Also: obligatory "not your keys, not your coins" and "don't keep your coins on an exchange".
Unless lobbying can still stop it the EU parlement will outlaw self hosted wallets. Only coins on exchanges will be allowed.
It would just bring crypto back to its roots as a government resistant alt currency. Being uncontrollable was the whole point. Particularly regarding Bitcoin and Monero.
Defi exchanges are the next major advancement to government resistance as well. This space would rapidly mature under government regulating away self custody.
Being the exclusive currency accepted for tax payment is an important part of what makes fiat currencies money.
The government is going to have to suck it up and accept taxes in cryptocurrency. In my country such laws have already been proposed.
I say have to as otherwise a rich private currency economy will grow unmolested by tax collectors.
Honestly I wouldn't mind that either. Governments in general are absurdly corrupt and taxes finance that corruption the same way drug users finance cartels.
Isn't it self-hosted anonymous wallets?
Yes, and the proposed restrictions only apply to transactions which directly involve an exchange. You can still have an anonymous self-hosted wallet, you just can't withdraw to it directly; you have to move the funds to a verified wallet address first.
So far I haven't seen any proposed rules about what you can do with the crypto once it's in your wallet, so all this means is that you need to withdraw to your own wallet first before sending the funds anywhere you want.
> (29) This Regulation applies not only to transfers of crypto-assets where both the crypto-asset service provider of the originator and beneficiary are involved but also to transfers of crypto-assets to or from a distributed ledger address not linked to a crypto-asset service provider, so called “unhosted wallets”, as long as there is at least one crypto-asset service provider involved in the transfer of crypto-assets.
> (29a) In cases of a transfer of crypto-assets made from or to a distributed ledger address not linked to a crypto-asset service provider, the crypto-asset service provider will have to obtain information both on the originator and the beneficiary, usually from their customer. However, the crypto-asset service provider will have to verify the accuracy of only the information on their customer and not on the originator or beneficiary with the distributed ledger address not linked to a crypto-asset service provider.
So when a transfer is made to or from an external, non-hosted wallet the exchange is responsible for identifying the wallet's owner.
Also note this clause in the proposed text of the regulation (under Article 2 paragraph 4):
> This Regulation shall not apply to person-to-person transfer of crypto-assets as defined in Article 3(14) of this Regulation.
So transfers between two unhosted wallets are unaffected.
This regulation has been widely misreported, so don't believe everything you read, especially if it doesn't cite the actual text of the regulation.
[0] https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/ST-14259-2021-...
[1] https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2021...
Absurd and laughable.
I can't wait to start printing and handing out long random numbers.
Now what ?
When you put in a sell order through the normal "retail" interface you're trading with Coinbase itself. Those coins can stay offline in cold storage, as they're just moving numbers around in their database, off-chain. Only withdrawals and periodic internal rebalancing operations (making up for an imbalance between buys & sells) strictly require online access to the keys, and those only affect a small part of the total.
It's really akin to the LME trade halt fiasco, which then became even worse when they retroactively reversed trades. The point is, when they're about to lose money they'll change the rules of the game. If you don't recognize that then you're the sucker at the table.
The LME situation and the DTCC/meme stock situation have very little in common, besides both of them being triggered by extreme price movement. It's much easier to argue that LME was rigging the game, but commodities are a different market that hit a little closer to home when things go bad. If the LME let short hedges get vaporized, the idea that they should have been left out to dry would be very unpopular in the fallout of that situation. Maybe they should have, but you're going to have a hard time convincing people not involved in finance of that.
Unless you are an institutional trader, the market isn't out to get you specifically. You aren't even shit on their shoe. You're shit three counties over, if that. They barely think about you. They barely even know you exist. You're background noise that most large players need to filter out to find out who is actually on the other end of the trade. Financial markets are rigged in the sense that big players will be bailed out and cut loose no matter what. They are not rigged in the sense that a retail investor can be on the losing end of a trade because they didn't understand what's actually happening.
Yes, it's literally their job to account for situations like this. They failed. Pointing out how insane the situation was only points out how poorly they predicted what might happen with private information they still haven't shared publicly. If they can't account for the bets placed then we don't have functioning markets. They knew what the short interest was, they knew what the options chain was, they have data about trades the public can't even see. There were multiple traders pointing towards a potential short squeeze in GME going back well into 2020, so if they could see it why the fuck couldn't the DTCC?
Your stance is "their job was hard therefore it's not their fault." That's quite frankly batshit insane when we're talking about the stock market which is an enormous functioning part of our economy. Yeah man, I'm concerned they don't know what the fuck they're doing because they've already proven they don't. If they didn't care they wouldn't have changed the collateral requirements - you're contradicting reality with your argument.
You can have the last word, I'm not going to respond any further.
- A clearinghouse cannot halt a market
- A clearinghouse's job is to ensure that trades settle, which requires adjusting collateral, which is exactly what they did
- A clearinghouse does not honor a trade, the buyer and seller (via their brokerage) do; if there's an increased risk of the trade not being honored, the clearinghouse raises collateral requirements
- DTCC controlled the situation the best they could from their end by raising collateral requirements, which is basically all they can do
- A market can be functioning perfectly fine even if clearinghouse collateral is at 100%
- A clearinghouse doesn't definitionally know what the outstanding short interest is; short positions are on broker's books and it is the broker that reports that data to FINRA, not the clearinghouse
- A clearinghouse preemptively "dealing with" with all outstanding options positions (or any position, for that matter) that they (there is not just one clearinghouse) know about boils down to collecting 100% collateral
- The OCC clears options, the DTCC (by way of the NSCC) clears equity; the data that the DTCC has regarding options is presumably very limited
- A clearinghouse is not going to require 100% collateral because somebody on the internet believes there's going to be a short squeeze
- I don't exactly know what you think you think they "don't care" about, but if you're implying that a clearinghouse requiring high collateral to deal with brokers not being able to make good on a trade because of activity on that broker's books is somehow rigging the market, you've completely lost the plot
I think you misunderstand what a clearinghouse does.
Agree to disagree. Cheers.
Exchanges are banks. They have the exact same problems, only with less regulation.
If you need assets to be immediately available to make on-chain transactions, you should not keep them under custody of centralized exchanges - they can and will delay withdrawals for a variety of reasons and most of them (including CB) do make this clear in ToS.
Now with Travel Rule regulation coming in (CB already started enforcing this in some countries but it will become mostly global over time), you need to specify name and physical address of recipient when withdrawing and this can be subject to manual checks as well, so withdrawals being delayed will become the norm IMO.
- nuCypher just randomly started going up on Binance
- the price was still low on coinbase
- the normal thing to do was to withdraw from coinbase and sell on binance
"Oops withdrawal of nucypher is temporarily locked", it stayed locked for 8 hours, all the crypto subs on reddit were screaming about it etc... a normal shitshow.
No explanation whatsoever was given, the only one that makes sense to me is that they do fractional reserve like everyone else, since there is no way everyone is going to withdraw at the same time right? in the 2021 bullrun coinbase received a lot of non technical people who are ok with keeping their funds on their website, so I guess they figured out they could just imitate the banks and start lending the funds people keep there and have you trade imaginary tokens you can't withdraw if you see a better opportunity.