the rest of the world combined.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 0xcafecafe on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:26AM (#31341386)
Diversity can be preserved for 86% of the green card quota. Why does need to be there for the other 14%?

Already this is forcing companies to make investments in offshore centers as it is difficult to hire here. There is enough proof this is bad for Americans but the current political climate makes any change impossible.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by valarauko on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:59AM (#31341833)
Doesn't the country cap also apply for family sponsored greencards?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by deltree7 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @01:36PM (#31343239)
Indians and Chinese make 40% of the global population, but only 1% of US population.

So, clearly the diversity of US isn't representative of the global population.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by amf12 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @02:03PM (#31343611)
> Benefit is greater diversity.

There are other "diversity" visas. One is a literal diversity lottery and a family permanent resident visa. Does it not make more sense to look at qualifications for employment petitions.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by yangikan on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @02:02PM (#31343597)
You get enough diversity from the 85% of people who come in through family based immigration. So, the majority of immigrants are not coming from countries like China or India irrespective of whether this discrimination persists or not.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by raverbashing on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:15AM (#31341190)
The purpose is twofold: diversity of origins and the fact that there are 1.3Bi Indians for 300Mi Americans

Diveristy actually means not getting everybody from the same place, being that inside or outside the US

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 0xcafecafe on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:28AM (#31341419)
We are talking about 14% of the total annual green card quota, 140,000/1,000,000.Everybody is not coming from same place and it will be a pure FCFS system if these archaic quotas are gone.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by tablespoon on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @06:09PM (#31346519)
>> Now i wouldn't want anyone to be discriminated but still it makes sense to limit green card based on nationality

> Why though? If Google is hiring an engineer, it doesn't make a distinction and does so purely on skill. Why should it matter if said engineer is from Argentina (arbitrary example) instead of India?

Because the priorities of the system don't have to be the same as Google's. Specifically, the US decided it prefers to get immigrants from everywhere rather than letting a couple big countries flood the queue.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by tarentel on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:18AM (#31340317)
If there's a demand for certain roles, which clearly seems to be the case, what difference does it make where the people filling those roles comes from?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by jaywalk on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:30AM (#31340477)
I'll flip your question on its head: why are the people filling these roles so heavily skewed to one country?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 22SAS on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:02PM (#31341864)
Most of the people who are interested in moving to the US, as expat workers, are mostly from India. Let's break this down piece by piece:

1. Canadians have TN visas, so they prefer to use that since there is no lottery for that and it's a simple process of taking your offer letter and have CBP stamp a 3-year TN visa. Even though it is not dual intent, people can and do apply for green cards on TN status since for Canadians the wait times are current and they can get a green card before they need to renew their TN visa.

2. Australians have E-3, so that is what they will use.

3. The Chinese use H1B's but the numbers have dropped as more Chinese prefer to stay in China or return there after their foreign education since a lot of big Chinese tech companies have sprung up.

4. Europeans either do not want to move to the US, they sometimes don't try to have a prospective employer sponsor for H1b visas since a lot of them seem to believe that Indians have a monopoly on those visas.

You're left with mostly Indians, most of who study STEM subjects in college, overwhelmingly come to the US for studies and then hop on to work visas post-graduation. Most of the highest paying tech employers in India are American companies even then many Indians still want to move to the US since there are still a lot of socio-political and quality of life issues in India.

Take all these points and that's how so many H1B's go to Indians.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by cuteboy19 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:48AM (#31340744)
It's a combination of factors

1. India is poor but not too poor

2. It has a huge population

3. A lot of upper class Indians already have family in the US

Of course, it is not clear why any of this should matter. Why should it be capped by country (as opposed to continent, zipcode or planet?)

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by rlewkov on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:10AM (#31341119)
IMHO it matters because of the "D" word ... diversity
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by cuteboy19 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @02:01PM (#31343582)
Considering that the people who have the easiest time with this system are from Europe/Canada or Australia maybe the D word ought to be discrimination
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by d3nj4l on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:45AM (#31340697)
Let me flip your question too: why do you think it matters?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by jaywalk on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:07AM (#31341072)
Because all else being equal, that skew shouldn't exist. There is nothing inherent to Indian people (or any other people) making them better at these jobs, so there is value to understanding why their numbers are so high. And by value, I mean value to US citizens. It could show us how we can improve within the country, or it could expose fraud in the system. Or a mix of both.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by valarauko on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:24PM (#31342148)
> There is nothing inherent to Indian people (or any other people) making them better at these jobs, so there is value to understanding why their numbers are so high.

Their numbers are so high simply because they represent almost a fifth of humanity - there are almost as many Indians as there are people in Europe, South & Central America put together.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by enriquec on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:29AM (#31341436)
This is just obviously and factually wrong. Even average age differs greatly between countries. Why would they have the same degrees/skills/value? You just want to chop down the forest because trees are different heights - you're optimizing for nothing based on nothing.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by codegeek on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:42AM (#31341598)
So what about Basketball ? Should there be more whites ? Is that skewed by design ? Have you ever thought about the various factors behind why a certain group dominates certain fields or you just think it is unfair and on purpose ?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by jaywalk on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @01:21PM (#31343033)
It's funny that you bring up sports, because one of the hot topics in the sports world right now is that there should be less whites in many positions, from coaching to ownership.

It's supposed to be accepted as fact that if there are a lot of non-whites somewhere, it's simply because they're better. But if there are a lot of whites somewhere, it's because of racism.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by codegeek on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @01:53PM (#31343466)
You didn't answer my question though and deflected. I am not talking about whites being discriminated (thats a separate topic). I am discussing the "skewed" comment you made. Why do you think Basketball has less whites ? Let me add a few more. Why do you think a lot of Gas Stations are owned by Asians ? Why do you think a lot of Landscapers are hispanics/Latinos/South Americans ?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by illplaythatgame on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:21AM (#31341300)
>>>> Let me flip your question too: why do you think it matters?

Sure, it matters because there are tens of millions of black, hispanic, and latino US citizens -- numerous with CS/STEM degrees -- who cannot get into FAANGs. Many end up in retail or as best buy tech squad reps or tmobile store salespersons.

Yet we're told that someone from a foreign country is a better candidate for these FAANG jobs. In my experience, half the foreign workers cannot even speak english legibly.

Do Americans and the US Government owe at least some chance to local citizens who are being passed over for jobs generation after generation?

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by frontman1988 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:54AM (#31341761)
Surely there must be something the profit driven FAANG companies are seeing that they prefer hiring broken English speaking Indians over American hispanics/blacks with tech degrees?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 22SAS on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:04PM (#31341885)
With FAANG companies it is not as much profit driven as much as it is that they get an employee who will have to work harder than others due to keeping their visa, and will stay for longer at least until their green card processing is complete and they have their I-140.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by amf12 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @02:10PM (#31343707)
> Sure, it matters because there are tens of millions of black, hispanic, and latino US citizens -- numerous with CS/STEM degrees -- who cannot get into FAANGs.

FAANGs aren't discriminating against black, hispanic and latino US citizens. If someone can't get into FAANG its not because of their "race" or "citizenship", it's because they can't pass the hiring bar -- whether hiring is broken is another question, but hiring isn't biased against blacks latinos and hispanics.

> Many end up in retail or as best buy tech squad reps or tmobile store salespersons.

This comparison is disingenuous. Had you said they therefore have to work in the government sector as software engineers, I'd say you might have a point. But your comment reads as: "because they can't get a job as at FAANG they work at t-mobile as salespeople.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by enriquec on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:30AM (#31341450)
So you're saying the hiring process is racist?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by screye on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:57PM (#31342682)
The hiring process is racist all-right. But, the direction of that discrimination might not always align with the most commonly held intuitions.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by fallingknife on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:23AM (#31340385)
Well, I would prefer them to come from the US instead of allowing companies to import cheaper workers from abroad.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:29AM (#31340470)
Why is that?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by jaywalk on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:32AM (#31340522)
The US government is supposed to first and foremost take care of US citizens, not just allow them to be pushed out of jobs because corporations would rather import cheap labor.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by zamalek on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:10AM (#31341113)
Oh, this tired talking point.

In the tech labor market (as per the post) the labor simply isn't available. We don't generally see American software engineers languishing and unable to find jobs.

I guarantee that the like of Microsystems, Google, and Amazon were not paying the poster a pittance.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by nebula8804 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:29PM (#31342245)
>We don't generally see American software engineers languishing and unable to find jobs.

That was me from 2016 to 2018. Trust me, there are weirdos like me out there in the country that can't get a job. I decided to go all in on this exciting tech stack called Ruby on Rails. I heard all the cool kids were doing it. Spend all my life savings trying to get in on the action. What I didn't realize is that they were all unemployed......as a result I don't think Matz is so nice.

I'm ok now, wasting my life writing one line of code a day on software that does not make one lick of difference in this world (and no its not in ruby on rails): The American dream™

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by illplaythatgame on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:24AM (#31341364)
Not sure who you hang out with, but black, hispanic, and latino US citizens have a very hard time getting jobs despite having software engineering degrees. They end up in GS-5 equivalent military tech "careers" or crappy geek squad jobs.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by renewiltord on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:52AM (#31341729)
If you have friends in each of these categories who are skilled, I’ll interview them. Job is onsite in San Francisco. Interview is leetcode style plus software design.

Since it isn’t based primarily on past experience, it won’t matter that they haven’t had opportunity if they do have the skills.

I’m in HFT. Only hire people I’d consider capable and I’m comfortable with our interview process. If they knock the interview off the hook they’ll be in. Let me know.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by nebula8804 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:35PM (#31342317)
Nobody wants to work for your crappy startup. What you are asking for requires a lot of sacrifice and investment (living in an overpriced dump called SF, leetcode interviews, dealing with people like you) for not enough benefits hence thats why you rely on outside "help".
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by zamalek on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:58PM (#31342700)
> Nobody wants to work for your crappy startup.

I rest my case.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by nebula8804 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @07:31PM (#31347345)
I wish you luck in filling those seats. You are probably gonna need it with those requirements.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by zamalek on Thursday May 12, 2022 @05:36PM (#31360406)
We're _not_ hiring engineers because we're already flush with an extremely diverse team.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 22SAS on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @01:10PM (#31342872)
I am in HFT too. Your firm, Cutler Group by any chance?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by renewiltord on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @07:39PM (#31347421)
No, we're a much smaller prop shop. Are you in SF? Want to hang out?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 22SAS on Thursday May 12, 2022 @08:49AM (#31353288)
Sorry, I am in Chicago. I'd be happy to meet up sometime if I am visiting SF, or you are visiting Chicago.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by renewiltord on Thursday May 12, 2022 @11:18AM (#31355445)
No problem! Just reply to my latest comment on HN if you are. Should be fun! Exciting times right now.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 22SAS on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:18PM (#31359684)
If you'd like to stay in touch off HN, could I ping you on the protonmail address on your profile? I made one for myself after looking at yours, haha.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by renewiltord on Friday May 13, 2022 @02:10AM (#31363936)
Yes! That’s what it’s for! Looking forward to talking! :)
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by sdfhdhjdw3 on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:16PM (#31358944)
I'm in HFT and Chicago. How can I get in touch with you?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 22SAS on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:17PM (#31359673)
Thanks. You can ping me at [email protected]
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by tarentel on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:47AM (#31340730)
I agree with your first statement. I've never felt threatened by imported cheap labor in my role though. I think our immigration laws should protect US citizens but what they seem to be doing is allowing companies to hire people for cheap but not giving a very good path for those people to become US citizens even though they're contributing to US companies and the US economy as a whole.

If you're worried about losing your job to cheap labor that's an issue with our immigration system not a problem with immigration in general. You should be asking yourself why companies are allowed to pay non-US citizens less for the same jobs we're doing.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by jaywalk on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:54AM (#31340850)
I, personally, have zero fear of being replaced by cheap labor. I've climbed high enough in what I do and I know how valuable my skillset is. But I see it all over the place, and it still concerns me.

> You should be asking yourself why companies are allowed to pay non-US citizens less for the same jobs we're doing.

I would ask myself this, but I know the answer. It's because these companies have our lawmakers in their pockets. That is the problem that really needs to be solved, which would take care of this and many other issues.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:44AM (#31340692)
I agree with that.

Do you agree that should be weighted by the need of the country to remain competitive, say in the hypothetically scenario where we came to the conclusion that the average american is lazy, and that that's the core reason why immigrants replace them?

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by jaywalk on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:57AM (#31340901)
The entire reason we have this system is so that the country can remain competitive, which is an important and valid reason. But it was never meant to be what it has become, which is just a way to import cheap labor. It needs to get back to what it was supposed to be, which is a way to bring in highly-skilled labor that simply can't be found in the US, at the same pay US citizens would receive.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @01:20PM (#31343020)
You have it backwards. Not importing cheaper labor would make it less competitive.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by meowtimemania on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:19AM (#31341253)
The country shouldn’t act in the interests of the “country” but rather in the interests of its citizens. “Replacing” the citizens (sounds a little genocidal) is not in the citizens best interests.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by mtoner23 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:41AM (#31340629)
Yes but these people and their children could also be US citizens why should they not be prioritized?
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by jaywalk on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:10AM (#31341110)
I'm not understanding how people imported from abroad could be US citizens.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 29athrowaway on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:50AM (#31340785)
In other words, a brain drain, which is the real problem to fix.

There is no amount of money that can make you truly happy being away from your friends, family, your culture, etc.

If there were good opportunities in India, people would be happier there.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by cletus on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:34AM (#31340537)
This is an emotional subject. I've gone through this but come from a country that has a relatively easy path.

The source of the huge delay for Indian-born people is these four facts:

1. India has a population exceeding one billion;

2. Green cards have a diversity rule that no more than 7% of applicants can come from a single country;

3. Your category is based solely on country of birth not country of citizenship; and

4. H1B visas have no per-country caps or quotas (beyond the total annual quota).

The companies that are really ruining this for anyone are the bodyshops like Tata and Infosys who direclty benefit from the situation. As the article mentions, if you have a pending I140 petition you can stay beyond the 6 year limit and changing jobs is dangerous. So employes get to hold this over employees creating an indentured servant type situation for 10+ years. These bodyshops flood applications and create the lottery problem.

There are numerous problems with all of this and (I really do hate to say this but it's true) the only administration who even made noises about reforming the H1B system was the Trump administration like basing H1B on salary (these bodyshops pay low for software engineers). None of this came to pass.

Here's one big problem: children ageing out of the system. If an Indian national has a pending green card petition and their child is born outside the US and that child gets to age 18 before the petition is approved, they are no longer eligible to receive a green card as part of their family's petition. Given how long Indian delays are, this may mean deporting someone to a country they left when they were 6 months old and have no memory of. They may not even speak the language.

Prior to the pandemic a couple of bills floated around to fix this backlog, most notably S369 [1]. These all ultimately went nowhere and (IMHO) had a lot of problems. For example, this didn't really increase the annual caps (it did, kinda, by only counting the petitioner and not their family against the quota) and eliminated the per-country cap. But what this would've done is made things terrible for everyone else for a transition period of years.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31338329

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 22SAS on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:10PM (#31341965)
I am an H1B holder and an Indian national. The bodyshops alone did not screw this up. A TON of Indians come here for graduate school, the main motive being that it is an easier path to getting a job here in the US. A lot of them also end up on H1B's and have their companies sponsor them for residency permits. A lot of those students have zero passion in what they're studying but it's all ok for them for a chance to work here.

A family friend's kid just arrived here for his MS CS. He told me upfront that he plagiarized all through his undergrad and couldn't write basic programs. I was like "why on earth would you purse an MS in CS then?". I saw a lot of folks like that.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by 0xcafecafe on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:53AM (#31340841)
Attributing all the problems to those bodyshops is a bit disingenuous IMO. Yes they are part of the problem. Even Chinese nationals face 5+ years backlog for their green cards. Limiting immigration from populous countries based on arbitrary country caps for employment based immigration makes no sense. As it is it is a small piece of the overall immigration pie (14% and if we count only primary applicants, ~5%).

What is happening due to this is all advocacy to fix this has to be done by the folks in backlogs (Indians & Chinese) and the rest of the world folks can happily go about business as usual. Yes, H1 reform is needed but green card reform is needed yesterday.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by cletus on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:41PM (#31342416)
All of the factors I listed apply to China. But even though both countries have similar populations, around two-thirds of H1B applicants are Indian nationals. Bodyshops are a big factor here. This flood of H1B applications is a big factor in everyone having to go through a lottery.

So if two-thirds of the H1B applicants are Indian nationals but the current system caps per-country green cards at 7% (per category), you see why Indian nationals have a much longer wait time than anyone else.

In saying that I'm not denying others (eg China, Mexico, the Phillipines) don't have long wait times too.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by huy-nguyen on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @03:24PM (#31344578)
This is a great point that is rarely mentioned. China has larger population than India yet has a much shorter backlog so is it really the fault of the US immigration system that India has a long backlog? The Indian outsourcing industry and India’s lower level of economic development are parts of the problem.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by valarauko on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:33PM (#31342305)
Why do you suppose that is? Indians are forced to remain on H1B visas for decades while other applicants move onto Green Cards.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by throw123123123 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:27AM (#31340433)
What doesn't make sense is putting limits whatsoever.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by meowtimemania on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:22AM (#31341313)
Why does it not make sense? Imagine you have factory workers making 15$ an hour and a company decides to import labor to work at 10$ an hour because there’s “no limits” to immigration. The government should act in the interests of its citizens.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by throw123123123 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:33AM (#31341488)
It's in the interest of citizens to get their goods at the cheapest price. Thats why you have imports, which is no less than importing the produce of labor.

With people, you have the added benefit that if people working within your country they spend and consume in your country.

Countries all over the world fight each other for talent, and the US immigration system is doing to itself what other countries spend money to prevent.

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by thunkshift1 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:01PM (#31341851)
My theory: green cards only go to christian nations
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by muzaffarpur on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @03:32PM (#31344672)
Do you know what discrimination means? This is literally discrimination. Yes, it is encoded in law, still is discrimination. Imagine this, next time you getting interviewed by someone, and he rejects you,because you are not chineese/Indian. Then you'll be discriminated and that would be acceptable, per law. I'm sure your definition of discrimination won't change then.
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by robinsoh on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:51AM (#31340805)
> Now i wouldn't want anyone to be discriminated but still it makes sense to limit green card based on nationality

You're saying you want people to be discriminated by nationality. Correct?

Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by np- on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:26AM (#31341387)
Not the op, but to be pedantic, every single international border crossing in the world is an official government “nationality discrimination” department. That’s what passports are for. (Not saying I necessarily agree with this, but it is the world we live in)
Re:My journey through the American immigration system as a c... by robinsoh on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @12:38PM (#31342366)
I'm just trying to understand the meaning of "I wouldn't want anyone to be discriminated" in the context of "Now i wouldn't want anyone to be discriminated but still it makes sense to limit green card based on nationality". I just think it is unclear. If we want to discriminate by nationality then we should just admit it and say we're going to discriminate by nationality instead of being covert about it.