Re:The End of Industrial Society
by zozbot234 on Sunday May 08, 2022 @06:09PM
(#31308544)
That wasn't just men fighting for titles, it was quite literally men fighting for their turf. The modern equivalent would be an all-out war among drug cartels. Later on, with the onset of the early modern era powerful monarchies managed to check the violence and gradually turned noble titles into more of a social reward for public services rendered. This is the context that those who view "kings and aristocracies" positively might have in mind.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The End of Industrial Society
by AnimalMuppet on Sunday May 08, 2022 @09:25PM
(#31309554)
Well, that's an interesting point. Before we follow some far-right vision of restoring the nobility, we'd better find out exactly which version they have in mind. We'd also better think seriously about what constraints are going to be able to prevent it from turning into the worse version.
Re:The End of Industrial Society
by Apocryphon on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:23PM
(#31309813)
These fancy historical metaphors should be put next to actual modern examples of monarchy in action: the British and European aristocracy and the covert power they wield and the hidden wealth they hoard, the House of Saud and other Gulf Arab royals and their excesses, and what is the ruling regime of the DPRK if not a virtual monarchy under the Kims?