Somehow if you take two thirds of an engineering degree and two thirds of an econ/mgt degree, two thirds of the work is the engineering degree.
Most of the reading in management is discovery channel style: lots of interesting things, there's no doubting that, but not real skills. They raise simple ideas to a level of respect that is not warranted by the content. Eg Porter's Five Forces can only really be a superficial checklist for strategy, it doesn't actually tell you anything about what matters in some industry, and you might come across some business where those five items are not so clear cut. Same with SWOT analysis and various other acronyms, they are simply trivial things that cannot stand next to the content of a technical degree.
There's also an inherent problem with MBA training: it assumes that there's a general training that is useful to every business. If you're going to apply the material, every grad will end up putting a round peg in a square hole. Fortunately there's not really anything to apply, you get the cool jobs because you're showing that you're smart and ambitious, not because you are qualified technically to do it.
Engineering on the other hand is quite hard to BS. We built a crappy radio in the first term, but it was a radio and it played the radio when you turned it on. You had to understand how radio spectrum worked and how to solder the little RLC components together to make it work.
Looking at both......the MBA is indeed trivially easy compared to my engineering degree. By an order of magnitude. Thanks for opening my eyes to that.
And the other is that a lot of the decisions that bring up anti-MBA shitstorms and flamewars make it more than obvious that ethics were not much of a part of the MBA program the offenders attended.
The most obvious example of ethics getting railroaded was Boeing, and look where it got them to.
Look at the Boeing MCAS and VW emissions scandals. Individual engineers and test pilots were named and faced repercussions. The MBAs that sustained the environment where this poor decision making happened? Aside from the very senior executives, we have no clue who they are. They were able to stay in role or slink off to another opportunity. They might not even think they had any culpability.
* Enron
* General Electric and the lord and savior of MBAs, Jack Welch
* Valeant Pharmaceuticals
* Sears
* IBM
* McDonnell-Douglas (and later Boeing)
* Intel
* Stock buybacks in the airline and retail industries
41 years later, we are probably now cutting bone instead of fat.
You managed to figure it out, so why blame unknown, unseen, unnamed "MBAs" when virtually anyone of modest competency can realize that achieving 100% perfection is not cost-effective? And certainly not isolated to rail transportation. Do FAANG (or any software companies) produce 100% bug-free software? Do stores attempt to achieve 100% theft reduction? Virtually everyone knows that going from 98% success to 99% is very expensive, to 99.9% even more so, and 99.99% ridiculously so. 3, 4, 5, 6-sigma, and all that. If lives are at risk in these derailments, that's an issue. But these are freight trains.
However, the author didn't definitely show that insanely long trains increase these dangers. They seemed frustrated that driving these trains sucks and talked about how frequently derailments occur and seems to believe the two things are related. The NHSTA numbers seem to indicate the trend for derailments is going down? Perhaps as train size increases, the number of trains decrease and the risk to the individual conductor goes up? Don't know enough about the subject matter to knowledgeably infer an answer, so I won't.
- they are harder to start and stop, because size. One mistake.. Shorter trains are easier to control, physically
- Crews are exhausted by these trains because they take too long in infrastructure not built for them (1940s yards), and adding to waiting time, making it much slower to add / move carriages / trucks around, and other logistically disproportional wastes of time
- The trains are too long for communication purposes too. radios don't have the distance. Safety and important messages get missed
...among other things.
But if the derailments are <X% of the trains, and the rest of the trains are more cost-effective enough to make up for those, especially if the costs of the derailment to the environment, communities, and employees and such are externalized away from the MBA making these decisions, then they may decide it is worthwhile.
This is one of the reasons so many people have varying levels of distaste aimed at "MBAs"... it's not that hard to train people to push numbers around in any number of industries. It's easy to equip somebody with an MBA capable of doing that. Heck, based on what I've seen of MBA training, it's trivial compared to an engineering degree, no offense particularly intended, but it really isn't that hard to tell whether this number is bigger than that number, even with some statistics thrown in. The problem is that there is no way to scale up understanding all the details that are not and perhaps even can not be in the numbers, and that's where the MBAs can go trampling over companies.
I'm sure the numbers on these jumbo trains look great, even accounting for the derailments. I'm sure of that because the fact they're running them is pretty much proof of that. If the numbers weren't good, they never would have become popular enough to be worth writing about in the first place. The question is, what about the things not in the numbers? That I can't speak to and must defer to people with experience in the industry. So must the MBAs, but they are trained, deliberately or otherwise, not to.