News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by jclardy on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:17AM (#31014920)
On the leaf image: “The reason I like this so much is the obvious layering. The depth of field created with the iPhone here very clearly shows you what the focal point is, and represents a fantastic example of how good the software is at completely isolating the foreground, leaving the background blurry. A perfect example of computational depth of field.” — Peter McKinnon

Is this correct? From what I've shot in macro on my DSLR, the blur is natural because the focus plane is so thin. I realize the phone has a much smaller sensor, but is the blur in macro mode computational? I thought that effect was only applied in portrait mode shots.

Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by dylan604 on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:30AM (#31015072)
At this point, I don't know how to apply any natural photography rules to camera phone results. There is so much processing going on that it is hard to even try to do things the "old" way. From the skin softening, to the pushing of the contrast/color balance/saturation, to the correcting of content replacing a person's face with a leaf type examples, etc, I really don't want to use the damn camera at all from a purist point of view.
Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by jitl on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:50AM (#31015337)
The leaf was actually a leaf. https://twitter.com/mitchcohen/status/1476951534160257026?s=...

Using Halide or similar with RAW substantially improves your control.

Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by astrange on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @06:19PM (#31021003)
It doesn't actually do any of those, people just hear "computational photography" and make up things in their heads.

"Real digital cameras" also have computational photography a.k.a. sharpening, auto exposure and auto white balance.

Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by dylan604 on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @07:04PM (#31021408)
"real digital cameras" have all of those features you mentioned as options.

"real photographers" set up their camera with the settings they prefer and develop in post. i'm deliberately using quotes there as photo journalists have been forced to do certain things that would go against the norms as mandates have come down upon them. These mandates are meant to ensure claims about mainipulation in post has a little ground to stand on, but the people making those mandates don't understand what they are mandating with their PHB directives.

Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by astrange on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @08:02PM (#31021855)
So do phones, but if you set everything to full manual that doesn't mean you're going to do any better. (Even autofocus can work a lot better than manual.)

Part of that developing is taking 10x the number of actual photos you want so you can delete the ones that're overexposed or too blurry. And you have to deal with all the data of keeping uncompressed RAWs around.

Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by Arkadin on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:32AM (#31015098)
I believe every photo on iPhone 13 pro is enhanced.

https://www.newyorker.com/culture/infinite-scroll/have-iphon...

You're right though that this isn't a "perfect example of computational depth of field" as the background leaf looks far enough away where you could have achieved the effect optically on iPhone sensor with right aperature. That being said the blurring does look unnatural to me as it is not even across the background leaf despite similar distance from lens. It's not clear cut though.

Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by JoBrad on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:53AM (#31016184)
You can shoot RAW photos on the iPhone. Don’t think most laypeople do, though.
Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by camillomiller on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @03:54PM (#31019455)
This is the stupidest, laziest, and less informed article I’ve ever read from the New Yorker. I honestly don’t know how it got published.
Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by formerly_proven on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:53AM (#31016192)
At that magnification I would expect some amount of blur, and the bokeh in the shot is very nervous, so I'd say it's mostly optical. Phone camera lenses generally have very poor bokeh, though you can rarely see much of it.
Re:Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Mac... by uuyi on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:59AM (#31016280)
Yep. The iPhone 13 Pro bokeh is miserably bad. On point sources, you're lucky if you can get any out of it and if you do it's got a hole in the middle.

Example here: https://imgur.com/a/cPG3YSP