FWIW, speeding causes actual deaths of members of society
But I don't think this is the solution. The solution is better road design (road diets, narrower lanes, etc)
Ok? Heart disease kills more, from which obesity is a factor. How about I make an app that encourages users to snap pictures of people in public (totally legal) who are eating a big mac?
If we save even one life, it's worth it right?
On the other hand, maybe deploying technology at scale to encourage random people to police others is bad.
You eating a big mac isn't a threat to me, my family or my friends.
This attempt to portray all speeding as some kind of victimless morality crime is truly bizarre. Speeding is more akin to firing a gun into the air and then crying "Why are you persecuting me? I'm not harming anyone"
From a random document summarizing the process:
"With the definition of 85th percentile speed, it would seem that the signed (posted) speed limit of a street would be highly influential in determining the 85th percentile speed, however the exact opposite is the case. A deeper dive into 85th percentile speed helps to reveal why it is a major consideration in determining a street’s posted speed limit. As described above, the 85th percentile speed defines the speed that 85 percent of drivers will drive at or below under free-flowing conditions. Most people don’t drive according to the posted speed limit, but account for the visual aspects of the street and a ‘feel’ for the street. The visual factors that influence speeds can include:
• Lane and shoulder configurations, widths, and presence of curbs
• Presence of vertical and horizontal curves
• Sight distance and obstructions
• Presence of surrounding developments to the street
• Access management characteristics and medians/turn lane configurations"
"This uniformity of vehicle speeds increases safety and reduces the risks for vehicle collisions. When vehicles deviate from a standard speed, either faster or slower, the potential for crashes increase, whether caused by a slow car in a rear end collision or a fast car completing lane changes to maneuver through slower traffic. By setting the speed limit to the 85th percentile speed this uniformity is achieved and safety is increased."
https://www.lincoln.ne.gov/files/sharedassets/public/ltu/tra...
It's more the culture and actions that go around it. Speeding's bad when you're not paying attention. Even driving slowly is bad if you're in the overtake lanes. I think it's much more about paying attention to one's sorroundings. I'm not saying this should apply near residential homes, but I do speed on highways because I can go fast and I only overtake through the left-most lane; I use blinkers, I light cars to let them know. I don't overtake in curves. I don't put people in danger. I don't go through yellow/reds. But to be honest, my situation is probably far more different that in the US, I live in Mexico. Most people here do speed and there's barely any authority to stop vehicles from speeding.
We really need better platforms than what we have now, these types of people deserve to hear what we really think of them, instead of being protected by "moderation".
Do you also condone citizens witnessing other crimes and doing nothing or is your opinion limited to dangerous driving only?
Next up, hunting drug users, people who get abortions, jaywalkers, the homeless, etc.
Hyperbole? Yeah, duh, but also the reality a significant portion of society wants to realize. Don't enable these people.
"Yeah, our app has a full database, plate and facial recognition, geolocation, everything. We're on around 10 million devices in the state right now"
"How hard would it be to add a button to report drug users too? You said you had facial recognition and GPS?"
"Oh completely trivial, we'll just add a field to the schema and another ui element..."
And? "Speeding" as is experienced in the life of the daily American is a joke. Tens, if not 100+ million Americans "Speed" every day.
Remember that speeding is just 1 MPH over the limit, and that limits are set to unrealistically low levels all over the country for purposes ranging from revenue generation to empowering racial discrimination.
Not the person you're replying to but yes, for all civil infractions and most criminal ones for which there is no readily identifiable victim.
In the overwhelming majority of cases it is not. 10-100M people in the US speed every day. "Speeding" as a term makes no distinction between the common 5-10 over and doing 120 in a 75.
Meanwhile US speed limits are incredibly low, and treat a sports car on an open dry road the same as an 80,000lb semi on wet tarmac.
This is a classic law enforcement trope. I'm sorry but no-shit "speed" is a factor in a collision, so is the strong nuclear force. Stating such a thing proves nothing towards:
1) If someone was _actually_ speeding, as often the precise speed is totally unknown at the point of impact/accident. A cop that rolls up to a car impacted on a tree has no idea if they were doing 50 or 60 in a 55, but you can bet the farm they'll check the "speed as a factor" box.
2) If the accident would have happened had they been traveling 5MPH slower (speeding vs not speeding)
3) If the person would have survived at 65MPH vs 70. Remember that survivability has a cut off point, you're dead. Hitting a concrete wall head on at 65MPH is 100% lethal, 70MPH doesn't make any difference with respect to "survivability".
Couple all this with speed limits being insanely low throughout the US and routinely exceeded by 10+ MPH, no-shit that it's "a factor" in the majority of collisions... everyone does it. That's garbage data.
According to german data, reducing the speed limit from 50km/h (~30mph) to 30km/h (~20mph) reduces heavy injuries and deaths by 60-70% (https://www.vsf.de/fileadmin/inhalte/public/06_Engagement/te...) and decreases fatalities after a collision with a pedestrian from 80% to 30%. That's not quite mad max, but still very bad.
We know that even for interstates speed limits have an large effect (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000145759...), with deaths rising by ~15% after the speed limit was increased from 55mph (afaict, for urban interstates it was mostly raised by 10mph, with average travel speed only changing slightly). So even at those speeds there is a very noticable effect on deaths.
If these numbers apply to speed limits, it's obvious that they should also apply to speeding. Even more so, it makes it clear that setting the speed limit higher has an pretty large effect on safety, so people do use the speed limit as a guide (with, as you said, often some amount of additional speed), so raising the speed limit seems like a very bad idea.
All the figures I've seen for US speed limits seem in line with most of the speed limits commonly used in Germany, which are more on the high side for the EU. I don't know how you come to the conclusion that they're amazingly low.
Really, 30mph car impacts with pedestrians had an 80% fatality rate?
What about 45, 75, and 150 MPH? Should we analyze those as well, or should we realize how silly this all is?
The solution has always been to physically isolate pedestrian traffic from vehicles at anything above trivial speeds. 30-45mph car traffic on a flat plane with joggers and moms pushing strollers is stupid. These aren’t hard problems to solve, we’d just rather spend $15 Billion on our 14th aircraft carrier instead of pedestrian bridges/walkways/tunnels/elevated roadways etc.
No one is suggesting obvious interface points like airport drop off/pickup lanes allow 75mph traffic. The point is that for the VAST majority of roads in the US pedestrian traffic is nonexistent and speed limits are 20-30% too low. So low even the cops don’t really enforce them (unless you’re black or the officer has a quota to meet).
We have huge stretches of flat, controlled access, well maintained super highways stuck at 1950’s speed limits (65MPH). Yet when we talk about fixing this all we hear about is how someone killed a bus full of nuns doing 70 in a 25mph school zone. Otherwise rational people seem entirely incapable of nuance when it comes to the speed discussion.
Why? It's an important question to have data on. It's essential to designing neighborhoods
> The solution has always been to physically isolate pedestrian traffic from vehicles at anything above trivial speeds
How in residential roads? By installing overpasses everywhere (they suck for pedestrian traffic and accessibility), installing traffic lights everywhere (they're already way to common in America and really suck for traffic flow) or do the same thing other countries have done, which is to slow drivers down (by design & by law) in residential roads.
The first two options are also pretty expensive, can take a lot of land and many counties already suffer financially from their road infrastructure.
In general, roads with speed limits above 30mph are not common inside urban environments in germany (with quite a few exceptions, especially for large arteries, which are often being put underground or getting their speeds reduced).
Installing sidewalks more commonly in the US would already be great, but this data is from germany, where a street without a sidewalk is an uncommon (although not totally rare) occurrence.
Having >30mph traffic inside urban areas is mostly stupid. It increases land use, costs, discourages anything other than car use and is really dangerous. There should be at most only a handful of roads with higher speeds in cities with >500.000 people.
> US pedestrian traffic is nonexistent
There are somewhat obvious reasons for that, among them hostile road design & high speeds. It's close to suicide to try to walk anywhere in many places in the US.
> So low even the cops don’t really enforce them
I don't know if you've looked at other countries, but enforcing speed limits, especially in such a way to act as an effective deterrent, isn't commonly done (with exceptions like switzerland).
Regarding the highways: That's the reason I've searched for data in the US regarding the change of the speed limit from 55mph to ~65mph, which has a very significant (but not as large as in residential roads) effect. I can't imagine further increasing it not having a similar effect. That also shows that the speed limit does have a somewhat large effect on travel speed (at least in the top end), because otherwise there wouldn't be that many issues.
I'd also be interested in changes for the average travel speed in the US, because it doesn't increase as much as you'd think in the >100km/h in many european places, even without significant amounts of speeding, due to cars scaling really badly at density with higher speeds.
A huge issue is that american residential roads are way overbuilt, further encouraging speeding. A lot of residential roads in Central Europe have specific provisions encouraging and forcing drivers to slow down. The residential streets in America sometimes look like a small, two-lane, highway regarding their width and straightnes.
True, but I think it’s better said as longer stopping distance. This is fine though. The speed limit should be the speed that no reasonable person would exceed, but what we have in the US is in fact the speed no reasonable person would drive. Again, the cops don’t even enforce the posted limits until +10 because they’re so low. That’s not ok.
>more death
Not really. Death clips the risk function. You can’t go above 1.0. An airliner nose diving into the ground (like that one recent case) is equally fatal at 300, 400, and 500MPH. No one is suggesting slowing planes to save lives.
Similarly, a concrete wall teleporting to 150ft in front of you is going to kill you on a highway at 60, 70, and 90 MPH. The goal therefore is to prevent spontaneous debris from entering the roadway, and of course keep relative speeds among motorists as low as possible. Impacts with stationary objects should always be sloped, for example a guard rail and not a bridge support column.
That’s how you actually save lives, not something ridiculous like capping all transit to 25mph.
I am guessing your defence of speeding relates to less populated areas where the chances of hitting a pedestrian are pretty much zero?
Case in point. Many neighborhoods have 15mph limits and speed bumps. Everyone drives 25-30 plus and it's far from mad-max. We live in a world where exceeding this particular "limit" by 60% is not only safe, it's common.
On first glance it just seems stupid, but on deeper inspection the real goal of these systems becomes obvious. If everyone is speeding, you can arbitrarily pull over anyone at any time with legal justification. These types of selective enforcement schemes are how bias slips in to what should be deterministic systems.
Speeding is probably one of the reasons why there are almost no pedestrians and kids on suburban streets now.
It's funny how there are so many road accidents caused by people with this very same attitude. Since it isn't their poor driving that's at fault, obviously, what do suggest is?
Remember that my 60% claim was someone doing 25 in a 15 in a neighborhood. 15 mph is unreasonably slow in even the worst-case scenario.
The real speed-do-not-exceed in my neighborhood is 35MPH, but instead of setting that and enforcing even 1MPH over they set the speed limit to 15 hoping people actually go 25-30.
My argument is that this system is stupid and should be reformed.
The problem is reckless incompetence, ego and ignorance behind the wheel.
Reporting the guy who rolled through my fence to the police and then them allowing him to keep driving because he requires driving to earn a living is where the problem is. He should have forfeited his right to get behind a wheel there and then and had to live with the consequences. I'm sure he's probably killed someone by now.
The car was doing under the speed limit when it was rolled into my garden.
If it becomes accepted as an automated solution where either a very quick human check or no human check is required, it would reduce their burden.
To put it politely, please take off the rose tinted spectacles.
Incase it had escaped your observation, a whole industry has sprung up where specialist lawyers make themselves available to challenge speeding tickets.
These speeding tickets are challenged on technicalities.
These technicalities relate to ?
That's right, issues with CALIBRATED fixed or mobile speed detection equipment, operated and maintained by trained individuals.
Typically the crux of the legal challenge is built around ?
Yes, that's right. Issues with the calibration of said equipment.
So, the chances of law enforcement issuing fines based upon "evidence" of speeding based on something that some random app on someone's phone has spat out ?
Yes, that's right. Zero, zilch, nada.
Assuming simple s = d/t
1. The wheelbase data source is accurate. (d)
2. The vehicle type identification is accurate (d)
3. The centre of the wheels is identified correctly (d)
4. The wheels being on the same vehicle are identified correctly (d)
5. The measurement resolution is limited by pixel resolution so the image needs to be large enough to not lead to quantization errors (d + t)
6. The direction of travel of the vehicle is accurately determined (rate of motion is different if car moving away) (d)
7. The rotation of the vehicle is accurately measured (wheelbase compressed if turning away from the camera) (d)
8. The phone's camera is digitizing frames at the same rate without jitter (t)
9. The video source is actually coming from an actual camera and has not been modified by the user to incriminate them (d+t)
10. The camera isn't being moved in sympathy with the reference frame (d+t)
11. The reference frame is identified correctly (d+t)
12. the correct set of wheels on the vehicle are identified (d)
13. The shape of the lens of the camera (wide angle lens distortion) (d+t - possible calculus fun there)
I'd take the other arguments apart but I don't think I need to.
Edit: keep finding more problems with this.
There's a reason most police departments forbid personal devices from being used to collect evidence in most circumstances.
I disagree with points 6 and 7 entirely. You can observe wheelbase compression standing on a tight bend with your eyes which are fairly low precision.
Also throw an extreme scenario on the table. If you're travelling at 70mph, that is 31m/s or 1m image resolution for a 30fps video. If your wheelbase is 3m that's a resolution of three frames to pass which is well below any threshold where a credible measurement is possible as you convert from discrete to continuous time.
Of course that brings in the problem that lower speed resolution is probably better so I should probably be driving around at 70mph in a 30mph in my 6x6 Land Rover 130 (sorry couldn't resist that).
I think there are too many assumptions to make a reliable measurement within a tolerance for the purpose described. The existing measurement devices have to be calibrated and must be operated within certain constraints to make an accurate measurement otherwise the information is inadmissible. Your app doesn't contain 1/10th of the assurance or competency that would be required. All it does is allow really annoying people to annoy people.
I want to embarrass people who are speeding through my neighborhood at 2x the local speed limit, just because they can. In some cases, including school buses.
Uploading only the most egregious cases to YouTube on an automated basis would make me happy.
The new SaaS is Stasi as a Service.
Citation needed. I'd argue that without surveillance we wouldn't even have society. We'd just have warlords and anarchy
This terrific app is a good step towards closing the feedback loop, establishing a direct line from a transgressive behaviour to social condemnation, punishment, and perhaps ultimately banishment.
As Libertarian demiurge Robert A. Heinlein has taught us: A well-armed society is a polite society.
Firstly, anything which normalises surveillance by citizens on citizens is a death spiral for society. On top of that the £14.99 for 1000 credits approach empowers only the lunatic classes of society who would consider that as a price worth paying to get people into trouble.
Secondly, I have problems with the accuracy claims here which are presented disingenuously. The measurement of vehicle wheelbase and the system clock and frame rate is seen as the reference with no mention of the issues with accurately measuring that nor issues like frame stalling and jitter.
Thirdly, this will create a lot of noise for law enforcement agencies which may mask other higher priority crimes.