News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by datadata on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @09:22AM (#31014337)
Accredited investor rules was an example of not having a even playing field. The market is not open to everyone which contributes to unfair outcomes. I'd welcome reforms to transparency as well there, as lack of transparency also contributes to unfair outcomes (the company can exploit investors).
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by thwayunion on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:27AM (#31015031)
> Accredited investor rules was an example of not having a even playing field.

1. Having an income that qualifies you as an accredited investor doesn't mean that you will have access to higher quality investments.

2. Even if you don't qualify as an accredited investor, you probably still have access to the same set of investments that a capital-poor accredited investor has access to. As an accredited investor, I've never had access to an investment opportunity which I couldn't have also accessed without being an accredited investor. No one checks, and the "opportunities" are mostly not great anyways unless you have a lot of capital and connections.

The operative things that unlock unfair investment opportunities are 1. one's professional network (or family), and 2. access to large amounts of capital.

You can counter this assertion by providing a list of investments which are open to all accredited investors, do not require significant amounts of capital, and which have higher expected return with lower risk than investments that are available to non-accredited investors.

The common misconception that becoming an accredited investor suddenly gives you access to high quality investments with super high returns for low risk is one of the best justifications I've ever seen for keeping the rule in place... which is particularly funny because I'm not even an avid fan of the accredited investor rule.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by datadata on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:37AM (#31015168)
You are basically saying that accredited investor rules are not successful in excluding people from making certain types of more desirable investments, because there are other barriers that are in place anyway. I think this is true, but beside the point. If you want to have an even playing field for investing, every barrier is an obstacle.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by thwayunion on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:45AM (#31015273)
> I think this is true, but beside the point.

I think you missed my point. To reiterate: the fact that people believe that it's not true is, ironically, a convincing justification for the accredited investor rule.

I'm pointing out the irony, not defending the rule per se.

> If you want to have an even playing field for investing, every barrier is an obstacle.

This clearly isn't true.

First, it's sort of prime facie false. Investments usually happen in markets. Markets are human inventions comprised of collections of barriers on behavior and enforcement mechanisms for those barriers. (Investments that happen outside of markets do exist, but they usually involve violence and/or coercion under threat of violence, so probably not what you mean when you say investment.)

Second, there are many ready examples. E.g., SEC filings and public exchanges are clear barriers to entry in fund raising, but also clearly level the playing field. The alternative is that the only way to know about a company's finances is to know the right people.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by datadata on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:04AM (#31015524)
I agree that markets are not natural and don't happen magically without human oversight and rules. But generally we want those systems to increase participation in the market. The criteria of net worth as a obstacle to market participation seems pretty indefensible here. It is hard for someone to commit to changing their net worth in the same way that a company can decide to become public, or that a wealthy person can sign a contract saying they are aware of investment risk. I would support some rule like "you must have either this net worth or prove that you are knowledgeable about investment in some way". The criteria has to be something that people are able to overcome.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by abduhl on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @02:07PM (#31018074)
>> I would support some rule like “you must have either this net worth or prove that you are knowledgeable about investment in some way”

This is the accredited investor rule. You qualify as an accredited investor through income, net worth, or having a current Series 7/65/82 license.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by datadata on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:58PM (#31022979)
Thank you for pointing this out, I had no idea!
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by thwayunion on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:52PM (#31017012)
At the risk of sounding like an incredibly broken record:

>> I think you missed my point. To reiterate: the fact that people believe that it's not true is, ironically, a convincing justification for the accredited investor rule. I'm pointing out the irony, not defending the rule per se.

and

>>> I'm not even an avid fan of the accredited investor rule.

So, as I've stated in every single post in this thread, I'm not defending the accredited investor rule. Cool?

The justification for the accredited investor rule is "people are idiots". Again, not even that rich = less of an idiot. The premise of the rule is that rich people can afford to be bamboozled by scams and shitty investments... er, I mean, take on "higher risk investment opportunities".

I find that justification uncompelling on face.

But then people come along and complain "I can't use prosper.com to make unsecured personal loans to randos for an expected return of 5.7% per annum on loans with 15%-20% APY during a time when every other asset class out-performed and with the front end of that window overlapping with a time when unfathomably higher quality debt products were offering similar returns on 3 year timeframes". And just listening to them makes me second-guess myself.

My point? It is ironic and humorous that the most compelling justification for the accredited investor rule is listening to people talk about how they would invest if the accredited investor rule didn't exist.

For the record, since people keep completely losing the plot: I think something like an educational requirement makes a lot more sense.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by mistrial9 on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:08AM (#31015578)
neither you nor parent post are absolutely right, of course. In the USA in the 2000 era, a lot of people with the ability to place large betting stakes on the table, using access to market-makers and leveraged buys of all kinds, were able to push around a LOT of money, mostly profitable, for quite a while. The party ended, except it didn't. The same over-leveraged tactics by players with access, except this time against one of the most protected asset classes, homes, almost collapsed the entire system with their excess. There are tomes written about this now, fifteen years later. Its not clean, fair or balanced.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by tastyfreeze on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:02AM (#31015499)
Prosper.com and similar lending platforms do not require a lot of capital but users are required to be accredited investors.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by thwayunion on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:19AM (#31015709)
On the customer side, this website offers high APY personal loans (my credit card is literally a better deal). On the investor side, the advertised rate of return is 5.7% between 2019 and 2022.

1. An effective return of 5.7% on unsecured loans with 15%-20% APY is... not a good deal. This signals either exceptionally high origination fees or extraordinary risk. Except it looks like you are investing in individual loans? So you don't even get this amortized 5.7%, but actually something that looks closer to "either 15% return or you lose your principal".

2. The rate of return is lower than every other broad asset class over that time period except for investment grade bonds, which weren't that far behind in 2019 and were probably a better deal given the enormous difference in risk profiles. Certainly high yield corporate debt was a way better deal on a risk-adjusted basis than given randos high-yield unsecured personal loans.

3. Most importantly, to my original point, you can get much higher quality exposure to high yield consumer debt via any brokerage account.

This is sort of exactly what I mean. Most of the "opportunities" widely available to accredited investors are really shit deals.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by TacticalCoder on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:37PM (#31016811)
> Prosper.com and similar lending platforms do not require a lot of capital but users are required to be accredited investors.

Last I checked to be an accredited investor, in the EU at least, you had to have 1 million EUR available for investments. So an organism (like a bank), where you have that amount, will certify that you have it and then you can get labelled "accredited investor".

As a sidenote I don't see it as proving you're savvy or anything: it's more like a club where they don't want "plebs" to pollute their members.

The whole concept stinks.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by thwayunion on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:40PM (#31016844)
In the US $200K income suffices.

Also, if prosper.com is the "club", then it's a pretty shit club. VISA provides exposure to the high yield consumer credit market and had returns that were modestly higher than prosper over the same time frame. By which I mean ~100% appreciation over 3 years vs. 5.7% per annum. And the risk profile of the equity play might even be lower; we don't know, since the distribution of defaults is not published by prosper.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by fragmede on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @06:36PM (#31021167)
These days there are a number of platforms like Globevestor that show the kind of deals available to accredited investors. They don't get you access to the same deals that you get by working Sequoia, but that's still better than what non-accredited investors get access to.

(WeFunder, specifically, tries to skirt the accredited investor regulation and offers tiny (they advertise "as little as $100") investments to non-accredited investors. It's not clear to me how they're doing that legally other than handwaving "crowdfunding platform" around.)

Accredited investor status itself doesn't give you access to higher quality investments, but it keeps the poors out from being able to angel invest in their professional network. If I'm not an accredited investor and I have $10k that I've saved up and want to plow into my kid's friend's uncle's big thing that they're working on? It might turn out that the uncle's a total scam artist or the next Elon Musk, but it's my $10k. I'm allowed to go to vegas and put it all on black if I wanted to, so why aren't I allowed to invest same as an accredited investor?

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by jakelazaroff on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:02AM (#31014757)
The accredited investor rules are in place to protect people who can’t bear the losses from an extremely adversarial financial system. I promise you that even if you get rid of the rules, people with a few thousand dollars to spend still would not have access to the best investments.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by datadata on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:52AM (#31015368)
I believe that every financial transaction has the potential to be adversarial, there are many ways outside of investing that the poor are disproportionately exploited (lotteries, debt interest). I think the libertarian perspective is that we shouldn't have protections that prevent people from making personal choices that result in harm to themselves, but only from harming others. I think that transparency for the companies seeking investment, or education of the investors themselves are better ways to restrict investment. Net worth/Income is not a fair criteria.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by kyleplum on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @02:23PM (#31018310)
> I think the libertarian perspective is that we shouldn't have protections that prevent people from making personal choices that result in harm to themselves, but only from harming others.

There are a few ways that someone bankrupting themselves via bad investments does hurt others:

Dependents will be significantly harmed

They are more likely to end up homeless or in jail on the dime of society

They are less likely to be a productive member of society.

I suppose the libertarian response would be that if someone bankrupts themselves, let them die homeless on the street - but I don't think you'll get agreement from any significant portion of society on that approach and even then someone has to pay to clean up their body.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by jcranberry on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:05AM (#31014788)
Accredited investing requirements are to keep non-experts or people without money to lose from being swindled by companies which aren't required to be transparent with their financials.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by TheColorYellow on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:46AM (#31015283)
Public companies swindle quite often, and usually with more catastrophic results.

When are we going to admit that the current rules are no longer working?

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by FabHK on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:45PM (#31016921)
So, given that companies swindle with catastrophic results, you're suggesting to have fewer rules and regulations? Less enforcement and oversight?
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by Goronmon on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:11PM (#31016433)
So then you agree that accredited investing requirements aren't the problem?
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by skybrian on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:03AM (#31014766)
Could you be clearer about what you mean by transparency? Do you think private companies should make their financial statements public? Do they need to be audited?
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by datadata on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:12AM (#31015631)
I think trading on the basis of private information at the expense of other shareholders without the same information is the problem. I'm less concerned about the specifics of filing requirements, and more concerned about information asymmetry regardless of auditing/reporting obligations. I'm not sure I know enough to recommend a specific policy here, my original comment was just what I believe to be some of the flaws that 'crypto fans' see in traditional systems.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by skybrian on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:59AM (#31016273)
Okay, fair enough!

However, reporting requirements and auditing are all about making sure everyone has access to the same, accurate information about a company's financial situation. Insiders will learn about changes in a company's finances before outsiders. If they can disclose this to some investors but not others, or even disclose it to some investors first, then that increases information asymmetry.

But this doesn't seem to be something that crypto fans are interested in, because they're not really investing in companies?

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by nybble41 on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:56PM (#31017061)
As I see it, insider trading rules are less about "information asymmetry" and more about avoiding conflicts of interest between the decision-makers in a company and the investors they are supposed to be working for. It is a given that not everyone will have exactly the same information—combining all those separate viewpoints to arrive at a single market price is why the market exists. However, the insiders have a duty to their employers—the shareholders—and insider trading puts the insiders' personal profit at odds with the decisions which will best benefit the company. They weren't given access to that information and a position where they can guide the direction of the company for the purpose of enriching themselves at their principals' expense.

The difference being: Under this interpretation insider trading is purely a dispute between the shareholders and their hired employees / agents. No one else has any standing.

Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by datadata on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:51PM (#31017006)
I think if the investment story of companies was better, maybe there would be less demand for crypto in the first place? Another big appeal is that in crypto the rules (governing the crypto itself) are not changeable by humans. This eliminates a large category of manipulation by insiders (while opening the door to other problems).
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase by FabHK on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:47PM (#31016955)
One could argue that companies ought to go public sooner, with the concomitant obligations and transparency on one hand, and the investment opportunities for unaccredited investors on the other. Rules with criteria such as revenue, employees, or something could achieve that.