News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear John Carmack. by kennymeyers on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:01AM (#3113959)
This article is so full of incendiary bullshit, I'm surprised it even got on the front page.

Some of the most critically acclaimed games, as well as highest selling games, have stories.

For example: Grand Theft Auto 3. Final Fantasy VII. Ico. Metal Gear Solid. Arkham Asylum. Mass Effect. Dragon Age. Dark Souls. Demon Souls. Starcraft. Starcraft II. Modern Warfare. World of Warcraft.

Do you know what else made these games stand out? Art direction.

Give me a break.

Re:Dear John Carmack. by stephth on Saturday October 15, 2011 @01:35AM (#3114156)
Some of the most critically acclaimed games, as well as highest selling games, have stories.

He's not saying games don't have stories, of course they do, he's saying that some game designers get distracted from making good mechanics, which I agree, is a huge mistake. Mechanics is the core of the medium, and shouldn't be put second on the list.

Valve gets that. Their attention and talent put into storytelling and art direction is top-notch, yet that has never distracted them from making sure their mechanics are excellent.

Re:Dear John Carmack. by grannyg00se on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:09AM (#3114403)
Mechanics are not the core of the medium. It can be for some games but the medium is much wider than that. How do you explain games that have basically no mechanics at all? I'm talking about simple point and click games like Myst. There are no significant mechanics there, but there can be a great story, and great visuals to keep you interested.
Re:Dear John Carmack. by stephth on Saturday October 15, 2011 @07:28AM (#3114621)
How do you explain games that have basically no mechanics at all? I'm talking about simple point and click games like Myst.

what exactly are you talking about? myst has significant game mechanics. all games have game mechanics.

Re:Dear John Carmack. by learc83 on Saturday October 15, 2011 @10:01PM (#3116322)
I've played plenty of games just because of the story. Think about Bioware games, they are basically interactive Cinema.
Re:Dear John Carmack. by hboon on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:17AM (#3114008)
What about games like Minecraft? I don't know if it's possible to fuse a high quality 3D engine with less amounts of artist generated content and still have a great game.

Challenge assumptions.

But if anyone can do it, Carmack can. (and that was an assumption, but oh well).

Re:Dear John Carmack. by kennymeyers on Saturday October 15, 2011 @02:03PM (#3115358)
I was not asserting that ONLY stories with games or great art direction succeed.
Re:Dear John Carmack. by thret on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:35AM (#3114035)
You think SC and SC2 stand out due to art direction? Well, sure, in the same way Chess does.
Re:Dear John Carmack. by brianobush on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:36AM (#3114038)
Yes, these games made it big and were good, but did they really push boundaries and invent new styles of play? No, they are just a story with an engine - the OP is talking about JC going off and doing something "different."
Re:Dear John Carmack. by potatolicious on Saturday October 15, 2011 @07:06AM (#3114600)
You're not serious.

Grand Theft Auto 3? The grand-daddy of open-world gameplay? It even gave birth to an entire genre of clones.

World of Warcraft? Didn't invent a new style of play? They took Evercrack and distilled it into pure, fine weapons-grade MMORPGing!

Metal Gear Solid? Didn't have an incredibly unique (and much cloned, and much parodied) style of play? Whose story and art direction is so famous that today we have people running around conventions with big exclamation marks over their heads?

Ditto Mass Effect - whose conversational mechanics practically redefined how all games do it today?

Arkham Asylum? Whose unprecedented combination of unique art style, stealth mechanics, pitch-perfect voice acting, investigative gameplay, and open-world format was widely lauded by both players and critics?

Oh yeah, those games. I'm sure the stories were not at all core to the games' success. It's all the mechanics, I'm sure.

Re:Dear John Carmack. by brianobush on Saturday October 15, 2011 @08:26PM (#3116193)
Fortunately, I haven't played a single game you mentioned. So I can be serious and totally off base at the same time. However, I have played games by JC and they are more of the same. Hoping his next gig isn't Rage++, but something new
Re:Dear John Carmack. by xenophanes on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:56AM (#3114079)
you don't think starcraft, the best and hardest strategy game in esports, pushed any boundaries or brought new styles of play?
Re:Dear John Carmack. by tripzilch on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:46AM (#3114459)
Yes, but because of the non-story PvP gameplay.

Yes there is a story in it, but that's not the part where it pushes boundaries.

Re:Dear John Carmack. by jQueryIsAwesome on Saturday October 15, 2011 @01:05AM (#3114104)
GTA3 revolutionized the open world games. And some people think is a genre itself. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Theft_Auto_clone)
Re:Dear John Carmack. by calebmpeterson on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:04AM (#3113969)
Half-Life
Re:Dear John Carmack. by dbbo on Saturday October 15, 2011 @12:39AM (#3114043)
It's also full of spelling, punctuation, and grammatical errors. I had to reread every other sentence to get the gist of it. If the content was gold I could probably overlook that, but it's not. It's basically a carelessly scrawled rant.
Re:Dear John Carmack. by DanBC on Saturday October 15, 2011 @05:14AM (#3114493)
Even taking into account that the writer's first language wasn't English the article is pretty poor. Maybe a lot was lost in translation.

>There is a Swedish saying that goes something like "Give the bear honey, and it will take you entire arm off".

I love this idiom. It feels much nicer than "Give them an inch and they'll take a yard / mile"

Re:Dear John Carmack. by dbbo on Sunday October 16, 2011 @03:12AM (#3116775)
As a linguistics student, I have a good deal of sympathy for people using a secondary language-- but I don't think this author even proofread his post before submitting it.
Re:Dear John Carmack. by JVirissimo on Saturday October 15, 2011 @01:30AM (#3114142)
I played Deus Ex when I was in high school and was more impressed by its storyline than anything I read in English lit.
Re:Dear John Carmack. by Legion on Saturday October 15, 2011 @05:18AM (#3114500)
That hurts to read. I enjoyed Deus Ex - a lot - but the narrative there is the stuff of cheap sci-fi paperbacks. It's just that such a narrative is more enjoyable when you get to actually walk around the world it's portraying.