News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why your new programming language won't work by dextorious on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @06:04PM (#3100538)
"I understand how it gets here, but I wish people wouldn't upvote this kind of pointless pandering. I'm sure it has a place somewhere, but it's not HN."

Should HN only reserve a place for the other kind of pointless pandering, the one the article mocks?

Re:Why your new programming language won't work by zobzu on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @06:09PM (#3100568)
Anything that does not remotely target Google is allowed. /pun
Re:Why your new programming language won't work by sukuriant on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @06:21PM (#3100629)
So the Google search command at the bottom is disallowed? :P
Re:Why your new programming language won't work by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @06:10PM (#3100577)
People trying to improve things should be encouraged; even if they always fail; and if its related to programming it should be here.

People that mock those people should be taken as amateur comedians, and should be on reddit (not here).

Re:Why your new programming language won't work by caf on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @07:32PM (#3100887)
The really clever part about this is that it's hard to tell whether it's mocking people trying to design new programming languages, or mocking people who criticise attempts to design new programming languages... or perhaps even both at the same time.
Re:Why your new programming language won't work by dextorious on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @08:15PM (#3100993)
"People trying to improve things should be encouraged; even if they always fail"

No, people trying to improve things should be presented with (sane) "barriers to entry".

While there is no "right" way to improve things, there are tons of certified wrong, dead-end, been-here-done-that ways that should be avoided. Engineering is nothing if we don't learn from our collective mistakes, our history, and from proven theory. Else, you get the equivalent of those countless kooks who claim to have invented "cold fusion", "perpetual motion machines" but the "establishment doesn't believe them".

People trying to improve things is not by itself beneficial. Even if we restrict this to programming, we have fragmentation of effort, and you get like 200 frameworks for the same thing with marginal differentiation. If someone comes along with some radical idea, more power to them.

But we reserve the right to mock those coming up with YET ANOTHER tired cliche of a concept and/or implementation. They don't get free applause just for effort.

Re:Why your new programming language won't work by Cushman on Wednesday October 12, 2011 @11:12AM (#3103214)
Is it too much to ask that an intellectual community like HN be a place free from both adulation and derision?