News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by markbao on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:15AM (#3114414)
Like Palm's WebOS open source releases [0], this is the code of the modifications they made to open-source projects, some of which they are supposed to release under GPL.

The title should be updated to reflect this.

[0]: http://opensource.palm.com/packages.html

Re:Amazon kindle source code by nikcub on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:49AM (#3114465)
This is why, in my opinion, having the GPL force code sharing may sound nice in theory, but in practice it isn't very interesting.

Amazon are just providing the bare essentials, there is no development community here, no way for them to take back any changes, no user or developer feedback, no documentation, build instructions, etc. - just a site that reads and looks like a legal obligation (and it is in the legal section of the Kindle docs).

Compare this to Webkit - where there is no requirement to share code, but you have a number of companies that have setup very successful developer communities around the code base and a lot of products taking advantage of the work with both the rendering engine and the Javascript interpreters.

You can require somebody to release code, but you can't force them to actively support it.

Re:Amazon kindle source code by wheels on Saturday October 15, 2011 @05:50AM (#3114531)
> Compare this to Webkit - where there is no requirement to share code, but you have a number of companies that have setup very successful developer communities around the code base...

Huh? Webkit was based on an open source project (KHTML under the LGPL) and there is a requirement that the code be shared. Also Apple basically did the same thing as Amazon did here at first: they just dropped huge tarballs on the developers with no comments. In fact, attempting to merge Apple's changes in without comments was so divisive that the forks split, and only years later did Apple open up to an extent with WebKit that it became a proper collaborative effort.

As for whether or not it's useful in practice ... note that I am one of the authors of one of the things they released, and my first reaction was to run a diff against the original to see if they'd made any interesting changes (they haven't).

Re:Amazon kindle source code by ra on Saturday October 15, 2011 @07:50AM (#3114642)
> This is why, in my opinion, having the GPL force code sharing may sound nice in theory, but in practice it isn't very interesting.

GPL becomes tremendously powerful once the licensed technology becomes significantly important enough that companies will accept the GPL in order to benefit from the technology.

Linux is testimony to this.

Re:Amazon kindle source code by Maakuth on Saturday October 15, 2011 @01:06PM (#3115194)
The point (of GPL) is not that new community has to form around this released source, nor that the consumers having bought devices using GPL software would be able to recreate them with their own software modifications. The point is that for example Linux developers get to utilize possibly useful modifications made by product vendors, say bug fixes.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by sorbits on Sunday October 16, 2011 @06:44AM (#3117047)
> The point is […] utilize possibly useful modifications […]

The ideology which spawned the GPL is that systems should be open. When a consumer buys something like the Kindle, he or she should be able to make changes to the system, i.e. rebuild a modified version of the OS and use that instead of Amazon’s original version.

The GPL is an ingenious way to transform the world of closed software to one where instead it is open, case in point being the Kindle, where Amazon decided to build on source already out there, and due to the license (GPL) in turn has to make their device more open than had they e.g. used BSD licensed software.

Re:Amazon kindle source code by morsch on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:59PM (#3115171)
Code releases like this can still be very valuable to communities trying to open up the devices, often against the wishes of the device manufacturers. It's unfortunate if the OEMs only comply with the letter but not the spirit of the license, but it's still a lot better than completely proprietary code.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by diminish on Saturday October 15, 2011 @05:28AM (#3114508)
Kindle source code against KHTML/Webkit? I would rather compare it to OS/X or iOS which utilized the BSD and other open source codes and.. where is the community around them? oh no, where is the source code for them? Or did they just suck the open source code like a black hole? Now why would I blame GPL, because it forced Kindle to release at least, so that someone can benefit.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by anon1385 on Saturday October 15, 2011 @05:55AM (#3114532)
Re:Amazon kindle source code by sliverstorm on Saturday October 15, 2011 @06:46PM (#3116010)
If people really cared, they would figure it out. That's the point of making them release the source- it can be figured out.

It is my opinion that nobody has screwed around much with the Kindle because it pretty much already does everything everybody wants it to do. Biggest want I've ever heard was that it doesn't support ePub, but you can convert to mobi so I don't think anyone has really been aching to patch it.

Re:Amazon kindle source code by ippisl on Saturday October 15, 2011 @08:44PM (#3116217)
The kindle's browser suck. i would be very interested in an opera version for the kindle.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by sliverstorm on Saturday October 15, 2011 @09:04PM (#3116234)
Interested enough to do it yourself?

... I rest my case.

Re:Amazon kindle source code by Xuzz on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:37AM (#3114445)
Apple has an equivalent page for iOS, but they've done a very good job phasing out anything GPL or LGPL licensed, and are now down to a very small set of tools with any code released: http://opensource.apple.com/
Re:Amazon kindle source code by mp3geek on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:45AM (#3114458)
The very reason why I prefer the GPL/LGPL over the BSD license, no obligation to give back/share with the community.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by pallinder on Saturday October 15, 2011 @09:20AM (#3114757)
And the very reason I dont, I have no intention of forcing my views of what should be done with the sc onto people that might benefit from using it.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by burgerbrain on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:40PM (#3115121)
You mean distribute it, not use it.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by jamesaguilar on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:54AM (#3114471)
I don't get it. What purpose do the licenses serve if the software goes unused?
Re:Amazon kindle source code by nknight on Saturday October 15, 2011 @08:30AM (#3114685)
You could basically say the same thing about any proprietary license.

It won't go unused by anyone who needs it and is willing to abide by the provisions of the license, same as any other software license. And there are many millions of people happily using GPL'd software every day.

Re:Amazon kindle source code by tobylane on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:52AM (#3114467)
It seems that what is left of GPL software there is either things that they've changed beyond recognition since taking on (webkit) or absolutely basic parts like gcc. Bit of a shame the larger pieces, all the way up to Darwin have nearly died.
Re:Amazon kindle source code by nknight on Saturday October 15, 2011 @08:27AM (#3114680)
Not sure what you mean, exactly. GCC went away for 5.x, sure, but that's because they've switched over to clang, which may not be (L)GPL, but is open source, and I haven't heard any stories of secret modifications to it.

Everything else seems to have remained from one iOS release to the next...?