Imagine hundreds, or thousands of houses out there all with 25+ year old coax jacks in walls, 4-way splitters jammed into ceilings, leaky outdoor connectors that have been chewed on by squirrels, etc.
It's a miracle that DOCSIS3 works at all.
I'm vaguely familiar with the issue that the axe-grindy guy in the original webpage referenced here is complaining about, specific to some series of chipsets used by a popular cheap cablemodem for a few years of manufacturing run... But what he's found is actually a tip of an iceberg of terrible about why maintaining last-mile copper last wireline infrastructure (POTS wiring/DSL or coax for cablemodems) is a losing bet in the long run.
All copper in my city is replaced by fiber, and only copper is from the FTTx box in front of my apartment to my flat. Eeerything (landline, internet, IPTV, etc.) runs from a single, dark fiber.
With cabling already in place and VDSL can reliably provide 5 units of bandwidth (where 4 units is used for download and 1 unit is used for upload, e.g. 32/8 mbps), with a theoretical ceiling of 350mbps, I'm pretty happy with what I have.
While I'd love to have fiber at home, I definitely don't want to rerun cabling.
Also, the term looks like it has both meanings.
Having a "dark fiber infrastructure" means having a web of unconnected fiber cables point to point, but since you connect your own devices to it, you don't have to share it with others.
As a result, its presence and its state is only known to you (i.e. it's in the dark).
I understand that my usage is not completely true, but in that context, it's not a flat-out blatant mistake either.
Even the name means: "it's dark, no light, as in no data, because that's what light is in this case"
It has two meanings. I have heard it most commonly used in reference to private fibre networks.
I can't wait until my HFC NBN service here goes the way of the dodo.
While I have 1000mbps down, the 50mbps upload is just miserable. And the cost is painful, $130 AUD a month.
For the price I pay I should be able to have a shared 10000/1000 (in reality it will probably be 2500/1000).
All of this for the swag, I am ,ot likely to use the bandwidth anytime soon (despite serving a few things from home)
Now at least I can play my video games while my partner watches 4K shows on our TV.
Interestingly, moving from 100mbps to 1000mbps has given me a 5ms lower ping: 31ms to 24-25ms with a decrease in jitter of 5ms too, in Valorant -- this is to the exact same server from the physical same PC. I'm guessing even on the same damned cable, the 1000mbps customers get some kind of routing priority or something.
This makes it the best option by far for communication in hour-long blackouts when, for instance, cell phones and cellphone towers would have ran down their batteries.
The great thing about this was they could circumvent telecommunications law that requires them to rent out circuits at a competitive rate to small carriers, basically putting the nail in the coffin of small, independent DSL ISPs, since the copper loops are gone. And you, the customer, are now stuck with 6Mbps DSL from a single provider for $80 a month.
Almost everywhere in the US you can get at least 25mbps for less than $80 a month. And within almost all cities and their suburbs, you can easily get 100mbps+ for less than that.
Unbundled network elements was a stupid utopian idea to begin with. No one who knows a lick about broadband policy actually wants to go back to anything like that. The current model is essentially that you're responsible for building your own infrastructure if you want to be an ISP. That has actually spurred an incredible amount of investment in infrastructure across the country, since you know that if you spend a ton of money laying a thousand miles of fiber, you'll be able to reap the rewards of it, not have to rent it out at cost to your competitors.
American internet service is the best or one of the best in the world for a large, populous country. Certainly, the major European powers don't come close (remember when Europe had to beg Netflix and others to reduce video quality to 720p early in the pandemic? US internet service held up perfectly without any throttling.). Only Japan and large parts of China are comparable (again, not counting small or lightly populated countries).
There's a lot more to robust internet service than what you get on speedtest.net or in optimal conditions. Further, the internet speed statistics show that European internet service is on average slower than American service. It's great that you good service, but the point I'm making is that American service is on average faster and more robust, and we got there by abandoning the unbundled network elements nonsense.
But even if speeds were equivalent or better in the US, prices in the US are still multiples of European prices for the same service.
Also what's available and what I'm purchasing is different. I'd pay about 35$ for uncapped 100/100 and that's enough for me. But everywhere where you can get 100 you can also get 1000 for maybe 90$ a month. I don't want 1000 because it's useless for my use case, and I don't have anything to prove so instead of wasting money I'm staying on 100, I think most people are because it's just enough. There's also 250 and 500 inbetween which some might get too.
This is Sweden, which is supposedly 50 Mbit behind the US (x for doubt)
It's a beautiful ideal to reach for, but it's expensive, because it implies actually investing in infrastructure instead of exec bonuses.
We're also apparently building out train infrastructure quite extensively in Europe, and when you lay down train tracks you lay every other piece of infra down with it.
I'm all for private actors and all that, but not when the actors are allowed to pay politicians to not regulate them.
- 4 different fiber ISPs (in practice only 2-3, because 2-3 of them are sharing the same fiber line)
- 1 ADSL on the copper line
- up to 4 5G connections
- who knows how many satellite connections
That would be total overkill for 99+% of the people of course, but it's really nice to have 0 downtime when switching ISPs because the previous one still works when you start using the new one !
And regardless, while that might be a useful property in certain circumstances, the copper-based NBN we've ended up with is so woeful, that they're basically declaring technical bankruptcy and moving to FTTP after all that in the end anyway. Just a decade late and with billions down the drain for sub-par expensive flaky internet.
I can run 1 Gbps symmetric for ~48h without power by running my optical network terminal (ONT) and a teeny travel router on battery packs. (Used this set up through several long power outages.)
all the above describes my apartment connection in Astoria. and the neighbors were DIY tapped into it too. At any given time I lived there there was an appointment scheduled or being scheduled to have a field worker try to fix the downtime issues. they never did and i moved out
I was given a modem by my ISP that had a Puma 6 chipset and it was a nightmare - it would completely cut out multiple times per day, latency was all over the place, and it was a truly terrible experience.
Doing a bit of digging I was able to short-circuit a lot of troubleshooting and replace the modem, which immediately solved the problem. It truly was negligent how bad those chipsets work - even for basic tasks it was nearly unusable.