News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by paulpauper on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:23AM (#31206321)
"get up at 4 am and be rich"

"cut the daily latte habit, cancel your Netflix is the key to prosperity"

Favoritism, luck (which includes having rich and generous parents), and connections plays such a huge, largely uncredited role for success, especially in businesses. Even Bill Gates, as smart as he is, benefited from lots of luck.

The business racket is not much different from the pundit racket. It's the same insularity and being out of tough with reality.

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by bsder on Friday April 29, 2022 @06:46PM (#31211473)
> Even Bill Gates, as smart as he is, benefited from lots of luck.

Luck ... read as rich parents.

Bill Gates had parents who had connections with extremely important people in multi-national companies.

Bill Gates had access to a computer as a child (via his expensive private academy) back when computers were ferociously expensive.

Bill Gates had parents who could cut a check for $50,000 (in the 1970s) on the whim of their child.

Bill Gates had the ability to drop out of Harvard knowing that he could always go back or to somewhere else because his parents could pay for it.

The child of a steelworker, for example, has no ability to take any of these chances because if they fail there is no recovery. If you get into Harvard, you will go the full four years. Even if your business idea is great, your parents will not cut a $50K check as that would pay for your college (and a house and a car and college for your siblings and still have about $25K left over) at the time. Even including the adults around you, none of the people around you have access to those expensive "computers". And your parents certainly don't have access to the senior executives of US Steel, for example.

The "leeway to fail" is a big deal in allowing you to roll the dice to make "luck".

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by rektide on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:10PM (#31207040)
Notably Bill Gates's mom got to know the board of IBM & helped connect & land her son's contract for a disk operating system[1] at a time when the DoJ used to have active anti-trust deparments, and was hounding IBM for vertically owning the market.

[1] https://www.biography.com/video/bill-gates-help-from-mom-208...

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by creaghpatr on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:18PM (#31208006)
Unpopular opinion: becoming the beneficiary of favoritism is a skill that can be cultivated.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by jjmorrison on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:50PM (#31208517)
Racing is a great manifestation of this. Drivers often claim bad luck for being hit by another car. But the best drivers just seem to rarely have bad luck.

Knowing how to keep yourself out of situations where unlucky events may happen is just as important a skill in racing as driving fast.

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by aaaaaaaaata on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:31AM (#31214360)
"To finish first, you must first finish."
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by jjmorrison on Saturday April 30, 2022 @01:43PM (#31217716)
<3 Love that
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:33PM (#31208271)
As true as that may be it also completely ignores the point that luck might include that an individual's parents are wealthy, as well as generous enough with their wealth to lend - or give - some to said individual.

I think to your point: all the luck in the world won't fix a bad execution. It could still be commendable when a person who gets lucky is able to turn that luck into success.

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by creaghpatr on Monday May 02, 2022 @11:59AM (#31236880)
Yes, and I think the points about wealth and nepotism still hold true.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by zeruch on Friday April 29, 2022 @06:19PM (#31211243)
...unpopular or unsavory in its implications?
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by browningstreet on Saturday April 30, 2022 @01:54AM (#31213702)
Take away the born-to connections, in orgs at the upper levels, there’s often a temperament that prevails. That may come from experience, confidence, connection, etc. could come from support (err, favoritism) or the golden contract.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by ithkuil on Friday April 29, 2022 @06:25PM (#31211302)
I guess a lot depends of what are the grounds of favoritism. You know, sometimes just being good at doing stuff and having somebody who has first hand experience of you being good at something and then backs you for something else that they couldn't objectively know you'd be good (compared to tons of other candidates) but, you know, good old gut feeling "I know this person has it" ... well that's technically favoritism, yet it certainly feels quite different from favouring somebody for other reasons like being family or doing some kind of personal favours.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by jjmorrison on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:01PM (#31208643)
The "credit" one deserves in business success isn't about having created a successful business. It's for having fought and survived the psychological trauma that one goes through to create a successful business.

Not everyone will have the opportunity to slay a dragon. But in my opinion those who have the opportunity, and succeed, are deserving of recognition.

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by sandworm101 on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:56PM (#31208586)
I am up at 4am. At work by 5am most days. I'm not rich. In fact none of my many bosses are ever at the office before 8am.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by melony on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:47AM (#31206646)
Being the scion of a well-connected family in law and banking probably helped him the most.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by aaaaaaaaata on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:52AM (#31206744)
Yes, well-known his mother put him where he needed to be.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by staunch on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:12PM (#31207069)
No doubt Bill Gates had massive privilege (in the traditional sense the word). He came from an upper class family with particularly powerful connections. The same is true of Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk to a possibly lesser extent.

But almost every person with even greater levels of privilege manages to do so much less than them. Which proves that one can't rightly attribute their great success to privilege alone. If one wants to be correct (and not just feel good) one has to admit that they did some amazing things based in large part on merit.

And that's the rub. Merit alone is often not enough. Privilege alone is often not enough. And luck always plays a role in determining the magnitude of anyone's success.

It takes extraordinary merit to be a John Carmack, Palmer Luckey, Larry Ellison, or Steve Jobs. People who had no privilege (in the traditional sense) and yet their merit (and luck) was so great that they did big things despite the fact.

Many people use the privilege argument to try to dismiss what people like Elon Musk have done. As if they could have done just as well had they been privileged. Envy is clearly clouding their thinking and confusing them. It's totally understandable for people to feel this way but ultimately and obviously incorrect in most cases.

A goal for modern societies should be to give everyone the kinds of opportunities that only the privileged historically had. But this won't prevent some people from doing much more with new opportunities than others. Merit will come to dominate outcomes instead of privilege. This will make the world much richer but won't solve everything.

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by melony on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:29PM (#31207306)
You are missing the network effects. Wealth compounds, capital grows, assets beget assets. If an ordinary person is lucky, he or she may win the literal lottery and may never have to work again. If a massively privileged person wins the proverbial lottery, he or she will have enough money to rival the GDP of nations and appear on Forbes magazine. The difference is hardly linear.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by wpasc on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:11PM (#31207902)
One of your examples I believe hurts your point: "Whether they win $500 million or $1 million, about 70 percent of lotto winners lose or spend all that money in five years or less."

https://www.rd.com/list/13-things-lottery-winners/#:~:text=W....

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by staunch on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:59PM (#31209297)
How do network effects apply here? Do you mean to refer to compounding growth?

It's true that wealth begets wealth. Zuckerberg's kids are billionaires without having to do anything. Bill Gates would've been rich even if he had not started Microsoft, just through inheritance.

But Steve Jobs led the creation of the most valuable company on the planet. There was no blocker to him being richer than Bill Gates or Elon Musk. Larry Ellison is among the richest people on the planet. John Carmack and Palmer Luckey have generational wealth.

Creating a massive company is what makes someone as rich as an Elon Musk or Bill Gates. They had more opportunity to create a massive company than a person from a lower class, but it's got nothing to do with network effects. The main driver of these people's massive fortunes is technology that scales globally.

Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by mxkopy on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:59PM (#31207699)
I think this makes sense, but luck is a weird way to put it. I'm sure Bill Gates' family had plans to create generational wealth; at the very least they didn't ignore the possibility. The question of whether or not Bill is lucky because he wasn't responsible for starting those plans is the same question of if I'm more lucky to have been born in this body or in one 500 years into the future.
Re:Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021) by Apocryphon on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:34PM (#31208292)
Sounds like that actually happened, at least in one instance

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31207040