My dog also used "outside" + "water" to express her need to pee. I would be inclined to agree with you if she couldn't use them in the abstract, but she can.
Re:How Intelligent Are Cats? (2004)
by DangitBobby on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:14PM
(#30979212)
Realizing that making the sounds for "outside" allows you to go outside is not very far from language. I see people saying this every time dog buttons come up and it's very curious to me. What exactly do they need to do, model the parts of a sentence?
language is simply a form of communication between 2 beings. If those buttons are pushed so that a specific outcome may occur through another party (human) I would qualify that as a form of language.
They understand making a specific sound produces a specific result. It's a bit far from language.