News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by justin66 on Friday April 22, 2022 @09:01PM (#31130289)
> Rural productivity is vital to urban concentration. Raw material does not come from the depths of the subway system, nor do the land and seaports magically produce goods. Food, fiber, fuel, etc come from the rural reaches.

We pay a premium to buy food from the rural US in the form of common import tariffs that stifle or eliminate competition at the expense of the consumer and to the benefit of agricultural interests, and of course, taxes that subsidize agriculture. Large volumes of food need to come from some rural area, but if left to its own devices, the market would never demand that so much of it come from the rural US, or that the rural US make so much from the crops it produces. That's presumably some of what the OP was hinting at.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by briHass on Friday April 22, 2022 @11:07PM (#31130999)
One of the main points of the parent posts was the impact of climate change and/or subsidies for fuel. Our local agricultural system is already hopelessly dependent on fossil fuels, and you propose that this situation is improved if the US starts importing most of its food?
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by TZubiri on Friday April 22, 2022 @11:50PM (#31131206)
So the US would stop producing food and import it instead?

First, why? Second, from an ecological perspective this wouldn't change anything, just shift shit around.

Ridiculous, stop.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by justin66 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @08:03AM (#31133533)
> So the US would stop producing food and import it instead?

Is that how US agricultural interests would react if they had to compete on the free market? They would simply give up and let the land lie fallow?

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by TZubiri on Monday April 25, 2022 @07:20PM (#31162127)
You just said government would lift tariffs. Most of the land would go to a monoculture for export. The only land that would grow diverse foods for domestic consumption would be to cater to the demand for local consumption. And in the world where government lifted tariffs, we must assume that they acted in representation of the people, so that demand mustn't be so high.

This is pretty basic.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by rdtwo on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:14AM (#31163875)
The food you eat as a wealthy person is probably in a good part produced in other parts of the world due to cheap labor. Sure we provide lots of corn and and soy but a lot of that is for export fuel and meat production
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by giantg2 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @07:30AM (#31133315)
"Large volumes of food need to come from some rural area, but if left to its own devices, the market would never demand that so much of it come from the rural US, or that the rural US make so much from the crops it produces."

Why not? The US exports a lot a food and consumes a lot of food (per capita). If we were to cease exports and even some domestic production, then prices will rise. The worldwide demand isn't going anywhere but up, while arable land is the same or shrinking.

In a way I do think that many farm subsidies should be examined and maybe done away with, but in another way I realize that we can't compete globally (exports), and many likely can't afford to pay the the true cost of domestic production. Not to mention if we become an importer because of this, we could outbid other nations and instigate famine in the poorer nations.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by justin66 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @07:56AM (#31133477)
> Why not? The US exports a lot a food and consumes a lot of food (per capita). If we were to cease exports and even some domestic production

To clarify, removing tariffs and agricultural subsidies might not affect our overall agricultural output much (I wouldn't want to make a prediction on that) but it would lower the cost of goods which were previously subsidized with taxes or tariffs.

> Not to mention if we become an importer because of this, we could outbid other nations and instigate famine in the poorer nations.

It's worth pointing out that almost all economists of all political leanings are opposed to agricultural subsidies (it's one of the rare political things economists agree on) and one of the commonly cited reasons is that buying food produced by third-world economies at a true market price would be a natural and valuable step in helping those countries develop and grow out of poverty. The number of powerful people (including people who would normally give lip service to free markets) who, when confronted by this consensus among economists, basically don't give a shit is... disheartening.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by giantg2 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @08:30AM (#31133706)
I think that would be true and work, but only if our output wasn't reduced enough to interfere with other nations (supply needs to exceed nutritional need as it does today, and the distribution and supply chain also needs to be unaffected or improved). No idea of it would normally or not. But I'm guessing the high inflation and potential food crisis from the war in Ukraine would make this a unlikely candidate for a time to make that switch.
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by derstander on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:35AM (#31134627)
> The number of powerful people (including people who would normally give lip service to free markets) who, when confronted by this consensus among economists, basically don't give a shit is... disheartening.

Domain experts reach consensus and their recommendations aren’t followed in a lot of disciplines. I agree in this case it makes economic sense to stop farm subsidies — which could result in lower domestic food production and greater imports from abroad. And when the world economy is humming along smoothly that’s great. But if there’s a hiccup in the world economy —- e.g., in the case of war in a place where it makes economic sense to grow a lot of wheat or a problem in the logistics network shuttling things from where they’re produced to where they’re consumed then it’s not as clear-cut.

My naive view of politics, when they’re running well, is to navigate conflicting priorities from groups, including domain experts, the populace, etc.

And I think the farm subsidies could be interpreted to involve national security concerns on top of then economic concerns. If a world war breaks out and we’re on the opposite side from places we normally source our food then they have leverage over us.

TL/DR I think there’s more at play than just the economic concern.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by justin66 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:51AM (#31135341)
Regarding the security concerns, I assume the reduction in poverty overseas would have tremendous security benefits here. I also tend not to believe US agriculture would not simply reduce its output to dangerously low levels, but that’s harder to speculate about.
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by TulliusCicero on Friday April 22, 2022 @09:41PM (#31130565)
Exactly.

It's bizarre how often you see people arguing as if a lack of rural or farm subsidies would suddenly mean food disappearing.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by ochoseis on Friday April 22, 2022 @10:32PM (#31130838)
The core function of the government is to provide basic necessities to its constituents. In other words, guaranteeing a food supply is a critical national interest and there’s no better way than to incentivize home-grown food.
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by landemva on Saturday April 23, 2022 @12:43AM (#31131479)
The primary function of government was to protect liberty. The USA liberty experiment is nearly done.
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by gameman144 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @04:10AM (#31132384)
These two go hand-in-hand. As a whole-cloth believer in government's main goal being the protection of rights, I'd propose that it's pretty tough to guarantee those rights if you have invading armies or revolting citizens. Guaranteeing stability for the nation (in economic, military, and civic spaces) is needed, even if only as a means to protect liberty.
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by nitrogen on Friday April 22, 2022 @10:34PM (#31130852)
Consider this scenario:

1. The US drops all agricultural subsidies and tariffs.

2. The US begins importing most of its food from elsewhere.

3. "Elsewhere" goes to war with a US ally and stops selling food to the US.

4. The US then wishes it hadn't given up its abilty to grow food.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by bombcar on Friday April 22, 2022 @10:43PM (#31130890)
The amount of “the worlds economy is so interdependent that no country would go to war” argumentation seems to have died somehow.

Also I don’t know how “we will get food from even further away rural communities argues against food coming from rural communities”.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by TulliusCicero on Friday April 22, 2022 @11:47PM (#31131190)
> 2. The US begins importing most of its food from elsewhere

Gonna stop you there. This wouldn't happen, because the US has plenty of growing acreage and plenty of demand. The farming industry doesn't need subsidies, and removing them would affect total output only slightly on average.

Now, if we were more like Japan and had issues with enough space for farming, then yeah I'd agree with you.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by ungamedplayer on Saturday April 23, 2022 @01:25AM (#31131633)
Unless medium to large scale farming in the US is significantly different than the rest of the world, Land availability and demand are only tiny parts of the puzzle and not even the hardest issues to solve when farming. The need for immediate scale for any kind of shortage is guaranteed to cause significant shortages + massive price hikes starvation in the short term.
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by TulliusCicero on Saturday April 23, 2022 @02:11AM (#31131869)
Lol, just how big do you think the farm subsidies are? This is some big-time Clancychat you're throwing out there.
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by ungamedplayer on Saturday April 23, 2022 @08:49AM (#31133818)
Lol, i'm not talking about scale changes, not subsidies! loloolol
Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by justin66 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @08:11AM (#31133587)
> 2. The US begins importing most of its food from elsewhere.

I'd argue that the more plausible outcome is what economists predict: US agricultural interests would have to compete and domestic prices for food would go down, while the price that struggling economies which export food can charge for that food would go up. Competition... and the various parties involved focusing on what they're good at producing.

On the other hand, we in the US do tend to be pretty idiotic about largely abandoning business sectors when the going gets rough.

Re:Ask HN: Are there any rural tech communities? by kevin_thibedeau on Friday April 22, 2022 @11:36PM (#31131134)
The prime growing areas will just move north where there is already plenty of rural land not being used.