I fully agree with you (and it's one of the few strongly held opinions of mine), but I'm not really sure why you would bring this up within the context of patent trolls. Patents do run out, rather quickly even.
It's other intellectual property -- namely copyright -- that needs to run out way faster. The trademark system that we have right now is alright imo and doesnt need to be "fixed".
Not to get off-topic with copyright despite being an "older author", notwithstanding the sibling comments, I'd agree it's too long.
Now, it's nice that patents time-out quite quickly, and indeed that motivates for useful development, but what I'm talking about is adding serial (AND) conditions that require they're capable of being used.
Alice has a fresh patent on a method for manufacturing a drug. She can sell it to Bob who also runs a pharmaceutical company and is in the process of expanding his portfolio of medicines. If Alice sells it to Charlie who runs a hair salon and fashion company, because Charlie, who is not in the business of making medicines, she cannot sue or leverage using that patent in any way or it's immediately null and void. Charlie doesn't have an "interest" in the patent and so loses the patent by misusing it, without any further need to prove the patent invalid. Crazy as that may sound to some, I think its a reasonable amendment to present law.
Wow, I like the direction of this, pragmatic enough to get implemented but also on its way to establish the commons as a party in the deal.
I’ve long thought that the commons need a stronger representation in policy.
At the end of the day, "justice" is what we buy with our conformance to society. When nations fight over systems of government, it's really a fight over what justice means. The current system is broken, but it's owned by old, rich, intelligent people who know what power is and how to use it, how to keep it, how to rationalize it. Even the good ones fall, when they see how goodness and self-restraint is rewarded by their peers, lest they lose their power.
I do not think there is a realistic path to reform. The US justice system should be replaced, entirely, with something closer to the German system, which is far less concerned with where evidence comes from, for example, and far more concerned with whether its true. Things happen much faster, and most argumentation is done in writing. Attorneys are forbidden from advertising - which used to be the case in the US, too. But of course they got that changed. It's also remarkable how often a German attorney refers to the law - they treat it as a rulebook as for a board game, whereas in the states the judge, in practice, has absolute power over all participants and is free to ignore the law, or invent new law. (Well, they aren't supposed to be, but the process for holding a judge to account is, if you can imagine it, even worse than the rest of the system. Gee whiz, I wonder how that happened?)
I'm not required, thankfully, when selling something to do deep background on the person purchasing it. Further, you'd have to prove that my knowledge of this person included the fact that they intended to do something bad with the gun I sold them before I sold it to them.
Finally.. I may have just sold them the gun. Perhaps it's more important to ask this question of the person who sold him the bullets. In this analogy, I suppose that would be the patent law firm.
> Ultimately its probably better if we move to a world where a lot of "intellectual property" expires with it's holder and passes into the public domain.
You move from a high premium on participating in a market, which by some arguments, is my right to participate in to having no participation in it at all. I think more harm than good comes from this.
> To apply a leverage point analysis, it's probably time to reexamine and change the rules about the transferability of patents. Does the purchaser have a legitimate justification to hold the patent? If no, it forfeits.
You'll trade outright patent transfers for shell company transfers, and the small inventor takes a back seat in all of this.
This situation is unfortunate, but I don't think improvements come from hamstringing everyone.
Aside from everything else in your argument, this is a really bad point to lean on - in America laws are specifically structured to leave the selling party blameless in all but the most extreme circumstances.
As a more general response:
I also think the thing that makes anti-troll legislation difficult is that making it harder to attack patents, and making it harder to defend patents makes it harder for smaller businesses trying to defend their property from larger businesses. If we start leveraging personal penalties on the attorneys of bad faith suites we need to have confidence that that also won't be turned into a tool to silence legitimate claims from small parties...
If we decided, for instance, to fine every bad faith attorney for 1 million dollars we'd need to make sure that large companies can't use the threat of that fine to strong arm small businesses into compliance.
This is a really complicated question and, at the end of the day, it's why we need to be really careful about maintaining a high quality in our federal judges - bad judges cause extreme harm by making justice inaccessible.
But this is more interesting;
>> If you sell a gun to an unstable crazy who shoots up the neighbourhood then some blame lies with you.
> bad point to lean on - in America laws are specifically structured to leave the selling party blameless
True perhaps. But I did not raise a point of law. This is an ethical chestnut that traces back to at least Plato. Perhaps unclear from my wording I'm implying you know the buyer to be a killer, and so it would be irresponsible to sell. Anyway, my suggested legal revision doesn't rely on whether the seller knows or not, but on the buyers legitimacy to hold the patent.
This is an extremely divisive topic in America so I'd really just suggest avoiding any gun or self-defense related analogies whenever possible.
From the context it seems like a more common analogy would be better to illustrate, rather than using an example of something that almost never happens.
A "use it or lose it" model to defang patentholders who don't manufacture their patents is a good idea, as well as using them as assets.
Take that further. The stakes should be high against all adjacent patent holders. Ultimately if we want to keep a working patent system it's too much work to rely on piecemeal independent cases like this, albeit a great success. The system has to self-police to be fair, and perhaps the best people to keep trolls and mischievous opportunists on a leash are the bigger players with legitimate patents. They must be fiven a motivated interest in eliminating trolls.
If you sell a gun to an unstable crazy who shoots up the neighbourhood then some blame lies with you. While the transfer of patents between concerned partner companies and subsidiaries seems okay, the market for trading patents simply as value assets needs destroying. Ultimately its probably better if we move to a world where a lot of "intellectual property" expires with it's holder and passes into the public domain.
To apply a leverage point analysis, it's probably time to reexamine and change the rules about the transferability of patents. Does the purchaser have a legitimate justification to hold the patent? If no, it forfeits.