News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by arcticbull on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:47PM (#31331727)
> Disclaimer - I have invested 1% of my savings into stable cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin and Ethereum etc.

... well, this individual appears not to know the definition of stable, but do go on.

> Cryptocurrency returns are a zero-sum game i.e. if 1 person gets a $10 profit, another person has to lose $10.

First, equities are positive-sum games, which makes them, on the whole, in the fullness of time, a strictly better investment. It is not true that someone has to lose for someone else to win in the equity markets. Shareholder returns are derived from the business itself.

Second, proof-of-work currencies are negative sum, since the miners have to expend unfathomable quantities of electricity and generate mountains e-waste. This costs money. This money is obtained by selling the block reward, which puts negative price pressure on the cryptos. So not only are the only source of returns other gamblers, there's also a hole in the bucket. In gambling parlance, that's the rake in a game of poker.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:55PM (#31331847)
> So not only are the only source of returns other gamblers, there's also a hole in the bucket.

But there's also someone constantly filling the bucket with pretend water (Tether) faster than the real water falls through the hole.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by thebean11 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:49PM (#31331751)
> Second, proof-of-work currencies are negative sum

Assuming the network doesn't produce external value to the people transacting on it (for example, lower transaction fees than alternatives, lower cost to enforce contracts, lower spread trading equities or currencies etc).

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by arcticbull on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:51PM (#31331787)
> Assuming the network doesn't produce external value to the people transacting on it (for example, lower transaction fees than alternatives, lower cost to enforce contracts, lower spread trading equities or currencies etc).

The hypothetical value generated accrues to those who hold equity in the miners or network operators (stakers in a PoS system) - not the tokens themselves. If Starbucks pre-sold coffee as tokens, the fact that Starbucks is selling more or less coffee means nothing for the value of the token.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by thebean11 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:12PM (#31332062)
I'm talking about value created for users of the network, not token holders miners or stakers.

Let's say I use the network to send $5k to a relative in another country and this transaction costs me $1. If I otherwise would have paid $5, then $4 of value is created external to the network itself.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by arcticbull on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @05:35AM (#31337654)
The way I'm looking at it: if I save money moving dollars using Wise instead of PayPal, that doesn't change the value of a dollar. So why would saving money moving dollars using ETH instead of Wise change the value of either ETH or USD? The value doesn't accrue to the token holder in any case. Am I missing something?
Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by thebean11 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @09:55AM (#31339981)
To some extent it does. The person moving money is paying transaction fee in ETH creating demand for ETH. Additionally, a part of that transaction fee is burned (permanently deleted) creating a deflationary effect on all other ETH.
Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by arcticbull on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @03:02PM (#31344321)
I can see that argument, yeah. Curious to see it quantified, but I concede.
Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by thebean11 on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @03:11PM (#31344407)
The ETH burning is easy to quantify: https://watchtheburn.com/

Currently there are inflationary block rewards so the net may still be ETH creation (depends on the day). That will change after the merge when inflationary rewards are removed though.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by jonny_eh on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:51PM (#31331785)
> Assuming the network doesn't produce external value

They don't, definitely nowhere near the amount currently invested.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by thebean11 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:13PM (#31332079)
Sure, the point is there's a difference between:

"this system is currently costing more than it is producing"

vs

"this system, by definition, is negative sum"

The first is a comment on the current state of the thing, the second is an immutable statement about the thing's nature, which in this case is false.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by PaulHoule on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:52PM (#31331797)
but isn't it really higher transactions fees, algorithmically enforced 'contracts' that get exploited by hackers, ... ?
Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by thebean11 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:36PM (#31332338)
Yeah that's true in practice but I think a lot of new tech was in the same boat. The first cars were much worse than horses to use an old example
Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by notch656a on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:54PM (#31331833)
>Second, proof-of-work currencies are negative sum

You could have just said currencies are negative sum. Your argument doesn't pertain exclusively to crypto. It cost electricity and resources to print and wire transfer dollars and yen, for instance.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by arcticbull on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:56PM (#31331865)
I suppose so, but currencies aren't investments. There's a big difference in how they're marketed. Your goal is never to hold dollars for a long period of time - after all, average case the dollar goes down at minimum 2% per year. Your goal is to productively allocate that capital into actual investments.

On the other hand crypto is marketed as an investment that you are to hold for long periods of time. Crypto is sold as something that goes up over time, and should be compared to other things that are marketed that way.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by notch656a on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:06PM (#31331986)
I suppose it depends on how you use the underlying instrument.

Some people use currencies or their derivatives as investments, particularly forex traders.

Some may use crypto essentially as a currency. The 'marketing' isn't unified and depends on who you listen to. For instance, the bitcoin whitepaper itself doesn't promise real returns on 'investment.'

>On the other hand crypto is marketed as an investment that you are to hold for long periods of time

I'm with you that this is probably not a good viewpoint to take, but I don't think that's the only viewpoint out there on how to use crypto.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by arcticbull on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:11PM (#31332038)
In Forex trading, you're short-selling one currency and buying another. It's not an investment, it's a pair trade. Nobody buys USD or NZD or any other currency expecting to walk away with more value in the currency itself. You're making money on the divergence or convergence in purchasing power of a currency in one country vs. another.

Your goal is to walk away with more units of your currency than you had to start, not that each of those units will be worth more.

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by notch656a on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:19PM (#31332146)
>you're short-selling one currency and buying another

>It's not an investment, it's a pair trade.

So borrowing USD and selling it to buy BTC means you're not investing in BTC?

Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by arcticbull on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @06:05PM (#31333312)
Hm, that's fair. I guess I could say you're not investing in the currency but rather in the convergence or divergence of their relative purchasing power in their domestic economies. I'm not trying to be nit picky, I'm open to being wrong here.
Re:You shouldn't invest in the crypto currency? by gogo61 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:25PM (#31332209)
*relatively stable. I know you are referring USDT as stable coin.