It prevents me from falling into a trap of crafting posts that have a bias toward what I think people might want to read, it keeps it pure.
Same with blogging, except I can publish any old crap on my blog without moderation.
Can you please elaborate? Because I was (and still am) under the exact same impression. The only appearance of the word "comments" on the home page is this:
• Comments (alpha)
and there is no link.
Phrasing my comment a slightly different way: what’s the point of writing *in public* if you don’t get feedback?
- Writing publicly is minimum viable pressure to make me better formulate my ideas. It doesn’t require feedback; 80% of the value is in my words being public. When my ideas are better formulated, it leads to me new ideas I wouldn’t have had otherwise
- Over time (I’ve been blogging since 2000) I’ve found that the most valuable feedback is in email. You don’t get good signal to noise in comments or Web Mentions. RSS + a public email address is all I need
- I can afford for my network to grow slowly. I don’t need to build big community with flurries of debate in a comments section. Writing publicly is an excellent way to keep in touch with the broad network I already have
And the usefulness of writing isn't connected to if people can reach the author or not.
It’s a cliche that every musicians best work is their early stuff. Once you become popular, famous, entangled in expectations and opinions, you lose the thing that made you great.
—-
Original comment:
I don’t get it. If you want to write and don’t care how much you’re read, write privately (Google Docs, a journal, text file, etc.)
If you’re writing publicly presumably it’s for public consumption. The way you know if your writing is read is through feedback - comments, shares, email subs, etc.
Feedback on your writing both helps you understand where you need to think more deeply about what you wrote AND provides valuable positive reinforcement: somebody is reading what you put into the world.
Not providing hooks for these seems to defeat the purpose of writing in public.