People absolutely drive considerably faster. There are many reasons for that, but they do. When I was a kid roaming around on my own in the 1980s and 1990s, the roads simply weren't as dangerous as they are now.
People not only drive faster, but driver visibility is much worse--because A frames, because SUVs, etc.
I agree fear has grown considerably. But not all that extra fear is irrational--at least some of it is justified.
In addition to buying more guns, people also fear everyone else. CPS gone wild is a direct result of that.
I read somewhere that some states are passing laws now specifically to protect parents from prosecution for letting 9 year olds play in parks unsupervised. I guess people see kids playing without parents now and think it's some kind of child abuse.
https://ithacavoice.com/2018/11/city-proclaims-ithacas-kids-...
Please don't upvote if you found this helpful. I want to get back down to 777.
In our rural school district, you're probably not even going to be on the school bus schedule if you live within a mile unless you're still in elementary school. In middle school/high school you can have up to a 1 mile walk to the bus before they will add a new stop. Elementary school kids have to be farther than 1/4 mile from the bus stop before they add a new stop.
Bear in mind though, that a lot of these rules are because it gets so cold here and they don't want 6 year-olds walking a mile to school in a blizzard when it's -20F.
This is a good point, although I would like to see some data to know whether this is actually common, or whether it's merely a common perception. If you actually control for things like population density, demographics (most notably age distribution), traffic, road design, city design (distance to schools, playgrounds, etc.) do you see a clear pattern of reduction in the number of children playing freely outside?
I have no doubt that there are plenty of places where this has happened, but I also have anecdotes of places where this hasn't happened (at least in the area I grew up in since I was a kid in the 90s).
I also do believe kids are over-scheduled and that youth sports require wildly excessive investment compared to my era.
Exactly. We had Super Nintendo, which was great, but you were limited by the carts you owned or rented. You had to sit down in front of the TV at a specific time each day to catch the show you liked, and that was it—one episode, now go find something else to do.
The Internet is an infinite supply of everything. You can watch an entire season of your favorite show nonstop in one sitting, or download ROMs of every SNES game ever created and play through them one by one. And as soon as a kid figures this out, it’s game over.
I’ve started seeing more white kids out in my neighborhood this spring though, maybe things are going back?
https://crimereads.com/how-the-disappearance-of-etan-patz-ch...
Fascinating to me.
I wouldn't want a child of mine doing that without a helmet, and I'd prefer a bicycle, but if he's going to break a bone doing a jump over a little hump on the side of the road, haha, more power to you little fellow. Go break that bone. Learn the limits of your power. And I think I could do that in Grover Beach if I wanted.
This is definitely true, here in BC. Kids under the age of 11 should not be unsupervised at any time; the rules aren't clear, but the case precedent make it not worth the risk.
https://www.crossroadslaw.ca/blog/what-age-can-you-leave-a-c...
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/editorials/bc-to-par...
https://cwrp.ca/sites/default/files/publications/Legal%20Age...
Because they got richer and all their "real problems" evaporated.
Kids play in the street where I live. But I live in the kind of place that makes HN demographics hand wring about violent crime and bad schools.
The 1982 F-150 had around 200 horsepower, depending on the configuration. If you believe the majority of people are driving between 1,000 to 2,000 hp cars today you are badly mistaken. An Abrams tank has around 1,500 hp but not too many of my neighbors drive those to work.
https://itstillruns.com/1982-ford-f150-specifications-759817...
You could also get pickups with 52 horsepower in 1982 as well:
http://vwtruckforsale.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/specs-s...
A 2021 Ram TRX has 13.5 times that amount of power. (702hp)
The smallest pickups you can get in the US today, the Maverick and the Santa Cruz both start at 3.7 times that amount of power (191hp).
I think a combination of increased vehicle size and number of vehicles per capita probably explains why parents would feel less comfortable having their children walk down country roads to school.
[0]: https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-s...
But not all suburbs are like this, and I do think that low density and focusing on cars over people makes kids unlikely to go outside. Where I live, yea the school is nice, but I've seen kids standing in the middle of 5 lanes of traffic (they are standing in the turning lane) trying to pass and standing there with, say, a skateboard.
This is definitely a problem.
On the other hand, I think kids are just staying inside and playing with electronics more too. But why are they doing that? Is the neighborhood not stimulating enough? Is there anything to do outside? Again in the suburbs I'm in, what is a kid to do? You can't really walk to any store, park (besides the school area), or anywhere else. You can't even bike anywhere. You'd definitely get hit by a car at some point.
So I think it's a bit of a cultural shift, sure, but I think that doesn't account for poor urban planning. Most likely in the past kids were just so damn bored that they'd overcome crappy neighborhoods because there was literally nothing else to do. Now? Why risk riding down a country road on your bike and getting hit by a car when you can just sit at home and text your friends?
Well, that one is easy: their parents permit it. The rule in my home was simple: if you start a video game, you also start a 30 minute egg timer. If you forgot the timer and got caught, you lost the privilege for a week. The egg timer could be upgraded to an hour if I was getting good grades, but the thought of playing games for several hours a day was almost inconceivable. I only got away with that when I was home alone.
Sometimes when I was feeling mopey and started complaining about being bored my mother would get sick of it and yell at me "GO BE BORED OUTSIDE"
Taking for granted this is true for the discussion:
Electronics are way more prevalent, stimulating and social than ever before.
Well for one thing this happened; and received a lot of national news:
Every morning and afternoon there's a crowd of parents waiting with their kids in the morning or for their kids in the afternoon.
I don't know why. The kids are old enough to walk to and from. In elementary school I walked home, middle school I waited at the bus stop with only other students, no parents and it was only a few of us on the corner.
I also get a kick of parents driving there on a perfectly good day and blocking the roads...a whooping 30 second drive.
I feel if I have my kids walk the few minutes by themselves I'll be labeled a bad parent.
With apologies, I don't believe this is true.
Where does this requirement come from and to whom would she deliver these reports ?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandatory_reporting_in_the_Uni...
However, if I understand correctly, the law is the mandatory reporting of abuse or neglect ... but the directive she received, that " ... a child walking to school by themself was evidence of neglect ..." is not a law.
What school district is this, by the way ? What ages are we talking about ?
https://nationalpost.com/news/world/child-protection-aervice...
https://www.cnn.com/2014/07/31/living/florida-mom-arrested-s...
I know this would severely reduce the content on NextDoor, r/PublicFreakout and r/byebyejob, but it’s a price we should be willing to pay.
I used to walk to school frequently, every time I missed the bus it was a two mile walk down country roads. If the weather was nice, sometimes I'd choose to walk without even missing the bus. My mother retired from that school district last year, and she tells me things are very different. She would be required to report any kid who was walking to school, it simply isn't allowed anymore. So what changed? Did the town get bigger? Nope, it actually shrunk a bit since the plant was sold. Did the roads get narrower? Twistier? Nope, they're the same as they ever were. The school? Still the same place they ever were. The only thing that changed was people became more fearful.