News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by j7ake on Saturday May 07, 2022 @01:46AM (#31292430)
Diminishing returns on productivity is obvious (eg working 80 hours a week outputs productivity somewhere between 1 to 2 times the productivity of 40 hours a week).

However, rewards for work is also highly nonlinear, and usually rank based. For example, Usain Bolt is not twice as fast as the second fastest runner but Bolt is rewarded many multiples more than the second fastest runner.

What is rational is to think of the payoff or reward space, and think how even a tiny incremental increase in productivity (which compounds) can result in disproportionately large payoffs.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by ChrisMarshallNY on Saturday May 07, 2022 @07:54AM (#31293823)
This is absolutely true, which is why people at the tip of the spear are always well-rewarded, but also incredibly stressed.

Not everyone can deal with stress, and even those that "successfully" deal with it, often break down, earlier in life than others (Look for old pro football players, or old pro wrestlers, for instance).

Congratulations! You're rich!

Which is good, because you'll need good nursing care, in your sixties.

It's not something that can be applied in generalities. Individual variance is key, until we get to a "Gattaga-style" society, where everyone is "tuned" for maximum performance.

This was something that I was thinking about, the other day, in a different context (long story).

I can't in good conscience, tell anyone that they "shouldn't go for the brass ring," but the chances are pretty high that they may not make it, and punish themselves for the rest of their lives, as a "failure," or, maybe even worse, get it, and end up regretting it.

In my case, I was forced into a situation where I had to eat humble pie, and accept a lower-echelon lifestyle, yet I'm deliriously happy. When I finally accepted the terrain, instead of gazing longingly at the map, things suddenly "clicked."

The key is acceptance, discipline, and moderation, for me.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by beepbooptheory on Saturday May 07, 2022 @08:29AM (#31293989)
I for one very much hope we don't get to a Gattaca-style society! That movie doesn't leave me with a particularly positive view of such a system, but maybe that's just me.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by ChrisMarshallNY on Saturday May 07, 2022 @03:05PM (#31297507)
I agree. Speaking as one that is far from perfect, I'm almost positive that I would have been flushed down the toilet, rather than be born.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by brandnewaccount on Sunday May 08, 2022 @07:24PM (#31308957)
Small nitpick about your argument: equating stress to physical contact sports isn't a very convincing argument. What would be better is looking at the health of CEOs as compared to other relatively wealthy individuals who work much less and are under less stress.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by koonsolo on Saturday May 07, 2022 @04:21AM (#31292979)
Most studies on the topic indicate that >50 hours has <1 factor on productivity. So probably working weeks on end at 80 hours is the same as working at about 20-30 hour workweeks.

https://igda.org/resources-archive/why-crunch-mode-doesnt-wo...

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by caffeine on Saturday May 07, 2022 @05:03AM (#31293111)
What’s true on average might not be true for certain individuals, and power-law mechanics might make those individuals more significant than everyone else who makes up the average.

Like imagine Elon Musk works 80 hours a week and he doesn’t suffer any negative consequence, he just becomes the most productive human ever according to the market.

And then a bunch of other people work 80 hours and they do suffer burnout and become slightly less productive than if they had worked 40 hours.

If you say “What’s the expected value of working 80 hours rather than 40?” in that scenario, it’s extremely positive, because the tiny chance you become Elon and have half the wealth in America offsets the very high probability you become a burnout who does no better than average.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by koonsolo on Saturday May 07, 2022 @05:39AM (#31293236)
I'm pretty smart and a hard worker. I have a Masters degree in computer science. I can do about 4 to 6 hours of concentrated work per day. I never seen anyone do more or better. I know plenty of people who claim to work a crazy amout of hours. But in the end it always turns out they are deceiving themselves.

I don't know Elon, so maybe he is different. But in the end, I'll believe it when I see it.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by caffeine on Saturday May 07, 2022 @06:16AM (#31293392)
You are doing solo, technical, concentrated work.

I have seen a lot of people do more and better. But different work, not coding.

Like leading and managing people is very possible for some elite people to do for say 70 hours a week and mostly involves talking, persuading, answering emails and phone calls, and most importantly making good decisions.

The value of good leadership and good decisions is directly proportional to the number and quality of people being led.

So that could be a huge value. Doing twice as much of it could way more than double that value with compounding.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by koonsolo on Saturday May 07, 2022 @09:51AM (#31294428)
I also don't agree with this point of view, and it seems Jeff Bezos shares this point of view: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/articl...

Quality of work beats quantity any day of the week. And at 80 hours, there just cannot be any quality left. At that point, your mistakes will cost you more. Maybe the people below you might offset your stupidity at that point.

I had managers doing 60+ hours. They were not the greatest, in fact, they were terrible.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by inglor_cz on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:03PM (#31305251)
Around 30 years of age, I was able to pull off productive 10-hour days, but three in a row or so. Definitely not for weeks.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by leaflets2 on Sunday May 08, 2022 @01:31PM (#31306143)
I'm older. 10-12 hours is not a problem to me if I sleep 1 hour at noon, and take short running breaks, just 1.5 km does wonder.

Been doing this for years :-). Software development.

I love my job. It's not for money; it has a purpose. I guess that otherwise I would not recommend this o.O

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by dav_Oz on Saturday May 07, 2022 @05:54AM (#31293307)
Isn't there a sweet spot though?

As Elon, by virtue of his massive wealth now, is depriving an ungodly amount of people of financial resources and opportunities. I mean on that scale I venture to say it's like a Usain Bolt sucking up nearly all the sponsoring for 100m sprinting so there are very few left to even challenge him in a professional sense which makes him even more "valuable". [Of course in this analogy (achievements in sports/wealth) there is a external natural limit in sports all acknowledge: "age"].

So, while form a individual perspective (one-dimension) the expected value investing 80hr/week in becoming a centibillionaire is "positive" on the whole this approach can at aome point severely limit the space of possibilities in terms of technology. I guess that's why Elon - certainly aware of this - tries to push concepts like "rate of innovation" where he makes his patents "open source" so he can offset his own stifling influence.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by caffeine on Saturday May 07, 2022 @06:05AM (#31293351)
> As Elon, by virtue of his massive wealth now, is depriving an ungodly amount of people of financial resources and opportunities.

That doesn’t make any sense at all. His wealth isn’t made up of financial resources and opportunities that other people could have used - his wealth is the price that other people would be willing to pay him to own shares in the companies he created.

I think it’s a common misconception out there that paper billionaires like Elon and Jeff Bezos have like a giant pile of cans of food in a warehouse somewhere that they could give out to people but don’t because they like having the biggest pile.

That’s not really the case.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by gugagore on Saturday May 07, 2022 @06:19AM (#31293411)
No one believes they are hoarding cans of food. People say they are hoarding wealth, and assuming it's liquid.

https://ncarteron.medium.com/the-billionaires-arent-liquid-a...

Which it is.

They absolutely could, and the only reason they don't is because they like being in the club of biggest-pile-havers.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by leaflets2 on Sunday May 08, 2022 @01:41PM (#31306239)
What would you suggest they do with it?

I'm wondering if "getting rid" of that much money, using it for good things, but without most of it disappearing in corruption, is more than a full time job

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by kqr on Saturday May 07, 2022 @06:34AM (#31293462)
> His wealth isn’t made up of financial resources and opportunities that other people could have used

This is literally how profit works. You make sure your costs (salaries you pay your workers) are less than the value they produce. In other words, you keep some of the financial resources and opportunities that others could have had.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by sokoloff on Saturday May 07, 2022 @09:30AM (#31294288)
That’s a hyper-localized view. The teams of people who tamed farming, semiconductors and medicine have added many multiples more value than they kept to society.

Imagine that a novel creation is worth 100 units of value to society. It’s entirely possible for society to take 50 units, the workers to share 25 units, and the CEO to keep 25 units and for literally everyone to be better off than if that creation was never made.

The view above compares against an alternative split of 60/35/5 while ignoring the case where the split is 0/0/0.

Even in a 90/9/1 split, why are the workers depriving society of such a large share by hoarding 9% for themselves?

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by ibeckermayer on Saturday May 07, 2022 @01:44PM (#31296777)
> In other words, you keep some of the financial resources and opportunities that others could have had.

Those workers needed to be organized in such a manner that the value they produce is actually worthwhile and their productive output sustainable over a long period of time.

Think about the example of a production line worker in a Tesla factory -- is that individual worker being paid less than the overall value they produce for the company? Hopefully, or else Tesla will soon be going out of business (simplified obviously, but I think you'll see my point). Now consider if Tesla failed to profit off of their workers, and the factory did go out of business. Does that line worker now have more financial resources and opportunities than they would have had, which you claim were being in a sense taken from them by Musk?

Of course not! Instead, they're just out of a job entirely, because their productive output on that production line is worthless if the rest of the line isn't working (and the rest of the company isn't functioning). And chances are, that line worker doesn't have the vision, drive, knowledge, skills, etc. of Musk to get the Tesla factory up to being something economically sustainable and productive all on his own. That's not a knock on the production line worker, it's just a simple fact that such a feat is insanely difficult, and very few people have the characteristics, judgement, and luck to build anything of the sort.

So in the case of Tesla profiting off the worker, the worker gets some financial resources and opportunities, whereas in the case that Tesla fails to profit off the worker, the worker gets zero financial resources and opportunities (plus the world gets zero Teslas, battery tech improvements, etc). In the ideal, free enterprise truly is a positive sum endeavor.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by mrow84 on Saturday May 07, 2022 @08:43AM (#31294055)
Even if you believe that:

1. the wealth of such people corresponds solely to an increase in the pool of available wealth (as opposed to just redistribution from other people), and

2. that increase is solely attributable to them,

it remains true that the distribution of the wealth pool is an arbitrary social choice. Billionaires being billionaires deprives other people of resources, by definition.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by sokoloff on Saturday May 07, 2022 @09:24AM (#31294260)
If a billionaire increased the size of society’s pie by more than their total amount of pie, they’ve made both themself and the rest of society overall better. You can argue that none of them have done this, but I don’t agree that it’s obvious or definitionally true that none of them have.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by kochikame on Saturday May 07, 2022 @10:25AM (#31294741)
Example: what value to assign to the productivity benefits that Amazon and AWS have created for individuals, companies etc and society in general? I think we can all agree that it is an enormous amount in dollar terms.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by imtringued on Saturday May 07, 2022 @03:11PM (#31297568)
1. saved money does not necessarily represent an increase in wealth. A rich individual can save against the will of the rest of the population. When you remember that total debt = total credit (savings on your bank account) then you are basically keeping people waiting and making them unable to pay their debts back.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by goodpoint on Saturday May 07, 2022 @07:17AM (#31293637)
On the contrary, wealth is mutually exclusive by definition.

Regardless if it's cash, stocks, land or a pile of cans of food - if I have a piece of it you don't have the same piece.

So yes "by virtue of his massive wealth now, is depriving an ungodly amount of people of financial resources and opportunities" is exactly how wealth works.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by testcase_delta on Saturday May 07, 2022 @10:55AM (#31294990)
I don’t disagree with your point, but I think it doesn’t take the following in to account: Wealth is not a fixed sum. The global GDP increases over time, which I interpret has new wealth being created. If Elon hadn’t created his businesses, his wealth wouldn’t be in the hands of other people, it just wouldn’t exist.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/world-gdp-over-the-last-t...

I also assume that over 1 or 2 generations that his wealth will mostly circulate around.

Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on this.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by goodpoint on Saturday May 07, 2022 @02:57PM (#31297433)
It's very well understood that making a product can create surplus value. This is basic economics. Contrarily to simply robbing someone else, which would be 0-sum (if not negative).

However if the product is being sold you are still taking someone's money. If you wanted to purely increase wealth for everybody you would be giving away the product for free. Many no-profits do that. (duh)

Yet, the tradeoffs are complex and some economic activities are purely exploitative.

In fact, inequality is rising across various societies and quality of life is actually decreasing for hundreds of millions.

Wealth redistribution through taxes has been a cornerstone of modern society and one of the biggest push to move societies out of feudalism. And now we are witnessing something described as technofeudalism.

> If Elon hadn’t created his businesses, his wealth wouldn’t be in the hands of other people, it just wouldn’t exist.

Either Musk made cars entirely by himself (which is not the case) or his employees did it. You are assuming that such workers would have all been unemployed if Musk did not exist, which is very unlikely.

Also, it's false that ALL of Musk's wealth would not exist. Only the fraction due to value created by the company (if any). [And I repeat, the products are obviously created by the workers]

An interesting question would be: if company X never existed, could the workers be doing something more beneficial instead? Plenty of organization has been described as a net negative for humanity.

And this is without accounting for negative externalities, e.g. causing pollution, or making another company go bankrupt, regulatory capture, creation of monopolies and the list is pretty long.

> The global GDP increases over time, which I interpret has new wealth being created

That's incorrect. Part of GDP is due to production of products and services, but a significant part is due to speculation that is not backed by any increase in productivity.

Additionally, GDP is in no way able to measure overall real wealth, quality of life, access to opportunities and so on: not destroying the environment does not increase GDP. As much as going for a walk with your SO does not increase GDP.

> I also assume that over 1 or 2 generations that his wealth will mostly circulate around.

This is provably false.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by inglor_cz on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:11PM (#31305353)
"You are assuming that such workers would have all been unemployed if Musk did not exist, which is very unlikely."

No, they would work, but would they be more productive in those other jobs? Possibly not.

I wonder what would happen if current engineers at SpaceX were suddenly "redistributed" to Boeing or Blue Origin. Maybe they would raise the technical aptitude of those companies. Or maybe not, maybe the companies would grind them down to their corporate level.

You can demotivate smart people and reduce their creativity to almost zero by insisting on idiotic corporate rules and punishing them for "transgressions" (e.g. innovation that wasn't approved beforehand). They will still be working in highly qualified positions, but their collective effort won't be as productive.

It is notable what a big portion of contemporary technology is attributable to relatively small organizations (such as Bell Labs) which were able to motivate smart and creative people to do their best.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by goodpoint on Sunday May 08, 2022 @02:07PM (#31306497)
> No, they would work, but would they be more productive in those other jobs? Possibly not.

On possibly yes - it depends. Yet, the company mission and priority is usually "maximize shareholders value".

Not "maximize worker creativity and happiness and empower them as much as possible".

Not "maximize technology, wealth, quality of life for humanity"

The last two might sometimes happen as fortunate side effects. Often not. See all the complaints from Tesla workers around safety and anti-union activities.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by kochikame on Saturday May 07, 2022 @10:27AM (#31294759)
No, most of Bezos’ or Musk’s wealth is tied to the value of their companies. To this extent, they don’t “own” a thing that someone else is deprived of.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by goodpoint on Sunday May 08, 2022 @02:09PM (#31306505)
Stocks are mutually exclusive by definition.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by beepbooptheory on Saturday May 07, 2022 @08:36AM (#31294025)
Investors choose to put there money in profitable businesses. Where do you think profit comes from? Elon isn't responsible for the profit, he is just in the position to claim it, sell it off. You don't have to be a communist to think this, its just how things work.
Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by systemvoltage on Saturday May 07, 2022 @01:49AM (#31292437)
Olympics is an extremely atypical competition. Cooperative culture amongst humans is why we are where we are technologically. Without the spirit of collaboration, we have no MRIs and modern medicine, no transistors and semiconductors, no airplanes and bridges.

I wish HN wasn’t so damn depressing. Reading some of cynical stuff here is sometimes harmful for my own mental health.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by j7ake on Saturday May 07, 2022 @04:14AM (#31292959)
Maybe I’ll give a tech related example instead.

I sometimes browse local shops websites to buy products, but if the page loads too slowly or there are some hiccups, I tend to quickly search on Amazon to see if I can buy with a single click.

The total amount of time spent shopping at local website may be only a tiny bit more than if I browsed Amazon, but the improved experience at Amazon is enough to tilt my spending away from local websites.

Amazon probably spends multi millions to shave off fractions of seconds off their page loads, and the rewards pay off handsomely.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday May 07, 2022 @04:45AM (#31293058)
Which works until Amazon becomes flooded with second rate product sources from Alibaba boosted by fake reviews, and a "job" means back-breaking work in a warehouse, or a precarious delivery gig with no security.

This society only operates because a lot of people don't care to understand how it really works. You get your trinkets more quickly, but the negative externalities for others are huge and damaging.

And there's a good chance that sooner or later those negatives will affect you too.

Meanwhile the lift from increased efficiency is often temporary anyway.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by derbOac on Saturday May 07, 2022 @06:39AM (#31293486)
FWIW, I'm not sure cynicism per se is the problem, or the only problem. It's a certain belief system and acceptance of certain assumptions as true because those justify certain outcomes.

The target essay could have stopped in the first couple of paragraphs and there would still be plenty of societal problems to discuss.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by Jare on Saturday May 07, 2022 @02:17AM (#31292549)
> working 80 hours a week outputs productivity somewhere between 1 to 2 times the productivity of 40 hours a week

Effort and energy spent will be somewhere between 1 to 2... but as soon as stress and exhaustion set in (which may happen fairly soon) you may find actual productivity tanking well below 1 and even into the negatives, due to all the mistakes and bad decisions you start making.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by bbarnett on Saturday May 07, 2022 @04:36AM (#31293031)
I think this is like machine maintenance.

Take a delivery truck. Regular maintenance detects, and prevents breakdowns during deliveries. EG, oil changes, lubing, brake pad changes, etc.

Scheduled repairs are far cheaper, and take less time than unannounced repairs.

If the truck breaks down during deliveries, the repairs are still needed, may be more severe.

It also require loads of extra work, a replacement truck must show up and offload deliveries, a tow truck dispatched, someone had to organize this, customers upset and called, etc, etc.

As you say, humans are the same. Reduced sleep and leisure time (scheduled maintenance)?

Well, it's far more work to deal with in the long run. It takes more maintenance to recover from a lack of it.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by inglor_cz on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:13PM (#31305371)
This is, by the way, the vicious circle in which the Russian war effort in Ukraine is now.

The more tanks, trucks, fighter jets you lose, the more sorties/tasks the remaining fraction has to pull off. Which means more wear and tear, higher risk of failure.

Re:The diminishing returns of productivity culture (2021) by kochikame on Saturday May 07, 2022 @10:27AM (#31294765)
Great analogy