News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by fguerraz on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:13AM (#30943407)
Except that Le Monde is not really quality journalism.

It is owned by the wealthiest French people, gets government subsidies, and has advertising on it.

All of these are fighting against the independence and objectivity of the content.

Mediapart, who doesn't have these problems, also has content in English, if you're desperate for a French point of view.

Le Monde will only serve you more liberal, globalist propaganda.

https://www.mediapart.fr/en/english

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by StevePerkins on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:19AM (#30943468)
Possibly the most respected periodical that I hear discussed on HN is "The Economist". Which is not classically-liberal and globalist due to conspiracy theories involving malevolent overloards. That's just legitimately what it is.

Your definitions of "quality" vs. "propaganda" are wildly ideological. Whatever one's personal subjective beliefs and perspectives may be, they should at least be self-aware about them. "Anything that doesn't confirm my biases is biased!" is not a healthy way to frame your world.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by pram on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:32AM (#30943580)
Huh? The Economist is THE neoliberal globalist journal. What a bizarre characterization.

Did you mean ZeroHedge or something?

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by ch4s3 on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:22AM (#30944083)
You can't be a neoliberal if you were publishing from the same viewpoint in 1843, they're classically liberal and helped define what that even means.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by tablespoon on Thursday April 07, 2022 @10:02AM (#30944538)
> You can't be a neoliberal if you were publishing from the same viewpoint in 1843, they're classically liberal and helped define what that even means.

That seems like a distinction without a difference. Isn't neoliberalism just liberalism, but willfully ignoring all or most of the problems that led to it going out of fashion the first time?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoliberalism:

> Neoliberalism, or neo-liberalism,[1] is a term used to describe the 20th-century resurgence of 19th-century ideas associated with free-market capitalism.

Also:

> In 1938 at the Colloque Walter Lippmann, the term neoliberalism was proposed ... ultimately chosen to be used to describe a certain set of economic beliefs.... According to attendees Louis Rougier and Friedrich Hayek, the competition of neoliberalism would establish an elite structure of successful individuals that would assume power in society, with these elites replacing the existing representative democracy acting on the behalf of the majority.

Oof.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by ch4s3 on Thursday April 07, 2022 @11:07AM (#30945426)
My point is that they aren't revivalists, but an organization that has always had a classically liberal perspective. They also aren't Hayekians, anti New Deal, or particularly animated by a need to shrink states to their bare minimum. You also aren't going to find the Economist fiercely beating the drum of privatizing the public sphere which is a key focus of neo-liberalism. You'll also find them criticizing things like shock therapy.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by darkteflon on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:11AM (#30943963)
“Classically-liberal” is a much fairer description of the Economist than “neoliberal”.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by dboreham on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:40AM (#30943644)
I think you may have mis-parsed the parent comment. They're saying exactly what you are saying.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by iorrus on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:27AM (#30943540)
I'm curious why you consider a periodical that you admit is heavily biased and has a certain agenda, the "most respected".

I read the Economist occasionally with exactly the caveat that you mention, it is an extremely biased periodical that only presents a certain world view. To be frank I feel this takes away from the quality and definitely verges on propaganda so the two are related.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by StevePerkins on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:34AM (#30943598)
It has a worldview, and is fairly open about it. Most everyone reading it is aware of that worldview, and seek it out either because it matches their own or because it counterbalances their own. Within its worldview, the articles are generally well-researched and well-written and increase the knowledge of readers.

Everything has a bias. Period. It's not a matter of things being "respectable" for confirming your own bias, it's a matter of not lazily labeling as "propaganda" things that don't.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by libraryatnight on Thursday April 07, 2022 @11:46AM (#30946080)
One thing I find with the Economist is I can generally read an article on a current event and come away with a factual account of the event and separate their view from it. From their own account I can argue and question their interpretations and extrapolations.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by darkteflon on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:09AM (#30943946)
I think of the Guardian in those terms, too - “advocacy journalism”. Things were a bit different under Rusbridger but now it’s got a strong, almost singular focus on a climate change agenda. Which, frankly, I think is fantastic. We need a paper like that.

I also tend to think it’s much more productive to categorise news sources as either “bona fide” - an earnest attempt to thoroughly research and report what you observe, as you observe it - versus “mala fides” - everything else.

As you say, there’s no such thing as unbiased reporting. Every paper has a world view - I’ll quite happily nail my colours to the humanist mast of a paper like the Guardian.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by iorrus on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:18AM (#30944035)
I'll leave this H.L. Mencken quote here that aptly describes the Economist. The nature of periodicals and newspapers especially militant, crusading ones is timeless.

“One of the principal marks of an educated man is the fact that he does not take his opinions from newspapers -- not, at any rate, from the militant, crusading newspapers. On the contrary, his attitude toward them is almost always one of frank cynicism, with indifference as its mildest form and contempt as its commonest. He knows that they are constantly falling into false reasoning about the things within his personal knowledge, within the narrow circle of his special education, and so he assumes that they make the same, or even worse, errors about other things,whether intellectual or moral. This assumption, it may be said, is quite justified by the facts.”

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by ch4s3 on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:27AM (#30944132)
Mencken did his fair share of crusading, and commenting brashly about things he didn't know much about.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by starwind on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:55AM (#30944460)
As I am an educated man, I'll take H.L. Mencken's advice and not take my opinion from his crusading in the Baltimore Sun. So I'll cede my entire political worldview to the Economist.

Nice to scratch one big thing off my to do list

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by p10_user on Thursday April 07, 2022 @01:06PM (#30947327)
But you would still need to get your news from somewhere? Seems like this quote is an even bigger impetus to read many news sources so you don’t fall into a default position held by a newspaper
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by gumby on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:57AM (#30943816)
> definitely verges on propaganda

It was specifically founded 180 years ago to propagate free trade. Its mission hasn’t changed, and is no secret.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by mardifoufs on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:06AM (#30943901)
Its mission for the past 2 decades was seemingly to also agitate for every war it could. And honestly the articles are just shallow in general

Just these headlines themselves are a bit disgusting honestly:

https://twitter.com/NaneAam/status/1504168188212387841

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by jcranmer on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:35AM (#30944230)
> also agitate for every war it could

It isn't agitating for a wider Russian-Ukrainian war right now (hell, it's explaining why it would be a poor idea for NATO to get directly involved in the war). It didn't agitate for a military response to the Russian annexation of Crimea. It didn't agitate for war against Iran, not even when Trump was considering it after the Iranian missile attack on a US base in Iraq. It's been a while, but I think it's criticized all of Israel's recent wars, as well as the proxy war going on in Yemen.

It's also criticized the Iraq War, and they are very open about the fact that a) they originally supported the Iraq War, and b) that support was a mistake. You don't find too many people who will admit to both--for most people, if they now believe the Iraq War to have been a mistake, they try very hard to bury the fact that they ever thought otherwise.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by fguerraz on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:28AM (#30943555)
I am fine with your criticism I am biased, and unapologetic about it.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by NeutralForest on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:32AM (#30943581)
The Economist is pretty decent altogether.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by ur-whale on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:17AM (#30943450)
> Except tha le Monde is not really quality journalism.

Agreed, but the other source you mention (Mediapart) is not what I would call quality journalism either, their political bias is intense.

I'm likely naive, but in my book, quality journalism is supposed to report facts, as much as they can be established without tainting them with a selection bias and must steer clear of injecting one's opinion in the content produced unless it comes with a truly clear warning ("this is an opinion piece").

Mediapart is profoundly not that.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by Jallal on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:40AM (#30943645)
Actually, every newspaper has some bias regarding the information they publish, and it's unavoidable. The most honest ones acknowledge that, contrarily to "Le Monde" and all the others main french newspapers ("Le Figaro", "Libération") claim.

Regarding Mediapart, it is indeed strongly opinionated newspaper, but you know that beforehand.

They have significant issues, but I'll never say it's not quality journalism (part of it actually). I've been a subscriber for years because of the quality of their investigations. For the record, none of these are pursued by big newspapers in France anymore: "Le Monde" and all major newspaper just relay the general information/propaganda, with no strong analysis. When they talk about scandals, they are never at their origin, and mostly relay the work done by others.

And when you know that most of them are owned by billionaires who have their own agenda, and that a significant chunk of their money (several millions per year) comes from the French state, you understand why.

You cannot be independent if your owners are billionaires, and if your income don't exclusively come from people who are paying for you to be independent (ie. subscribers). Everyone that argue against that is a liar. And you have in France 2 newspapers matching this criteria : Mediapart, and of course "Le Canard Enchainé".

The main issue I had with Mediapart (which led to cancel my subscription) was indeed the fact that on some subjects (mostly the "woke' things), they twist the facts to match their agenda. Some would say it's another view on the same facts but my opinion was that sometimes, they tried to make allegations on something not strong enough. Regarding the other subjects, I had nothing but praise for them.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by athrun on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:41AM (#30944298)
> The main issue I had with Mediapart (which led to cancel my subscription) was indeed the fact that on some subjects (mostly the "woke' things), they twist the facts to match their agenda.

> Regarding the other subjects, I had nothing but praise for them.

It’s weird how you noticed they are twisting facts to match their agenda on a specific topic, and somehow still think they’re not doing the same elsewhere.

Mediapart is a very unreliable source.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by Jallal on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:47AM (#30954392)
This is an oversimplification of things, but I'll gladly explain.

First, behind the term "newspaper", you have journalists. Not all of them are equal. Some are professionals, some have connections, and some are not good enough. Like every human. Yo also hae some journalist that specialize in some areas, when you better have solid arguments to avoid a lawsuit when publishing (and usually, only part of it is published to be able to react). I know the ones that I consider to be good. To drop a few names, Kevin Arfi, Laurent Mauduit, Martine Orange, etc. I mean, their career and their work speak for themselves, their papers are detailed, well structured, they provide facts and proofs, etc.

Then, sometimes, facts speak for themselves. You have so many evidences on a scandal that there is no point arguing. You may object that some other facts are deliberately hidden, but more often than not, the accused people never answer on the substance, always on the form. It speaks volume. I mean, Mediapart is not a young newspaper anymore, and they have their track record.

Also, in any case, you're free to form your own opinion based on the facts provided. I have sometimes - as I said on the "woke things" a different interpretation of the facts that the journalist. But to be able to do that, you still need the facts, and they are provided. I "just" read the things differently.

I take everything I read with a grain of salt, whether I like or not the newspaper, whether I pay for it or not.

But let's go. Tell me some cases when Mediapart was wrong ? It should not be difficult for an "unreliable" source. Oh and tell me also what are your reliable sources, especially on the subject of investigations. I'm curious. Because apart from the "Canard enchainé", I don't find any.

Because it will always be easier to discredit a newspaper like Mediapart, than to provide alternatives and fact. And if you want me to give some examples when scandals published in Mediapart proved to be true, I have many.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by Mondialisation on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:29PM (#30951976)
> Mediapart is a very unreliable source.

As opposed to what?

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by mardifoufs on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:37AM (#30944252)
Sure but Le Monde, with all the veneer of real journalism (tm) that it supposedly has , is arguably even less neutral than the less respected mediapart.

French society is extremely "dérigée" by the traditional vielle elite, much more so than the US for example. And it's not because they are conspiring to keep control or anything! It's mostly just due to how french society is structured. Power is very centralized and so are cultural institutions, in both cases around Paris. The education system is even more elitist, with the Grandes Écoles acting as a very selective gatekeeper. To the point where a career at Le Monde is probably a lot harder if impossible to sustain without having attended those schools.

What does that all mean? Well you get a very incestuous relationship between state, industry and media and a media that is extremely "parisian". They all went went to the same school, know the same people, share networks, etc.

Once they get in that very bourgeois clique, they become less trustworthy than even an opiniated source like Mediapart imo.

[Especially since direct state interference in the media/culture (or in general) is much less of a taboo in France than in the anglosphere. ]

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by fguerraz on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:23AM (#30943505)
They definitely have a bias for the left. But they are, objective enough to be the first to report on, for example, embarrassing campaign funding issues from Mélenchon's last campaign, a few weeks before the election taking place these days.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by psychoslave on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:43AM (#30943666)
I like the idea of situated knowledge. No one speak out of nowhere without any bias.

No one can cover all facts, and so any report will inevitably reflect biases in picking. For example, most human media out there are heavily anthropocentric. That doesn’t mean it is intrinsically bad, but this will definitely lead to covering events of the universe as if human actions was some kind of epitome phenomenon, despite the fact we have been capable of standing back as far as having pale blue dot.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pale_Blue_Dot

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by rospaya on Friday April 08, 2022 @07:11PM (#30963616)
> globalist propaganda

Using the term "globalist" undermines your arguments, the history of its usage is deeply tied to various conspiracy theories. It's polarizing, so the people you're pointing your comment to won't consider it serious because of it.

Imagine if I started quoting Mao - the rest of the comment fades.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by jillesvangurp on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:30AM (#30944161)
As opposed to Rupert Murdoch, Jef Bezos (washington post), and other billionaires. who own and control a lot of English news properties and use this to spoon feed you right wing and left wing populist drivel?

I tend to sample across different media to get an impression of what is going on. Lately, I've been using Al Jazeera, the Times of Israel, BBC News and a few others. They each have their biases. But, if you have Al Jazeera and the Times of Israel agreeing with each other, you are dealing with solid information probably. Often the subtleties in wording, emphasis, etc. is also very telling. Adding le Monde to that list will help me understand how the French look at this world. Der Spiegel International sadly pulled the plug a few years ago but used to be similarly helpful with understanding the German perspective.

If you only read stuff that confirms your own biases, you are probably not getting informed very well.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by Jyaif on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:29AM (#30943563)
> Except that Le Monde is not really quality journalism.

Yeah. They are living off their prestigious name, but nowadays I find that a good chunk of their articles are essentially opinion pieces.

On the other hand they now publish some high quality and well researched youtube videos.

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by libraryatnight on Thursday April 07, 2022 @12:27PM (#30946717)
This seems to be a problem with some of our press institutions in the US too. The NYT is inundated with horrible opinion pieces. They still do some decent reporting but you have to sift through a lot of garbage to get to it. It's still better than, and not at all comparable to, the news from an alternate dimension on Fox or the (somehow) crazier smaller nationalist networks, but extremely disheartening.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by thriftwy on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:20AM (#30943475)
I've checked Mediapart and every single piece on that page is about France, even Russia-Ukraine coverage is all about what Macron said. Just saying :)
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by zouhair on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:34AM (#30944218)
Le Monde Diplomatique though is high quality.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by stefanve on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:23AM (#30943504)
yeah do a way with liberalism let us go to populism history teaches us that this is a much better system
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by fguerraz on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:25AM (#30943522)
And these are the only two choices, right?
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by stefanve on Thursday April 07, 2022 @08:30AM (#30943571)
communism, stalinism, totalitarianism, feudalism and some others. afc depending on where you live (eg USA) people from EU are living in a communist society ;)

Not saying that things can't be improved but most politicians that are railing against liberalism are very much populists

Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by hemreldop on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:02AM (#30943868)
Propaganda is a strange word to use when the alternative you’re implying is literally batshit insane blood libel level conservative drivel.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by sidibe on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:59AM (#30944510)
These days hearing something called liberal globalist sounds like an endorsement to me. Not that I consider myself a liberal globalist but I usually find my opinions to be opposite of those who use that term.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by rahen on Thursday April 07, 2022 @12:56PM (#30947187)
I find it pretty hard here in France to find a media with a pro-market, small-governement stance. Basically the whole press is statist. L'Opinion and Les Echos are somewhat the least worst.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by speedgoose on Thursday April 07, 2022 @10:01AM (#30944529)
These adjectives are wrong, mediapart has done really useful investigations and have a good reputation. I’m not reading their work everyday, I prefer LeMonde which has a lot more interesting articles to me.
Re:Welcome to 'Le Monde' in English by TacticalCoder on Thursday April 07, 2022 @09:13AM (#30943985)
> Le Monde will only serve you more liberal, globalist propaganda.

> All of these are fighting against the independence and objectivity of the content.

Totally. It's, hidden behind nice typography (for the print version at least) and hardly ever a spelling mistake, the french version of "Pravda".