News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Speedcam Anywhere – catch speeding drivers from your smar... by traceroute66 on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @12:35PM (#30934296)
> if it becomes accepted as an automated solution where either a very quick human check (e.g. that the wheel locations are indeed correctly identified) or no human check is required, it would reduce their burden

To put it politely, please take off the rose tinted spectacles.

Incase it had escaped your observation, a whole industry has sprung up where specialist lawyers make themselves available to challenge speeding tickets.

These speeding tickets are challenged on technicalities.

These technicalities relate to ?

That's right, issues with CALIBRATED fixed or mobile speed detection equipment, operated and maintained by trained individuals.

Typically the crux of the legal challenge is built around ?

Yes, that's right. Issues with the calibration of said equipment.

So, the chances of law enforcement issuing fines based upon "evidence" of speeding based on something that some random app on someone's phone has spat out ?

Yes, that's right. Zero, zilch, nada.

Re:Speedcam Anywhere – catch speeding drivers from your smar... by mrguyorama on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @02:55PM (#30936066)
Unfortunately what that all REALLY means is that this system will only catch/charge speeders who also happen to not be able to afford a lawyer to challenge it or take the time off to take it to court.
Re:Speedcam Anywhere – catch speeding drivers from your smar... by uuyi on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @03:22PM (#30936401)
Yes. To be fair all low value financial punishments are ethically reprehensible on this ground. They don’t dissuade anyone with money because the consequences are low or easy to appeal and people who are poor are punished harder. This ends up in a situation where punishment causes an even larger cultural divide or pushes people to other crime to make ends meet.
Re:Speedcam Anywhere – catch speeding drivers from your smar... by sidpatil on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @04:23PM (#30937036)
Some systems address this by scaling the fines to income. Finland comes to mind.
Re:Speedcam Anywhere – catch speeding drivers from your smar... by uuyi on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @04:38PM (#30937184)
That doesn’t really work either. I can afford to lose 75% of my income in any month. I have been in a situation where losing 5% of my income is financially crippling.