Less than that! In the event of a random audit, they will aggressively try to reclassify 1099 contractors that have no interest in being employees and don't meet the definition in any way.
Assuming they did decide to quibble about the classification what can they actually do to an entity that has no legal existence in the US?
"Making matters worse, if California’s tax assessments are not paid voluntarily, California frequently further tramples on the sovereignty of other states by issuing orders to interstate banks, demanding that they transfer funds in Arizona-based accounts for back payment. Those seizure orders threaten the banks that, if they do not transfer the funds, California will take the taxes and penalties owed from the banks instead. Not surprisingly, the banks almost uniformly consent to California’s strong-arm tactics.
Exhibit G in the filing provides an example where California demanded that Wells Fargo not only transfer the $800 tax, but also a $200 “demand penalty,” a $432 “late filing penalty,” a $79 “filing enforcement fee,” and $63.40 in interest, for a “Total Tax, Penalties, Interest and Fees” of $1574.40."
https://www.azag.gov/press-release/arizona-attorney-generals...
IANAL, but if you are building a software product, and you hire someone to do software development work on your core product, then CA may easily take the view that person is an employee because of the ABC test (as of September 2019).
1. You don't tell them what to do, you just negotiate an end product.
2. Your main business is something else.
3. They routinely have other clients.
All three, or they're an employee.
The plumber who unclogs your drains is an independent contractor. Someone who does the work of your business is an employee. It's that simple.
For example, see https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/exempt-job-categorie....
Software consulting probably (IANAL) falls under "Business to business consulting", at least if you structure your consulting shop correctly. If you're just working long-term full-time for one client and not offering your services up elsewhere as the GP's case describes, you're probably mis-classified under the ABC rule.
They absolutely hate orgs and individuals that provide an alternative to California's onerous requirements and don't pay into the state funds
Many companies hire through staffing companies, rather than hiring 1099s directly. But when the contracting company only provides a service to you, and their 1099s are only contracted to your offices, you may find that the employees of this other company are considered to be employees of your company instead. Courts can decide to pierce these abstractions. The most notable example is the Microsoft permatemp lawsuit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permatemp
If your company has so much piping that the local plumber hires staff dedicated to you for years on end, then it's conceivable that a court would decide that the plumbing company's employees are actually your employees.
Personally, I've always wondered whether government contractors could win a lawsuit to be considered government employees. The US government is by far the biggest "permatemp" employer and seems to itself regularly flout these kinds of laws.
Maybe if this nonsense was actually addressed and made strict, the US government would finally be forced to provide just compensation for it's employees instead of always just shoving piles of money at external contractors and allowing untold grift
You are engaged in a trade or business and the payment was made to another business that is incorporated, but was not for medical or legal services
Otherwise, you are supposed to file a 1099 (assuming it was trade/business work, not personal stuff for your house, etc).
https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
It certainly doesn't pass this contractor requirement...
"The worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business"
It's absolutely absurd.
Thats not to say there isn't tons of “real” contractor work available to people who actually work independently.
But it only takes like 5 minutes to read the IRS 20 factor test and it pretty much immediately makes it clear what’s a “real” contractor relationship and what isn’t. IMO people running a serious business shouldn’t have a problem doing the most basic research to make the determination.
To be super clear, California’s ABC test is only 3 factors and it codifies that those 3, which are already in the IRS test (A is 1, B is 3 & C is satisfied by 17 or 18). It mandates that these 3 (out of the 20 supplied by IRS) in particular must be present, clearing up the existing rules.
What I'm trying to communicate is that this understanding will NOT sufficiently protect you from the CA EDD. It goes MUCH deeper than the above and they have no problem making assertions that probably would not stand up in court if you hired a tax attorney, but they don't really care.
"The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States."
A sole owner of an Illinois business could be read in that text to have immunity from the California "minimum franchise tax."
It would be helpful to see the Supreme Court remove California's abusive interstate taxation.
This means, for example, that if a state wants to tax residents of other states that do business in their state, they have to tax their own residents for the same activities.
So, if CA wants to tax an Illinois business for its activities in CA, it would have to tax CA residents for those same activities. And CA absolutely does.
The plain text of the Constitution often does not mean what laypeople think it means.
"We the people" does not seem to be written for Ivy League lawyers to understand and translate to laypeople. A Constitution written in a way that only a small percent of people are "trained" or "authorized" to understand or apply is a big time failure. Just sayin'
The "danger" with a 1099 isn't that you don't get social security credit, it's that there's no withholding, so the recipient has to pay all of the taxes after the fact (instead of getting a refund come tax time like most? many?).
It shouldn't be a problem for someone used to this and plan/save accordingly, but it's easy for someone new to contracting to fall into a trap of "OMG, look at all this money!! I'm going to go buy something expensive..." and spend everything, without considering their tax liability down the road.
What do you mean? You still pay in but you have to pay 100% yourself instead of having the company pay half.
Many haven't yet, and many people can get "tricked" into it - there's a reason the government has to stomp on companies that try to 1099 everyone.
All can have big financial impacts to employees, and employees need to understand them before they accept an offer. There's no reason to be surprised by the tax implications of 1099 vs W-2.
1099 isn't necessarily worse than W2, it opens more tax deductions for the employee, but also requires more bookeeping and the employee needs to understand what the difference is.
It can be hard to find the exact details for comparison which is why it’s good to have contacts in an industry and in an area.
They ended up classifying me as a "contractor" working under one of their existing agency relationships but aside from who signed my paycheck there was no distinction
Dirty secret of remote work is that lots of companies are abusing the 1099 system to make it happen. The workers definitely don't meet rules for being 1099, but tax compliance (not to mention sorting out benefits) across a whole bunch of states and even countries is crazy overhead, so the realistic options are to make everyone 1099, or to only hire from one state.
... then again, a bunch of bigcos abuse 1099 for non-remote employees all the time and have for years, so, not like this is unique to smaller all-remote or remote-friendly companies.
Imagine the opposite: you set up your business out of state and employ California residents but don't follow any of their labor laws. You underpay them. You don't take out the appropriate amount of state taxes. You don't report their income to the state. You don't give them overtime pay. How is this not just a glaring problem?
Even a minimum wage employee working full time will cost that much in a week or two.
I feel for people who are on the lower end of the income scale that that try to do basically anything is California's hostile business climate.
This isn't really news. 15 minutes of reading about staring an LLC in Deleware and you'll find you have to register in the state you live as well - so it shouldn't be a shock you have to file in places you have employees.
1099 is definitely the way to go for as long as you can - people still get social security credit.
IANAL, this isn't legal advice, blah blah blah