News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by beebmam on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:19PM (#31319896)
That's 60% marginal rates.

Last year I paid 17% of my total income in taxes.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by hervature on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:52PM (#31320271)
I don't want to be rude, but if you paid 17%, that's basically the minimum income tax rate (10+4+3) for NYC. That's pretty far form the OP's "NYC high earners". Of course, if you got credits, that's orthogonal as normally those credits cost more than they are worth. For instance, the child credit is far from the cast of raising a child.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Spooky23 on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:54PM (#31320950)
If you own your home and are married the rate comes down until you make >500.

I live in NY, not NYC and pay ~18%, or ~22% with property tax.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by lr4444lr on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:56PM (#31321506)
I can't think of what county you must live in where you'd be able to afford a home in NYS and pay that little in fed+state+local without any special deductions.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Spooky23 on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:11PM (#31321629)
There are 57 of them. :)
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by ABCLAW on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:09PM (#31320469)
If you're a "high earner" there are a panoply of services that allow you to structure your income, wealth appreciation, or other forms of wealth generation in tax-optimized vehicles.

The tax universes at 200k/yr and 500k/yr-2m/yr income look very different.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by huuman12 on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:41PM (#31321383)
If you’re earning 500k-2m from your own business/investments, this might be true.

If you’re earning that as w2 income (as many of the nyc high earner taxpayers are), then yeah you’re gonna be paying >50% taxes if you live in nyc.

Speaking from my own experience.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by mortehu on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:24PM (#31320651)
If we're talking wages here, what are the options exactly? Is there anything bigger than 401(k)?

This is ignoring charity, which I believe is available to anyone anyway.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by MrWiffles on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:39PM (#31320797)
I believe - someone more financially literate (and far richer!) correct me if I'm wrong - that you can convert some of those wages into various different vehicles and get paid in non-wage forms in certain cases. Correlation != causation of course, but if you're making $500k/year chances are pretty good a large chunk of that is non-wage income such as capital gains, corporate bonuses, trust funds, etc. And even if it was all wage-derived, over time you could easily realize major capital gains on it if you're lucky enough to (a) make a huge chunk 'o change, (b) have low-enough cost of living to be able to move it into investments and then (c) have enough life stability to be able to continue this pattern for several years or decades (or better yet, have grandparents and parents who did then passed the wealth down to you). Even after taxes as high as 50%, with enough raw wage income you can definitely pivot your "margin" into vehicles that yield serious ROI over time, and can even leverage the highly disparate cost of living to your advantage: use NYC's housing market to justify a ridiculous salary, then live super cheap out there somehow (insert hand-waving magic reference here), and use the difference to buy housing out in, say, rural Texas or Kansas before the pandemic, rent it out via property company, reap profit month-after-month.

From there you follow the directions on your shampoo bottle:

1. Lather

2. Rinse

3. Repeat

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Spooky23 on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:31PM (#31321283)
401k, HSA, 529s for state taxes. You can give children gifts up to $28k, which is taxed at the kids rate. There are games you can play with home equity loans.

If you own a business there is a thousand ways to do it. One thing I’ve seen is people’s businesses “donate” to private schools and then get “merit” scholarships for their kids. You can accelerate depreciation of up to $500k of assets, etc.

If you’re smart, you’ll sometimes pay less tax in high tax states. Usually the low tax states have higher property and sales tax rates.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by kelnos on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:52PM (#31321974)
Re: 529s, do remember that tax treatment varies widely state to state. I was bummed to learn that California doesn't offer any deductions for 529 contributions.

(Of course the tax treatment for qualified withdrawals is the same regardless of where you live.)

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by ABCLAW on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @07:25AM (#31325785)
A number of the comments to your post have some vague sense of what's going on.

The key concept is that as you get more wealthy, you will have access to professionals and tax structures that allow you to defer and recharacterize significant portions of your revenue streams into tax advantaged forms. The exact mechanisms change depending on jurisdiction and asset mix.

Advisory services take money to purchase, but their cost, and the cost of various vehicles used to avoid taxes, do not scale linearly with the amount of wealth to shelter.

The panama and various other financial leak disclosure reporting provide a decently accessible area for lay-persons to investigate. If you'd like to see the effects of scale - there's a lot of literature regarding the multi-national corporation side of tax avoidance in academic journals that's easily found via google scholar or sci-hub.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by tbihl on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:51PM (#31320913)
I am not an accountant nor someone who benefits from these deductions, but I'm casually interested. From what I've seen, a few: 1. Charity can be meaningfully different from chipping in $200 to something if you can afford to pay for large parts of a program, meaning things can have your name on them, or you can get events that you care about hosted at your church while saving on your taxes. 2. Tax advantaged accounts everywhere. Max out all retirement of course, but also education accounts for your four kids. Then I think there's some interesting tax advantages to whole life insurance, but I don't know which end those come on. 3. Structuring more of your life as a business. For example, I use my affordable car almost exclusively for work but it's not worth the trouble to track it for deductions because I still do best with standard deduction. Once you pass that, may as well track everything. And you should buy a large SUV instead of a minivan for your family so you can use the more favorable depreciation schedule that encourages SUV use over minivan and car use. Deduct your laptop and phone and phone plan because if you're making a lot of money, there's almost no chance you're using those for personal stuff more than for business. Probably some travel and dining fit as deductions too. Clothing, maybe? This is all completely legitimate (well, maybe it's not because of my ignorance on particular applications, but the spirit is consistent with how deductions work.)

You also may have the ability to structure some of your income as business appreciation so as to not pay taxes yet. True, it's still trapped until you pay taxes, but it's still resources you have available to you that haven't yet caused you to suffer tax expenditures. As a rule, you should never volunteer taxes that you can legally defer.

It'll all add up, though probably not to an overwhelming amount. My impression is that a lot of the exaggerations of low tax rates come from very slimy accounting driven by agendas (to say nothing of expressing taxes in a given year as a fraction of total accumulated wealth.)

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by DenisM on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:12PM (#31321634)
> For example, I use my affordable car almost exclusively for work but it's not worth the trouble to track it for deductions because I still do best with standard deduction

That's not how business expenses work. Talk to an accountant, you're leaving money on the table.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by jrodthree24 on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:05PM (#31320433)
Probably depends what you mean by high income. I think someone making 100k will not pay that much and that is considered high in a lot of places. But I am not sure that is considered high in NYC. High is probably more like 150k - 200k+ and that still wont be anywhere near 60%.

I do get to ~40% when you add up federal, state and city. I don't think anyone is really looking at an actual 60%. Maybe 50% if you're making like over a million.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by colatkinson on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:33PM (#31320747)
Median household income in NYC for 2020 was $67k [0]. $100k (especially for a single earner, as is often the case in tech) is considered quite high, but not outrageously so if that makes sense? That's "1BR apartment in a nice but not too trendy neighborhood outside of Manhattan" money, so well on the upper side of middle class. I think people tend to overestimate how much money those outside of the tech bubble actually make.

[0] https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcitynewy...

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by charrondev on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:40PM (#31320812)
I’m in Quebec so I paid 29% on everything over 66k to federal and my provincial rates were 20% (over 50k), 26% (over 100k), and 29% (over 150k).

We also have a 15% sales tax. I paid more than a 50% effective rate last year. This is the cost of our social safety net. It feels like too much too me and I’ll be relocating next year.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by bawolff on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:47PM (#31320871)
Quebec has one of the higher tax rates in canada. You still get a similar safety net in the rest of canada for lower (albeit still high if you are a high earner) taxes.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by charrondev on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:29PM (#31321264)
Yes, for sure. I’m not sure what causes Quebec to be so much higher. Our health care system has struggled immensely with the pandemic even with so much funding.

We may have a stronger government programs than most (subsidized parental leave, subsided childcare, subsidized French language media, etc), but almost none of them give any benefit to me.

Part of the difficulty to me is our high rates seem to kick in very early. A lot of other regions also have very high top tax brackets, but very few places are starting their top tax brackets at 100k/y income.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Taniwha on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:16PM (#31321141)
yeah here in NZ we pay 39% marginal over $180k, 33% $70k-180k - no state tax - mostly free public health (5$/drug $100 max per year, $30 to visit GP, nothing for hospital/urgent care/everything else)

What we don't do is spen d all our money on a military industrial complex

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by dahfizz on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:44PM (#31321401)
> What we don't do is spen d all our money on a military industrial complex

I know it's a bit of a meme, but military spending is far from our only problem. We could cut military spending to $0 and not even make a dent in the defecit, let alone be able to cut taxes. Social security, Medicare, and medicaid together make up 42% of federal spending. (Not to mention food assistance, housing assistance, unemployment, or the dozens of other programs). The US spends a lot on social programs! We just don't get much of anything for it.

EDIT: for completeness - defense spending was 12% of the federal budget in 2021.

[1] https://www.thebalance.com/u-s-federal-budget-breakdown-3305...

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Taniwha on Monday May 09, 2022 @11:39PM (#31323168)
last year we spent 25% on social welfare (everything from retirement pensions to the dole), 17% on healthcare for all, 13% on education (from preschool to tertiary) - military was ~3%

One big difference of course is that here in NZ the govt owns the hospitals and doesn't run them for profit, no one takes a cut providing insurance either. We bulk buy pharma for the entire country. We also have a no-fault accident insurance scheme that takes personal injury out of the courts (fewer courts, fewer lawyers, smaller law schools in universities)

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:38PM (#31320115)
You paid much more than that. A substantial part of your rent is property taxes. I also doubt you included sales taxes in that number. Then there's more esoteric stuff like tariffs, etc
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by thebean11 on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:42PM (#31320164)
NY has low property taxes compared to most no-income-tax states
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by vlan0 on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:50PM (#31320251)
Where is that?

My parents lived in North County and paid 13k+ a year on a $350k house. Their current place in Tampa is about 400k and the taxes are less than half of what they were in NY. Maybe Florida is a special case?

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by thebean11 on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:17PM (#31320561)
I'm basing this off of apartments in NYC. I often see ~$600k co-cops with $800 monthly co op fees (of which half is maintenance half is taxes). That seems low to me compared with similarly priced homes elsewhere.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by citiguy on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:18PM (#31321689)
Property tax in New York City tends to be lowered because there is also an income tax. Try comparing homes outside the city.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by dman on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:03PM (#31321029)
NYC has has a city tax on your income. If you are living in the tristate area youre paying one way or the other :)
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by lotsofpulp on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:53PM (#31320289)
WA is also lower than NY. I have a few properties, and I would say property tax is 0.75% to 1% of market value, max.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by RHSeeger on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:29PM (#31320707)
NY's property taxes are among the highest in the nation (top 10).
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by d_burfoot on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:20PM (#31321179)
Spot check, here's a ~1M apartment in NYC, vs a ~1M house in New Hampshire:

https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/41-W-72nd-St-APT-8C-New-Y...

https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/491-Marcy-St-Portsmouth-N...

Property taxes on the NYC place are estimated by Zillow at 715/month, while NH place is 1445/month. NH has no income tax.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by RHSeeger on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @02:19PM (#31330504)
So, I made a comment that it was in the top 10. Then you listed one that was dramatically higher. While I agree that NY doesn't compete for the top spot; your example in no way invalidates my point.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by lotsofpulp on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:30PM (#31321281)
NH is uniquely tilted towards real estate property taxes because it has no income and no broad sales tax.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by xtrimsky1234 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @08:27AM (#31326246)
NY has insane property taxes. I pay 11k for a 400k house. I have not seen property taxes so high anywhere else in the country.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by jonahbenton on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:34PM (#31320751)
No. Property tax rates are extremely- some would say criminally- low in NYC. I would think it unusual for more than 20% of rent to go to property tax.

Mortgage much much more likely to be the dominant expense for a residential landlord, but varies significantly with age.

There are many longtime landlords for whom their tenants are now nearly all profit. Which is INSANE.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:39PM (#31320793)
Why are you assuming he lives in NYC?
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by halfmatthalfcat on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:16PM (#31321144)
Because they are responding to the OP (who is talking about NYC) and further elaborating on NYC taxes, while describing their (supposed) NYC tax burden.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:40PM (#31321373)
OP didn’t say anything about NYC?
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Aunche on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:14PM (#31321654)
Prices are determined by supply and demand. Both are rather inelastic, especially in a highly desirable city like NYC, so very of the property taxes gets passed to the renters. If this weren't true, then renters in California would see savings from prop 13, but clearly that isn't happening.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:47PM (#31321936)
Bobby gave Lisa $10. Lisa then gave $3 to Uncle Sam. What percentage of Bobby's money went to Uncle Sam? 30%. It's that simple. Bobby gave Uncle Sam 30% of his money.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Aunche on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:20PM (#31322217)
If you use that logic, 100% of Bobby's money goes to Uncle Sam after a long enough chain of transactions.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @12:45PM (#31329261)
We can stop at 3rd parties. That's reasonable enough.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by dwallin on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:47PM (#31320223)
You can't just assume tax increases directly lead to increased 1:1 consumer prices, that's not how supply and demand works.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:48PM (#31320243)
Where did I assume that?
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by ABCLAW on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:10PM (#31320487)
>A substantial part of your rent is property taxes.

Here.

Without determining elasticity, it's impossible to determine how much of that cost is flowing through or how much goes to impact margin.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:28PM (#31320693)
You're making a pretty fundamental mistake. I am not speculating about the elasticity of rent. If taxes went to 0, would rent go down? Probably not.

So what?

The percentage of rent that is taxes is exactly the amount paid in taxes by the landlord. Period. It is an absolute number.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by colinmhayes on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:27PM (#31321250)
But if property taxes go up you'd still be paying the same rent. I don't see how it makes sense to say you're paying property taxes when they have next to zero effect on your cost of living.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:58PM (#31322032)
> I don't see how it makes sense to say you're paying property taxes when they have next to zero effect on your cost of living.

Why do they need to have an effect on rent for you to understand that you're paying them?

Bobby gave Lisa $10. Lisa then gave $3 to Uncle Sam. What percentage of Bobby's money went to Uncle Sam? 30%. It's that simple.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by colinmhayes on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:02PM (#31322061)
It’s not Bobby’s money that went to the government. It’s Lisa’s.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by ABCLAW on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @07:09AM (#31325667)
>You're making a pretty fundamental mistake

No I'm not. This is pretty entry level econ material. Price elasticity is very well studied and there's plenty of resources to learn more about it.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by dwallin on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:58PM (#31320353)
- A substantial part of your rent is property taxes.

Without detailed analysis there's no way to know if this is true, or how true it is. It is entirely possible for an increase in taxes to lead to no increase in end prices or even a drop in rent prices. It's a complex system.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by akimball on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:19PM (#31320595)
All property taxes are paid from rents unless the landlord is operating at a loss.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by colinmhayes on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:28PM (#31321261)
Landlords are price takers. Supply is fixed short/medium run so just charge the maximum people will pay. Property tax rates have next to 0 effect on that.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:04PM (#31320427)
I didn't say anything about increases in taxes. You added that. I also didn't say anything about increases or drops in rent. You added that again.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by jonathankoren on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:49PM (#31320245)
The renter is not paying the property taxes. The landlord is. This feels like a slight of hand that leads to double counting.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by revnode on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:59PM (#31320366)
That's not how things work. When you file your taxes, your rental properties will be treated as a business and the taxes paid there are a business expense. They are deducted from any rental income before the income is counted for the landlord. It is essentially as if the renter is paying the government directly.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by abfan1127 on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:00PM (#31320373)
I'm entirely sure that landlord is not taking a loss on those property taxes. It is passed onto the renter.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by azinman2 on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:59PM (#31320365)
And what do you think rent price includes?
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by sixothree on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:40PM (#31320806)
And don’t forget your healthcare costs.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by sdenton4 on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:49PM (#31320889)
"To some economists, the question is moot: Americans already pay a massive “tax” to fund health care, they say. It just happens to go to private insurance companies, rather than the federal government."

...

"Health insurance costs raise the average effective tax rate on American labor from 29 percent to 37 percent, they said."

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/10/16/americans...

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by countvonbalzac on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:39PM (#31320126)
Rent is not tax, what an absurd comment.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Manuel_D on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:41PM (#31320149)
The point is, the apartment owner pays property tax and collect rent from tenants to pay for that. If property taxes go up, property owners raise rents to compensate. So the tenants are paying the property tax, albeit indirectly.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by strombofulous on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:52PM (#31320279)
If the tenants will pay and it doesn't break any rules, why not raise rent before taxes go up and pocket the extra? (serious question)
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by winstonewert on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:52PM (#31320918)
If one landlord raises the rent, this will tend to make renters go to other landlords who are not raising the rent. But if the taxes are increased on all the landlords, they will likely all raise their rents together and renters can't simply go to another landlord who isn't raising the rent to avoid the increase.

Its actually much more complicated then that, depending on factors such as the propensity of landlords to cease renting out units if their profit decreases, the propensity of renters to shift to smaller dwellings in the face of rent increases, etc.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by neon_electro on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:19PM (#31320588)
This happens all the time. Deciding whether a raised rent price is justification for moving out is a complicated and personal process and yet it fuels all of the response to landlords that do this.

Also, 1-year leases are typical in the U.S. (at least Philly/NYC northeast U.S.), so from that contractual perspective, your rent can go up every year and that's totally legal.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by dwallin on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:55PM (#31320316)
Landlords are also competing with each other and tenants have limits based on what they can actually afford to pay. At some point they can be forced to move out of the city to a lower cost of living location, dropping demand. In fact it's entirely possible for a significant increase in tax rates to make rental units a poor investment, causing housing prices to plummet and rents to drop.

Your mistake is assuming that people who bought up housing stock are guaranteed future profit on their speculative investment.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by disillusioned on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:10PM (#31320485)
Step 1) Raise taxes on rental properties astronomically.

Step 2) Force out investor class and/or repossess properties out of tax adjudication.

Step 3) Public housing!

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by Manuel_D on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:18PM (#31320579)
> In fact it's entirely possible for a significant increase in tax rates to make rental units a poor investment, causing housing prices to plummet and rents to drop.

How does this logic work? Building apartments becomes a bad investment. Then developers don't build apartments. And somehow constrained supply is supposed to result in lower prices?

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by IX-103 on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:16PM (#31321143)
What if developers built too many apartments so there is no shortage? What if the builders all decided to tear down the cheap apartments and build a bunch of Luxury Condominiums when the the housing market is full broke college students who can't even afford to cover the taxes on individual units?

You can say the market won't let it happen, but the second case is the current real estate market for the town I went to school in.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by listless on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:42PM (#31320168)
I’m a landlord and yes it is. My taxes doubled last year because of the stupid housing bubble and so we had to raise rent as well. Gotta make a profit here for this investment to be worthwhile.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by ryan_lane on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @01:56AM (#31323931)
Sell your building. Your taxes went up because your property value went up. You aren't entitled to a profit on rent. If you sell your building below what it's valued at, you'll still make a hefty profit, and it'll cause the value of other buildings to lower.

Land owners seem to feel entitled to businesses with no risk. Costs are always passed down, even if it makes people homeless. I'm more than happy with you going out of business if an event that makes you richer isn't an event that you can handle in terms of cost.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:00PM (#31320375)
Maybe if people didn't buy property they don't live in as an investment then things like the stupid housing bubble might not happen in the first place.

Personally I think owning a residence you don't actually live in should just straight up be illegal, but I'm admittedly pretty radical about parts of the system that seem to exist solely to make the rich richer.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by RHSeeger on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:35PM (#31320764)
So, if I am going to live in an area for a year... I should be required to purchase a house, including all the money, time, and effort that involves? I would hate to live in a world where that was the case.

I have both owned and rented at different points in my life. There have been times where renting was a better choice for me, for a variety of reasons. I am glad that renting is an option.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by coding123 on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:31PM (#31321289)
In a world where there was no rentals there would probably be new things we can't imagine such as community ownerships. The specific thing that shouldn't exist - in parent commentors and myself is that the renter is paying money so that the actual owner pays off the property for their benefit, not the renter.

If some kind of community property system exists (not for ALL properties but a large number of them) then any rent you pay in say New York is also paying down a virtual mortgage you have the the "community" that spans the country. Like a virtual HOA.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by cleftie on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:44PM (#31321405)
That's how it used to work in the UK with social housing. The local authority would collect the rent and it would be used for upkeep of the properties, with surplus going to other public works. This was set up in the decades following the Second World War as Britain rebuilt, and it generally worked really well.

But then a right-wing government came to power and sold most of the social housing off, while banning local authorities from building any more. So now, we have the situation here where the large majority of tenants are renting from private landlords, who are just pocketing all the rent for themselves and doing the bare minimum upkeep, while holding a rapidly appreciating asset.

Which is exactly what the right-wingers wanted, but of course doesn't help everyone else who isn't a landlord, and just wants somewhere decent and affordable to live.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by barry-cotter on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:13PM (#31321114)
> Maybe if people didn't buy property they don't live in as an investment then things like the stupid housing bubble might not happen in the first place.

Sure would be awful for a rental market to exist. Without rental there’d be only be home owners and homeless and that is clearly a better world.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by rabuse on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:20PM (#31320599)
If government reduced their hold on zoning restrictions and allowed for more properties to be built, we wouldn't be in this mess. Supply and demand.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by IX-103 on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:37PM (#31321339)
I'm not sure of your logic.

There's no guarantee that builders will use the loosened restrictions to build the most efficient housing. In fact they will most likely build the most profitable housing instead.

The most profitable is on the high end - so marble countertops, stainless steel appliances, etc. All the builders will race to build as much of that as they can, as fast as they can. Then, when the market is glutted, they'll be unable to sell off their investments. Builders will end up with their capital all sunk in cheap land and expensive housing. no one can afford to buy. The builders can't sell the cheap land since they leveraged it to pay for developing the expensive housing. They can't sell the expensive housing because the market has temporarily dried up. The builders will just wait until the glut resolves and continue business as usual.

Meanwhile, there is not really that much more actual housing for the low end market. Some builders made a bunch of money and some craftsmen got extra work building houses they can never afford.

Capitalism at it's most typical.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by barry-cotter on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @05:01AM (#31324968)
> Then, when the market is glutted, they'll be unable to sell off their investments. Builders will end up with their capital all sunk in cheap land and expensive housing. no one can afford to buy. The builders can't sell the cheap land since they leveraged it to pay for developing the expensive housing. They can't sell the expensive housing because the market has temporarily dried up. The builders will just wait until the glut resolves and continue business as usual.

If there’s a glut in the market prices fall. If you have invested a lot of money in something in the hopes of selling it at a profit and you can’t you go out of business and your assets are sold. So if you over leverage and prices fall you go out of business and lose all your assets and the bank may lose some of its assets. Housing supply increases though. In a market where there’s excess demand at current price points (rising prices) that’s good.

Capitalism doesn’t make ever increasing housing prices, zoning does.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by listless on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:30PM (#31322297)
I respect the honest response. In my case, I'm not rich. I’m just trying to build up enough passive income to retire someday. There’s no pension for me. I can’t depend solely on my 401K. I’m just trying to be moderately responsible about my own future.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by thebigman433 on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:15PM (#31320546)
> My taxes doubled last year because of the stupid housing bubble and so we had to raise rent as well. Gotta make a profit here for this investment to be worthwhile

Surely you see stuff like this is part of what is driving this very bubble?

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by listless on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:26PM (#31322265)
Yeah - that’s not lost on me. I didn’t even pass the full cost on. I’m still down. Just trying to hedge my losses at an acceptable rate.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by colinmhayes on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:30PM (#31321277)
You should've raised rent sooner. People clearly willing to pay.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:40PM (#31320139)
If you're renting, your landlord is paying property tax and passing it on to you.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by kevin_thibedeau on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:45PM (#31320200)
Some states let you deduct a portion of rent in place of property tax.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by jonathankoren on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:51PM (#31320262)
By that logic, no one pays taxes except consumers.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by prepend on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:28PM (#31320695)
I mean you’re sort of right. There’s no such thing as a free lunch. So stuff is all ultimately paid by the consumer since that’s the end of the line.

There’s really no way to increase taxes without impacting consumers. Unless you try to limit rents, but then you have other problems with people not wanting to invest in apartment buildings.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by paulmd on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:12PM (#31321103)
That assertion depends on an efficient market though, and that is provably not true - the existence of corporate profits demonstrates this, because in an efficient market everyone makes 0 profit, and any rent-seeking will cause every single one of your customers to flee to a competitor who doesn't rent-seek. Everyone has to price as aggressively as possible given the costs, or lose customers to someone who does, and that means zero profit above the actual cost of production/service.

In a world where corporations make profits, some competitors choose to eat the taxes and retain customers, while others may increase prices and lose some customers, and some customers may eat the increased price and remain even though they're getting a worse deal than before. This is the concept of "consumer surplus" vs "producer surplus", and taxes are cutting into those surpluses differently depending on the specifics of each market participant.

All of this has been debated endlessly by economists, in terms of just how much of corporate taxes get passed along to consumers and so on. And the answer seems to be "not zero, and not 100% either", and everything beyond that is up for debate. So no, not "everything is ultimately paid by the consumer", that is the 100% answer and that's pretty clearly wrong in a market where producer-surplus exists.

In reality, real-estate and rents are probably one of the least-efficient markets imaginable. The frictional costs to buying and selling property, and finding a new tenant who might be a problem/deadbeat/etc, or spending a bunch of time apartment-shopping, picking up your life and packing your stuff, and moving, are immense, and all parties involved are highly emotionally invested as well. Landlords are trying to make a long-term calculation about whether the property is going to appreciate - even if they are losing money today, if they expect to make capital gains in the long term it could be worth it. And all parties are operating with minimal information. Out of all the markets in the world, real-estate and rental living spaces are probably one of the least efficient possible.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by barry-cotter on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:39PM (#31321361)
Yes. Companies are legal fictions and all people buy goods and services. Some people buy those services through those legal fictions so they consume the fraction of them corresponding to their to ownership fraction. Ultimately a person pays all taxes and all people are consumers.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by mypalmike on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:57PM (#31320972)
One of many counter examples: Corporations holding investments with capital gains aren't sourcing tax payments from consumers.

Pass-through taxes exist though, yes.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by kingrazor on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:47PM (#31320875)
Isn't this basically the case at the end of the day? Just about everything seems to eventually get passed on to the consumer.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by jonathankoren on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @01:36PM (#31329898)
Would you say my employer pays my income tax, since they're the ones giving me money?
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by kingrazor on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @05:27PM (#31332947)
Don't they, technically? Since the income tax is withheld from your paycheck before you get it?
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by daenz on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:42PM (#31320173)
"rent" != "a substantial part of rent"
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by ch4s3 on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:42PM (#31320160)
> Last year I paid 17% of my total income in taxes.

Was that in NYS? It doesn't take a lot of income to hit the state rate of 6.33%, everything after $80,651 filing alone, which isn't unusual downstate. You can add roughly 3.8% to that if you live in NYC and another 22% Federally, all just on income.

Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by huuman12 on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:47PM (#31321425)
If you’re earning 1m + in w2 income, then your effective rate is right about 50% in nyc. If the marginal tax bracket goes to 60%, high earners will definitely be moving. Nyc really has a high opinion of itself if they think people are going to be willing to pay 20% extra in taxes for the privilege of living in a city where garbage is left on the sidewalks and infrastructure is constantly breaking down
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by bingohbangoh on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:41PM (#31320818)
I paid 38% of my total income in taxes in New York City.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by HEmanZ on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:05PM (#31320435)
I don't think the op is talking about you. Many professionals in NYC already pay over 40% in effective income tax.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by dahfizz on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:26PM (#31321242)
How do you manage that? I get 31% taken straight from my paycheck (state + federal income, socsec, medicare, etc, and this is after 401k deduction) and then have sales tax and property tax on top.
Re:NY Senate Bill S5474 proposing a universal single payer h... by namlem on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:51PM (#31321967)
In NYC?