News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by throwaway1777 on Sunday April 17, 2022 @11:10AM (#31061373)
I actually disagree. It’s kind of a power law distribution thing where 1% of the people make 99% of the real scientific breakthroughs. We should absolutely optimize for geniuses.
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by DubiousPusher on Sunday April 17, 2022 @11:28AM (#31061489)
> 1% of the people make 99% of the real scientific breakthroughs

That is maybe the single most dubious statistic I've seen thrown out so offhandedly in my entire time on HN.

Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by atq2119 on Sunday April 17, 2022 @12:38PM (#31062099)
I mean it's bound to be true and actually more extreme than that if you're taking the entire population as your reference. If you take as reference the subset of people who are trying to get to scientific breakthroughs, then yeah, it's dubious.
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by throwaway1777 on Sunday April 17, 2022 @11:32AM (#31061526)
I’m talking specifically about stuff like the discovery of gravity or electricity, not the very important and significant inventions that aren’t really a step change. The number of people who make these discoveries may even be hundreds or thousands but that is vanishingly small on a planet of billions of people.
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by DubiousPusher on Sunday April 17, 2022 @11:42AM (#31061606)
Most academic discoveries come from the same kind of hand-me-down process as practical inventions. Newton's tutor was the one who encouraged him toward studying proto-calculus. He even wrote down the fundamental theorem of calculus himself once but not realizing its importance never publicized it.
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by xNeil on Sunday April 17, 2022 @12:28PM (#31062018)
Interesting! I'd appreciate any sources though.
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by mattkrause on Sunday April 17, 2022 @01:25PM (#31062506)
Here's a nice example of the "contingency" of scientific success by Bol, de Vaan, and van de Rijt (2018). https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1719557115

Grants are reviewed and ranked by a panel of experts. While they often agree in the broad strokes, their scores also have random or subjective components: different reviewers might prefer different approaches; even the same reviewer might give slightly different scores if they re-reviewed a grant (e.g., due to their mood). However, someone eventually does need to set a payline, or threshold for funding.

As a result, you'd expect people who submitted the worst funded grants and the best unfunded grants, which have very similar scores, to have similar career trajectories. After all, their abilities--as measured by grant scores--are virtually indistinguishable. However, the winners go on to win nearly twice as much funding in the next eight years. This presumably reflects the fact that funding begets more funding (you can collect more and better data for subsequent work) and prestige begets more prestige (you've now got another thing to put in the "awards" category).

Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by derbOac on Sunday April 17, 2022 @05:06PM (#31064516)
This gets even murkier when you consider that grant award and citation statistics are correlated only like 0.3 or something.

It's the Matthew effect multiplied by Goodhart's law.

Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by DubiousPusher on Sunday April 17, 2022 @01:45PM (#31062659)
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by mattkrause on Sunday April 17, 2022 @12:27PM (#31062009)
I really doubt that.

Being smart certainly helps, but you also need the right opportunities, environment, and colleagues to “produce” science. These all feed back onto each other in complicated ways: funding gives you time and space to work on tough problems, which attracts talented colleagues, who can make you yourself smarter and thus able to attract more funding and more colleagues…and so on. This works the other way too: a funding squeeze limits what you can work on (if anything), etc.

I can certainly believe that it looks like a power law, but I doubt “intrinsic ability”, insofar as that’s even a thing, has a similar distribution.

Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by peepop6 on Sunday April 17, 2022 @11:32AM (#31061525)
Sounds like a good way to create even more cults of personality and egotistical assholes who can't work in a team.

Breakthroughs aren't made by lone geniuses anymore. We just have that superhero fetish eg. picture of black hole where credit was practically given to that one woman in the picture.

Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by compiler-guy on Sunday April 17, 2022 @01:33PM (#31062556)
Breakthroughs were rarely made by lone geniuses even before. Sure, there are some, but even Edison had a huge lab full of people doing the work.

Bell labs was extremely successful (at least on the innovation front) not due to lone geniuses, but due to a large collection of very smart people all collaborating together.

Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by nyuszika7h on Sunday April 17, 2022 @05:30PM (#31064673)
Not everyone who dislikes working in a team is an "egotistical asshole". Some of us are just neurodivergent and have social anxiety.
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by vsareto on Sunday April 17, 2022 @11:20AM (#31061430)
That seems worthless if they find their own way to knowledge outside of the schools.

I think the K12 system destroying potential geniuses is a seriously overblown concern, especially in the internet age.

Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by Mezzie on Sunday April 17, 2022 @12:24PM (#31061994)
Disagree, but I'm concerned about the geniuses as a group of neglected children, not whether or not we're extracting maximum financial/scientific benefit from them. I always sigh whenever the discussion treats these kids/young people as tools.

The current system is terrible for genius kids' emotional and social development, and in some important ways it hobbles them. (Particularly when it comes to encouraging them to develop resiliency, accept that sometimes they need help, and develop their own sense of self-worth rather than derive it from the accolades of the adults around them).

Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by DubiousPusher on Sunday April 17, 2022 @11:29AM (#31061496)
Yes. The "geniuses" will be alright.
Re:Fuck Your Miracle Year by Natsu on Sunday April 17, 2022 @11:20AM (#31061432)
I feel like things are going to diverge further, between people floating around through the system and learning almost nothing vs. those self-learners who ignore that and learn on their own, not letting anything hold them back.