You're talking about their recommendation engine for users they already have, which is completely different.
We also have to take into account that there's a lot of "misses" in those recommendation engines - which is normal. But when they nail it, people have positive emotions towards it, so it's a good feedback loop.
Personalization would be to have Spotify recommend you only songs about expensive watches after you've searched for a Rolex on Google, with ads in the middle about Rolex ahaha.
You mean the recommendation engine? Hardly ever it worked for me.
What Spotify is built on is "play albums/songs you select or follow playlists on genres you like". The recommendations are tacked on, and bad.
Maybe it varies dramatically by genre?
For example, take the "Phonk" genre, which I only was introduced to due to the Ukrainian war. To mean these recommendations give me a lot of new music to listen to. But then you have people lamenting that "Phonk" has really been overtaken by "Drift Phonk". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAV7hnCB_ZE&ab_channel=yokai
On the other hand, I personally enjoy albums and songs major artist after they achieve critical success, when they establish their signature sound, like David Bowie(1970-1983), Stevie Wonder (1972-1976), or Peter Gabriel(1986-1992), but if I "like" any of these songs on Spotify, it means I get their entire catalog mixed in my daily mixes, and if they ever release a live album, those tracks show up. This is not what I want.
Music genres change, that's nothing new at all. Just look at the type of trance from the early 2000s and compare it to today's trance. It's a completely different sound. Would the author also complain about "progressive trance" taking over "trance"? It's natural that some sub genres might become more popular, while others lose listeners relative to the newcomers. Same happened in techno, rap etc.
While Spotify might accelerate this process through a positive feedback loop, this video is just another form of gatekeeping and saying "I knew XYZ before it was cool".
Which is neither here nor there. Apple music came later, and Spotify already had a headstart, a good UI, a good selection, and a good free plan.
Spotify, Pandora caught on because they were the first good streaming solutions, at the time bandwidth, mobile phones, etc, were in place and ripe for streaming. Not because of their recommendations...
I prefer to use YT Music s it seems thoroughly confused by having each person in family use from my service account to the point the suggestions are general in nature. They still do not get played though. I refuse to click on suggestions in any product as that reinforces their data on me/us. I’m quite ok if any music engine thinks I’m a polyglot toddler with penchant for death metal, Thai ballads, and ancient Chinese orchestral Music. Such a profile makes me soooo much less likely to get other music or junk marketed to me ;-)
Sure, I've had some good recommendations, but I'd expect any recommendation engine to do that just by chance.
What I can say is that Spotify has never proposed something truly new and interesting to me. If I listen to a lot of metal, it'll recommend me the most bland stuff in the same genre. What's even worse is that it keeps playing the same songs over and over again. It's like the recommendation engine just gives up and starts repeating its suggestions again.
I simply gave up on it. Why have access to everything when I only got the crap. Going back to my personal collection increased my good/bad song ratio considerably.
"It" being reality?
>If Spotify's recommendation engine wasn't as good as it was, it would not have the users it has
Now that's just confirmation bias + circular logic.
A streaming service can have users regardless of how good its recommendation engine is. YouTube has crappy recommendation (and has had worse for most of the time it existed) but tons of users.
For Pandora and Spotify, merely offering a convenient way to stream music, a free tier, and a big catalog, was enough.
You seem convinced of some bizarro idea that a media/streaming service can only succeed based on its recommendation engine.
Where did you get that from?
That's not an argument
Canceled and would not consider a recommendation based service that does not let me explicitly remove something from being recommended.
Disclaimer: I work for Spotify nowadays but have been an avid user for more than a decade before joining, my opinion is based on my personal experience with the service and not as an employee.
As I read this article, this meaning of "personalisation" is not the one used by the authors.
Tech companies like Spotify and Pandora are just intermediaries. They may help to "deliver" commercial product, or advertising, however they do not create the product referred to in this article. The article uses the term "personalised creative" to refer to product. Tech companies operate as middlemen and produce no content. They are dependent on others to produce it. This is the bait for computer users. Tech companies sell advertising services to companies that produce content.
Tech companies gather data about individual computer users, e.g., web browsing histories. This is "personal" data. Tech companies allege this makes it especially effective and therefore valuable. The studies cited in the article suggest this is claim is false.
Disney produces content. There is no shortage of personal data being collected and sold by tech companies which is available to Disney. The article highlights that, despite the availability of personal data collected by tech companies, Disney generally does not produce "personalised creative".
In sum, the article is not about what "tech" companies do, it is about what content producers do. More specifically, it is about whether, based on available research, producers of creative should or should not attempt to use personal data about computer users collected by third parties in order to produce "personalised creative".
They do create a "product", the delivery system. This is a creative product as much as any of the music. A lot of software was written to allow this and all of that is the "product".
Most major value creation happens well before Disney+ or Pandora. They just have somewhat broadly defined parameters that will get you more of the same, from what has been created.
As easy examples, there are a lot of good kids shows that adults could enjoy, but my guess is that they are not recommended to most adults. Just as really good folk music is likely to get suggested to someone that hasn't listened to folk music. Or music/movies from another nation.
Which is all too say that the personalization is ultimately a customer fitting themselves to what they want, from what they know. Dropping someone in fresh with no prefit is probably a lost cause. Even though that is how most personalisation talks brand themselves.
Just remember that when you think this, the reality is that you are just that predictable based on half a dozen meaningless datapoints.
In fact, they're actively building it and selling it to advertisers. Disney+ and similar platforms are the tools that media companies have every intention of using to drive the accuracy numbers much higher.
E: I should note that I work for Snowflake, we're marketing this capability pretty hard. I'm not directly involved though.
(Or so it seems to me)
I mean if you are into a movie there might be only three ones like it which you allready have watched and surely are not on Netflix.
However, as soon as you use your Spotify account for kids or parties the engine gets messed up forever. It is a shame since it helped me find alot of artists.
Any time Spotify is brought up (which is really any time music is brought up) it's a good bet the quality of discovery of recommendations are mentioned. The Discovery Weekly and Daily Mixes are loved. My anecdotal evidence is the dozens of people I've talked to about this over the years. This HN thread is the first time I've seen anyone suggest otherwise.
I know for myself, if it wasn't for the discovery that Spotify offers, I wouldn't use it.
I also prefer Spotify user-run playlists better, which I pick myself, searching for genres and songs explicitly.
Nothing to do with preferring the personalization.
"No" seems to suggest that you're disagreeing with your parent's post, but your parent is saying why they chose it, not why you did:
> I assume, perhaps incorrectly, that everyone has the same catalog (at least for my fairly boring taste in music) and actively choose Spotify’s personalization over Apple Music’s tighter integration with my phone, car, etc. Just a single data point though.
And I am saying why I chose it. You don't need to read too much into the "no", nor have to find some perfect formal consistency in a quick response. It's just "no" as in, "no, that's not my case".
Similarly, clothing brands like stitch-fix and trunk club are personalization specific.
Regarding Disney, we just signed up for Disney+ and the first step was to decide if you wanted mature content and the second was to decide on your avatar. I think Disney+ will allow the company to cater to personal tastes more than they ever could through theaters and we will see that in the future.
Finally, for the longest time marketers have looked at demographic groups to target with their products, this is a weaker form of personalization. Obviously that won’t be abandoned, so I wonder why the author thinks companies should only target mass markets?